New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

What seems apparent.

JV-12

Mayor
A Catholic, like myself, speaks of the realities and of the Catholic faith and its virtues and the “thoughtful” response I might get is “why should we listen to baby rapers?”

Christianity has raised the dignity of women who were subjugated and treated as property by nearly all pagan contemporaries and the enemies of the Church have it in their mind that women have been only persecuted by this faith because of a male priesthood.

You document a million instances where the Church has been charitable to the most needy in this world, sacrificed themselves thousands of times as missionaries caring for strangers with food, medicine, education, etc., and all they can speak to is the Inquistion or the Crusades. Bear in mind their secular version of either of those events is of gross distortions and claims.

They accuse the Catholic Church of being enemies of science and progress because of Galileo, but totally ignore the facts of history. The Catholic Church has made innumerable contributions to science in every century, along with enormous advances on government, law, education, medicine, et al.

The facts of the miracle at Fatima are undeniable, they are reluctantly admitted to in a Lisbon Marxist newspaper by those journalists who were initially there to mock the prophesied sign to come. The eye witnesses are in the tens of thousands. The predictions of Mary come true. And the whole matter is dismissed by the skeptics or referred to as mass hallucination. Either way, it is always forgotten, and yet they demand “give us a sign.”

Weeping statues of Mary or Jesus number in the scores. No one really wants to investigate said phenomena. They prefer to contend the witnesses all lie or that the nuns are assembling gimmicks to feign the miracle. Yes, real integrity or scholarship there.

Padre Pio has to suffer with hands and feet bleeding daily for 50 years as a true sign from God, but the proud and defiant are sure he is faking it for attention. They ignore how truly impossible such a task would be to stage, but still act as though God never manifests himself in any credible way. To these deniers of the faith no miracle assumes any greater credibility than an alleged image of Mary on a grill cheese sandwich.

The Catholic Church teaches that all are sinners, prone to human weakness and temptation and fall short of the glory. And so when it occurs repeatedly within the priesthood, the mocker uses this as his evidence the faith is false. No matter it is a very small percentage of priest guilty of gross disobedience, they remain the reason all priests are of no value, the reason the teachings of Christ are false. Indulgences were sold as a fast ticket to heaven and Martin Luther rebelled, and threw the baby out with the bath water. The Church has shown great sin and weakness and paid heavy prices, but the truths remain. So does all its virtues. Even Christ had a traitor in his own ranks, why should we expect purity in ours?

They accuse the pope of acting as though he is perfect, infallible in all his words. Of course they should know that has never been the case, but still it is waged against the Church. Meanwhile, we acknowledge corrupt popes in the past and try to explain it is not the man who is divinely ordained, it is the office established by Christ, first with fallible Peter.

Some new age philosopher of educated or amateur status assures the world that “I am spiritual but not religious.” Another gains viral popularity by saying “I love Jesus but hate religion.” How insightful and profound! These are the voices of people who do not want to find the one true God, the voices of people who want to live their lives according to how they would like God to be --- that is, one who lets them have their cake and eat it too. Oh please go on preaching because Augustine and Aquinas and Padre Pio were fanciful fools who led so much of us astray hitherto.

Another tiresome defense of secularism: “religion is the cause of more wars than all others.” As wrong as that is, the fact they have to keep using the word “religion” so they can group Catholicism with Islam, et al. is disingenuous. But still they take comfort in that thinking this is a good reason to ignore God in any church.

Then we must suffer idiotic musings such as “Can God make a rock too heavy for Him to lift?” As though if we cannot answer that question satisfactorily then they think they have demonstrated we have a faith that makes no sense. What is the true ulterior motivation for all their bizarre questions?... it is obvious.

Oh and now there is another “scholar” who thinks because we are at odds with the definition of atheism according to his understanding of the Catholic position or whatever, that we are lost in the details. We have no clue what we are preaching. As though a battle of semantics is the crux of the matter. Insufferable sophistry.


So here it is. Yes, secular and agnostic world, we know and admit that many of our priests and bishops are guilty of heinous crimes against their fellow man. It is unforgiveable (in some sense only), especially the cover-ups. This wound in the Church and its effectiveness in witnessing will never heal. The devil has won a great battle. We know this. All that can be done now is to ask forgiveness and try to make amends with the victims of the past and corrections for the future. And despite foes calling Benedict a nazi and an enabler he has made great efforts to do the right thing. It will never be acknowledged. Even though less than 5% of priests have been accused or involved and an even smaller percentage of bishops engaged in a cover-up, the whole Church is guilty, the whole Church is corrupt, and their many accusers are the true “holy ones” of this world apparently?

