New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

"Thug"

Since so many [Unwelcome language removed] Liberals keep whining about Boooosh "stealing" the election 16 years ago and other actions 16-7 years ago, I see no problem using anything within that time frame.

Hey man.. keep on trucking..

You made my morning...what with a flashback to the gasbag of yore...
 
That's your rejoinder? Pathetic.

Hey...go ahead and find all the times I bitched about Bush.
Dude, insult, bitch, whine, etc all you like. The facts are

1)
The hypocrisy of Wingers who claim "thug" is a racist term then use it themselves.
2) You admitting you bitch about Bush.
3) You, once again, making this about me instead of the topic.
 
Dude, insult, bitch, whine, etc all you like. The facts are 1) the hypocrisy of Wingers who claim "thug" is a racist term then use it themselves, 2) you admitting you bitch about Bush and 3) you, once again, making this about me instead of the topic.

You dug up a two year old post solely to insult Julie...

You then say I bitch about Bush...yet fail to show anyone all these times I supposedly did so.
 
Racist, or not?

For years mobsters and bullies have been called "thugs".

We've covered this song and dance before. The term "Thug" was adopted by the rap culture, Tupac being the first and main culprit. "Thug" became a compliment to those in the rap and hip hop community. If you were successful in something or stood up and defeated someone, you were "straight thug" or "went straight thug on them". It's been in the lingo for quite awhile.

Thus, when people dressed in the manner, they were dressed as "thugs", admittedly by those within.

Then, the PC culture began their "code word" crusade, and cherry-picked the word out of context.

That's all that has happened.
 
Racist, or not?

For years mobsters and bullies have been called "thugs".
Depends on the context.

I remember a number of years ago, Howard Cosell was announcing a game and, watching an African American player scamper around, he said "look at that monkey go," or something like that. People immediately reacted as if it were a racist comment, given the long history of monkey comparisons by white racists directed at black people. But then people pulled up examples of Cosell, on tape, using the same phrase about white players in similar plays. That pretty much let him off the hook. You could still say that he ought to be more sensitive to the racial baggage of the term and to avoid it in such contexts so as not to give inadvertent offense (and I'm sure he avoided it after that), but clearly his use of the term hadn't been consciously racist, or even subconsciously driven by racial stereotypes. It was just an innocent, unfortunate choice of words.

I think that using "thug" to describe black people has similar racial baggage, and so to avoid inadvertently giving offense, a person would be wise to be sensitive enough to try to avoid its use in such contexts. But, that doesn't mean that everyone who uses "thug" to describe a black person is driven by conscious or subconscious racism. In a lot of cases, the person can probably point to the use of the term in similar settings directed against white people, to make a pretty convincing case that for him or her the term doesn't have any racial implication.

We can actually do something here pretty easily. Type in the person's name and the word "thug" in a search, and find out who the person has called "thug" -- especially in older posts, before there was as much sensitivity to the racial freight of the term. A racist will have a tendency to have used the term predominantly or exclusively to label racial minorities. In my case, I've used it to describe, among others, Rush Limbaugh (for his attacks on Sandra Fluke), Mitt Romney (for his history of bullying in High School), and Adolf Hitler. Obviously, for me, the term doesn't come with a particular anti-black flavor. For some others, though, it may be coded.

For an example of the importance of context, a former poster here, NCMusicman, referred to Obama as a "low class street thug" (which he contrasted with Romney). It's hard not to pick up the racist vibe there. Whatever issues a person has with Obama, he's an upper-class, Ivy-Educated lawyer with no record of violent criminality. There's nothing particularly "low class" "street" or "thuggish" about him, other than his skin color looking like NCMusicman's mental image of such behavior. In context, yes, that was racist. If, on the other hand, he'd called Obama a thug based on some particular violent policy (say, drone strikes), and had used the same term to describe the same behavior by Bush, then the context would say it wasn't racist.
 
We've covered this song and dance before. The term "Thug" was adopted by the rap culture, Tupac being the first and main culprit. "Thug" became a compliment to those in the rap and hip hop community. If you were successful in something or stood up and defeated someone, you were "straight thug" or "went straight thug on them". It's been in the lingo for quite awhile.

Thus, when people dressed in the manner, they were dressed as "thugs", admittedly by those within.

Then, the PC culture began their "code word" crusade, and cherry-picked the word out of context.

That's all that has happened.
Agreed on the predominant "gangsta" culture among inner-city black kids and even among some white kids. It's not healthy, IMHO.
 
