New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Trolls

Rick, many liberals nowadays are atheist and while some of them have built their own moral coding, most have no compass for things like empathy or sympathy or compassion. They legislate politically correct behaviors that really have no reason for existing other than the law they are written into.

Ridiculous statement
 
So, if a morality is "discovered" then it would then be reasonable to assume that a morality already exists before being discovered by the person discovering it. Would that in itself be a faith in God?

Hence, true morality based on discovery is everything liberals say that they are against, "Darwinism".

In nature, the strong regularly protect the weak. In fact, it's an almost universal feature among more sophisticated animals. Granted, simpler animals don't always show that trait, but birds and mammals do. If the strong (like parents) didn't protect and support the weak (like children), the higher animals would all go extinct.

So any morality outside of that framework is created, either by a higher power, or in the case of liberals, the state. A morality which is perceived as coming from a higher power requires faith in order to follow its tenets. A morality which comes from the state requires regulation and force to enact its tenets. It is clear to see which morality the liberals embrace.

I am an atheist, and I regularly do selfless things that are not required by the state. So, clearly, morality need not come either from the state or the imagination of a higher power.
 
In nature, the strong regularly protect the weak. In fact, it's an almost universal feature among more sophisticated animals. Granted, simpler animals don't always show that trait, but birds and mammals do. If the strong (like parents) didn't protect and support the weak (like children), the higher animals would all go extinct.



I am an atheist, and I regularly do selfless things that are not required by the state. So, clearly, morality need not come either from the state or the imagination of a higher power.

Did you really just say that "in nature, the strong protect the weak"? That is about as preposterous a statement as I have ever heard. The weak, more often than not, are the favored prey of predators, and in migratory species, the weak are left behind.

Aside from certian social groups associate with higher level mammals, the weak are regularly abandoned. Parents and children, on the other hand, are associated instinctually, not morally.

You say you're an athiest, and yet you still measure your morality by religious dogma. That giving to total strangers is selfless. That isn't YOUR morality, that is the morality of many different beliefs, and that you adopted. To some, your act is just as much selfish as you think it is selfless.
 
Aside from certian social groups associate with higher level mammals, the weak are regularly abandoned. Parents and children, on the other hand, are associated instinctually, not morally.

Perhaps we're having a semantic issue, here. How do you define morality?

You say you're an athiest, and yet you still measure your morality by religious dogma.

No, I don't. I believe some things are moral that happen to be contained in religious dogma. And I believe other things in religious dogma are immoral. For example, I favor the idea that, other than in some exceedingly uncommon cases, it's immoral to bear false witness.... and that's consistent with an article of dogma from the Old Testament. But I think it's immoral to stone a child to death for being rebellious towards his parents, even though the same source of religious dogma insists that God Wants you to do that.

Every religion I know of has adopted some aspects of morality. Unfortunately, they've also adopted some terribly immoral beliefs. All moral people need to decide which I things to follow and which not to follow, and that decision ALWAYS comes from outside the faith.
 
Did you really just say that "in nature, the strong protect the weak"? That is about as preposterous a statement as I have ever heard. The weak, more often than not, are the favored prey of predators, and in migratory species, the weak are left behind.

Aside from certian social groups associate with higher level mammals, the weak are regularly abandoned. Parents and children, on the other hand, are associated instinctually, not morally.

You say you're an athiest, and yet you still measure your morality by religious dogma. That giving to total strangers is selfless. That isn't YOUR morality, that is the morality of many different beliefs, and that you adopted. To some, your act is just as much selfish as you think it is selfless.
Morality is nothing more than codified behaviors that allow us to expect and predict behaviors that enable a group to live together. For example, religions codify a "don't murder" moral code that exempts the killing of 'the other.' This is just so that we can protect our own and defend our own against outsiders. Similarly, religions codify "don't fornicate (have sex outside of sanctioned bounds)," which is just so we can have some reason to identify who parented whom. Same with don't steal, etc. We all want to live in an environment in which we can have some assurance of our safety and that of our kin, and we want to feel confident that what we gain (gather, hunt, etc.) is protected from others. Absent some religion, these are ideals we would all like everyone to live by. We all know that there are those who will break these 'rules.'

We can encompass these rules within a religion, or we can call them social order, or we can simply punish or ostracize those who break the rules. But the rules of a group of people living together, a society or a civilization, will exist independent of religion. And they are currently called morality. But they don't need a God to describe or enforce them; they will be enforced regardless because we all want to protect ourselves and our families and our possessions, and this did not begin with the invention of religion (and as you note, all religions have them in common - another clue they predate religion).
 
