New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Under God

Yet, if the majority is against your obsession, the GOP, then it is suddenly TRULY about "Majority Rule", isn't it?

and you won't assume they'll "be fine". Based on your history, you'll tell them to "shut the F*^k up" and take it.

I usually don't infer like this, but it's easy here.

Friscus, Jen wants to run roughshod over people with the minority religious view.

I know you're a Religious Righty and would have no problem with that. But a few of us still want a secular government and the 1st Amendment.
 
Atheists in the military want atheist chaplains. Atheism is also based on faith. You can't disprove God and yes a negative is proven in mathematics and logic all the time.

If these atheist "chaplains" start performing supernatural rituals and dispensing revealed wisdom of higher powers , I'll regard that as a religion. If it's just a label used for people who perform the non-religious functions that are part of the job description of religious chaplains, then I'm not going to get hung up on that label.

I can't disprove God any more than you can disprove the idea that there is an invisible, intangible turnip between your ears that is causing you to reason so poorly. If we posit the existence of something that, by our very description of it, cannot be detected in any verifiable way, then of course, by definition, it will be impossible to disprove its existence. But that doesn't change the fact that it would be silly to believe in such a being.
 
They spend $20K + per student per year in DC? How much neglect is that? Atlanta has a great tax base on business properties. The busiest (?) airport in America. Arky, you make a lot of stuff up. It's always whitey's fault is patently absurd.

Atlanta has an insufficient tax base to counteract the inevitable problems associated with urbanization. In order to deal with those properly, it would need to pull more money in from the wealthy suburbs. In areas where the wealthy suburbs take more responsibility for making the cities better, you get great cities. In areas where they don't, you get lousy cities.
 
If these atheist "chaplains" start performing supernatural rituals and dispensing revealed wisdom of higher powers , I'll regard that as a religion. If it's just a label used for people who perform the non-religious functions that are part of the job description of religious chaplains, then I'm not going to get hung up on that label.

I can't disprove God any more than you can disprove the idea that there is an invisible, intangible turnip between your ears that is causing you to reason so poorly. If we posit the existence of something that, by our very description of it, cannot be detected in any verifiable way, then of course, by definition, it will be impossible to disprove its existence. But that doesn't change the fact that it would be silly to believe in such a being.
It's always good to know that there is someone out there who claims they know exactly how the universe works, and is so comfortable in their knowledge that they're willing to call other people "silly" for believing something else. I thought atheists were rebelling against that sort of orthodoxy. Now they're as bad as the little old ladies trying to save the souls of people going into new age bookstores.
 
Where is "God" mentioned in the Constitution?
It's odd that the Founders went so far out of their way to avoid invoking God if their intent was to set up a religious government. Even the oath of the president, which has come, as a de facto matter, to include "so help me God," includes no reference to God in the version provided in the Constitution.
 
If these atheist "chaplains" start performing supernatural rituals and dispensing revealed wisdom of higher powers , I'll regard that as a religion. If it's just a label used for people who perform the non-religious functions that are part of the job description of religious chaplains, then I'm not going to get hung up on that label.

I can't disprove God any more than you can disprove the idea that there is an invisible, intangible turnip between your ears that is causing you to reason so poorly. If we posit the existence of something that, by our very description of it, cannot be detected in any verifiable way, then of course, by definition, it will be impossible to disprove its existence. But that doesn't change the fact that it would be silly to believe in such a being.


But they are performing supernatural rituals when they absurdly claim that something came from nothing because some chief priest theoretical physicist believes it to be true based solely on a Gedanken experiment that won't likely get tested until long after God is proven or dis-proven.

Take your spaghetti monster argumentation and eat it.
 
It's always good to know that there is someone out there who claims they know exactly how the universe works, and is so comfortable in their knowledge that they're willing to call other people "silly" for believing something else. I thought atheists were rebelling against that sort of orthodoxy. Now they're as bad as the little old ladies trying to save the souls of people going into new age bookstores.
I don't know how the universe works. What I know is that it's silly to assume you do know in the absence of any evidence. I'm open minded about the existence of God. Show me some verifiable evidence and I'll believe. But it would be foolish for me to believe without evidence, just as it would be foolish to believe an infinite number of other possibilities without evidence.

