New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

This may be a silly question,

Wahbooz

Governor
but I'm curious about something. Not speaking of support for anyone, just a curiosity about some minds thinking. I do realize 'a mind is a terrible thing', but this seems rather weird to me.

Since Obama ran in the first election he has been accused of being a Muslim.

Then the Rev. Wright 'scandal' came on the scene, and then the Rev. Wright was labeled Obama's pastor, and this was a blight on Obama.

Now it comes full circle again, and Obama is a Muslim again. As one Republican candidate said, religion is NOT a test for holding public office, and he was right; but yet the accusations flew. Obviously it must not matter if Obama is a Christian or a Muslim, he's wrong. But I'll let Matthew quote the words of Christ in Matthew chapter 7, as a word to the wise to those who claim to be Christian and make accusations.

Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged; and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye? Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye? Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thine brother's eye.
 
I would like to respond, but I don't quite know where to begin since I thought there would be a question (the subject line led me to believe that) but there is no question. So I just don't know where to start and I want to address specifically what you want addressed, rather than start meandering.

So please ask a question or ask several regarding your post and I will be glad to attempt an answer.
 
I would like to respond, but I don't quite know where to begin since I thought there would be a question (the subject line led me to believe that) but there is no question. So I just don't know where to start and I want to address specifically what you want addressed, rather than start meandering.

So please ask a question or ask several regarding your post and I will be glad to attempt an answer.

How can Obama be a Muslim, and have a Christian pastor?

What does it matter what his religion is?

Who has been given the right to judge but God?
 
How can Obama be a Muslim, and have a Christian pastor?

What does it matter what his religion is?

Who has been given the right to judge but God?

Last question first.
We don't have the right to judge a person's soul. But we can make many other judgments - like what kind of person we want as a President. Carson has given his opinion. He doesn't think that a Muslim president would be good for this country. That's not making any judgment that belongs to God. God doesn't say that we can't have opinions.

First question:
"How can Obama be a Muslim and have a Christian pastor?" I am answering my answer, nobody else's. I don't know what Carson or Trump or anyone like that would say. But all of us know that Obama was raised as a Muslim or at least surrounded by Muslims. He said in his boo that the morning call to prayer by Muslims was "the most beautiful sound on earth" so it wasn't a bad experience for him. Obama went to Muslim schools as a child. You and I both know, Wahbooz, that things like that influence a child greatly and become part of that child. I don't know and don't care what religion Obama feels is his in the heart of his being, but it would be wrong to assume that Islam wasn't influential in the making of the man Obama is now. He was heavily influenced by Islam and it shows that he cares deeply for its people. That's neither bad nor good.........it is what it is. He has also, obviously, embraced Christianity whether it is for political reasons or not. Rev Wright said in an interview that the Obama's aren't church people. Neither of them were raised going to church nor did they attend regularly or send their kids to Sunday School. LINK This also lends more credence to thought that Islam is more than just influential. So Rev. Wright's Christian church was just window-dressing. That's all it was.

Second Question:
Does it matter what his religion is?
It might.
It seems like Christianity is not viewed in a positive light these days. Much of it is due to the secular nature of our people now. Our president's religion only matters if that president seeks to change everyone to think like he does. It was feared that when JFK was elected, the Pope would be our real president...........that didn't happen. Unfortunately, we can't know whether it matters or not until much later than an election date.
 
Last question first.
We don't have the right to judge a person's soul. But we can make many other judgments - like what kind of person we want as a President. Carson has given his opinion. He doesn't think that a Muslim president would be good for this country. That's not making any judgment that belongs to God. God doesn't say that we can't have opinions.

Christ was not speaking of a person's soul, when he mentioned a mote. A mote is a speck, not a person's soul. Christ did not say we can judge people, as long as we stay away from judging their soul. Labeling a person is no less a judgment, and as Christ said in John 8:7 "He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her." It is very easy to create an illusion of big sins and little sins.

