New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wealth over work

Why anyone would think that quoting Krugman gives credibility to a thread is beyond me.

I agree with most people that Krugman doesn't really realize this is what the GOP is doing. The party is rightly generally understood to favor the turning the poor into the wealthy vs Democrats turning the wealthy into the poor and middle class. But many don't realize that even among the wealthy, they favor those whose income doesn't come from their own labors, but labors of jobs created which feed fanmilies If you earn half a million dollars of income by being a world-class surgeon, you pay fairly high taxes on that (nearly 50% in federal taxes, on the top dollar, after counting income and payroll taxes). If you "earn" the exact same income from interest, dividends, and capital gains, you pay far less (as little as 15%). And if you "earn" it by drawing it from an estate, it's possible it won't be taxed at all..after all taxes are paid...provided that the estate doesnt has more than 5 million and then if more than 5 million then the estate pays up to 60 percent in income taxes and you the beneficiary of the estate pays up to 60 percent meaning you as the beneficiary could owe up to 20 percent of the estate to the federal govt for inheriting 5 million dollars and if you are the middle class or lower and now have to pay 1 million in taxes...just because someone left you(say an Uncle who liked you) and you make 75,000 per year and now owe 1 million in taxes...sorry buddy but you didn't think this through.

The GOP is becoming the party that serves people who look like Bush or Romney, Cain or Cruz or : rich, middle class, poor boys and girls from rich, middle class, and poor families whose incomes are primarily investment gains, slaries , Jobs, hard work. rather than welfare. Even among the wealthy, those who get their income in exchange for productive labor are seen as second-class citizens to Democrats. It's actually similar to government in earlier, feudal eras, when rich shopkeepers and tradesmen were taxed heavily, while the aristocracy with their grand estates were protected by special Obama privileges.

You should really think through what Krugman is saying before looking so stupid...you know nothing about taxation...and neither does Krugman. You are now officially unwelcomed language removed here!
 
You keep providing that formula, but haven’t we repeatedly established that it’s patently nonsensical? Again, to remind you:
If I produce $1000 of value, and save $1000, then, by your formula, I should now have $1 million of wealth, since production times savings equals wealth.


If you produce $1000 of value one month and save $1000, you're net worth is now $1000.

If you rinse and repeat for 12 months, you have created $12,000 in wealth.

But go ahead and tell me the communist formula in creating wealth.. I'm, sure it will make for a good laugh.
 
I'm not one who's convinced necessarily, that income and capital should be taxed at the same rate. I think it better that both be taxed at their most efficient rates, even if that leads to different rates.

But...at least in terms of our current economic reality, capital is being taxed way below its most efficient rate. We may wonder how capital gets away with that, since logic suggests that capital should be represented by considerably fewer voters than labor.

But...this thread highlights the "problem". All too many laborers have convinced themselves that they're capitalists.

*Yes...we're ALL labor and capital, but it's a matter of balance.
I'm OK with taxing them at different rates if there's good cause. But I'd define "efficiency" much more broadly. I think that arguments that insist lower rates (or even zero taxation) for capital gains are best are often very narrowly analyzed, for the express purpose of trying to prove the prejudice with which they started. They tend to look at the value of lower capital gains tax rates, without accounting for the corresponding increase in all other tax rates in order for that to be revenue neutral. As a practical matter, lower capital gains taxes and other taxes on unearned income will increase taxes on earned income, putting far more burden on that one source of revenue, and creating larger distortions in the market (as people distort their behavior in order to treat an income as a capital gain). For example, lets say you hire me to perform some transformations on a data set for you. What you pay me would be ordinary income, taxed at a particular rate. But let's say you instead sell me a hard drive containing the data sets, and I perform the transformations on the data, then sell the hard drive back to you a a big profit. Now that's a capital gain, and I pay a much lower tax for the exact same transaction. The farther apart the income tax rate and the capital gains tax rate get, the greater the incentive for that kind of imbecilic, inefficient distoriting of the market for the sole purpose of getting a money stream seen as a capital gain rather than an income. The system is much more efficient if people are focused, to the greatest extent possible, on creating real value, rather than doing a little dance routine to take advantage in large gaps in the treatment of two form of income. But right-wing economists very studiously avoid thinking about that, because they serve the very rich, who are paying them good money to argue in favor of special tax treatment for their main source of income.

The proponents of low taxes on unearned income also tend to ignore entirely the long-term efficiency problems of such policies favoring the accumulation of wealth into the hands of a small economic elite.