Believers get that in 99.9999999999999999999% of cases. A Christian, for example, doesn't believe the Cosmos was created by the Greek Gods, or the Egyptian ones, or the Roman ones, or the Norse or Chinese, or Japanese ones. He doesn't believe the world rests on the back of a giant turtle, or that we're all a figment in the mind of some autistic child, or that he'll break his mother's back if he steps on a crack in the sidewalk, or that mushroom circles are places where fairies come out at night and dance. The Christian mind functions sanely in the vast majority of cases where it considers the possibility of some supernatural idea. But, when it comes to one particular set of silly ideas (to which he was ordinarily exposed at a very impressionable age by people he trusted), a Christian behaves insanely -- believing strongly without any evidence. And the same is true for most other people in the world (the only difference being which set of irrational beliefs are embraced).

That's what makes the Christian objection to atheists so funny. They act as if we're presumptuous to do something in 100% of cases that they do in 99.9999999999999999999%. Christians and atheists agree, for example, that there's no reason to think that God will punish you for eternity if you don't have your daughter's genitals surgically altered, and no reason to think that cows contain the spirits of our ancestors and so eating them is morally wrong. Christians think just like atheists in the majority of cases. It's just that they're taken aback when atheists are consistent in that thinking, rather than making exception for the one set of superstitions Christians believe in.
 
But they are performing supernatural rituals when they absurdly claim that something came from nothing because some chief priest theoretical physicist believes it to be true based solely on a Gedanken experiment that won't likely get tested until long after God is proven or dis-proven.

Take your spaghetti monster argumentation and eat it.
I couldn't make heads or tails of your argument here.
 
It's odd that the Founders went so far out of their way to avoid invoking God if their intent was to set up a religious government. Even the oath of the president, which has come, as a de facto matter, to include "so help me God," includes no reference to God in the version provided in the Constitution.

If stipulating what you say is true, they were being sensitive to other Christian faiths and not to atheists. I don't think you were central to their thoughts when they put it all together to make a Republic. Yeah, they made allowances for the conscientious objector or two. They had no idea what deamon they'd set loose though. I bet they regret it.
 
I don't know how the universe works. What I know is that it's silly to assume you do know in the absence of any evidence. I'm open minded about the existence of God. Show me some verifiable evidence and I'll believe. But it would be foolish for me to believe without evidence, just as it would be foolish to believe an infinite number of other possibilities without evidence.

Believers get that in 99.9999999999999999999% of cases. A Christian, for example, doesn't believe the Cosmos was created by the Greek Gods, or the Egyptian ones, or the Roman ones, or the Norse or Chinese, or Japanese ones. He doesn't believe the world rests on the back of a giant turtle, or that we're all a figment in the mind of some autistic child, or that he'll break his mother's back if he steps on a crack in the sidewalk, or that mushroom circles are places where fairies come out at night and dance. The Christian mind functions sanely in the vast majority of cases where it considers the possibility of some supernatural idea. But, when it comes to one particular set of silly ideas (to which he was ordinarily exposed at a very impressionable age by people he trusted), a Christian behaves insanely -- believing strongly without any evidence. And the same is true for most other people in the world (the only difference being which set of irrational beliefs he embraces).

That's what makes the Christian objection to atheists so funny. They act as if we're presumptuous to do something in 100% of cases that they do in 99.9999999999999999999%. Christians and atheists agree, for example, that there's no reason to think that God will punish you for eternity if you don't have your daughter's genitals surgically altered, and no reason to think that cows contain the spirits of our ancestors and so eating them is morally wrong. Christians think just like atheists in the majority of cases. It's just that they're taken aback when atheists are consistent in that thinking, rather than making exception to the one set of superstitions Christians believe in.
You are caught up in terminology. Supernatural is just a label for that which doesn't conform to scientific inquiry. Science is a valuable tool, but extremely limited. For example, there are all kinds of explanations for the big bang. Christians assign it as an act of God, while atheists take it on faith that something else is the cause. What science has shown is that nature works in patterns, and patterns are a sign that things are directed and not random.

