New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Various responses

Simplistic comparisons between methods of murder make for wonderful cartoons. At the heart of this cartoon is the inescapable truth that mankind has the power to kill using whatever tool is handy. I can think of no argument changing this basic fact of human history or behavior. Let us take each of these instruments of death and consider the options we might have to keep them from ever being an instrument of death.

1. The bat or stick is available anywhere in nature where there are trees or man made objects resembling a bat or stick. The sources are uncountable. Keeping someone from using them would demand that every tree be burnt, that every piece of plastic or artificial material be either of a size too large to wield or too small to harm. Therefore, there is nothing that can be done if someone decides to use them for murder. The only remedy is the hope that the penalty is severe enough to prevent the murder.

2. The string, rope, vine or artificial equivalent is also ubiquitous and follows the same line of reasoning as my comments relating to the stick.

3. The knife is much less abundant and is man made with the exception of plant like knives such as an agave leaf or a mineral or coral based implement. These items are also too numerous to eliminate and thus this tool of death is yet another fact of life.

4. The gun though is different is it not? It only exists as the product of man and his machines. It is a fabricated device where we know exactly where the sole sources lie in factories which can be closed. It exists because someone made a profit selling it and it has a long shelf life. There is a world possible where no one has them and thus no one dies from it. It existed here on this planet before the gun was invented and prior to that event, no one in the 4.5 billion years of earth's existence ever used one to kill a human being. The only interesting question then is how do we eliminate every single one of them so that this option never occurs. It is intuitively obvious that the closer you get to that mythical state of man prior to the commonality of guns, the fewer people will be killed with guns. And thus the concept of a nuclear free world is born.
 
It's unrealistic to think we could get rid of blunt objects, ropes, or sharp pieces of metal. So, we're not going to have any luck trying to tackle the murder problem in this country by addressing those potential weapons. However, we can, of course, reduce access to firearms. In fact, that's something that pretty much every other wealthy nation has done -- and they all, not coincidentally, have lower murder rates than us. Of course, if we reduce access to firearms, some of those who would have used guns to kill will simply kill with something else (or will find a way to get their hands on guns, anyway). But some won't.

As for the cartoon you posted, it isn't funny because it lacks that element of truth. We all know that the fourth panel is simply not an accurate rendition of the societal reaction to gun violence. We do, in fact, demand answers about what's wrong with someone who kills someone else, when he uses a gun just as when he uses a baseball bat. If you'd like me to point you to stories speculating about and investigating into the psychology of the various spree shooters, I can do so. But it's a waste of time, because you know perfectly well that one of the first and strongest reactions in the wake of such events is to demand answers about what's wrong with such people.

It's just that we also have the other reaction, too -- looking into what it is we can do to make such people less deadly. Murderously disturbed people are inevitably doing to pop up within a society. We can, perhaps, make them less common through good mental health care and efforts to address sociological issues that drive such dysfunction. But such people pop up all around the world in large numbers, including in all the other wealthy nations. So, we're unlikely to come anywhere close to eliminating such mental dysfunction from our society. People are going to crack in murderous ways, no matter what. But, we can make it less likely that those who crack will actually kill someone, and we can make it so those who do crack and kill someone are less likely to kill a lot of people.

That's where gun control comes in -- and where every other wealthy nation has succeeded much better than us. Sure, they may produce fewer sociopaths than us, thanks to more liberal social systems, universal healthcare, or some other factors. But that doesn't explain the entirety of the problem. The gap between the US and these other countries in terms of murder is much greater than it is in terms of lesser crimes, suggesting that there isn't just a difference in the frequency of sociopathy, but also a big difference in the murders produced by a given number of sociopaths in different countries. And the prevalence of firearms is a meaningful part of that. Even if we could get our frequency of mental dysfunction down to what's normal in other wealthy nations, we'd still have unusually high murder rates, because when guns are conveniently in reach, people who go over the edge are more likely to kill.
 
Perhaps the dumbest RW post ever. Guess you didn't hear about the school knife attack in China where 20-some were wounded, but nobody was killed.

Figures. And btw, still waiting on you awesome current link on Boca's contention that a father who's son plotted a school murder isn't relevant to a productive conversation about sensible gun legislation.

You people are not only insane, you're irrelevant and boring.
 
Back
Top