So, fine, it if it be your lot in life to use the sex scandals and cover-up to dismiss all truths revealed by the Catholic Church since the time of Christ, then so be it. Let that be your defense when you come before your Creator at the time of death. Tell God why you ignored all the truths preached to you, why you demanded a sign but then callously dismissed all those signs with the most flimsy of arguments. Tell God the reason you went through life without any real prayer, why you taught your children nothing of spiritual importance, why you did not think being that charitable to your neighbor mattered that much, was because you were angry at the Catholic Church for sex scandals. Tell God the reason you were sure all that was revealed by the Catholic Church was false or meaningless was because you knew of some bishops who did not properly report a priest who committed a sexual crime. Tell God the reason you engaged in a life of materialism, lust, self indulgences and comfort was because you never saw any sign of God or eternal truths during your life’s experiences, so you felt entitled to go it your own way. And any time some witness brought forth the love of Christ in the Church or a reason to believe, you just said “what good is a church that has baby rapers?” It will all make perfect sense to a God who apparently never expected anything more than that from you.


“For in the way you judge, you will be judged; and by your standard of measure, it will be measured to you.”
 
I rejected your chosen religion long before the pedophile Priests were brought to light. They aren't really the problem -- they are merely one symptom of the problem.
 
gigi, you asked me "Who said the Catholic Church was perfect?".....well?


Well, what, Gordon?

YESTERDAY, a full day before JV wrote this post, you claimed he said the Catholic Church was perfect. I asked you yesterday to show me where he said that and you never answered me.
Usually you'll take a half sentence or a line out of context with ... to replace what was actually said that belies your asserton. But you didn't even give me that.


Now he writes a post about the Church, never claims the Church is perfect but instead speaks very frankly about problems the Church has had, and you're trying to use that? Something he wrote after you accused him of something he didn't say in the first place?

BS. I"m sorry but there is no more accurate or kinder term for it.
 
JV,

That was a agreat post. With your permission I'd like to copy it.

Here, mostly, you'll get dead air on what you've actually said though. They're not interested in the truth of what goes on in or what is believed by the Church. Especially when someone near and dear to many of them has positioned himself as the latest David to the Goliath people he can count on, like Maureen Dowd, work to fabricate. Even Catholics here will perpetuate lies about Church teaching for the sake of politics. Not much that can or should be done, except to take heart in the fact that nothing anyone says can actually change the Truth.

It's one thing not to be a particular religion. It's quite another to lie about that religion in order to turn people off to it. These are two very different things and I think motivation is what God will judge in the end. As least that's what we're all taught. I don't think there's a Catholic around who can deny that intention is a big deal with God.
 
this fairy godfather you speak of may be apparent to you but we dont see it. what we DO see very plainly is an organization that reassigns child molestors, hiding them from the police and allowing them to molest again. THAT is very apparent!! And That is what should be judged!
 
its not the priests that are the major problem. it is the cover up by the heirarchy! THAT is the real problem. they allow a few priests to pay the price and no one has the guts to after the higher ups.
 
One has to consider the medium, JV. Many people are genuinely unaware of how the CC understands itself, and for those, any clarification can be helpful. It is also good, if somewhat bracing, to see what some people think, IMO, about the CC.
 
Well, what, Gordon?

YESTERDAY, a full day before JV wrote this post, you claimed he said the Catholic Church was perfect. I asked you yesterday to show me where he said that and you never answered me.
Usually you'll take a half sentence or a line out of context with ... to replace what was actually said that belies your asserton. But you didn't even give me that.


Now he writes a post about the Church, never claims the Church is perfect but instead speaks very frankly about problems the Church has had, and you're trying to use that? Something he wrote after you accused him of something he didn't say in the first place?

BS. I"m sorry but there is no more accurate or kinder term for it.

He doesn't "speak frankly about the problems of the Church"....he uses the "few bad apples, but compared to everything it's done throughout the centuries, no big deal...and besides the RCC is God's sole source of Truth" apologia....same as he always does.

And again, YOU tried to change it to "the people IN the Church were perfect"....not what I said.

I said those who claim THE CHURCH is perfect...as an institution in and of itself.

Does JV deny that???
 
Then we must suffer idiotic musings such as “Can God make a rock too heavy for Him to lift?” As though if we cannot answer that question satisfactorily then they think they have demonstrated we have a faith that makes no sense. What is the true ulterior motivation for all their bizarre questions?... it is obvious.