First question:
"How can Obama be a Muslim and have a Christian pastor?" I am answering my answer, nobody else's. I don't know what Carson or Trump or anyone like that would say. But all of us know that Obama was raised as a Muslim or at least surrounded by Muslims. He said in his boo that the morning call to prayer by Muslims was "the most beautiful sound on earth" so it wasn't a bad experience for him. Obama went to Muslim schools as a child. You and I both know, Wahbooz, that things like that influence a child greatly and become part of that child. I don't know and don't care what religion Obama feels is his in the heart of his being, but it would be wrong to assume that Islam wasn't influential in the making of the man Obama is now. He was heavily influenced by Islam and it shows that he cares deeply for its people. That's neither bad nor good.........it is what it is. He has also, obviously, embraced Christianity whether it is for political reasons or not. Rev Wright said in an interview that the Obama's aren't church people. Neither of them were raised going to church nor did they attend regularly or send their kids to Sunday School. LINK This also lends more credence to thought that Islam is more than just influential. So Rev. Wright's Christian church was just window-dressing. That's all it was.

I have seen people who profess to be Christians, who go to church 'religiously', and who have told me they do not 'know' if God is real, or if Christ is savior, they 'pray' just incase. They claim to be Christian, and yet the object of what is supposed to be their faith is non-existent. And I have seen people who choose not to step foot in a church, and are extreme believers in God and Christ. What they choose to do and not do should not be a reflection on their faith. I don't need a church, the best church is God's creation. I can get more from the trees, the rivers, the sky, than I can get from 4 walls. Being Christian is only from believing Christ is the savior, nothing else.

But it seems few people understand that the worshipers of Islam follow their own lineage back to Abraham or Ibrahim.

Actually the call to prayer is beautiful, as well as Shinto chants are beautiful. As well so are Buddhist chants. And people need to remember, as there are radical Muslims, there are also radical Christians.


Second Question:
Does it matter what his religion is?
It might.
It seems like Christianity is not viewed in a positive light these days. Much of it is due to the secular nature of our people now. Our president's religion only matters if that president seeks to change everyone to think like he does. It was feared that when JFK was elected, the Pope would be our real president...........that didn't happen. Unfortunately, we can't know whether it matters or not until much later than an election date.

This I do not agree with. Are there atheists who see Christianity as ridiculous? Yes, but that is a persons opinion, and as man fell from grace in the garden he was given free will. Orthodox Jews do not believe in Christ, ergo they are not Christians. Are they viewed as evil, like all Muslims are? No, they're usually embraced by Christians. That secular nature has always been inherit in man, and it seems people reserve the right to judge one religion over another by their own prejudices. I've known Baptists who criticize Catholics and say they are sinners who are not worthy of God's salvation.

Is it any wonder I worship in God's creation and not mans?
 
Christ was not speaking of a person's soul, when he mentioned a mote. A mote is a speck, not a person's soul. Christ did not say we can judge people, as long as we stay away from judging their soul. Labeling a person is no less a judgment, and as Christ said in John 8:7 "He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her." It is very easy to create an illusion of big sins and little sins.
Sins are sins......... all equal. But you are right. It's difficult for us to understand that concept. We are asked to "judge" every time we vote for our leaders. Our criteria for that judgment is either shallow or strong, but all of us do that. I agree with you that labeling a person is a sort of judgment we should avoid. But if a woman's husband beats her every night, she's not going against the teachings by making a judgment call that she needs to leave their home or die.

But your comment brings me to something I've said here before. Religion is used to control people. I don't think Jesus or God had that in mind. Or maybe that's something else to discuss.



I have seen people who profess to be Christians, who go to church 'religiously', and who have told me they do not 'know' if God is real, or if Christ is savior, they 'pray' just incase. They claim to be Christian, and yet the object of what is supposed to be their faith is non-existent.

I've seen the same. Sometimes I feel that way. Life isn't easy. I won't judge people who say that.

And I have seen people who choose not to step foot in a church, and are extreme believers in God and Christ. What they choose to do and not do should not be a reflection on their faith. I don't need a church, the best church is God's creation. I can get more from the trees, the rivers, the sky, than I can get from 4 walls. Being Christian is only from believing Christ is the savior, nothing else.
I don't go to church yet I strive to behave like a Christian at all times. I do it because I can see how it just makes for a better life AND because I believe God is in control and Jesus died for my sins. I don't feel that church attendance does anything but stress me out a lot so I don't go.

