New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Under God

Why is the public school model dying?
Not including post 18 y.o. GED earners.

50% of blacks don't finish school
50% of hispanics don't finish school

In urban settings blacks and hispanics should be given vouchers to escape a broken public system.
 
Depends on your definition of a "religious righty".. I've had people call me a "Religious Lefty" in some areas.




I'm all for the 1st Amendment.. which includes allowing people to proclaim their religion in any way they want, through any channels they want.

You can't claim to be a "free-thinker" while at the same time attempting to silence people of religion.


Wow... I made the list of "ignored". I am with good company. Talk about a boy who doesn't want another view. It's kinda like Fox News, you hear only from people who share your hysteria.
 
Not including post 18 y.o. GED earners.

50% of blacks don't finish school
50% of hispanics don't finish school

In urban settings blacks and hispanics should be given vouchers to escape a broken public system.


That is black MALES...females have a higher rate of graduation and college and they go to the same schools.
 
That is black MALES...females have a higher rate of graduation and college and they go to the same schools.

Have you spoken to a 'college graduate' these days?

There was a time when a H.S. grad could turn around and teach school themselves.
 
Meanwhile, our DNA is filled with information... which by any scientific standard would be assumed to have been created by an intelligence.

There is simply no way mutation could produce such information.

Darwin's theory is looking more and more like the flat-earth theory these days.
 
I found it hard to believe that there was this much interest in a silly little throwaway "pledge". Having skimmed over the thread, however, I see that it has veered almost completely away from the original topic.
 
A coupla quick points...What difference would it make if some DID believe than an insect could fly at supersonic speeds? My question is NOT rhetorical. I think it would be an issue if we diverted resources from more worthwhile causes, based on that belief, or in the same vein, if we diverted significant intellectual capacity based on that belief. OR, it might be an issue if based on that beleif, we caused tangible harm to that which we know to be real. But otherwise.....what difference would it make?

And...everytime I hear someone link "faith" to war, I wonder if those people have ever pondered the question of how much war DIDN'T happen, due to faith.
It would, as you suggest, make a difference in proportion to the amount of social and psychological energy we put into the faith in the existence of a supersonic insect. I think the belief in the supernatural is similar. If it's mostly just a lark that has little impact on our behavior, like the semi-belief that if we wish on a candle on our birthday the wish can come true, it's not big deal. If, on the other hand, it's something that results in a hundred million people wasting a couple hours every Sunday sitting around unproductively in their church, while gobbling up plenty of economic output in the form of tithes spent supporting a worthless priestly caste and gold-plating relics, then it's a big deal. Worse would be if it sidetracks a significant portion of a nation's intellectual capacity, as during the Middle Ages, when a large portion of Europe's best and brightest frittered away their lives doodling in the margins of fairy tale books, our debating how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

As for the question of how much war didn't happen, due to faith, I'm open to argument about that, but given the way there's been a major decline in the frequency of warfare as society has become more secular, I'm inclined to believe the net impact of faith has been to encourage war. Sure, there may be an occasional peace forged by a cleric calling on scriptural ideas, but if you're going encourage people to risk their lives to kill their fellow man, the notions of an afterlife and of a divine crusade are immensely helpful.
 
That's pretty much just the outspoken, American Protestant Evangelists.

As for me, I base my faith on many things.. But your atheist message is claiming to know what is better for the majority of people than they do. Correct?

I suppose that's a fair enough description. But I don't think it's peculiar to atheists. Every religious person I've ever met has, at least implicitly, claimed to know that his religion would be a good thing for others, even if they don't realize it themselves.
 
Meanwhile, our DNA is filled with information... which by any scientific standard would be assumed to have been created by an intelligence.

There is simply no way mutation could produce such information.

Darwin's theory is looking more and more like the flat-earth theory these days.
No, you misunderstand badly. It is simply incorrect to say that any scientific standard would assume that something filled with information must have been created by an intelligence.

