New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wealth Redistribution

LeilaniMP

Empress
Question for those of you who favor "spreading the wealth around" (as 0bama said to Joe the Plumber)

Whose wealth do you think should be redistributed?

What level of income do you think should qualify for redistribution?

How much of your personal means do you think should be redistributed to others? Or, do you think only those who have more than you should have to share their means?
 
Question for those of you who favor "spreading the wealth around" (as 0bama said to Joe the Plumber)

Whose wealth do you think should be redistributed?

What level of income do you think should qualify for redistribution?

How much of your personal means do you think should be redistributed to others? Or, do you think only those who have more than you should have to share their means?

There should be no wealth redistribution.
 
The left is alway wonderful when it comes to spreading other people's money around but they clamp up like a bull's a-hole in fly time when their wallet get's mentioned.
Very consistent effect/affect with lefties.

JO

Now to be fair. I don't like wealth redistribution but we also have to close the tax loopholes for the wealthy and big business.
 
Now to be fair. I don't like wealth redistribution but we also have to close the tax loopholes for the wealthy and big business.

I have come to the conclusion that I am more of a socialist that the lefties who post here but it is a pragmatic approach not necessarily a humane one.

Systems, any kind of system requires system dynamics and systemic maintencance for them to operate consistently and efficiently. Our economy is a system......allowing large number of imporverished people to live on the fringes of the system does nothing at all for anybody...there is no gain for the rich or the poor in this situation.

The hard and sometimes hated fact that it is cheaper to feed them than it would be to remove their dead bodies from the streets is just too pragmatic to argue with. This is a system we are talking about and whether we see it from the standpoint of humanity or simply from the standpoint of cold hard sytem mechanics....certain motions within that system will make it work either better or worse.

For the wealthy ..... making an investment in their immediate surroundings makes total sense. If that means using their wealth to improve the lives of those people who are in one way or another connected to them in a business way, a geographical way or even in a poltical way then that's what it means....after all one replaces a leaky roof for a reson not just because it's time to replace it.

JO
 
I have come to the conclusion that I am more of a socialist that the lefties who post here but it is a pragmatic approach not necessarily a humane one.

Systems, any kind of system requires system dynamics and systemic maintencance for them to operate consistently and efficiently. Our economy is a system......allowing large number of imporverished people to live on the fringes of the system does nothing at all for anybody...there is no gain for the rich or the poor in this situation.

The hard and sometimes hated fact that it is cheaper to feed them than it would be to remove their dead bodies from the streets is just too pragmatic to argue with. This is a system we are talking about and whether we see it from the standpoint of humanity or simply from the standpoint of cold hard sytem mechanics....certain motions within that system will make it work either better or worse.

For the wealthy ..... making an investment in their immediate surroundings makes total sense. If that means using their wealth to improve the lives of those people who are in one way or another connected to them in a business way, a geographical way or even in a poltical way then that's what it means....after all one replaces a leaky roof for a reson not just because it's time to replace it.

JO

I would say the real answer isn't entitlements, it is a robust economy where there are jobs for everyone that needs one.

Grow the economy and all of the entitlement problems take care of themselves for the most part and the debt interest becomes a small amount of gdp like it was under Clinton.
 
I would say the real answer isn't entitlements, it is a robust economy where there are jobs for everyone that needs one.

Grow the economy and all of the entitlement problems take care of themselves for the most part and the debt interest becomes a small amount of gdp like it was under Clinton.

Yes...a good economy would solve much of what needs to be addressed...the availablity of wealth makes certain social problems disappear. But I think in our current situation we need a tow truck to get out of the ditch before the car can run down the road again.

The Wealth gap has been growing at a record pace and we need to look very carefully at the workings of our system to find out why....as long as that continues there will be too much miserey to move forward.

JO
 
Now to be fair. I don't like wealth redistribution but we also have to close the tax loopholes for the wealthy and big business.

Indeed... And we need to do the same with redistribution/welfare programs like EIC. Everyone needs to pitch in. It's time the free ride for the poor ends.
 
Question for those of you who favor "spreading the wealth around" (as 0bama said to Joe the Plumber)

Whose wealth do you think should be redistributed?

What level of income do you think should qualify for redistribution?

How much of your personal means do you think should be redistributed to others? Or, do you think only those who have more than you should have to share their means?