But it seems few people understand that the worshipers of Islam follow their own lineage back to Abraham or Ibrahim.

I understand that. God promised Abraham that He would make of him a great nation. Abraham went through one of those times where he wasn't certain if God was there or not or maybe God might have forgotten him and he and Sarah had gotten too old to have children..............so he had a child with a servant. God kept his promise for both sons and the people from both have been at each others' throats ever since.

Actually the call to prayer is beautiful, as well as Shinto chants are beautiful. As well so are Buddhist chants. And people need to remember, as there are radical Muslims, there are also radical Christians.
Yes. I never said otherwise. I am not nor have I ever been Catholic, but "Ave Maria" ( all versions) is one of the most beautiful songs ever written. In the little town where I spent my childhood, the Catholic Church played Shubert's Ave Maria (my personal favorite) over a loudspeaker every Sunday morning. To me that was the most beautiful sound on earth. My saying that was to show that Islam holds a dear spot in Obama's heart.




This I do not agree with. Are there atheists who see Christianity as ridiculous? Yes, but that is a persons opinion, and as man fell from grace in the garden he was given free will. Orthodox Jews do not believe in Christ, ergo they are not Christians. Are they viewed as evil, like all Muslims are? No, they're usually embraced by Christians. That secular nature has always been inherit in man, and it seems people reserve the right to judge one religion over another by their own prejudices. I've known Baptists who criticize Catholics and say they are sinners who are not worthy of God's salvation.
I understand what you are saying here and don't disagree. But let's take individual religions out of the equation and talk cultures. The Muslim culture is very different from ours. People of the Muslim religion in America have, for the most part, adapted to the European-style culture that has always been ours. The more radical Muslims seek to drastically change our culture. I think that is more what people are reacting to than the religion of Islam. Some Americans are racist. But for the most part, America is a pretty good melting pot and welcomes people of all religions and cultures. But if some culture wants to radically change America, there's trouble.

Is it any wonder I worship in God's creation and not mans?
No wondering about that all. I do the same. When I have gone to church, and for much of my life I went to church as my parents helped to start churches in inner city areas, and worked tirelessly in those churches for my entire childhood. As an adult, I was a church piano and organ player and held other administrative offices. But at a point I realized that although I dearly loved the people of the church, those who administrated the church (not my local church, but the whole denomination) were leading the church in a bad direction. I checked out other churches and found the same thing going on. So, for the last 15 years I have not gone to church. It's not the "sinners" in the church that's corrupt. It's the leadership.

It's been a great conversation. If you give me a response here, I'll answer you back tomorrow. It's late and I'm exhausted. I hope I wrote this in a way that makes sense.
 
but I'm curious about something. Not speaking of support for anyone, just a curiosity about some minds thinking. I do realize 'a mind is a terrible thing', but this seems rather weird to me.

Since Obama ran in the first election he has been accused of being a Muslim.

Then the Rev. Wright 'scandal' came on the scene, and then the Rev. Wright was labeled Obama's pastor, and this was a blight on Obama.

Now it comes full circle again, and Obama is a Muslim again. As one Republican candidate said, religion is NOT a test for holding public office, and he was right; but yet the accusations flew. Obviously it must not matter if Obama is a Christian or a Muslim, he's wrong. But I'll let Matthew quote the words of Christ in Matthew chapter 7, as a word to the wise to those who claim to be Christian and make accusations.

Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge, ye shall be judged; and with what measure ye mete, it shall be measured to you again. And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye? Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye? Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thine brother's eye.


Damned if he do and damned if he don't.

I don't like Obama but yes I agree this damning him for his 'religion' see saw is odd.

How the hell he could be thought to a Muslim is beyond me, everything about his actions is anti Islamic as well as his murdering of perhaps millions of and causing the displacement of so many millions of innocent Muslims. It is Israel he seems to be clearing the Land for, not for Muslims but of Muslims.
 
