Then you misread my response. I did not intend for you to take the two actions as mutually exclusive. I thought I made clear that both were necessary, but that I see democrats as taking the former too far and the republicans not taking the later far enough.
I agree with you whole-heartedly that republicans have been far too focused on shrinking government and not focused enough on the things that would allow for shrinking the government to be viable. The only way for fovernment to be shrunken, at this point, is to make it so that the private sector can sustain people as much on it's own as possible. This comes through education, entrepreneurship, and the ability for business to grow, prosper, and bring in more people to produce goods and services. Republicans have been going about it the wrong way, but I believe so have democrats.
Democrats have been focusing so hard on providing the bandaids that they see every situation as terminal, and that they must intercede in every situation. In the meantime, they keep putting pressure on the companies they need to hire people and get the economy moving, to buy bandaids, while restricting their ability to prosper.