Arkady
President
Joseph Stiglitz has a recent New York Times editorial about how wealth inequality is holding our recovery back. Stiglitz is a Nobel Prize-winning economist and the former head of the Clinton administration's economic advisers, so the piece is well worth the read. I've seen other prominent economists making similar arguments, especially about the role wealth inequality has in bringing about more frequent and more severe recessions. That's consistent with the national record -- prior to the New Deal, which dramatically decreased wealth inequality, recessions showed up much more frequently and dragged on for a lot longer, on average.
However, even if you believe it's possible for the economy to grow strongly despite severe wealth inequality in this country, there are countless other national problems that are convincingly attributable, at least in part, to the huge gap between rich and poor here. For example, wealth inequality plays an important role in our country's crime problems, which, like our wealth inequality, are unusually bad for a developed nation. People who grow up poor, in the shadow of conspicuous opulence, with little class mobility, feel they have little incentive to play by a set of rules that seem stacked against them. This probably also has a role in our drug and obesity problems, both of which are much worse among the underclass. Similarly, severe wealth inequality is also a major part of our national health problems -- our health stats among the middle class don't compare all that unfavorably with other wealthy nations, but our stats among the poor are so disgraceful as to pull our national averages down into that disgraceful territory. Likewise, our education system in middle class areas, while nothing to brag about, isn't the key to understanding our very low average rankings on international tests of academic achievement -- rather, it's the near illiteracy in which we allow the underclass to remain. The greater the gap between rich and poor grows --and we have every reason to think it will keep growing-- the worse we can expect these problems to be.
So, what's causing this growing inequality? A typical economist will cite globalization and technology as the most important factors. If a new technology allows one person to do the work of ten, or if a new foreign labor market allows someone to do the work for 1/10 the labor cost, it's not like the savings are shared evenly among all Americans. It would be possible to set our system up in such a way that displaced workers got a sizable portion of the new wealth generated when their jobs are eliminated, but that's not how we've set it up. Instead, the savings are typically shared among the consumers, the owners of the businesses, and the senior executives. The portion that goes to the consumers helps to hold inflation down, so that the middle class doesn't necessarily slide (but often does, when wages don't keep pace even with minimal inflation), but the displaced workers who can't find decent replacement jobs form a larger and more impoverished underclass, while the enriched owners and executives form an ever-richer elite.
That is, no doubt, the largest reason for the growing gap between rich and poor. In that dynamic, the government's fault is an error of omission, rather than commission -- the market itself is driving a spread between rich and poor, and the government merely isn't being as active as some earlier governments in counteracting that effect. You could think of it as the market forces spinning up, creating centrifugal acceleration that would pull the nation apart, and the government, right now, isn't doing enough to reinforce the centripetal forces that hold us together. In the past, reinforcing our national socioeconomic coherence included such things as high taxes on the very rich (as high as a 92% rate for federal income taxes on the top bracket), along with huge government jobs programs, the GI Bill, and other things that could give the lower class a step up, financed by the upper class.
However, there are other factors where the government is having a more direct role in causing the problem. Take copyright law, for example. The Founders wanted copyrights to expire in less than 20 years. These days, copyrights are, effectively, eternal (every time some new things are about to fall into the public domain, Congress extends the copyright, to keep valuable corporate copyrights like Mickey Mouse from becoming public). The extension of those copyrights is a direct transfer of wealth from the people as a whole to the giant corporations. When you have to pay a corporation to listen to a Beatles song or to watch the Godfather, rather than just downloading it for free, it's because Congress handed those rights, which would have belonged to the public by now, to the plutocracy, at no cost. We're talking about hundreds of billions of dollars of direct transfers of wealth from the masses to the elite, thanks to that change. And it impoverishes the masses indirectly, as well, by forcing new generators of intellectual property to put themselves under those giant corporations if they want any access to the material that should long ago have fallen into the public domain. If you want to do a new version of The Sound of Music, set in 1990s Yugoslavia, the way, Leonard Bernstein did a new version of Romeo and Juliet in West Side Story, you can't just work on your own -- you'll need to pay the owners of the movie and play rights through the nose, and they're always welcome to deny you the ability. Especially in the age of desktop film editing and YouTube, when there are few TECHNICAL hurdles for a poor, talented person looking to bring his vision to the public, this has an ENORMOUS impact in preserving the near-monopoly of a few giant for-profit entertainment corporations on the creation of new culture, thus worsening wealth inequality. To a lesser extent, the systematic narrowing of the "fair use" exception has the same role.