Morality is nothing more than codified behaviors that allow us to expect and predict behaviors that enable a group to live together. For example, religions codify a "don't murder" moral code that exempts the killing of 'the other.' This is just so that we can protect our own and defend our own against outsiders. Similarly, religions codify "don't fornicate (have sex outside of sanctioned bounds)," which is just so we can have some reason to identify who parented whom. Same with don't steal, etc. We all want to live in an environment in which we can have some assurance of our safety and that of our kin, and we want to feel confident that what we gain (gather, hunt, etc.) is protected from others. Absent some religion, these are ideals we would all like everyone to live by. We all know that there are those who will break these 'rules.'

We can encompass these rules within a religion, or we can call them social order, or we can simply punish or ostracize those who break the rules. But the rules of a group of people living together, a society or a civilization, will exist independent of religion. And they are currently called morality. But they don't need a God to describe or enforce them; they will be enforced regardless because we all want to protect ourselves and our families and our possessions, and this did not begin with the invention of religion (and as you note, all religions have them in common - another clue they predate religion).

First of all, there is little, if anything that predates religion. I think you probably meant modern organized religion. Secondly, you're absolutely right, morality is a means by which civilization creates and enforces social bonds. That was my point to Arkady. Many believe that morality comes from a higher being. Many of those moral codes may seem archaic, but they had a purpose. On the other hand, moral codes can be mandated by the state. Unfortunate attempts at such social engineering has caused the deaths of millions.

What Arkady was talking about in people "discovering" their morality, I suspect, is that people chose to be moral not because a God demands it or the state mandates it, but that people chose it as a means of getting along. However, what if the morality you discover doesn't conform to the traditional religious or state dogma? One example thatI brought up before was selflessness. Is it selfless or selfish to give a begger a 20 dollar bill? A case could be made for either.
 
First of all, there is little, if anything that predates religion. I think you probably meant modern organized religion. Secondly, you're absolutely right, morality is a means by which civilization creates and enforces social bonds. That was my point to Arkady. Many believe that morality comes from a higher being. Many of those moral codes may seem archaic, but they had a purpose. On the other hand, moral codes can be mandated by the state. Unfortunate attempts at such social engineering has caused the deaths of millions.

What Arkady was talking about in people "discovering" their morality, I suspect, is that people chose to be moral not because a God demands it or the state mandates it, but that people chose it as a means of getting along. However, what if the morality you discover doesn't conform to the traditional religious or state dogma? One example thatI brought up before was selflessness. Is it selfless or selfish to give a begger a 20 dollar bill? A case could be made for either.
Well, I think people do 'discover' morality - each of us as children 'discovers' morality as we mature into empathy - the recognition that others feel like we do under similar circumstances. When we live in societies, we further 'discover' morality when we're chastised into certain behaviors (your 'state'). Some of us become 'immoral' WRT the 'state,' or 'religion.' But that morality is by definition that of the 'state' or the 'religion.' But the fact that religions or the state define a specific morality doesn't change the fact that 'morality' is intrinsic to empathy.

I completely disagree with you that little predates religion unless you want to simply equate 'acting for the good of my group' (where 'group' can be as small as a single family) with religion, in which case you could just as easily make the argument that all animals that live in groups have 'religion,' and maybe that's the argument you're making. When birds fly together in a 'v' formation for the better survival of the majority of the group, is that religion? When a few prairie dogs chatter to warn of the peril of a circling hawk (at the much greater risk of themselves being swept up, but to the ultimate benefit of the rest of the town), is that religion? If your answer is yes, I'll concede that religion predates almost everything if you concede your definition of religion is social order to maximize the group's chances. In that case I'm going to argue that ants and bees have the most effective religion of all (and they're all female except during certain times so maybe that's something to mimic).

Giving a beggar a $20 bill is not a moral act. It's simply an act. If the beggar uses the $20 to buy food for his children, that's a good outcome. If the beggar uses the $20 to shoot up the fatal shot of heroin, that's not a good outcome. But the giving of the $20 is amoral, as it could be good or not. The choice the beggar makes is where morality comes into play. The giver of the $20 is just the agent for the eventual moral choice (sort of like a religious person would say that God, the giver of life, doesn't make the moral choice by giving the life - as it could be the life of a good person or an evil person; God in this case is the amoral agent of the giving of life; what the recipient of that life does with it is the moral choice).
 