And what IS that "true ulterior motivation"?
 
"Christianity has raised the dignity of women who were subjugated and treated as property by nearly all pagan contemporaries and the enemies of the Church have it in their mind that women have been only persecuted by this faith because of a male priesthood."

Wrong - many Pagan communities treated women as equals, women even fought in battle alongside their men.

As for the Catholic Church and the dignity of women - you have to be joking.

The local Council of Carthage in North Africa (from 345 AD) introduced rules imposing abstinence from intercourse on bishops, priests and deacons.

Local Councils in France: Orange (441 AD) and Epaon (517 AD), decreed that no women deacons were to be ordained in their region. The obvious reason was the fear of menstruous women defiling the sanctuary.

Pope Gelasius I (494 AD) objected to women serving at the altar.

The diocesan Synod of Auxerre (588 AD) decreed that women had to cover their hands with a ‘dominical’ cloth in order to receive communion.

The Synod of Rouen (650 AD) forbade priests to give the chalice into the hands of women or to allow them to help in distributing communion.

Bishop Timothy of Alexandria (680 AD) laid down that couples should abstain from intercourse on Saturdays and Sundays and on the day before receiving communion. Menstruous women may not receive communion, may not receive baptism or visit the Church at Easter.

Bishop Theodore of Canterbury (690 AD), ignoring Pope Gregory the Great's letter to his predecessor, forbade menstruant women to visit a church or receive holy communion. Mothers remained unclean for forty days after giving birth.

Bishop Theodulf of Orléans (820 AD) forbade women to enter the sanctuary. Also: “Women should remember their infirmity, and the inferiority of their sex: and therefore they should have fear of touching whatever sacred things there are in the ministry of the Church.”

Even Islam, gave women legal rights, at a time when the CC denied them any.

Sure the Church has been charitable to many of the worlds' needy, so have many other organisations, and individuals. Also, many other religious bodies sent missionaries all round the world. Hell, we even get Mormon missionaries knocking the doors here in Scotland.

I see you gaily skip past the inquisition, and the crusades, and, no mention of the genocide against the Cathars - that's where the famous saying: "kill them all, God will sort them out" originated; Pope Innocent III, if my memory is correct.



I would love to see you list the contributions that the CC has made to science and medicine - another joke?

The miracles of Fatima; the big proof of God. There's lots of healing springs dotted around the world. In Europe, all of the early Catholic churches were built on the sites of pagan holy springs. Sure, people go to Lourdes and get cured, a very, very, small percentage of them. No mention of the millions who go, and return, in the same state they started out with.

As for weeping statues etc - I give up.

The sexual abuse by Catholic priests isn't something casual, as you try to make out. It's pandemic. It's something that has been happening all over the world. You must know that the prior consideration of the Catholic Church is the preservation of the Church.

As long as you aren't taking any beans off my table I don't give a darn what superstition you follow.
 
for the moment, only the points about science & medicine:

Uh, IIRC, the university system in Europe was founded by Catholic institutions. Now, are you going to take a guy like George LeMaitre as part of the Church, or only an individual who happened to be a priest? The list of well known science types who are also catholic priests or deacons might be pretty lengthy. Francis Bacon? Gregor Mendel? Copernicus, a deacon?

http://www.catholic.com/magazine/articles/fathers-of-science

FWIW, a Wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Roman_Catholic_cleric–scientists
 
The top post was remarkably well thought out, and written. One needn't be Catholic, nor accept it point by point, to see that.

In particular, I appreciate mention of the fact that established religions do far more good than bad. The top-poster writes of Catholicism specifically, but I think this truth extends to established religions generally. After all, if they didn't do more good than bad, they wouldn't have become established!

So....some choose to focus on the bad. That's alright with me. Somebody's got to focus on the bad. But, all too many of the "focus on the badders" seem to believe that by ridding ourselves of religion, we eliminate the bad. Maybe that's true, but we ALSO eliminate the good. And, if there is no good, isn't that bad?
 
'' Christianity has raised the dignity of women who were subjugated and treated as property by nearly all pagan contemporaries and the enemies of the Church have it in their mind that women have been only persecuted by this faith because of a male priesthood ''

Christianity has raised the dignity of women ?!!!! Dear Lord the last time we saw true equality between the sexes was The Bronze Age before Literalist Christianity what are you talking about ? ................ You may know all about the RCC but you seem to know bugger all about other Philosophys and Religions JV- .therefore you have nothing to compare the RCC with in reality. well except the propogandas that have lasted two thousand years.