That's what government does and has always done. You're pitiful "wealth redistribution" meme is tired and laughable. People who make more, pay more. Or at least they did until recently where they pay 13.9% on 20 million in capital gains (or nothing in the case of many Fortune 500s) and discovered those cool banks in the Grand Caymans.
 
That's what government does and has always done. You're pitiful "wealth redistribution" meme is tired and laughable. People who make more, pay more. Or at least they did until recently where they pay 13.9% on 20 million in capital gains (or nothing in the case of many Fortune 500s) and discovered those cool banks in the Grand Caymans.

How did the U.S. government redistribute wealth in the 1850s? The 1890s? It barely had operational taxation before the turn of the 20th century.

For that matter, where is the "redistribute wealth" authority granted in the U.S. Constitution?
 
That's what government does and has always done. You're pitiful "wealth redistribution" meme is tired and laughable. People who make more, pay more. Or at least they did until recently where they pay 13.9% on 20 million in capital gains (or nothing in the case of many Fortune 500s) and discovered those cool banks in the Grand Caymans.

Talk about something being, "tired and laughable", bo-bo......DAMN.

"People who make more, pay more. Or at least they did until recently where they pay 13.9% on 20 million in capital gains"??????

Really?

So someone who is paying 13.9% of 20 MILLION dollars, that is not "paying MORE" than others?????

See, I am on to you loony libs/Democrats, I KNOW see what you do when you whail about the dreaded "rich" not paying "more". You dearly LOVE to dwell on percentages in these cases, yet when we discuss cost, paying, earning, ANYTHING ELSE other than taxes, we discuss dollar amounts.

The military paid X dollars for a hammer and you are shocked. A welfare mom gets X amount of dollars and you Democrats howl about how she can't live off of that. Obamicare costs "only" X dollars, actually less than the Y dollars you believe we spend taking care of the uninsured now. On and on we can go............

But NOT when you are crying about wanting more of the monies of OTHER PEOPLE. No, THEN it is a percentage. To be "fair".(?)

Look, we have people who contribute almost nothing, some who contribute hundreds, some thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, even millions of dollars every year to our government. We ALSO have some who will not ONLY not contribute any but will actuall receive some of what others contribute.

And ALL of us will benefit from what our government provides. We ALL, regardless of what if any we contribute, benefit from our military, our roads, schools etc.

Yet SOME will "pay" little or nothing. SOME will pay tons of dollars. Those will benefit from the government as will thos who contribute little. However, those who contribute little will ALSO benefit from government supplied checks, homes, transportation, foot, clothing, daycare, healthcare etc.

How is that "fair"?

To be "fair" as you libs want to define it here the "rich" should be forced to pay a percentage of their worth for EVERYTHING, not just taxes.

A grocery buggy full of food may cost a single mother of four 50% of whatever her weekly check is so to be "fair" the "rich" SHOULD have to pay 50% of THEIR income for a week for the same amount of food, right?

Shit, why should Donald Trump get the exact same food for "only" one half of one percent of what HE earns in a week as this poor lady above, know what I mean, sport?

And who should define who is "rich"? The guy living in a freezer box under an overpass might look at the guy living in a trailer park and think he looks "rich". Shouldn't we accept the opinions of everyone equally, to be "fair", I mean?


Straight up, how much of other people's monies would it take to satasify that insane lust all of you Democrats/libs suffer from, bo, give us a chance to argue or agree..............
 
Talk about something being, "tired and laughable", bo-bo......DAMN.

"People who make more, pay more. Or at least they did until recently where they pay 13.9% on 20 million in capital gains"??????

Really?

So someone who is paying 13.9% of 20 MILLION dollars, that is not "paying MORE" than others?????

See, I am on to you loony libs/Democrats, I KNOW see what you do when you whail about the dreaded "rich" not paying "more". You dearly LOVE to dwell on percentages in these cases, yet when we discuss cost, paying, earning, ANYTHING ELSE other than taxes, we discuss dollar amounts.

The military paid X dollars for a hammer and you are shocked. A welfare mom gets X amount of dollars and you Democrats howl about how she can't live off of that. Obamicare costs "only" X dollars, actually less than the Y dollars you believe we spend taking care of the uninsured now. On and on we can go............

But NOT when you are crying about wanting more of the monies of OTHER PEOPLE. No, THEN it is a percentage. To be "fair".(?)