Well, I think people do 'discover' morality - each of us as children 'discovers' morality as we mature into empathy - the recognition that others feel like we do under similar circumstances. When we live in societies, we further 'discover' morality when we're chastised into certain behaviors (your 'state'). Some of us become 'immoral' WRT the 'state,' or 'religion.' But that morality is by definition that of the 'state' or the 'religion.' But the fact that religions or the state define a specific morality doesn't change the fact that 'morality' is intrinsic to empathy.

I completely disagree with you that little predates religion unless you want to simply equate 'acting for the good of my group' (where 'group' can be as small as a single family) with religion, in which case you could just as easily make the argument that all animals that live in groups have 'religion,' and maybe that's the argument you're making. When birds fly together in a 'v' formation for the better survival of the majority of the group, is that religion? When a few prairie dogs chatter to warn of the peril of a circling hawk (at the much greater risk of themselves being swept up, but to the ultimate benefit of the rest of the town), is that religion? If your answer is yes, I'll concede that religion predates almost everything if you concede your definition of religion is social order to maximize the group's chances. In that case I'm going to argue that ants and bees have the most effective religion of all (and they're all female except during certain times so maybe that's something to mimic).

Giving a beggar a $20 bill is not a moral act. It's simply an act. If the beggar uses the $20 to buy food for his children, that's a good outcome. If the beggar uses the $20 to shoot up the fatal shot of heroin, that's not a good outcome. But the giving of the $20 is amoral, as it could be good or not. The choice the beggar makes is where morality comes into play. The giver of the $20 is just the agent for the eventual moral choice (sort of like a religious person would say that God, the giver of life, doesn't make the moral choice by giving the life - as it could be the life of a good person or an evil person; God in this case is the amoral agent of the giving of life; what the recipient of that life does with it is the moral choice).

I assumed when you were talking about predating religion, you referring to society, not individual development.

The question was whether giving a begger 20 dollars was selfless. It's assumed that it stems from a person's morality, but is it selfless, or selfish?
 
I assumed when you were talking about predating religion, you referring to society, not individual development.

The question was whether giving a begger 20 dollars was selfless. It's assumed that it stems from a person's morality, but is it selfless, or selfish?
I was referring to society. Which is made up of individuals.

I guess I don't understand your selfless v selfish thingy with the $20. Those aren't the only two options by a long stretch and it's a spectacularly unimportant question.
 
I was referring to society. Which is made up of individuals.

I guess I don't understand your selfless v selfish thingy with the $20. Those aren't the only two options by a long stretch and it's a spectacularly unimportant question.

Then I won't push the issue.

As for society and religion, I have little doubt that people always wondered about the world and their place in it.
 
I see that all of the morally centered "Christian conservatives" continue to cower from my simple challenge to reconcile their stated views with Jesus' words.

Going on two days now. It appears that they think the challenge was to change the subject and run off into the woods ranting about their superior morality and frantically waving their arms.

So there's not one Christiancon here who isn't ashamed of himself? Not a single one who can explain why he prefers Limbaugh over Jesus?

Mission accomplished....again.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Which is the very definition. Their "values" superseded the very lives of others. Let's suppose you were holding a baby in your arms and someone told you they were going to let that baby die because saving that baby was beyond the scope of their "values" about the extent of govt. involvement in health care. Would you consider that a lack of empathy ? Because it seems as if you are trying to portray it as a excess of principle. But I am willing to bet that principle comes with the caveat. It exists as long as it is not their baby dying in your arms.
Demonstrably incorrect. You conflate "state" and "individual" agencies. I do not. You refuse to even consider or allow that those who seek address of needs outside of collectivized state address of needs care, are compassionate, or have empathy. In other words, you are directly equating "state" and "empathy". In your errant analogy above, I'll take that baby myself and save it, fund it's care, and/or align in voluntary associations to help her. You, however, afford me this choice: "agree with my preferred policy prescription, or you don't care".

That is illiberal absolutism. It does not logically follow. And it represents an intolerant, anti-pluralist, bad faith shirking of good stewardship as fellow citizen. How is it that "liberals" become so very closed-minded?
 
How about substituting "liberalism" for "religious conservatives" here and you will see what I see....just about everything you wrote above applies.
"Just about everything I wrote" applies to the other guys...and none to us...

Yes, Renee, that was rather my point. Thanks.
 
Did you really just say that "in nature, the strong protect the weak"? That is about as preposterous a statement as I have ever heard. The weak, more often than not, are the favored prey of predators, and in migratory species, the weak are left behind.