Anyway, I agree with the thrust of your comments. There's a lot of money out there being used to convince labor that its interests are aligned with capital, and I think that is why politicians can get away with disdvantaging the 95% of us who make most of our money through labor in favor of the 5% who acquire money through capital. Rent-seeking is a big money thing, and money distorts the political dialogue.
 
This discussion is a perfect example of why conservatives and progressives can never agree on economic issues. Conservatives believe in equal opportunities for all, while progressives believe in equal outcomes for all (at the point of a gun, if necessary).
Where, in the thread, do you see anything arguing in favor of equal outcomes for all? Did you get confused and post to the wrong thread?
 
If you produce $1000 of value one month and save $1000, you're net worth is now $1000.

If you rinse and repeat for 12 months, you have created $12,000 in wealth.

But go ahead and tell me the communist formula in creating wealth.. I'm, sure it will make for a good laugh.

I have no idea what the communist formula is for creating wealth, as I am not, and never have been, a communist. But, we’re discussing YOUR formula, right now. Where did you get the idea that multiplying production by savings gave an output of wealth? How could $1000 of savings and $1000 of production equal $1 million of wealth?
 
Lowering taxes doesn’t lower prices or raise wages or encourage more capital investment. Prices, wages, and capital investments are already netted out before taxes are assessed.

Lowering taxes does not INCREASE prices as higher taxes will.

And of course EVERYTHING IS NETTED OUT. But HIGHER TAXES means HIGHER COSTS which even a special needs commie should be able to grasp.
 
I have no idea what the communist formula is for creating wealth, as I am not, and never have been, a communist. But, we’re discussing YOUR formula, right now. Where did you get the idea that multiplying production by savings gave an output of wealth? How could $1000 of savings and $1000 of production equal $1 million of wealth?

million dollars?.. is that your measurement of wealth?

If my net wealth is ZERO, I can only create wealth by producing and saving, the more I produce and save, the more wealth I am creating.

However, If I borrow 1 million dollars and go on a Michelle Obama like vacation, I am $1M in debt and have nothing to show for it except an Obama/Mao T-Shirt

obama_mao_light_tshirt.jpg


To create $1M in wealth will require you to PRODUCE more than $1k a month. However, PRODUCTION is heavily taxed and regulated in the post land of the free.
 
Last edited:
I'm OK with taxing them at different rates if there's good cause. But I'd define "efficiency" much more broadly. I think that arguments that insist lower rates (or even zero taxation) for capital gains are best are often very narrowly analyzed, for the express purpose of trying to prove the prejudice with which they started. They tend to look at the value of lower capital gains tax rates, without accounting for the corresponding increase in all other tax rates in order for that to be revenue neutral. As a practical matter, lower capital gains taxes and other taxes on unearned income will increase taxes on earned income, putting far more burden on that one source of revenue, and creating larger distortions in the market (as people distort their behavior in order to treat an income as a capital gain). For example, lets say you hire me to perform some transformations on a data set for you. What you pay me would be ordinary income, taxed at a particular rate. But let's say you instead sell me a hard drive containing the data sets, and I perform the transformations on the data, then sell the hard drive back to you a a big profit. Now that's a capital gain, and I pay a much lower tax for the exact same transaction. The farther apart the income tax rate and the capital gains tax rate get, the greater the incentive for that kind of imbecilic, inefficient distoriting of the market for the sole purpose of getting a money stream seen as a capital gain rather than an income. The system is much more efficient if people are focused, to the greatest extent possible, on creating real value, rather than doing a little dance routine to take advantage in large gaps in the treatment of two form of income. But right-wing economists very studiously avoid thinking about that, because they serve the very rich, who are paying them good money to argue in favor of special tax treatment for their main source of income.

The proponents of low taxes on unearned income also tend to ignore entirely the long-term efficiency problems of such policies favoring the accumulation of wealth into the hands of a small economic elite.

Anyway, I agree with the thrust of your comments. There's a lot of money out there being used to convince labor that its interests are aligned with capital, and I think that is why politicians can get away with disdvantaging the 95% of us who make most of our money through labor in favor of the 5% who acquire money through capital. Rent-seeking is a big money thing, and money distorts the political dialogue.

Why do you even post this garbage...I am guessing by your own standards all you have is unearned.

1. Investments arent unearned income...otherwise give me your money and expect nothing in return and let's see how you feel about that.