Look, we have people who contribute almost nothing, some who contribute hundreds, some thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, even millions of dollars every year to our government. We ALSO have some who will not ONLY not contribute any but will actuall receive some of what others contribute.

And ALL of us will benefit from what our government provides. We ALL, regardless of what if any we contribute, benefit from our military, our roads, schools etc.

Yet SOME will "pay" little or nothing. SOME will pay tons of dollars. Those will benefit from the government as will thos who contribute little. However, those who contribute little will ALSO benefit from government supplied checks, homes, transportation, foot, clothing, daycare, healthcare etc.

How is that "fair"?

To be "fair" as you libs want to define it here the "rich" should be forced to pay a percentage of their worth for EVERYTHING, not just taxes.

A grocery buggy full of food may cost a single mother of four 50% of whatever her weekly check is so to be "fair" the "rich" SHOULD have to pay 50% of THEIR income for a week for the same amount of food, right?

Shit, why should Donald Trump get the exact same food for "only" one half of one percent of what HE earns in a week as this poor lady above, know what I mean, sport?

And who should define who is "rich"? The guy living in a freezer box under an overpass might look at the guy living in a trailer park and think he looks "rich". Shouldn't we accept the opinions of everyone equally, to be "fair", I mean?


Straight up, how much of other people's monies would it take to satasify that insane lust all of you Democrats/libs suffer from, bo, give us a chance to argue or agree..............

Poor Uppy, never gets tired of defending his wealthy overlords or waiting to be tinkled on. :)
 
Such wit.........

now that you feel you have amused all of your libby pals, care to even attempt to address anything I presented?

Or, as I would bet, will you once again opt to avoid actually trying to explain your insane lust for more and more of what others have?

With respect sport, you never EVER say anything new. So i really can't entertain you with another response to this your pet cause of yours that i've covered over and over and over again.
 
Talk about something being, "tired and laughable", bo-bo......DAMN.

"People who make more, pay more. Or at least they did until recently where they pay 13.9% on 20 million in capital gains"??????

Really?

So someone who is paying 13.9% of 20 MILLION dollars, that is not "paying MORE" than others?????

See, I am on to you loony libs/Democrats, I KNOW see what you do when you whail about the dreaded "rich" not paying "more". You dearly LOVE to dwell on percentages in these cases, yet when we discuss cost, paying, earning, ANYTHING ELSE other than taxes, we discuss dollar amounts.

The military paid X dollars for a hammer and you are shocked. A welfare mom gets X amount of dollars and you Democrats howl about how she can't live off of that. Obamicare costs "only" X dollars, actually less than the Y dollars you believe we spend taking care of the uninsured now. On and on we can go............

But NOT when you are crying about wanting more of the monies of OTHER PEOPLE. No, THEN it is a percentage. To be "fair".(?)

Look, we have people who contribute almost nothing, some who contribute hundreds, some thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, even millions of dollars every year to our government. We ALSO have some who will not ONLY not contribute any but will actuall receive some of what others contribute.

And ALL of us will benefit from what our government provides. We ALL, regardless of what if any we contribute, benefit from our military, our roads, schools etc.

Yet SOME will "pay" little or nothing. SOME will pay tons of dollars. Those will benefit from the government as will thos who contribute little. However, those who contribute little will ALSO benefit from government supplied checks, homes, transportation, foot, clothing, daycare, healthcare etc.

How is that "fair"?

To be "fair" as you libs want to define it here the "rich" should be forced to pay a percentage of their worth for EVERYTHING, not just taxes.

A grocery buggy full of food may cost a single mother of four 50% of whatever her weekly check is so to be "fair" the "rich" SHOULD have to pay 50% of THEIR income for a week for the same amount of food, right?

Shit, why should Donald Trump get the exact same food for "only" one half of one percent of what HE earns in a week as this poor lady above, know what I mean, sport?

And who should define who is "rich"? The guy living in a freezer box under an overpass might look at the guy living in a trailer park and think he looks "rich". Shouldn't we accept the opinions of everyone equally, to be "fair", I mean?


Straight up, how much of other people's monies would it take to satasify that insane lust all of you Democrats/libs suffer from, bo, give us a chance to argue or agree..............

No one will have an answer for this....this was a " last word" post that leaves no room for honest rebuttal. Well done .

JO
 
Back
Top