New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Where is Obama wrong here?

Bugsy McGurk

President
From a newsmax piece bashing Obama....is anything in it false?

On Saturday, the president presented reporters with the newest iteration of his story, the Times said, when asked if he had any second thoughts about pulling all ground troops out of Iraq.

"What I just find interesting is the degree to which this issue keeps on coming up, as if this was my decision," Obama said, according to the newspaper. "Under the previous administration, we had turned over the country to a sovereign, democratically elected Iraqi government.

"So let’s just be clear: The reason that we did not have a follow-on force in Iraq was because the Iraqis — a majority of Iraqis — did not want U.S. troops there, and politically they could not pass the kind of laws that would be required to protect our troops in Iraq. So that entire analysis is bogus and is wrong. But it gets frequently peddled around here by folks who oftentimes are trying to defend previous policies that they themselves made."

Read Latest Breaking News from Newsmax.com http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/Obama-Iraq-troop-withdrawal-Bush/2014/08/12/id/588204/#ixzz3ACFpKQy0
Urgent: Should Obamacare Be Repealed? Vote Here Now!
 
i think most people agree that obama was simply fulfilling a campaign promise to exit iraq. what they disagree with is his characterization that the al-maliki government was popular and able to secure the freedom of iraqi citizens against terrorists.

if obama is going to use 'the will of the iraqi people' as his rationalization for withdrawal though, why have we continued to stay in afghanistan? they hate us even worse, and karzai is even more unpopular and corrupt?

obama is as inconsistent as he is simplistic.
 
i think most people agree that obama was simply fulfilling a campaign promise to exit iraq. what they disagree with is his characterization that the al-maliki government was popular and able to secure the freedom of iraqi citizens against terrorists.

if obama is going to use 'the will of the iraqi people' as his rationalization for withdrawal though, why have we continued to stay in afghanistan? they hate us even worse, and karzai is even more unpopular and corrupt?

obama is as inconsistent as he is simplistic.

Actually, the Afghan government wanted us to stay, while the opposite was true in Iraq.

But where was Obama wrong in the quoted piece?
 
I don't think he was wrong at what he said...it's true, he tried to keep some of our military in Iraq past the deadline put in place by Bush. But he couldn't just decide on his own to do this without the Iraqi's approval, and he also couldn't have kept them there without having them protected.

I'm also on the fence about WHAT we should do now. I absolutely hate the idea of sending more troops over there (on the ground). The slaughtering needs to be stopped....maybe we should just drop some "special" bombs and take care of the problem all at once.
 
It's called "Saving Face"....Obama clearly stated the wars themselves were stupid, so why is he bowing out to send troops back, when he stood firmly on his campaign promise to pull them out? "Saving Face"

When standing firm only applies to get what you want. the Presidency.
 
I don't think he was wrong at what he said...it's true, he tried to keep some of our military in Iraq past the deadline put in place by Bush. But he couldn't just decide on his own to do this without the Iraqi's approval, and he also couldn't have kept them there without having them protected.

I'm also on the fence about WHAT we should do now. I absolutely hate the idea of sending more troops over there (on the ground). The slaughtering needs to be stopped....maybe we should just drop some "special" bombs and take care of the problem all at once.

An incredibly balanced, honest post. Quite rare in these parts.

I can't imagine Obama putting more ground troops at risk, with the possible exception of helping evacuate those slated for genocide by ISIS, such as the Yazidis. And if Obama does that he will first use all available air power to blast the smithereens out of the ISIS crazies.
 
This is what happens when you meddle in other countries affairs. From the days of Eisenhower til now....America has meddled and muddled in other countries affairs, forcing us to KEEP troops there to keep the peace...how moronic.
 
An incredibly balanced, honest post. Quite rare in these parts.

I can't imagine Obama putting more ground troops at risk, with the possible exception of helping evacuate those slated for genocide by ISIS, such as the Yazidis. And if Obama does that he will first use all available air power to blast the smithereens out of the ISIS crazies.

I agree on trying to get people out of there, especially the Christians that are being slaughtered! But how do you do that without it ending up in more fighting and more deaths to our soldiers? I don't want them going back there...I don't want them in Afghanistan any longer either. Both countries hate us...when we leave Afghanistan the same thing is going to happen there. There are actually people in both of those countries that do like us being there. But the haters outnumber them.

I always thought it was better to have our military over there fighting them on their land and keeping them out of our land. Now, with the mexican border so open it really doesn't matter. They will find a way to get in and that's the easiest way to do it.
 
I agree on trying to get people out of there, especially the Christians that are being slaughtered! But how do you do that without it ending up in more fighting and more deaths to our soldiers? I don't want them going back there...I don't want them in Afghanistan any longer either. Both countries hate us...when we leave Afghanistan the same thing is going to happen there. There are actually people in both of those countries that do like us being there. But the haters outnumber them.

I always thought it was better to have our military over there fighting them on their land and keeping them out of our land. Now, with the mexican border so open it really doesn't matter. They will find a way to get in and that's the easiest way to do it.

There is certainly a risk when attempting to prevent genocide. The alternative is doing nothing and just watching it on TV. I think most Americans are better than that.
 
i think most people agree that obama was simply fulfilling a campaign promise to exit iraq. what they disagree with is his characterization that the al-maliki government was popular and able to secure the freedom of iraqi citizens against terrorists.

if obama is going to use 'the will of the iraqi people' as his rationalization for withdrawal though, why have we continued to stay in afghanistan? they hate us even worse, and karzai is even more unpopular and corrupt?

obama is as inconsistent as he is simplistic.

We are leaving Afghanistan.
 
Back
Top