New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What next?

fxstc

Council Member
What next does the anti gun-nut lobby want?
What next will the anti gun-nut GET?

"We cannot continue to rely on our military in order to achieve the national security objectives that we've set. We've got to have a civilian national security force that's just as powerful, just as strong, just as well-funded."
"People of all ages, stations, and skills will be asked to serve."
 
Oh boy. Another out of context, excruciatingly dishonest distortion from a winger. A fan of Paul Broun, no doubt.

What is the truth behind Obama's statements that he wants to create a "civilian national security force that's just as powerful, just as strong, just as well-funded "?
A: This false claim is a badly distorted version of Obama's call for doubling the Peace Corps, creating volunteer networks and increasing the size of the Foreign Service.


The story carried a headline, "Georgia congressman warns of Obama dictatorship." It said that Broun "fears that President-elect Obama will establish a Gestapo-like security force to impose a Marxist or fascist dictatorship." And it quoted him this way:

Rep. Paul Broun, Nov. 10: It may sound a bit crazy and off base, but the thing is, he's the one who proposed this national security force. ... That's exactly what Hitler did in Nazi Germany and it's exactly what the Soviet Union did.

Similar claims have been circulating in right-leaning blogs and conservative Web sites ever since July, when Obama made a single reference to a "civilian national security force" in a campaign speech in Colorado. Obama's detractors make much of his expansive (and exaggerated) description of such a force as being "just as powerful, just as strong, just as well-funded" as the U.S. military. They also ignore the context.

Obama was not talking about a "security force" with guns or police powers. He was talking specifically about expanding AmeriCorps and the Peace Corps and the USA Freedom Corps, which is the volunteer initiative launched by the Bush administration after the attacks of 9/11, and about increasing the number of trained Foreign Service officers who populate U.S. embassies overseas.


http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=118x342608#342610
 
What will get passed is Universal background checks and perhaps the start of universal registration. And a ban on large capacity magazines.
 
You cannot have an UNARMED civilian force JUST as strong as the military.

You cannot have an ARMED civilian force JUST as strong as the military either....so the "We need our guns to fight a potential tyranny" b.s. makes no sense.


BTW, what's next?

The President puts out some proposals that have 70-80% support by the public....and he ONCE AGAIN boxes in the GOP into supporting the fringe position and thus further damaging their brand with the mainstream of America.

Thanks for asking. :)
 
I provided you a link to what Obama actually said and meant.

By all means, avoid reading it and keep on embarrassing yourself.
 
You cannot have an ARMED civilian force JUST as strong as the military either....so the "We need our guns to fight a potential tyranny" b.s. makes no sense.
Sure you can - if you let civillians have private "bearing" of the most powerful weapons in the Foederal Arsenal. And this WAS THE CASE during the first 120 or so years of the republic. Until the Civil War showed how modern weaponry was simply not viable to be held by private individuals.
 
Why do you think we want to seize all guns? We need them to arm our jack booted muslim storm troopers from Kenya!

Prepare for the imposition of Sharia Law, infidel!
 
What part of "JUST AS POWERFUL" as the military, do you not understand?
I fully understand it... but apparently the Supreme Court does not and has not for almost 100 years since Miller when it allowed the banning of "dangerous" weapons. Remember that in Heller Scalia even mused that "to Bear Arms" only applied to those "arms" a single individual could personally "bear" (ie physically carry). and Alito in McDonald went further asserting that the fear of an oppressive Foederal Military HAD NOT APPLIED to the 2nd amendment since the late 1800s...
 
I don't pay much attention to people who aren't aware that he's in his second term as POTUS.

From your stupid American Stinker link:

"Senator Obama aims to tap into the already active volunteerism of millions of Americans"
 
BTW, I see no evidence that you read my link. The one you provided just doubles down on the stupid dishonesty of conflating out of context quotes. Good job, Mittwit.
 
I fully understand it... but apparently the Supreme Court does not and has not for almost 100 years since Miller when it allowed the banning of "dangerous" weapons. Remember that in Heller Scalia even mused that "to Bear Arms" only applied to those "arms" a single individual could personally "bear" (ie physically carry). and Alito in McDonald went further asserting that the fear of an oppressive Foederal Military HAD NOT APPLIED to the 2nd amendment since the late 1800s...

The question doesnt pertain to what happened a hundred years ago, as the staement made by Obama was made only a few years ago.
If a court HAD to look at his statement today, how would they interpret it?
 
I fully understand it... but apparently the Supreme Court does not and has not for almost 100 years since Miller when it allowed the banning of "dangerous" weapons. Remember that in Heller Scalia even mused that "to Bear Arms" only applied to those "arms" a single individual could personally "bear" (ie physically carry). and Alito in McDonald went further asserting that the fear of an oppressive Foederal Military HAD NOT APPLIED to the 2nd amendment since the late 1800s...

This is not "an in your face question" but
Are you saying that if President Obama were to authorize, or attempt to authorize arming a civilian group, it would be unconstitutional?
 
The question doesnt pertain to what happened a hundred years ago, as the staement made by Obama was made only a few years ago.
If a court HAD to look at his statement today, how would they interpret it?
Which statement? Again - YOUR CLAIM was that the court has never ruled on Assault weapons. And what I pointed out is that you are wrong. While it is true that they do not have a ruling that specifically invokes Assault weapons, they also do not have a ruling that specifically invokes WMD (Padilla) or homemade bombs (Nichols, Zazi and others). But they do have Miller which sets the precedent for allowing the banning of ALL arms considered "dangerous" or "Unusual".

so in that context, Obama's statement about the "danger" posed by large ammo clips or the "danger" posed by gun sales without background checks (also invokes the Interstate Commerce Clause via Raich) and Obama is on solid Constitutional footing.
 
I fully understand it... but apparently the Supreme Court does not and has not for almost 100 years since Miller when it allowed the banning of "dangerous" weapons. Remember that in Heller Scalia even mused that "to Bear Arms" only applied to those "arms" a single individual could personally "bear" (ie physically carry). and Alito in McDonald went further asserting that the fear of an oppressive Foederal Military HAD NOT APPLIED to the 2nd amendment since the late 1800s...

This is not "an in your face question" but
Are you saying that if President Obama were to authorize, or attempt to authorize arming a civilian group, it would be unconstitutional?

And if he did, that you would oppose such a move?
 
This is not "an in your face question" but
Are you saying that if President Obama were to authorize, or attempt to authorize arming a civilian group, it would be unconstitutional?
No because Article 1 Section 8 allows for the Foederal Government to "call forth the militia".... but the purpose of the 2nd Amendment was to reassure states - particularly southern states - that they could have the armament to revolt against an overly oppressive Foederal Government. Particularly one that had become disconnected from the individual states.

And Alito in McDonald threw out that as a basis for 2nd Amendment challenges.
 
Which statement? Again - YOUR CLAIM was that the court has never ruled on Assault weapons. And what I pointed out is that you are wrong. While it is true that they do not have a ruling that specifically invokes Assault weapons, they also do not have a ruling that specifically invokes WMD (Padilla) or homemade bombs (Nichols, Zazi and others). But they do have Miller which sets the precedent for allowing the banning of ALL arms considered "dangerous" or "Unusual".

so in that context, Obama's statement about the "danger" posed by large ammo clips or the "danger" posed by gun sales without background checks (also invokes the Interstate Commerce Clause via Raich) and Obama is on solid Constitutional footing.

I believe I specifically said SCOTUS has never made a ruling on assault weapons.
 
Back
Top