New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What exactly is hate speech

Boca

Governor
It should be half a noodle obvious that any answer will be subjective not objective.

But it's kind of important constitutionally since hate speech is close to becoming a crime; heretofore being imprisoned or fined was objectively determined in a court of law.

Is offending someone hate speech? If so, then it gets down to words used. We are all offended by words. If I were to use the words "faggot" or "queer" no doubt someone would be offended. Some are actually offended by quotes from the Bible.

I rather imagine that some were offended when Senator Robert Byrd brought up the subject of "white N*****s" in a live televised interview just a few years ago. Yet he, a former KKK Grand Kleagle " lay in state" as they say in the Capitol Building of the United States? Was that because he was a revered Democrat icon?

Who knows...even though it makes sense it's still confusing.

Except for Saladin, Bugsy, and Fairsheet (a.k.a. mxstpkl or something like that') I'd appreciate your thoughts.
 
"Hate speech" is any true statement about a DEM voting, protected group...... that liberals don't like.
It's that simple.
 
I could call another white person a stupid idiot.....if I said that to a Black or gay person, it would be hate speech. We'll never win......
 
I could call another white person a stupid idiot.....if I said that to a Black or gay person, it would be hate speech. We'll never win......

With what went down in Nevada there's still a chance. Much to the dismay of liberals and the propagandized media, the validity of the 2nd Amendment was validated last week. They can't argue the point.

But back to Byrd...I'm thinking my childhood Unkie Bobby (another story) had Harry in mind when he said that about "white N*****s". After all they served together for decades.
 
Last edited:
...I think you have posted a very interesting topic. One not so easily defined or "legislated". There is a very good discussion on this topic at: http://www.americanbar.org/groups/p...es_awards/students_in_action/debate_hate.html

...in reading through the page they close with a very convincing case where a very controversial individual was allowed to address the student body and describe the result.

Then I about how different groups have handled the late Fred Phelps - it seems the more he was allowed to speak his message, as hate-filled as it was, the more marginalized he and his followers became...

...perhaps hate-speech is like pornography - you'll know it when you hear (see) it
 
I could call another white person a stupid idiot.....if I said that to a Black or gay person, it would be hate speech. We'll never win......

...that's is not necessarily true but I suspect you know that - since when did you start to feel so persecuted?
 
...oh, well here (PJ) and the "real world" are like alternate universe's ;)

That's true...people will be completely different here than they would be in "real" life. Some of these libs I can't stand here, I may get along with great if we went out for dinner and drinks. I have quite a few liberal friends, and we just agree to disagree and we have a great time.....
 
It should be half a noodle obvious that any answer will be subjective not objective.

But it's kind of important constitutionally since hate speech is close to becoming a crime; heretofore being imprisoned or fined was objectively determined in a court of law.

Is offending someone hate speech? If so, then it gets down to words used. We are all offended by words. If I were to use the words "faggot" or "queer" no doubt someone would be offended. Some are actually offended by quotes from the Bible.

I rather imagine that some were offended when Senator Robert Byrd brought up the subject of "white N*****s" in a live televised interview just a few years ago. Yet he, a former KKK Grand Kleagle " lay in state" as they say in the Capitol Building of the United States? Was that because he was a revered Democrat icon?

Who knows...even though it makes sense it's still confusing.

Except for Saladin, Bugsy, and Fairsheet (a.k.a. mxstpkl or something like that') I'd appreciate your thoughts.

Hate speech is useful. It tells you quite plainly who the [Unwelcome language removed] are. Why drive it underground and not know?
 
[quote="Figjam, post: 1044317, member: 8203
...perhaps hate-speech is like pornography - you'll know it when you hear (see) it[/quote]

True....yet some will hear speech and know it to be hate and others won't think anything of it. Hardly the basis for calling it a crime.
 
[quote="Figjam, post: 1044317, member: 8203
...perhaps hate-speech is like pornography - you'll know it when you hear (see) it

True....yet some will hear speech and know it to be hate and others won't think anything of it. Hardly the basis for calling it a crime.[/quote]

...right Boca and that is the problem, I agree.

...it is easy to defend the rights of someone we agree with but equally important are defending the rights of those we disagree with.

...as noted in the discussion piece I referenced, the "legal" definition of hate speech is, "Hate speech is speech that offends, threatens, or insults groups, based on race, color, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, disability, or other traits." They go on to note that, "In this country there is no right to speak fighting words—those words without social value, directed to a specific individual, that would provoke a reasonable member of the group about whom the words are spoken."

...in any case, this is a very interesting topic for thought...
 
It should be half a noodle obvious that any answer will be subjective not objective.

But it's kind of important constitutionally since hate speech is close to becoming a crime; heretofore being imprisoned or fined was objectively determined in a court of law.