Aaaand within Islam women are equal, ok in practice things don't always work out as they should but we can say that of both Christianity and Isalm.
 
A Catholic, like myself, speaks of the realities and of the Catholic faith and its virtues and the “thoughtful” response I might get is “why should we listen to baby rapers?”

Christianity has raised the dignity of women who were subjugated and treated as property by nearly all pagan contemporaries and the enemies of the Church have it in their mind that women have been only persecuted by this faith because of a male priesthood.

You document a million instances where the Church has been charitable to the most needy in this world, sacrificed themselves thousands of times as missionaries caring for strangers with food, medicine, education, etc., and all they can speak to is the Inquistion or the Crusades. Bear in mind their secular version of either of those events is of gross distortions and claims.

They accuse the Catholic Church of being enemies of science and progress because of Galileo, but totally ignore the facts of history. The Catholic Church has made innumerable contributions to science in every century, along with enormous advances on government, law, education, medicine, et al.

The facts of the miracle at Fatima are undeniable, they are reluctantly admitted to in a Lisbon Marxist newspaper by those journalists who were initially there to mock the prophesied sign to come. The eye witnesses are in the tens of thousands. The predictions of Mary come true. And the whole matter is dismissed by the skeptics or referred to as mass hallucination. Either way, it is always forgotten, and yet they demand “give us a sign.”

Weeping statues of Mary or Jesus number in the scores. No one really wants to investigate said phenomena. They prefer to contend the witnesses all lie or that the nuns are assembling gimmicks to feign the miracle. Yes, real integrity or scholarship there.

Padre Pio has to suffer with hands and feet bleeding daily for 50 years as a true sign from God, but the proud and defiant are sure he is faking it for attention. They ignore how truly impossible such a task would be to stage, but still act as though God never manifests himself in any credible way. To these deniers of the faith no miracle assumes any greater credibility than an alleged image of Mary on a grill cheese sandwich.

The Catholic Church teaches that all are sinners, prone to human weakness and temptation and fall short of the glory. And so when it occurs repeatedly within the priesthood, the mocker uses this as his evidence the faith is false. No matter it is a very small percentage of priest guilty of gross disobedience, they remain the reason all priests are of no value, the reason the teachings of Christ are false. Indulgences were sold as a fast ticket to heaven and Martin Luther rebelled, and threw the baby out with the bath water. The Church has shown great sin and weakness and paid heavy prices, but the truths remain. So does all its virtues. Even Christ had a traitor in his own ranks, why should we expect purity in ours?

They accuse the pope of acting as though he is perfect, infallible in all his words. Of course they should know that has never been the case, but still it is waged against the Church. Meanwhile, we acknowledge corrupt popes in the past and try to explain it is not the man who is divinely ordained, it is the office established by Christ, first with fallible Peter.

Some new age philosopher of educated or amateur status assures the world that “I am spiritual but not religious.” Another gains viral popularity by saying “I love Jesus but hate religion.” How insightful and profound! These are the voices of people who do not want to find the one true God, the voices of people who want to live their lives according to how they would like God to be --- that is, one who lets them have their cake and eat it too. Oh please go on preaching because Augustine and Aquinas and Padre Pio were fanciful fools who led so much of us astray hitherto.

Another tiresome defense of secularism: “religion is the cause of more wars than all others.” As wrong as that is, the fact they have to keep using the word “religion” so they can group Catholicism with Islam, et al. is disingenuous. But still they take comfort in that thinking this is a good reason to ignore God in any church.

Then we must suffer idiotic musings such as “Can God make a rock too heavy for Him to lift?” As though if we cannot answer that question satisfactorily then they think they have demonstrated we have a faith that makes no sense. What is the true ulterior motivation for all their bizarre questions?... it is obvious.

Oh and now there is another “scholar” who thinks because we are at odds with the definition of atheism according to his understanding of the Catholic position or whatever, that we are lost in the details. We have no clue what we are preaching. As though a battle of semantics is the crux of the matter. Insufferable sophistry.


So here it is. Yes, secular and agnostic world, we know and admit that many of our priests and bishops are guilty of heinous crimes against their fellow man. It is unforgiveable (in some sense only), especially the cover-ups. This wound in the Church and its effectiveness in witnessing will never heal. The devil has won a great battle. We know this. All that can be done now is to ask forgiveness and try to make amends with the victims of the past and corrections for the future. And despite foes calling Benedict a nazi and an enabler he has made great efforts to do the right thing. It will never be acknowledged. Even though less than 5% of priests have been accused or involved and an even smaller percentage of bishops engaged in a cover-up, the whole Church is guilty, the whole Church is corrupt, and their many accusers are the true “holy ones” of this world apparently?