Aside from certian social groups associate with higher level mammals, the weak are regularly abandoned. Parents and children, on the other hand, are associated instinctually, not morally.

You say you're an athiest, and yet you still measure your morality by religious dogma. That giving to total strangers is selfless. That isn't YOUR morality, that is the morality of many different beliefs, and that you adopted. To some, your act is just as much selfish as you think it is selfless.

Giving is not religious morality anymore than not stealing is. Religion has adopted the best of human nature (and the worst) and made it .theirs"
 
Perhaps we're having a semantic issue, here. How do you define morality?



No, I don't. I believe some things are moral that happen to be contained in religious dogma. And I believe other things in religious dogma are immoral. For example, I favor the idea that, other than in some exceedingly uncommon cases, it's immoral to bear false witness.... and that's consistent with an article of dogma from the Old Testament. But I think it's immoral to stone a child to death for being rebellious towards his parents, even though the same source of religious dogma insists that God Wants you to do that.

Every religion I know of has adopted some aspects of morality. Unfortunately, they've also adopted some terribly immoral beliefs. All moral people need to decide which I things to follow and which not to follow, and that decision ALWAYS comes from outside the faith.

In nearly every case, religion is the foundation of modern morality. Just because you pick and chose which moral tenets you follow, doesn't mean that the moral tenets don't come from a religious background. You're not choosing from "different" moralities, you're picking and choosing from a common morality, based on religious belief.

Would you say that it's immoral to steal or to kill? Because some religions teach that it is, yet you consider these things immoral. In truth, they're amoral. Everything, at some time, had it's purpose. People decided which was moral and which was immoral, based, in most cases, on religious dogma. Even stoning children, not that I believe there was such a social convention, would have had some moral basis at some period in time for some reason.

So you look at this buffet of morality, pick and choose which you want to keep, and which you want to throw out, but it's all the same morality, based on the same values.
 
Ever since print media "letters to the editor" were invented, it's been conventional and very rarely challenged wisdom, that in order for one's piece to appear in the paper, the writer MUST identify him or herself and be willing to have the editor call to check their veracity.

But then......this former "given" seems to've been completely ignored or swept under the rug in the context of the "intertubes".

Maybe the former understanding was good or maybe it was bad? But, considering how long it pertained, ya'd think it should've been confronted prior to the advent of all these intertube forums.
 
Not stealing is human nature? Really? Where, in God's name, do you get this stuff?

This makes no sense. Stealing IS a matter of human nature. NOT stealing, is a function of human reason. And, otherwise "good" people can take longer than others, to arrive at this reasonable conclusion.
 
Demonstrably incorrect. You conflate "state" and "individual" agencies. I do not. You refuse to even consider or allow that those who seek address of needs outside of collectivized state address of needs care, are compassionate, or have empathy. In other words, you are directly equating "state" and "empathy". In your errant analogy above, I'll take that baby myself and save it, fund it's care, and/or align in voluntary associations to help her. You, however, afford me this choice: "agree with my preferred policy prescription, or you don't care".

That is illiberal absolutism. It does not logically follow. And it represents an intolerant, anti-pluralist, bad faith shirking of good stewardship as fellow citizen. How is it that "liberals" become so very closed-minded?

What kind of egotistical nonsense is this ? Hey guess what. You exist Those voluntary associations exist. Guess who doesn't exist (anymore). The 45 thousand people who died every year in spite of the existence of your preferred policy prescription. And as far as I can tell. It is the choice you asked to be afforded that let it ( actually helped it) happen. And the fact still remains that apathy in pursuit of your own desire to see the state in a decreased role in spite those deaths is not only the very antithesis of empathy.

Actually this response pushes towards another part of the discussion. The narcissism on the right and in today's right. Because even though those people were still dying the policy prescription was great because it was your policy prescription.
 
Did you really just say that "in nature, the strong protect the weak"? That is about as preposterous a statement as I have ever heard. The weak, more often than not, are the favored prey of predators, and in migratory species, the weak are left behind.

Aside from certian social groups associate with higher level mammals, the weak are regularly abandoned. Parents and children, on the other hand, are associated instinctually, not morally.

You say you're an athiest, and yet you still measure your morality by religious dogma. That giving to total strangers is selfless. That isn't YOUR morality, that is the morality of many different beliefs, and that you adopted. To some, your act is just as much selfish as you think it is selfless.

Mr. Colorforms,

Perhaps he, as learned as he is, has never read Darwin's "On the Origin of the Species."
 
Back
Top