Let's say, for example, we're digging through the geological strata of the mesozoic era. The deposits of minerals and fossils laid down over those millions of years provide us all sorts of information about the world at that time. But that in no way implies that some intelligent being laid down those layers. It was a natural process which, by its nature, preserved information.

DNA is roughly analogous. It's a result of random mutations with non-random rates of survival, thanks to natural selection. That results in information.

Here's another analogy. Let's say you find a "fairy ring" of mushrooms -- a large, surprisingly circular arrangement of mushrooms, like this:
aupload.wikimedia.org_wikipedia_commons_thumb_9_96_Fairy_ring_76cc912f2f560fc3172612de3ebd8b20.jpg

Now, someone coming across that might assume that given the astronomically long odds of mushrooms just happening to grow in that pattern, it must have been planted by some intelligence (thus the early association with fairies). But that's not true. We can actually observe the process, and these fairy rings exist all over the world. What actually happened is that the mushrooms spread out from a central position. Every new generation of mushrooms would try to take hold at random locations around the last generation, but those trying to take hold inside the circle were on ground that had already been depleted of necessary nutrients by the grandfather generation, so they'd generally die. This results in an outward-expanding ring of mushrooms of the kind you see above. Like DNA, it's the result of a random process with non-random patterns of survival. The result embeds information into the system -- using that mushroom ring, for example, you could predict with pretty good accuracy where the first mushroom had grown (in the circle's center), since the current mushrooms will all be roughly equidistant from it. But the fact that information is in that system in no way implies that an intelligence must have been involved in the process.
 
Not including post 18 y.o. GED earners.

50% of blacks don't finish school
50% of hispanics don't finish school

In urban settings blacks and hispanics should be given vouchers to escape a broken public system.

First, I don't believe in simply inventing statistics. If you're going to make a claim like that, you should have the numbers to back it up, or people will come to regard you as someone who is driven by ideology instead of facts -- someone, in fact, who will lie to them about the numbers if it helps push his political agenda.

In reality, 66.1% of African Americans graduate high school on time, and 71.4% of Hispanics. Note, that's on time graduation --graduation within four years of entering high school-- which would exclude those who are held back or otherwise graduate late (not just those who get a GED later). So the numbers you provided are off by a great deal:

http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...1_graduation-rate-dropout-rate-asian-students

Moreover, dropout rates have been dropping very nicely for a long time. As the link above mentioned, on-time graduation is at a four-decade high, and dropout rates have fallen dramatically for all racial groups over the last twenty years:

http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=16

And things are actually quite a bit better than that if you aren't focusing on the former Confederacy, where graduation rates remain horrible:

http://www.ed.gov/blog/2013/01/high-school-graduation-rate-at-highest-level-in-three-decades/

Anyway, vouchers might be fine if we were talking about vouchers of sufficient size to make quality secular private school available to even the poorest kids. But that might require very large vouchers in areas where there aren't currently enough private schools to accommodate them -- in order to create an economic incentive for the building of new private schools.

As a practical matter, though, that's not what we're talking about. What nearly all conservatives advocate are vouchers that are small enough to subsidize flight by wealthier families from the public schools (and to act as a windfall for wealthy families that were going to send their kids to private school either way), but not big enough to make private school an economically viable option for the poor. For understandable political reasons, they frame their rhetoric in terms of helping blacks and Hispanics out of failing public school, but when it comes time to talk money, they nearly always propose amounts that would simply suck money and wealthier students out of the public schools, leaving them even worse places for most blacks and Hispanics.
 
Have you spoken to a 'college graduate' these days?

There was a time when a H.S. grad could turn around and teach school themselves.
Yes, in the past, when most Americans were farmers who only required the very basic literacy and math skills necessary to conduct simple agricultural business, someone with a decent high school education was more than enough to act as the kind of teacher they required.
 
You preferred the Rottweiler look then?

Can someone please tell me if he has Cyber Tourettes (or Cyber Aspergers) or some other disease whereby he just ejaculates some crazy or intense or meant-to-be intense response?