How can Obama be a Muslim, and have a Christian pastor?

What does it matter what his religion is?

Who has been given the right to judge but God?
Because Obama is Christian even though he's also familiar with the Muslim world.

It shouldn't, but ever since Jerry Falwell's Christian Coalition was allowed into the Republican tent in 1980, religion has become a key issue for RW candidates. I'm with Barry Goldwater on this issue:

“Mark my word, if and when these preachers get control of the [Republican] party, and they're sure trying to do so, it's going to be a terrible damn problem. Frankly, these people frighten me. Politics and governing demand compromise. But these Christians believe they are acting in the name of God, so they can't and won't compromise. I know, I've tried to deal with them.”
 
judge not lest ye be judged . . . . that's fine within the church community, I suppose. provided your church doesn't refuse to marry gays; shield pedophile priests; stone adulterers; concemn unbelievers to hell . . .

but here in the real world, there are a lot of (secular laws). everything from speed limits to identity theft to armed robbery to rape and murder. we can and do arrest, try, and judge people on the evidence.

this is nothing to do with Obama, and what religion, if any, he embrace.

let's judge Obama on why we're still in economic distress 6 years after he was inaugurated, okay?
 
judge not lest ye be judged . . . . that's fine within the church community, I suppose. provided your church doesn't refuse to marry gays; shield pedophile priests; stone adulterers; concemn unbelievers to hell . . .

but here in the real world, there are a lot of (secular laws). everything from speed limits to identity theft to armed robbery to rape and murder. we can and do arrest, try, and judge people on the evidence.

this is nothing to do with Obama, and what religion, if any, he embrace.

let's judge Obama on why we're still in economic distress 6 years after he was inaugurated, okay?

Judge his administration on the issues, not on his character; nor create false 'scandals' about him. There is enough to criticize, it isn't necessary to make shit up.
 
Sins are sins......... all equal. But you are right. It's difficult for us to understand that concept. We are asked to "judge" every time we vote for our leaders. Our criteria for that judgment is either shallow or strong, but all of us do that. I agree with you that labeling a person is a sort of judgment we should avoid. But if a woman's husband beats her every night, she's not going against the teachings by making a judgment call that she needs to leave their home or die.

But your comment brings me to something I've said here before. Religion is used to control people. I don't think Jesus or God had that in mind. Or maybe that's something else to discuss.





I've seen the same. Sometimes I feel that way. Life isn't easy. I won't judge people who say that.


I don't go to church yet I strive to behave like a Christian at all times. I do it because I can see how it just makes for a better life AND because I believe God is in control and Jesus died for my sins. I don't feel that church attendance does anything but stress me out a lot so I don't go.



I understand that. God promised Abraham that He would make of him a great nation. Abraham went through one of those times where he wasn't certain if God was there or not or maybe God might have forgotten him and he and Sarah had gotten too old to have children..............so he had a child with a servant. God kept his promise for both sons and the people from both have been at each others' throats ever since.

Yes. I never said otherwise. I am not nor have I ever been Catholic, but "Ave Maria" ( all versions) is one of the most beautiful songs ever written. In the little town where I spent my childhood, the Catholic Church played Shubert's Ave Maria (my personal favorite) over a loudspeaker every Sunday morning. To me that was the most beautiful sound on earth. My saying that was to show that Islam holds a dear spot in Obama's heart.




I understand what you are saying here and don't disagree. But let's take individual religions out of the equation and talk cultures. The Muslim culture is very different from ours. People of the Muslim religion in America have, for the most part, adapted to the European-style culture that has always been ours. The more radical Muslims seek to drastically change our culture. I think that is more what people are reacting to than the religion of Islam. Some Americans are racist. But for the most part, America is a pretty good melting pot and welcomes people of all religions and cultures. But if some culture wants to radically change America, there's trouble.

No wondering about that all. I do the same. When I have gone to church, and for much of my life I went to church as my parents helped to start churches in inner city areas, and worked tirelessly in those churches for my entire childhood. As an adult, I was a church piano and organ player and held other administrative offices. But at a point I realized that although I dearly loved the people of the church, those who administrated the church (not my local church, but the whole denomination) were leading the church in a bad direction. I checked out other churches and found the same thing going on. So, for the last 15 years I have not gone to church. It's not the "sinners" in the church that's corrupt. It's the leadership.