By calling yourself an atheist, you're saying that you know enough about the universe to say that we have the gist of it. We don't. Infinity can't be explained through science, and yet we know it exists. We are barely scratching the surface of what is.
 
If stipulating what you say is true, they were being sensitive to other Christian faiths and not to atheists. I don't think you were central to their thoughts when they put it all together to make a Republic. Yeah, they made allowances for the conscientious objector or two. They had no idea what deamon they'd set loose though. I bet they regret it.
It wasn't just Christian faiths. Way back in the Treaty of Tripoli, the generation of the Founders expressly agreed that this wasn't founded as a Christian nation. And some of them were Deists and Unitarians, not Christians.

Besides, including "So help me God" in the version of the Oath in the Constitution wouldn't have upset mainstream Christians. So why did they avoid it? Why did they choose "E Pluribus Unum" instead of "In God We Trust" as the national motto and the slogan on our money? Why are the only mentions of religion in the Constitution negative ones (forbidding government to interfere with free religious practice, forbidding laws respecting establishment of religion, and forbidding religious tests for people seeking office)?

They were students of the Enlightenment. Some were religious, some not. Some were Christians, some not. But they set up a system where the government was supposed to stay out of such matters.
 
Last edited:
I knew the spaghetti monster would throw you.
No. I got the spaghetti monster reference. Obviously, it's a reference to the flying spaghetti monster, and my variation on that (the intangible turnip in your brain) -- with both pointing out the absurdity of believing in extraordinary claims that have been defined in such a way as to make positive disproof impossible. It was the rest of your post I couldn't make heads or tails of.
 
You are caught up in terminology. Supernatural is just a label for that which doesn't conform to scientific inquiry. Science is a valuable tool, but extremely limited. For example, there are all kinds of explanations for the big bang. Christians assign it as an act of God, while atheists take it on faith that something else is the cause. What science has shown is that nature works in patterns, and patterns are a sign that things are directed and not random.

By calling yourself an atheist, you're saying that you know enough about the universe to say that we have the gist of it. We don't. Infinity can't be explained through science, and yet we know it exists. We are barely scratching the surface of what is.

No. Christians take it on faith that God created the universe. Atheists, like everyone else, have no evidence for the existence of a God, but, unlike the religious, don't simply assume God exists despite that lack of evidence. As for the idea that patterns are a sign that things are directed, what makes you think that?

I'm also not saying we know enough about the universe to say we have the gist of it. What makes you believe that's what I'm saying? I'm open to any number of possibilities that would utterly transform the way we think about the universe. I'm just not going to cling to one of those infinite possibilities without any evidence, because it happens to be the one I got told in fairy stories when I was a child. That's where atheists and the religious differ.
 
You are caught up in terminology. Supernatural is just a label for that which doesn't conform to scientific inquiry. Science is a valuable tool, but extremely limited. For example, there are all kinds of explanations for the big bang. Christians assign it as an act of God, while atheists take it on faith that something else is the cause. What science has shown is that nature works in patterns, and patterns are a sign that things are directed and not random.

By calling yourself an atheist, you're saying that you know enough about the universe to say that we have the gist of it. We don't. Infinity can't be explained through science, and yet we know it exists. We are barely scratching the surface of what is.