Your premise is wrong...and boy could you never be so far off from beig right...well wait till next time....Your theories border on delusional
 
BTW....You cant have money in the bank...it earns interest making it unearned income which needs to be taxed.......but I am guessing you do have money in a bank.
 
Correlation does't equal causation.

No, of course not. But the historical record sure does support my own, personal experience. I saved money when dividends were treated as ordinary income. I save money now, when they aren’t. I don’t at all see how lowering the dividends tax rate was supposed to make me more eager to save. If anything, it could make me LESS eager to do so. My main purpose for saving is the desire to set myself up to have enough of an income stream to live off of comfortably, in retirement. If I have to factor in higher tax rates on dividends, interest, and capital gains, then I need to save more money to have the same after-tax income as if I can factor in a lower tax rate on dividends, interest, and capital gains. Right now, my savings rate is only as high as it is because I have a suspicion that dividends, interest, and capital gains taxes are likely to rise back up to more normal rates before I retire. If I could be convinced they’d definitely stay so low, I could cut back on saving while maintaining the same expected quality of life in retirement. So, for me, the relationship is the opposite of what the theory suggests it should be. Higher taxes on unearned income actually promote accumulation of wealth.
 
I'm OK with taxing them at different rates if there's good cause. But I'd define "efficiency" much more broadly. I think that arguments that insist lower rates (or even zero taxation) for capital gains are best are often very narrowly analyzed, for the express purpose of trying to prove the prejudice with which they started. They tend to look at the value of lower capital gains tax rates, without accounting for the corresponding increase in all other tax rates in order for that to be revenue neutral. As a practical matter, lower capital gains taxes and other taxes on unearned income will increase taxes on earned income, putting far more burden on that one source of revenue, and creating larger distortions in the market (as people distort their behavior in order to treat an income as a capital gain). For example, lets say you hire me to perform some transformations on a data set for you. What you pay me would be ordinary income, taxed at a particular rate. But let's say you instead sell me a hard drive containing the data sets, and I perform the transformations on the data, then sell the hard drive back to you a a big profit. Now that's a capital gain, and I pay a much lower tax for the exact same transaction. The farther apart the income tax rate and the capital gains tax rate get, the greater the incentive for that kind of imbecilic, inefficient distoriting of the market for the sole purpose of getting a money stream seen as a capital gain rather than an income. The system is much more efficient if people are focused, to the greatest extent possible, on creating real value, rather than doing a little dance routine to take advantage in large gaps in the treatment of two form of income. But right-wing economists very studiously avoid thinking about that, because they serve the very rich, who are paying them good money to argue in favor of special tax treatment for their main source of income.

The proponents of low taxes on unearned income also tend to ignore entirely the long-term efficiency problems of such policies favoring the accumulation of wealth into the hands of a small economic elite.

Anyway, I agree with the thrust of your comments. There's a lot of money out there being used to convince labor that its interests are aligned with capital, and I think that is why politicians can get away with disdvantaging the 95% of us who make most of our money through labor in favor of the 5% who acquire money through capital. Rent-seeking is a big money thing, and money distorts the political dialogue.

Capital should be taxed right up to the point where it actually starts inhibiting investment. And on that note, taxation on capital can and should be employed to encourage investments in the sorts of things society likes.

Above, someone suggests that society encourages the "accumulation" of wealth, so that should the accumulator fall on hard times, they won't need help from the guvmint. That poster's naivete must be forgiven in that apparently unbeknownst to her, she's about the most radical SOCIALIST in this forum!

Of course, we capitalists understand that society encourages wealth creation specifically so's that wealth will be RE-invested in society. During the last election cycle, lots was made of the fact that Mitt/Ann had squirreled most of their wealth away in offshore banks. Many were convinced that what they did had to be illegal, but there's no evidence that it was.

Others were convinced that even if it was legal, it didn't speak well of Mitt/Ann. And, considering the position Mitt/Ann were after, they had a good point! We're foolish though, to concentrate too much of our ire on the Mitt/Ann-types. We need to focus on WHY Mitt/Ann decided that that was their best option. We have the power - through taxation - to make it their worst option and investing in America, their best.
 
Why anyone would think that quoting Krugman gives credibility to a thread is beyond me.

