New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Typical Democrat.

Warren: I used minority listing to share heritage

Democratic Senate candidate Elizabeth Warren, fending off questions about whether she used her Native American heritage to advance her career, said today she enrolled herself as a minority in law school directories for nearly a decade because she hoped to meet other people with tribal roots.

Warren is looking to shake off the story of her Native American background, which has hounded her since the Herald first reported that Harvard Law School has touted Warren as a minority hire. She also listed herself as a minority in a law school directory for nine years between 1986 and 1995.

“Being Native American has been part of my story I guess since the day I was born,” said Warren, who never mentioned her Native American heritage on the campaign trail even as she detailed much of her personal history to voters in speeches, statements and a video. “These are my family stories, I have lived in a family that has talked about Native American and talked about tribes since I was a little girl.”

Warren’s statements come as genealogists at the New England Historic Genealogical Society were unable to back up earlier accounts that her great great great grandmother is Cherokee. While Warren’s great great great grandmother, named O.C. Sarah Smith, is listed on a electronic transcript of a 1894 marriage application as Cherokee, the genealogists are unable to find the actual record or a photograhic copy of it, Society spokesman Tom Champoux said. A copy of the marriage license itself has been located, but unlike the application, it does not list Smith’s ethnicity.

http://bostonherald.com/news/politics/view/20220502warren_i_used_minority_listing_to_make_friends
 
Brown puts the Right in a tight spot. They know he's a sell-out most of the time...but keeping him is their ONLY shot at a GOP majority in the Senate.

So?...they try ANYTHING to take out Warren, since they can't support Brown and stay true to their "principles".

In other words?....a foreshadowing of their plans for Obama vs. Romney. :D
 
Brown and Romney are cut out of the same political bolt of cloth...they are both members of the RINO elite. While many on the right celebrated Brown's election into the Senate...true conservatives understood that he was just another NE liberal with (R) behind his name.
 
"your simple little mind just can't comprehend the complexity of the issue"
 
Seriously IRP...do you feel it's appropriate for someone...anyone...to claim a minority status when they are 1/32 minority blood and 31/32 Caucasian? That's the point...it's no different than Romney trying to claim his dad grew up poor...and several lefties were all over that one.
 
You mean that 1/32 equals the higher side of the whole? Is that where people "just can't comprehend the complexity of the issue"?
 
Here's one squeezing out his "patriotism!"

OOPS! There went he brains! (Time to give him a job in the State Department, I think!)






262179696_12179_occupy_wall_street_ows_dumping_flag_xlarge.jpg
 
Number_58,

Actually, my comment was really more a (possible) response to TomFitz's implicit question which was "what was the point in Sarge posting his message"? It seems pretty clear to me that Sarge feels that "Democrats are lying tools of Satan."

As to the incident, it doesn't sound like it was Elizabeth Warren's finest moment (though I do not know the full details). Nevertheless, I think equating this one incident done when she was a college student to Mitt Romney's serial prevarication and exaggeration while campaigning for political office is a stretch. I am not sure what Elizabeth Warren was trying to accomplish when she made that claim on a form but I am pretty sure that she was not out seeking votes from liberals or Native Americans.

BTW, if Elizabeth Warren had been 1/2 Native American and 1/2 Caucasian, would she qualify as a minority. (My kids are half Caucasian and half-Asian. What are they? The questions on forms are changing.)

Seriously IRP...do you feel it's appropriate for someone...anyone...to claim a minority status when they are 1/32 minority blood and 31/32 Caucasian? That's the point...it's no different than Romney trying to claim his dad grew up poor...and several lefties were all over that one.
 
In my opinion, when the division between heritage is 50/50, it's up to the person filling out the papers. I would have no problem whatsoever, using your children as an example, if they were to claim Asian status. However, 1/2 is much different than say 1/8 and drastically different than 1/32.

I don't think Sarge is accusing Democrats of being lying tools of Satan...but I do see that had the roles been reversed and a Republican had gained favor by claiming minority status, especially so had they claimed African American status, there would have been an uproar on the left that would have carried on for months, if not years. I think that is the double standard that causes Sarge to bring up this subject.
 
Number_58,

A couple of points. First, I think that the "double standards" cut both ways. I think that there are some LOC folks who just focus their attacks on conservative politicians and I think that there are some ROC folks who just focus their attacks on liberal politicians. I think that the numbers on both sides is about equal. There is another group of people - who include you (in my opinion) and (in my opinion) me - who, at least attempt to be somewhat evenhanded. (Nonetheless, I am sure that there are numerous ROC folks who think that I have double-standards and I am sure that there are many LOC folks who think that you have double standards.)

In any case, I am not familiar enough with the details of the Warren case to speak fully to it. But from the article that Sarge posted, it sounds like she just put that designation in a law school directory and got no particular advantage from it. Tt was not clear to me what was at stake. It sounded like she was just hoping to meet people. That said, I tend to agree that she didn't quite fit the "native American" category as I understand it. (I would say that a native American has to have some close association with a "tribe." They don't necessarily have to live on a reservation but ... Elizabeth Warren - like a number of folks that I know - has some "Indian blood." If she used the Native American designation to gain a significant advantage (and it doesn't sound like she did from the article), I might have a problem with it. From the story I am not sure she did.)

I also looking at the context surrounding an incident. What annoys me about Romney is the fact that he is a serial prevaricator. He seems to exaggerate and distort a lot. Now, again that might be my perspective. But he seems to me to do it more than GWB or Rick Santorum or a number of other Republican politicians that I don't care for.

In any case, I am not a Massachusetts voter. But if I was, this story would not have a big effect on whether I would vote for Scott Brown or Elizabeth Warren.


In my opinion, when the division between heritage is 50/50, it's up to the person filling out the papers. I would have no problem whatsoever, using your children as an example, if they were to claim Asian status. However, 1/2 is much different than say 1/8 and drastically different than 1/32.

I don't think Sarge is accusing Democrats of being lying tools of Satan...but I do see that had the roles been reversed and a Republican had gained favor by claiming minority status, especially so had they claimed African American status, there would have been an uproar on the left that would have carried on for months, if not years. I think that is the double standard that causes Sarge to bring up this subject.
 
Seriously IRP...do you feel it's appropriate for someone...anyone...to claim a minority status when they are 1/32 minority blood and 31/32 Caucasian? That's the point...it's no different than Romney trying to claim his dad grew up poor...and several lefties were all over that one.

Really 58? I remember a time when it was said that if you had one drop of negro blood in your veins then you were considered all negro. But I do understand your point. My own great grandmother was full blooded Choctaw, but I have never claimed to be a member of the tribe, as I take after my great grandfather, a blue-eyed German.
 
I can guarantee you there are LofC posters who "think that I have double-standards"...and much like I think you feel, I couldn't care less. One of the worst things regarding a political chat board is that the majority of the posters ALWAYS paint with a broad brush...and if someone spouts a couple opinions regarding an issue the other side disagrees with, the spouter is lumped into the _____-wing.

But, I digress...like I brought up on another thread...for me, claiming a minority status, for any reason, when you don't fit the (50% or higher) requirement is despicable...it is a slap in the face to those that meet the actual definition. I used the analogy of GWB claiming he's a Viet Nam Veteran when he never left the US...it's plain unacceptable.
 
Back
Top