It's been a great conversation. If you give me a response here, I'll answer you back tomorrow. It's late and I'm exhausted. I hope I wrote this in a way that makes sense.

You gave me a lot to think about, Jen, and when I have more time to absorb I'll respond. Take care of my, my friend.
 
Judge his administration on the issues, not on his character; nor create false 'scandals' about him. There is enough to criticize, it isn't necessary to make shit up.
Agreed about "false scandals" or other lies for that matter. OTOH, character is a legitimate issue. His actions regarding Martin, Brown and Bergdahl were wrong, regardless of how well intentioned.
 
Agreed about "false scandals" or other lies for that matter. OTOH, character is a legitimate issue. His actions regarding Martin, Brown and Bergdahl were wrong, regardless of how well intentioned.

Because the jury had a difficult time reconciling SYG, does not mean Zimmerman was actually innocent of the crime. And that is all I will say about that.
 
I don't go to church yet I strive to behave like a Christian at all times. I do it because I can see how it just makes for a better life AND because I believe God is in control and Jesus died for my sins. I don't feel that church attendance does anything but stress me out a lot so I don't go.

I think it's the mentality of some people. I was almost floored with surprise when someone told me birth control pills is nothing more than an abortion.

I understand that. God promised Abraham that He would make of him a great nation. Abraham went through one of those times where he wasn't certain if God was there or not or maybe God might have forgotten him and he and Sarah had gotten too old to have children..............so he had a child with a servant. God kept his promise for both sons and the people from both have been at each others' throats ever since.

True, and yet in places like the Iberian Peninsula Jew and Muslim lived in harmony together, until the monarchs drove them out. From what i've read and seen in documentaries, it was the same case in Palestine, particularly Jerusalem where Mosque and Temple sat side by side until the Crusaders invaded.

Yes. I never said otherwise. I am not nor have I ever been Catholic, but "Ave Maria" ( all versions) is one of the most beautiful songs ever written. In the little town where I spent my childhood, the Catholic Church played Shubert's Ave Maria (my personal favorite) over a loudspeaker every Sunday morning. To me that was the most beautiful sound on earth. My saying that was to show that Islam holds a dear spot in Obama's heart.

I love Ave Maria, it brings tears to my eyes with it's sound.

I understand what you are saying here and don't disagree. But let's take individual religions out of the equation and talk cultures. The Muslim culture is very different from ours. People of the Muslim religion in America have, for the most part, adapted to the European-style culture that has always been ours. The more radical Muslims seek to drastically change our culture. I think that is more what people are reacting to than the religion of Islam. Some Americans are racist. But for the most part, America is a pretty good melting pot and welcomes people of all religions and cultures. But if some culture wants to radically change America, there's trouble.

I'm not sure what you mean by culture, Jen, so I'll hold off on this. And while I'm sure there are 'American' men who would prefer a woman walk 10 paces behind him, I've known a number of ME men whose wives do that. As Anishnaabe, I know the government, with the assistance of churches, tried desperately to destroy our culture. I feel it is important to keep culture alive. Life to me would be so boring if societty was homogenized. But perhaps you're not referring to that.

No wondering about that all. I do the same. When I have gone to church, and for much of my life I went to church as my parents helped to start churches in inner city areas, and worked tirelessly in those churches for my entire childhood. As an adult, I was a church piano and organ player and held other administrative offices. But at a point I realized that although I dearly loved the people of the church, those who administrated the church (not my local church, but the whole denomination) were leading the church in a bad direction. I checked out other churches and found the same thing going on. So, for the last 15 years I have not gone to church. It's not the "sinners" in the church that's corrupt. It's the leadership.

I agree, and throughout history there have been lots and lots of corrupt leadership.

It's been a great conversation. If you give me a response here, I'll answer you back tomorrow. It's late and I'm exhausted. I hope I wrote this in a way that makes sense.