I agree with most people that Krugman doesn't really realize this is what the GOP is doing. The party is rightly generally understood to favor the turning the poor into the wealthy vs Democrats turning the wealthy into the poor and middle class. But many don't realize that even among the wealthy, they favor those whose income doesn't come from their own labors, but labors of jobs created which feed fanmilies If you earn half a million dollars of income by being a world-class surgeon, you pay fairly high taxes on that (nearly 50% in federal taxes, on the top dollar, after counting income and payroll taxes). If you "earn" the exact same income from interest, dividends, and capital gains, you pay far less (as little as 15%). And if you "earn" it by drawing it from an estate, it's possible it won't be taxed at all..after all taxes are paid...provided that the estate doesnt has more than 5 million and then if more than 5 million then the estate pays up to 60 percent in income taxes and you the beneficiary of the estate pays up to 60 percent meaning you as the beneficiary could owe up to 20 percent of the estate to the federal govt for inheriting 5 million dollars and if you are the middle class or lower and now have to pay 1 million in taxes...just because someone left you(say an Uncle who liked you) and you make 75,000 per year and now owe 1 million in taxes...sorry buddy but you didn't think this through.

The GOP is becoming the party that serves people who look like Bush or Romney, Cain or Cruz or : rich, middle class, poor boys and girls from rich, middle class, and poor families whose incomes are primarily investment gains, slaries , Jobs, hard work. rather than welfare. Even among the wealthy, those who get their income in exchange for productive labor are seen as second-class citizens to Democrats. It's actually similar to government in earlier, feudal eras, when rich shopkeepers and tradesmen were taxed heavily, while the aristocracy with their grand estates were protected by special Obama privileges.

You should really think through what Krugman is saying before looking so stupid...you know nothing about taxation...and neither does Krugman. You are now officially unwelcomed language removed here!
I made an honest effort to understand you argument here, but couldn't actually detect one. What is it you're trying to say?
 
I made an honest effort to understand you argument here, but couldn't actually detect one. What is it you're trying to say?

I bet you barely understood Krugman...here is the point...Krugman is a know nothing...and you are his mouth piece. Got it...if you understood anything about capital gains ...you would know that anything you own just about is subject to a capital gains tax if sold...and this affects all people...not just the wealthy...get it?...or is this over your head too?
 
million dollars?.. is that your measurement of wealth?

If my net wealth is ZERO, I can only create wealth by producing and saving, the more I produce and save, the more wealth I am creating.

However, If I borrow 1 million dollars and go on a Michelle Obama like vacation, I am $1M in debt and have nothing to show for it except an Obama/Mao T-Shirt

obama_mao_light_tshirt.jpg


To create $1M in wealth will require you to PRODUCE more than $1k a month. However, PRODUCTION is heavily taxed and regulated in the post land of the free.
You said wealth was equal to the product of savings and production. If you don't like the $1million example, try another. My company produces $1 million of value, of which is saves $100,000. Now, according to your formula, that’s $100 BILLION of wealth.
.
 
Why do you even post this garbage...I am guessing by your own standards all you have is unearned.

1. Investments arent unearned income...otherwise give me your money and expect nothing in return and let's see how you feel about that.

Your premise is wrong...and boy could you never be so far off from beig right...well wait till next time....Your theories border on delusional
How would my not wanting to give you money for nothing demonstrate that the money was earned?
 
BTW....You cant have money in the bank...it earns interest making it unearned income which needs to be taxed.......but I am guessing you do have money in a bank.
Eh? Of course I have money in the bank. And I should, in fact, pay taxes on the unearned income I get as interest, the same way I would if I actually earned it.
 
I bet you barely understood Krugman...here is the point...Krugman is a know nothing...and you are his mouth piece. Got it...if you understood anything about capital gains ...you would know that anything you own just about is subject to a capital gains tax if sold...and this affects all people...not just the wealthy...get it?...or is this over your head too?
The point is that capital gains are subject to a lower rate than income actually earned by labor.
 
Eh? Of course I have money in the bank. And I should, in fact, pay taxes on the unearned income I get as interest, the same way I would if I actually earned it.

But you actually did earn that money...it's not unearned money...you invested or deposited...and your actions per that agreement with the bank or investor determines how much you earn...that money did just get up on it's own and walk into the bank hop into an account...you would have had to make a conscious decision to put it into the bank and let the bank use that money and put it to woprk and you get paid for that.

My suggestion if you don't like how banks work or more in point for you...if you don't understand how they work...don't invest...but your action and choices earned you that income...just like someone's choice to take a job earns income.
 
Back
Top