That one's a pet peeve of mine, but there are plenty of other examples of the government actively working to increase wealth inequality in this country. And it's largely a bipartisan thing. Take Obamacare. We could have expanded Medicare to all, or we could have done what Germany, Switzerland, and several other wealth nations did and prohibited profit-taking on basic healthcare insurance. Alternately, we could have set up a public option, to cap what private insurers could get away with charging. But we didn't do any of those things. Instead, we have ordered people to get healthcare coverage, while doing almost nothing to prevent the insurance companies from profiteering shamelessly on those products. In defense of Obamacare, we did, at least, provide public assistance for those who couldn't afford insurance. But that acts as a net transfer of wealth from the taxpayers, in general (who finance the subsidy), to the giant for-profit health insurance conglomerates (who pocket that tax money for people who otherwise couldn't have afforded their products).
Stimulus funding is another example. We could have done what was done during the New Deal, when we set up a lot of direct government jobs programs, like the WPA, the Civilian Conservation Corps, etc., in order to make sure that the majority of those tax dollars either went to hiring struggling workers or improving public property. Instead, most of the stimulus was done as tax cuts (disproportionately going to those with higher incomes), or as corporate grants. Sure, those corporations, in turn, used some of the money to hire workers and some to improve public property (or otherwise to provide some public good), but they were able to siphon off a profit, and to fund their giant executive salaries, too.
I'd also cite the handling of public resources. Although the government is supposed to get fair market value for mineral rights and other public resources on our lands, in practice for-profit resource-extraction companies that are politically well-connected can get their hands on massive amounts of such resources for pennies on the dollar, helping them to remain some of the most profitable companies in the world.
In recent decades there has been a climate of hysteria about phantom socialism, and an unthinking embrace of corporate wealth. In that climate, it was, perhaps, too much to expect the government to step up and actively work against growing wealth inequality. But, at least, they shouldn't have been actively working towards it. The good news is that Obama seems to be focused more on the issue for his second term, and has particularly called for more reform of our tax system. So, there's hope. That said, Obama's always had a knack for saying the right things, so I'll remain cautious until I see signs that this time he's actually got the guts to fight for improvements, rather than rolling over for the centrifugal forces in our economy.
However, even if you believe it's possible for the economy to grow strongly despite severe wealth inequality in this country, there are countless other national problems that are convincingly attributable, at least in part, to the huge gap between rich and poor here. For example, wealth inequality plays an important role in our country's crime problems, which, like our wealth inequality, are unusually bad for a developed nation. People who grow up poor, in the shadow of conspicuous opulence, with little class mobility, feel they have little incentive to play by a set of rules that seem stacked against them. This probably also has a role in our drug and obesity problems, both of which are much worse among the underclass. Similarly, severe wealth inequality is also a major part of our national health problems -- our health stats among the middle class don't compare all that unfavorably with other wealthy nations, but our stats among the poor are so disgraceful as to pull our national averages down into that disgraceful territory. Likewise, our education system in middle class areas, while nothing to brag about, isn't the key to understanding our very low average rankings on international tests of academic achievement -- rather, it's the near illiteracy in which we allow the underclass to remain. The greater the gap between rich and poor grows --and we have every reason to think it will keep growing-- the worse we can expect these problems to be.
So, what's causing this growing inequality? A typical economist will cite globalization and technology as the most important factors. If a new technology allows one person to do the work of ten, or if a new foreign labor market allows someone to do the work for 1/10 the labor cost, it's not like the savings are shared evenly among all Americans. It would be possible to set our system up in such a way that displaced workers got a sizable portion of the new wealth generated when their jobs are eliminated, but that's not how we've set it up. Instead, the savings are typically shared among the consumers, the owners of the businesses, and the senior executives. The portion that goes to the consumers helps to hold inflation down, so that the middle class doesn't necessarily slide (but often does, when wages don't keep pace even with minimal inflation), but the displaced workers who can't find decent replacement jobs form a larger and more impoverished underclass, while the enriched owners and executives form an ever-richer elite.