This is baffling.
 
First, ...Hispanics.

In June, Romario Blair graduated from Henninger High School with a Regents diploma — scoring well above the threshold of 65 on the five required exams. In his junior year, he took Advanced Placement English and got an 84 on his English Regents.

That makes him a success story in the Syracuse school district, where fewer than half the students graduate from high school within four years.

But shortly after graduation, Blair got a surprise: His high school success didn’t prepare him to take entry-level English and math courses at Onondaga Community College.

He is among 40 city graduates who are spending five weeks this summer taking noncredit “developmental” courses at OCC through a collaboration between the college and Say Yes to Education, a nonprofit organization working to improve Syracuse schools.

The collaboration is new, but the problem isn’t. Half of the full-time, degree-seeking students who arrive at OCC each year must take catch-up classes, costing them both time and money.

Most of them graduate from high school in good standing — many with Regents diplomas. But graduates and their parents quickly find out that those diplomas, once considered the “gold standard” of education in New York, are no guarantee of future success.

more: http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2011/08/many_high_school_graduates_wit.html
 
Yes, in the past, when most Americans were farmers who only required the very basic literacy and math skills necessary to conduct simple agricultural business, someone with a decent high school education was more than enough to act as the kind of teacher they required.

You'd be very surprised how smart and well educated some of those farmers were. They did after all build this country into what it is.

http://newspaperarchive.com/ackley-enterprise

See how much better newspapers were back then than now and consider what that implies of the readership.
 
Last edited:
Can someone please tell me if he has Cyber Tourettes (or Cyber Aspergers) or some other disease whereby he just ejaculates some crazy or intense or meant-to-be intense response?

This is baffling.

You edited your original post before I answered it. In that first post you mentioned rotweillers. I had a zombie rotweiller avatar before this one.

Where you born a dick or do you just play one in forums :0)
 
As most of you probably know, the Pledge of Allegiance includes the theological assertion that our nation exists "under God" because during the Red Scare politicians modified the Pledge to incorporate that religious test. There have been several challenges to it, on the obvious grounds that Congress has no business encouraging citizens to make a statement of religious dogma that way, but thus far, no court has had the guts to overturn that law. I'm not expecting that to change, but there is a new challenge in the works, in Massachusetts, with a slight variation: they'll make a claim based on equal protection, rather than the first amendment's prohibition on laws respecting an establishment of religion.

Setting aside the legal question, consider the matter from a moral perspective. Morally, you should not do unto others things that you wouldn't want them to do unto you. So, if you're a monotheist, the test for the morality of supporting the "under God" phrase is to picture yourself and your kids in a society where monotheists were in the minority. If you were in a majority-atheist country, for example, would you want that majority to pass a law encouraging citizens (including your kids in public school) to recite the Pledge with the phrase "under no God." If not, then it is immoral for you to support a similar law with the phrase "under God," since that is doing unto the atheist minority (and assorted other non-monotheists) something you would not want done unto you if the roles were reversed.

I wish the plaintiffs well.

http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/school_law/2013/09/massachusetts_high_court_weigh.html
 
You edited your original post before I answered it. In that first post you mentioned rotweillers. I had a zombie rotweiller avatar before this one.

Where you born a dick or do you just play one in forums :0)

I never mentioned Rottweillers!! I have no reason to. I do not even comprehend where Rottweillers come into the discussion here. You are a liar. And have some other issues for sure.
 
I suppose that's a fair enough description. But I don't think it's peculiar to atheists. Every religious person I've ever met has, at least implicitly, claimed to know that his religion would be a good thing for others, even if they don't realize it themselves.

Yes, but thinking it would be good for someone else is much different than claiming insanity for not thinking your own way, as most atheists do.

I think most people of faith understand WHY people might reject or muddle faith... giving into temptations of pleasure, violence, etc. provide short term euphoria.

However, every atheist who I've debated with refuses to acknowledge any reason why someone of faith believes, and resorts to name-calling and negative labels.
 
Back
Top