New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Whataboutism

apparently someone has been reading PJ post



My favorite takeaway from your link:

However, there’s a deeper and more dangerous layer here, and it surrounds the issue of “whataboutism.” Whataboutism is a rhetorical trick used to deflect criticism with counter-criticism, and it’s used breathlessly in the debauched world of politics.

A Democrat did what?! Yes, but did you hear what this Republican did?

Yeah, a Republican did that, but that’s nowhere near as bad as what this Democrat did!



Yes, it does sound a lot like this very forum, no?

We can all do better if we are willing to make the effort.
 
apparently someone has been reading PJ post

My favorite takeaway from your link:

However, there’s a deeper and more dangerous layer here, and it surrounds the issue of “whataboutism.” Whataboutism is a rhetorical trick used to deflect criticism with counter-criticism, and it’s used breathlessly in the debauched world of politics.

A Democrat did what?! Yes, but did you hear what this Republican did?

Yeah, a Republican did that, but that’s nowhere near as bad as what this Democrat did!




Yes, it does sound a lot like this very forum, no?

We can all do better if we are willing to make the effort.
We can give thanks to Republicans for the invention of whataboutism.
 
Oh, my guess is they deserve about half of the credit...
Of course it is. But you can't honestly deny that the creation of whataboutism came from Republicans whining "but, but, but..."

And yeah, I'll give credit to using whataboutisms on steroids to Trump.
 
Of course it is. But you can't honestly deny that the creation of whatabouism came from Republicans whining "but, but, but..."

And yeah, I'll give credit to using whataboutisms on steroids, Trump.

Of course I can.

I wouldn't make such a statement unless I could back it up with documentation. Just saying it doesn't impress anyone.

Each side can accuse the other...And they're both right.
 
Of course I can.

I wouldn't make such a statement unless I could back it up with documentation. Just saying it doesn't impress anyone.

Each side can accuse the other...And they're both right.
Then you would be wrong. Do a little reading/research before giving us a whataboutism.
 
Of course I can.

I wouldn't make such a statement unless I could back it up with documentation. Just saying it doesn't impress anyone.

Each side can accuse the other...And they're both right.

exactly what the article said
wo evidently didn't read it
 
Then you would be wrong. Do a little reading/research before giving us a whataboutism.

Here you go:

According to lexicographer Ben Zimmer,[13] the term originated in Northern Ireland in the 1970s. Zimmer cites a 1974 letter by history teacher Sean O'Conaill which was published in The Irish Times where he complained about "the Whatabouts", people who defended the IRA by pointing out supposed wrongdoings of their enemy:

I would not suggest such a thing were it not for the Whatabouts. These are the people who answer every condemnation of the Provisional I.R.A. with an argument to prove the greater immorality of the "enemy", and therefore the justice of the Provisionals' cause: "What about Bloody Sunday, internment, torture, force-feeding, army intimidation?". Every call to stop is answered in the same way: "What about the Treaty of Limerick; the Anglo-Irish treaty of 1921; Lenadoon?". Neither is the Church immune: "The Catholic Church has never supported the national cause. What about Papal sanction for the Norman invasion; condemnation of the Fenians by Moriarty; Parnell?"
— Sean O'Conaill, "Letter to Editor", The Irish Times, 30 Jan 1974

Whataboutism - Wikipedia



Looks like you're incorrect.

See? Documentation.
 
My favorite takeaway from your link:

However, there’s a deeper and more dangerous layer here, and it surrounds the issue of “whataboutism.” Whataboutism is a rhetorical trick used to deflect criticism with counter-criticism, and it’s used breathlessly in the debauched world of politics.

A Democrat did what?! Yes, but did you hear what this Republican did?

Yeah, a Republican did that, but that’s nowhere near as bad as what this Democrat did!




Yes, it does sound a lot like this very forum, no?

We can all do better if we are willing to make the effort.

Yes, someone has been reading PJ post
 
Negative
MV invented it
Sheesh!

Just to be clear, neither middleview nor I invented whataboutism. Republicans just perfected it here in the U.S.


 
Here you go:

According to lexicographer Ben Zimmer,[13] the term originated in Northern Ireland in the 1970s. Zimmer cites a 1974 letter by history teacher Sean O'Conaill which was published in The Irish Times where he complained about "the Whatabouts", people who defended the IRA by pointing out supposed wrongdoings of their enemy:



Whataboutism - Wikipedia



Looks like you're incorrect.

See? Documentation.
No, I'm not incorrect. I stand by what I said that it was/is used here by whining Republicans.
 
No, I'm not incorrect. I stand by what I said that it was/is used here by whining Republicans.

Well, we know for a fact that "Whataboutism" existed at least as far back as the 1970s and appeared at that time in Europe. That's documented.

This disproves your assertion "We can give thanks to Republicans for the invention of whataboutism.".

Whether or not you can admit it or not is up to you, but everyone else will know.


No worries - It's all good.
 
Sheesh!

Just to be clear, neither middleview nor I invented whataboutism. Republicans just perfected it here in the U.S.



now leftist doing with to protect Joey and Camala
 
Well, we know for a fact that "Whataboutism" existed at least as far back as the 1970s, and appeared in Europe.

This disproves your assertion "We can give thanks to Republicans for the invention of whataboutism.".

Whether or not you can admit it or not is up to you, but everyone else will know.


No worries - It's all good.
Have you already forgotten that I distinctly said that "Republicans perfected it here in the U.S." ?

btw, you need to have a talk with Dawg. He thinks middleview invented the term.
 
Have you already forgotten that I distinctly said that "Republicans perfected it here in the U.S." ?

btw, you need to have a talk with Dawg. He thinks middleview invented the term.


Allow me to quoter you directly:


We can give thanks to Republicans for the invention of whataboutism.

Post #3


Whatever you said after that doesn't change what you incorrectly asserted in post #3.


I have even more documentation of how incorrect your assertion is...Before we called it "whatanoutism", it already existed as the "Red Herring Logical Fallacy", which goes back even further:


Red Herring Fallacy Definition
The term “red herring” was coined by William Cobbett in 1807. It’s a metaphor used to refer to a distraction designed to confuse people from the issue at hand.

The metaphor comes from a situation where Cobbett needed to distract some dogs from chasing rabbits in the English woods.

Cobbett’s chosen distraction was strong-smelling red herrings (the fish!). He put the strong-smelling fish out in the woods. The smell of the fish would overwhelm the smell of the rabbits, putting the dogs off the scent. The strong smell of the herring fish to distract dogs from chasing rabbits.

Today, we use the metaphor to explain any situation where someone tries to distract people from the true issue at hand.

Red Herring Fallacy Examples
1. What Aboutism




15 Red Herring Fallacy Examples (2023) (helpfulprofessor.com)


Good reading...Enjoy.
 
Back
Top