That is, no doubt, the largest reason for the growing gap between rich and poor. In that dynamic, the government's fault is an error of omission, rather than commission -- the market itself is driving a spread between rich and poor, and the government merely isn't being as active as some earlier governments in counteracting that effect. You could think of it as the market forces spinning up, creating centrifugal acceleration that would pull the nation apart, and the government, right now, isn't doing enough to reinforce the centripetal forces that hold us together. In the past, reinforcing our national socioeconomic coherence included such things as high taxes on the very rich (as high as a 92% rate for federal income taxes on the top bracket), along with huge government jobs programs, the GI Bill, and other things that could give the lower class a step up, financed by the upper class.
However, there are other factors where the government is having a more direct role in causing the problem. Take copyright law, for example. The Founders wanted copyrights to expire in less than 20 years. These days, copyrights are, effectively, eternal (every time some new things are about to fall into the public domain, Congress extends the copyright, to keep valuable corporate copyrights like Mickey Mouse from becoming public). The extension of those copyrights is a direct transfer of wealth from the people as a whole to the giant corporations. When you have to pay a corporation to listen to a Beatles song or to watch the Godfather, rather than just downloading it for free, it's because Congress handed those rights, which would have belonged to the public by now, to the plutocracy, at no cost. We're talking about hundreds of billions of dollars of direct transfers of wealth from the masses to the elite, thanks to that change. And it impoverishes the masses indirectly, as well, by forcing new generators of intellectual property to put themselves under those giant corporations if they want any access to the material that should long ago have fallen into the public domain. If you want to do a new version of The Sound of Music, set in 1990s Yugoslavia, the way, Leonard Bernstein did a new version of Romeo and Juliet in West Side Story, you can't just work on your own -- you'll need to pay the owners of the movie and play rights through the nose, and they're always welcome to deny you the ability. Especially in the age of desktop film editing and YouTube, when there are few TECHNICAL hurdles for a poor, talented person looking to bring his vision to the public, this has an ENORMOUS impact in preserving the near-monopoly of a few giant for-profit entertainment corporations on the creation of new culture, thus worsening wealth inequality. To a lesser extent, the systematic narrowing of the "fair use" exception has the same role.
That one's a pet peeve of mine, but there are plenty of other examples of the government actively working to increase wealth inequality in this country. And it's largely a bipartisan thing. Take Obamacare. We could have expanded Medicare to all, or we could have done what Germany, Switzerland, and several other wealth nations did and prohibited profit-taking on basic healthcare insurance. Alternately, we could have set up a public option, to cap what private insurers could get away with charging. But we didn't do any of those things. Instead, we have ordered people to get healthcare coverage, while doing almost nothing to prevent the insurance companies from profiteering shamelessly on those products. In defense of Obamacare, we did, at least, provide public assistance for those who couldn't afford insurance. But that acts as a net transfer of wealth from the taxpayers, in general (who finance the subsidy), to the giant for-profit health insurance conglomerates (who pocket that tax money for people who otherwise couldn't have afforded their products).
Stimulus funding is another example. We could have done what was done during the New Deal, when we set up a lot of direct government jobs programs, like the WPA, the Civilian Conservation Corps, etc., in order to make sure that the majority of those tax dollars either went to hiring struggling workers or improving public property. Instead, most of the stimulus was done as tax cuts (disproportionately going to those with higher incomes), or as corporate grants. Sure, those corporations, in turn, used some of the money to hire workers and some to improve public property (or otherwise to provide some public good), but they were able to siphon off a profit, and to fund their giant executive salaries, too.
I'd also cite the handling of public resources. Although the government is supposed to get fair market value for mineral rights and other public resources on our lands, in practice for-profit resource-extraction companies that are politically well-connected can get their hands on massive amounts of such resources for pennies on the dollar, helping them to remain some of the most profitable companies in the world.
In recent decades there has been a climate of hysteria about phantom socialism, and an unthinking embrace of corporate wealth. In that climate, it was, perhaps, too much to expect the government to step up and actively work against growing wealth inequality. But, at least, they shouldn't have been actively working towards it. The good news is that Obama seems to be focused more on the issue for his second term, and has particularly called for more reform of our tax system. So, there's hope. That said, Obama's always had a knack for saying the right things, so I'll remain cautious until I see signs that this time he's actually got the guts to fight for improvements, rather than rolling over for the centrifugal forces in our economy.