Is offending someone hate speech? If so, then it gets down to words used. We are all offended by words. If I were to use the words "faggot" or "queer" no doubt someone would be offended. Some are actually offended by quotes from the Bible.

I rather imagine that some were offended when Senator Robert Byrd brought up the subject of "white N*****s" in a live televised interview just a few years ago. Yet he, a former KKK Grand Kleagle " lay in state" as they say in the Capitol Building of the United States? Was that because he was a revered Democrat icon?

Who knows...even though it makes sense it's still confusing.

Except for Saladin, Bugsy, and Fairsheet (a.k.a. mxstpkl or something like that') I'd appreciate your thoughts.

I agree that it is hard to have a non-subjective definition, but what is needed is a legal definition hopefully agreed upon by people who are able to be rational and sane.

In my opinion hate speech is the use of pejorative wording (and the exact words really do not matter) meant to degrade and/or demean a particular group of people AND that are spoken or written in a place where those words can actually damage those people.

While there are certain words that we believe ARE hate speech no matter what, I don't think that's true. Any word can be used in such a way that it is not indicative of "hate speech". Those words should never be used in casual conversation, but when quoting someone (for example) the person doing the quoting is not guilty of "hate speech". So context must always be considered.

Some words not normally associated with hate speech can rise to that level when used in the context of hate. I feel that to be legally defined as "hate speech", two things must be present:
1. Pejorative words aimed at a person(s) and regarding that person's being in a specific group of people that is being slandered.
2. The words written or stated in a place where the person(s) they are aimed at can actually be harmed by them (loss of job, community standing, etc). Hate crimes involve harm. Hate speech should likewise involve harm. Just calling someone a name is no doubt hate speech, but should not be hate speech in a legal sense.
 
Last edited:
It should be half a noodle obvious that any answer will be subjective not objective.

But it's kind of important constitutionally since hate speech is close to becoming a crime; heretofore being imprisoned or fined was objectively determined in a court of law.

Is offending someone hate speech? If so, then it gets down to words used. We are all offended by words. If I were to use the words "faggot" or "queer" no doubt someone would be offended. Some are actually offended by quotes from the Bible.

I rather imagine that some were offended when Senator Robert Byrd brought up the subject of "white N*****s" in a live televised interview just a few years ago. Yet he, a former KKK Grand Kleagle " lay in state" as they say in the Capitol Building of the United States? Was that because he was a revered Democrat icon?

Who knows...even though it makes sense it's still confusing.

Except for Saladin, Bugsy, and Fairsheet (a.k.a. mxstpkl or something like that') I'd appreciate your thoughts.

Fairsheets is Kookie?

I thought he was either Smiley or Anse?

As for what is hate speech, well it is anything the right will write, and has wrote in the past... ( Joke )

Being serious I believe hate speech is anything that will incite hatred towards any group or individual...

It would be like a Progressive calling Condi Rice a House Negro that stayed on the plantation is consider hate speech, or when someone from the Tea Party right uses the N word to describe Obama or Holder...

I believe hate speech can be done from any race but the danger of passing a hate speech law would be how do the enforce it and will minorities be also held to the same standard as the white population of this country?

Also passing a Hate Speech law make me wounder if it can get past the USSC or be stroke down as Un-Constitutional?

Passing a law like that is not a wise thing to do even if the Progressive left believe it is... Passing a law like that would also allow the right to limit the left radical hate speech and deny them the basic freedoms that we have under our Bill of Rights...

In the end if a Hate Speech were ever pass and upheld by the USSC then the days of our freedoms would be gone forever...
 
[quote="Figjam, post: 1044317, member: 8203
...perhaps hate-speech is like pornography - you'll know it when you hear (see) it True....yet some will hear speech and know it to be hate and others won't think anything of it. Hardly the basis for calling it a crime.

Can you give me an example of someone who has been wrongly convicted of a hate crime? You do know there has to be a crime to go with the declaration that it was because of your hatred, don't you?

When those bozos in TX dragged a man to death for being black, was that a hate crime?

Was Matthew Shepard's torture and murder for being gay a hate crime?

Is it really that ambiguous? Someone who does that once will do it again for the same reason. I think everyone understands that when it comes to pedophiles. We want them under the jail. We have tailored the law to single them out to achieve that. A commonly targeted group needs extra protection. Violent bigots deserve less.
 
"In this country there is no right to speak fighting words—those words without social value, directed to a specific individual, that would provoke a reasonable member of the group about whom the words are spoken."

Back in my day, "yo momma wears combat boots" were fighting words. I saw no social value in it and thus was provoked on more than one occasion. Nothing like a bloody nose to set things straight...but that was then and this is now.

I think that now, as we become less and less unified as a nation and a people, it's far worse.
 
Back
Top