Speaking of terminology, I've oft-whined about how non-conservatives have co-opted the word "conservative" and non-progressives have co-opted the term "progressive"

To my mind...the term "Atheist" is somewhat similar. For what exactly IS an Atheist? . My purely anecdotal "feeling" is that most people who claim Atheism are more in the vein of Agnostics in that they don't claim certitude one way or another. Then, there are those self-described Atheists who choose to believe that there is no God, until and unless they're offered concrete proof of a God. But, what's the difference between them and most believers who choose to believe that there IS a God, until and unless it's proven that there isn't one? Or...what's the difference between them and the Agnostic who choosed to straddle the fence until and unless the question is answered once and for all?

And then,,,there are the Atheists who are absolutely convinced - absent any actual evidence - that there is NO God. So...what's the difference between them and the fundamentalist who's absolutely convinced that there IS a God, absent any actual evidence?
 
No. Christians take it on faith that God created the universe. Atheists, like everyone else, have no evidence for the existence of a God, but, unlike the religious, don't simply assume God exists despite that lack of evidence. As for the idea that patterns are a sign that things are directed, what makes you think that?

I'm also not saying we know enough about the universe to say we have the gist of it. What makes you believe that's what I'm saying? I'm open to any number of possibilities that would utterly transform the way we think about the universe. I'm just not going to cling to one of those infinite possibilities without any evidence, because it happens to be the one I got told in fairy stories when I was a child. That's where atheists and the religious differ.
If you don't think that we have the gist of the universe, how can you say that what you were told as a child are "fairy stories" or that they are not grounded in some truth? That's kind of my point. You say you don't have evidence for the existence of God, while Christians say we are living in evidence of the existence of God. The big difference is that, if I am gleaning your position correctly, that you don't know what the nature of the universe is, but it's not whatever Christians think it is. Again, how do you know? Atheism is just as faith based as Christianity, but it's worse in the fact that it spends it's time trying to tell everyone else that they're idiots for believing. For all we know, believing may be how the universe works.
 
It was the rest of your post I couldn't make heads or tails of.

I guess that is my fault. After all these debates about God I go into abbreviation mode believing other people have had endless debates too. It ends up being the same back and forth. I no longer really feel interested in challenging other's belief system anymore I guess - it verges on a nihilistic feeling really. Thanks.

Oh, well, God bless you Arkady. Peace.
 
If you don't think that we have the gist of the universe, how can you say that what you were told as a child are "fairy stories" or that they are not grounded in some truth? That's kind of my point. You say you don't have evidence for the existence of God, while Christians say we are living in evidence of the existence of God. The big difference is that, if I am gleaning your position correctly, that you don't know what the nature of the universe is, but it's not whatever Christians think it is. Again, how do you know? Atheism is just as faith based as Christianity, but it's worse in the fact that it spends it's time trying to tell everyone else that they're idiots for believing. For all we know, believing may be how the universe works.
No. My point isn't that I know the universe is not whatever Christians think it is. They might conceivably be right. Or maybe it's the Zoroastrians. Or the Muslims. Or the Scythians, worshipping their snake-woman goddess. Or the animists. Or the Jains. Or the Branch Davidians. Or the Scientologists. But, absent any evidence, it would be foolish for me to assume any of them are right. And that's where Christians, and all the rest, go wrong. They have no more evidence than me, but cling to one of the infinite number of possibilities. That's the difference between faith and reason. It isn't that I have faith that the Scientologists are wrong, in their stories about an alien blowing people up with nukes in a volcano, etc. I just don't have faith that they're right. Absent any such theism, I am a-theistic.

Have you ever read the book "Contact" by Carl Sagan? Or seen the movie? The premise is that we're contacted by aliens, and in the course of the book we discover that the universe we're living in was actually intelligently designed by some aliens who far predate the ones who contacted us. There is evidence within the order of the universe which essentially proves it had to be designed (e.g., when you work pi out to a certain number of figures and arrange it in a certain way, it creates a perfect circular design in a manner that would be infinitely improbable to have occurred randomly). If we found evidence of that sort, in sufficient abundance and without more probable explanations, I would be convinced that the universe was intelligently designed (just like the atheist character in the book is). But, absent any evidence, it would be a mistake to simply assume it was.
 
Back
Top