I've enjoyed reading it.
 
I think it's the mentality of some people. I was almost floored with surprise when someone told me birth control pills is nothing more than an abortion.
Oh I know what you mean. And that's something else in a church that I can't deal with. I taught in a religious private school where one of the teachers singled out different teachers each day to tell us what God had told her we need to do. It was sickening. I cannot be a church member. Period.

True, and yet in places like the Iberian Peninsula Jew and Muslim lived in harmony together, until the monarchs drove them out. From what i've read and seen in documentaries, it was the same case in Palestine, particularly Jerusalem where Mosque and Temple sat side by side until the Crusaders invaded.
My brother and sister-in-law spend a lot of time in Jerusalem for work (she is a symphony conductor and he is a lawyer). They have told me the same thing. I have good friends who have Muslim relatives and they all get along. Race wars are, I believe, started by politicians and media to line someone's pockets.

I love Ave Maria, it brings tears to my eyes with it's sound.
Mine too. So while I don't like Obama much, I won't begrudge him feeling that the call to prayer at dawn is beautiful. I understand.


I'm not sure what you mean by culture, Jen, so I'll hold off on this. And while I'm sure there are 'American' men who would prefer a woman walk 10 paces behind him, I've known a number of ME men whose wives do that. As Anishnaabe, I know the government, with the assistance of churches, tried desperately to destroy our culture. I feel it is important to keep culture alive. Life to me would be so boring if societty was homogenized. But perhaps you're not referring to that.

I've enjoyed reading it.
Culture is important to all of us. I grew up in the Hispanic culture of San Antonio, Texas and even now when I hear cantina music I like to just close my eyes and be in a kinder simpler part of my life. I lived in Italy and got into the culture there and loved it. One of my first dates with my husband was to a Christmas Eve barn dance in the mountains of Sardinia - where only a handful of people spoke English, the musician played Italian songs on the accordion and at midnight we ate some sort of special cake and kissed everyone on both cheeks. The wine was some of the strongest homemade opium-based wine I've ever tasted. Culture is the heart of life and I don't want it to disappear.

But my American culture is valuable too. And it's not right for Muslim culture to come in and take that away any more than it's right to destroy anyone else's culture. I would never seek to deny Muslims or anyone their culture. I don't want them to deny me mine. That's all I meant by that.

You know, Wahbooz, it hasn't always been so, but I feel that more and more Americans are holding tightly to and having great reverence for the cultures of those who were here before those of us whose ancestors came from Europe. That is important. Fortunately we have retained many of the correct names for cities and streets and places. I have lived in every time zone of this country (6 of them) and in every single one, there have been not just a few but many reminders of the Native Americans who were here when Europeans arrived. I think that's good.

Have a good evening.
 
Because the jury had a difficult time reconciling SYG, does not mean Zimmerman was actually innocent of the crime. And that is all I will say about that.
You don't have to comment on the jury nor SYG: Just admit that President Obama inserted himself into the judicial process only a few weeks after the shooting by saying "If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon Martin".

It doesn't matter if Zimmerman is guilty or not in your or my opinion in order to judge whether it was proper for a President to take sides in a legal because long before the investigation was complete and months before a jury selection.
 
You don't have to comment on the jury nor SYG: Just admit that President Obama inserted himself into the judicial process only a few weeks after the shooting by saying "If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon Martin".

It doesn't matter if Zimmerman is guilty or not in your or my opinion in order to judge whether it was proper for a President to take sides in a legal because long before the investigation was complete and months before a jury selection.

Too many people, long before the trial began, tried to portray Martin as a 'thug' or 'gangstah' in photos on the internet, so I can understand Obama's comment. And I do not see his comment as interjecting himself into the judicial process.
 
Too many people, long before the trial began, tried to portray Martin as a 'thug' or 'gangstah' in photos on the internet, so I can understand Obama's comment. And I do not see his comment as interjecting himself into the judicial process.
True, but the President of the United States isn't just "people".

You're fine with a President involving himself personally in local judicial cases, but I am not regardless of race or circumstance.

It wasn't the last time he did it either.
 
Back
Top