Arkady
President
As most people here know, the Democrats actually got more votes in the last round of House of Representatives elections, but the Republicans won a sizable majority of the seats. This was due to shameless gerrymandering by Republican-dominated state governments, which packed as many minority voters into a few districts as possible. That makes those districts very easy for the Democrats to win, but wastes a huge portion of those votes on landslide victories, leaving Republicans with smaller, but nevertheless effective, majorities in most districts. That way, even if most people in the state want Democrat-style representatives, most end up with Republicans. This will likely get worse now that the Supreme Court has removed prior scrutiny for voting law changes.
Even if Republicans didn't consciously play the racial gerrymandering game, though, it would still be hard to avoid a divergence of the popular will and the election results. Since liberals and minorities tend to cluster in cities, there's a natural effect that's similar to gerrymandering with any geographically drawn districts. So, here's an idea to neutralize the impact of both gerrymandering and natural clustering, while also addressing the problems inherent in a winner-takes-all election system. Unfortunately, it's only practical in larger states, since you need at least five representatives for it to really make sense.
The idea would be to have everyone cast two votes for the House. One would be for their local representative, as is currently done. The other is for a proxy organization to administer their "at large" vote. There would be a qualifying process to become one of these proxy organizations, with the goal of having ten or so organizations listed on the ballot who people can designate to vote on their behalf. These would likely include the GOP and Democratic Party, but also smaller parties like the Libertarians, Tea Party, and Greens, as well as maybe some other entities like the ACLU or NRA.
So, here's how it would work. First, each geographic district tally would be calculated, just like in our current system. Whoever got the plurality of votes would be elected to represent that district. However, any excess votes the person got --votes in excess of what was actually needed to win-- would be distributed to the proxy organizations in proportion to the votes they got in the proxy vote tally in that district. The proxy organizations would then get together and form coalitions that would then staff the "at large" representatives.
So, for example, let's say you have a state with 10 representatives. You'd divide it, geographically, into five districts. After choosing those five geographic representatives, the excess votes would be distributed. Let's say that this results in the GOP having 9000 votes, the Democrats 8000, the Greens 4000, the Libertarians 2000, the ACLU 2000, the NAACP 1000, the NRA 1000, the Reform Party 1000, the AFL-CIO 1000, and the Christian Coalition 1000, for a total of 30,000. In that case, the "price" for each of the five at-large seats will be 6000 votes. The GOP and Democratic Party can each appoint a representative, since they have over 6000 votes. That might be someone who lost one of the geographic races, or someone else from the party. However, after that, if they want to help pick another one, they need to convince another group to pool votes. So, the GOP might take its remaining 3000 votes and team up with the Christian Coalition, the NRA, and the Reform Party to pick another seat... which would have to be someone the Christian Coalition, NRA, and Reform Party found palatable. Or maybe they could form some other coalition. The smaller groups could likewise band together... say a coalition of Libertarians, the ACLU, the NAACP, and the NRA, to pick a candidate who focuses on Bill of Rights issues. If nobody can put together enough votes to "buy" a district, the price would be lowered gradually until someone did.
I see three advantages to this. First, it negates the advantage of gerrymandering. Sure, you can still gerrymander like crazy, to give your favored party dominance of the geographic districts. However, the landslide victory you'd give to those in the packed districts would have consequences: it would mean that the at-large seats would be dominated by ideologies that you're probably not so fond of. So, it's self-correcting... those drawing the districts might as well draw them for the honest purpose of best reflecting natural geographic and population lines, because there's no net political gain to be had by trying to game the map drawing process. The second advantage is that this would give people a way to express third-party support or to promote viewpoints otherwise neglected by the major parties (like government transparency, shrinking the military, etc.) People whose ideology doesn't hold a plurality in any geographic area could, nonetheless, manage to elect someone to Congress, simply by being the proxy vote of a significant minority of the population, with enough total support to "buy" one of those at-large seats. Third, it would probably cut down somewhat on pork-barrel politics, since half the House would consist of "at large" candidates who effectively represent a broad coalition of voters across their state, rather than a single district that can be kept happy by bringing home some local earmark spending.
Even if Republicans didn't consciously play the racial gerrymandering game, though, it would still be hard to avoid a divergence of the popular will and the election results. Since liberals and minorities tend to cluster in cities, there's a natural effect that's similar to gerrymandering with any geographically drawn districts. So, here's an idea to neutralize the impact of both gerrymandering and natural clustering, while also addressing the problems inherent in a winner-takes-all election system. Unfortunately, it's only practical in larger states, since you need at least five representatives for it to really make sense.
The idea would be to have everyone cast two votes for the House. One would be for their local representative, as is currently done. The other is for a proxy organization to administer their "at large" vote. There would be a qualifying process to become one of these proxy organizations, with the goal of having ten or so organizations listed on the ballot who people can designate to vote on their behalf. These would likely include the GOP and Democratic Party, but also smaller parties like the Libertarians, Tea Party, and Greens, as well as maybe some other entities like the ACLU or NRA.
So, here's how it would work. First, each geographic district tally would be calculated, just like in our current system. Whoever got the plurality of votes would be elected to represent that district. However, any excess votes the person got --votes in excess of what was actually needed to win-- would be distributed to the proxy organizations in proportion to the votes they got in the proxy vote tally in that district. The proxy organizations would then get together and form coalitions that would then staff the "at large" representatives.
So, for example, let's say you have a state with 10 representatives. You'd divide it, geographically, into five districts. After choosing those five geographic representatives, the excess votes would be distributed. Let's say that this results in the GOP having 9000 votes, the Democrats 8000, the Greens 4000, the Libertarians 2000, the ACLU 2000, the NAACP 1000, the NRA 1000, the Reform Party 1000, the AFL-CIO 1000, and the Christian Coalition 1000, for a total of 30,000. In that case, the "price" for each of the five at-large seats will be 6000 votes. The GOP and Democratic Party can each appoint a representative, since they have over 6000 votes. That might be someone who lost one of the geographic races, or someone else from the party. However, after that, if they want to help pick another one, they need to convince another group to pool votes. So, the GOP might take its remaining 3000 votes and team up with the Christian Coalition, the NRA, and the Reform Party to pick another seat... which would have to be someone the Christian Coalition, NRA, and Reform Party found palatable. Or maybe they could form some other coalition. The smaller groups could likewise band together... say a coalition of Libertarians, the ACLU, the NAACP, and the NRA, to pick a candidate who focuses on Bill of Rights issues. If nobody can put together enough votes to "buy" a district, the price would be lowered gradually until someone did.
I see three advantages to this. First, it negates the advantage of gerrymandering. Sure, you can still gerrymander like crazy, to give your favored party dominance of the geographic districts. However, the landslide victory you'd give to those in the packed districts would have consequences: it would mean that the at-large seats would be dominated by ideologies that you're probably not so fond of. So, it's self-correcting... those drawing the districts might as well draw them for the honest purpose of best reflecting natural geographic and population lines, because there's no net political gain to be had by trying to game the map drawing process. The second advantage is that this would give people a way to express third-party support or to promote viewpoints otherwise neglected by the major parties (like government transparency, shrinking the military, etc.) People whose ideology doesn't hold a plurality in any geographic area could, nonetheless, manage to elect someone to Congress, simply by being the proxy vote of a significant minority of the population, with enough total support to "buy" one of those at-large seats. Third, it would probably cut down somewhat on pork-barrel politics, since half the House would consist of "at large" candidates who effectively represent a broad coalition of voters across their state, rather than a single district that can be kept happy by bringing home some local earmark spending.