Agreed on the predominant "gangsta" culture among inner-city black kids and even among some white kids. It's not healthy, IMHO.
I see the "gangsta" culture of the urban poor as a counterpart of the "outlaw" culture of the rural poor. They each have their musical icons whose songs feature criminal conduct, substance abuse, and anti-establishment posturing, often by performers who have had real-life run-ins with the law and real-life histories of substance abuse. Among the urban poor, it's Tupac, etc. Among the rural poor, it's been "outlaw" country fixtures like David Allan Coe, Johnny Cash, Waylon Jennings, Merle Haggard, Willie Nelson, and Hank Williams Jr. The urban poor have their mythologized drug dealers. The rural poor have mythologized moonshiners.
 
I see the "gangsta" culture of the urban poor as a counterpart of the "outlaw" culture of the rural poor. They each have their musical icons whose songs feature criminal conduct, substance abuse, and anti-establishment posturing, often by performers who have had real-life run-ins with the law and real-life histories of substance abuse. Among the urban poor, it's Tupac, etc. Among the rural poor, it's been "outlaw" country fixtures like David Allan Coe, Johnny Cash, Waylon Jennings, Merle Haggard, Willie Nelson, and Hank Williams Jr. The urban poor have their mythologized drug dealers. The rural poor have mythologized moonshiners.
"Outlaw country" peaked in the 70s; a minor aftershock after the tumultuous 60s when the entire country turned upside down. That doesn't make it right, it just means it was more mainstream and indicative of the times.

Do you agree that an "outlaw country" music lover who acts like an outlaw deserves to be treated as one?
 
I see the "gangsta" culture of the urban poor as a counterpart of the "outlaw" culture of the rural poor. They each have their musical icons whose songs feature criminal conduct, substance abuse, and anti-establishment posturing, often by performers who have had real-life run-ins with the law and real-life histories of substance abuse. Among the urban poor, it's Tupac, etc. Among the rural poor, it's been "outlaw" country fixtures like David Allan Coe, Johnny Cash, Waylon Jennings, Merle Haggard, Willie Nelson, and Hank Williams Jr. The urban poor have their mythologized drug dealers. The rural poor have mythologized moonshiners.

In "gangsta" culture.. only Tupac?

Do you think the language and aggressiveness is equal between "gangsta" and "outlaw" cultures?

I need to remember that we've already begun a conversation in which you compared a elephant to a golden retriever in trying to put Jay Z and Johnny Cash as using a catalogue of lyrics over an entire career that are just as aggressive and violent. You provided one example of Cash, I provided a ton of Jay Z quotes. I even pointed out how Cash's lyric showed remorse, while Jay Z's did not.

Can we please stop the charade, and you just admit that Jay Z has used more violent and aggressive lyrics overall than Cash?
 
It really is dependent upon the context. Since you asked the question only to provoke some sort of right v left virtual fisticuffs, I doubt you are interested in my response; however, not every question lends itself to a simplistic answer. Bumper sticker thinking is easier, but thoughtful consideration is more productive - not to mention more interesting.

you can NEVER know whats in a womans heart or mind by inserting your OWN conclusions...

you can only SPECULATE...

you hear "thug" you think "racist"...

the definition you apply is in DIRECT RESPONSE to the one using the term..[race/ gender etc.]

you ASSUME its derogatory/racist/divisive because thats how YOU think....
 
"Outlaw country" peaked in the 70s; a minor aftershock after the tumultuous 60s when the entire country turned upside down. That doesn't make it right, it just means it was more mainstream and indicative of the times.

Yes, outlaw country declined after that 1970s peak. In a similar way, gangsta rap was largely a product of a particular socioeconomic setting. As you'll remember, the disastrous Reagan/Bush era included a net increase in black poverty and a horrifying erosion of our urban cores thanks to malignant neglect. The crack epidemic had burned out our cities and our leaders' only reaction was to try to throw as many brown-skinned people behind bars as they could. By 1991, the violent crime rate was higher than at any point in American history. From the mid-1980s through the early 1990s, gangsta culture thrived in reaction to that. That was the era of Ice-T's "Original Gangster," NWA, Public Enemy, Tupac, Biggie, etc. That ran through around 1996, then started to fade by the late 1990s, as prosperity and dramatic improvement in the black community drove culture in another direction. By the late Clinton era, black music was dominated by Brandy, Usher, Janet Jackson, Will Smith, TLC, Toni Braxton, Alicia Keys, and Destiny's Child, none of whom is remotely "Gangsta." Then, as American society began to deteriorate again, in the late Bush and early Obama years, you got a resurgence of gangsta culture, with Jay-Z's Original Gangster (2007), etc.

Do you agree that an "outlaw country" music lover who acts like an outlaw deserves to be treated as one?

I believe anyone who breaks the law should be treated like a law-breaker, regardless of musical tastes.
 
Can we please stop the charade, and you just admit that Jay Z has used more violent and aggressive lyrics overall than Cash?

I've never surveyed their entire catalogs, so I don't know. I'm unaware of Jay Z ever talking about shooting someone for no better reason than just to watch him die, but for all I know somewhere in his catalog there's material that depraved, as well.
 
Back
Top