So, fine, it if it be your lot in life to use the sex scandals and cover-up to dismiss all truths revealed by the Catholic Church since the time of Christ, then so be it. Let that be your defense when you come before your Creator at the time of death. Tell God why you ignored all the truths preached to you, why you demanded a sign but then callously dismissed all those signs with the most flimsy of arguments. Tell God the reason you went through life without any real prayer, why you taught your children nothing of spiritual importance, why you did not think being that charitable to your neighbor mattered that much, was because you were angry at the Catholic Church for sex scandals. Tell God the reason you were sure all that was revealed by the Catholic Church was false or meaningless was because you knew of some bishops who did not properly report a priest who committed a sexual crime. Tell God the reason you engaged in a life of materialism, lust, self indulgences and comfort was because you never saw any sign of God or eternal truths during your life’s experiences, so you felt entitled to go it your own way. And any time some witness brought forth the love of Christ in the Church or a reason to believe, you just said “what good is a church that has baby rapers?” It will all make perfect sense to a God who apparently never expected anything more than that from you.


“For in the way you judge, you will be judged; and by your standard of measure, it will be measured to you.”

I'm responding right now only to the "raising the dignity of women" aspect of this. First of all, one doesn't "raise the dignity" of women; women have dignity already; a dignity that exists outside of any 'ruling' body to 'raise' it - what an incredibly rude and insufferable thing to say at the outset. Second, outside of patriarchal religions there is no imposition upon women - what an incredibly parochial world view you have. Third, as long as any, ANY, opportunity is denied to women because of their sex you cannot claim that your church has done anything to "raise the dignity" of women. Women don't need you or the catholic church to raise their dignity, they just need you and the catholic church to understand that women have exactly the same claim to dignity (and intelligence, and ability, and leadership, and the ability to give council, and empathy, and understanding of the world, and on and on) as men do. Until the catholic church gets to that level of maturity and leaves off with believing that only a man can be pope ('cause Jesus was a man? well, he had a fifty-fifty chance, eh?) than the catholic church can go stuff itself.
 
I'm responding right now only to the "raising the dignity of women" aspect of this. First of all, one doesn't "raise the dignity" of women; women have dignity already; a dignity that exists outside of any 'ruling' body to 'raise' it - what an incredibly rude and insufferable thing to say at the outset. Second, outside of patriarchal religions there is no imposition upon women - what an incredibly parochial world view you have. Third, as long as any, ANY, opportunity is denied to women because of their sex you cannot claim that your church has done anything to "raise the dignity" of women. Women don't need you or the catholic church to raise their dignity, they just need you and the catholic church to understand that women have exactly the same claim to dignity (and intelligence, and ability, and leadership, and the ability to give council, and empathy, and understanding of the world, and on and on) as men do. Until the catholic church gets to that level of maturity and leaves off with believing that only a man can be pope ('cause Jesus was a man? well, he had a fifty-fifty chance, eh?) than the catholic church can go stuff itself.

I don't agree with your suggestion that dignity is inherent or innate. Dignity is dependent upon others - how they consider and treat me. I can feel that I'm "King of the World!", but unless others consider and treat me like I'm King of the World, I'm but a rambling loon.
 
I'm responding right now only to the "raising the dignity of women" aspect of this. First of all, one doesn't "raise the dignity" of women; women have dignity already; a dignity that exists outside of any 'ruling' body to 'raise' it - what an incredibly rude and insufferable thing to say at the outset. Second, outside of patriarchal religions there is no imposition upon women - what an incredibly parochial world view you have. Third, as long as any, ANY, opportunity is denied to women because of their sex you cannot claim that your church has done anything to "raise the dignity" of women. Women don't need you or the catholic church to raise their dignity, they just need you and the catholic church to understand that women have exactly the same claim to dignity (and intelligence, and ability, and leadership, and the ability to give council, and empathy, and understanding of the world, and on and on) as men do. Until the catholic church gets to that level of maturity and leaves off with believing that only a man can be pope ('cause Jesus was a man? well, he had a fifty-fifty chance, eh?) than the catholic church can go stuff itself.

Brilliant post, BT. All I can say is Thank You.
 
Back
Top