New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why a flat tax doesn't work

Arkady

President
In a thread below, a conservative objected to the rich paying higher income tax rates, and suggested that it would be fairer to charge everyone the same rate. That's a frequent conservative assertion, but I wonder whether people have considered what it would mean in terms of real world numbers.

The math is actually surprisingly simple. Right now, individual income tax receipts are about $1.2 trillion per year. That's the figure you'd have to hit with your flat tax to make it a revenue-neutral change. Right now there are approximately 119 million households in America, with mean income of about $68,000 per household. What that means is that even if you could collect taxes with 100% efficiency (not a single successful tax-dodger in the country) and you allowed no exemptions at all, you'd need to charge everyone 15% in federal income taxes in order to collect as much with your new flat tax as under the old tax. If there's any cheating, you'd need to set the rate higher than that.

Now, that would be a HUGE tax break for the rich. The top 1% currently pay around 20.6% as an effective federal income tax rate. But it would be an enormous tax hike on the vast majority of people. Obviously, for the roughly half of all Americans who pay no federal income taxes, that would be a huge hit. And considering a lot of them are barely scraping by as it is, it's not clear how they'd cope with suddenly having 15% of their scanty income taken from them. You'd be driving the lower middle class below the poverty rate and driving the poor into a state of utter dependence on the government. But even for the upper-middle-class, a 15% effective federal income tax rate would be a hit.

See here (Summary Table 1, "effective Tax Rate -- Individual Income Taxes):

http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/12-29-2005FedTaxRates.pdf

You'll see that the average effective federal individual income tax rate for the fourth quintile was 5.9% and for the highest quintile was 13.9%. So, if you're in the 60%-80% range (upper middle class), the flat tax would be an enormous increase in your tax liability, and even for those of us in the top 20%, it would be a slight increase (from 13.9% to 15%).

Essentially, what a flat income tax would do would be to hike taxes on 90% of Americans, in exchange for dropping them for the top 10%. If you're poor, it would devastate you, if you were middle class, it would impoverish you, and even if you were upper-middle class it would be a severe hit to the quality of your life. Between the 80th and the 90th percentile, there wouldn't be much of a change, but if you happen to be top-5% it would be a nice windfall, and if you're top 1%, it would be a huge increase in your already luxurious life.

Keep in mind, those are just the results for a revenue-neutral flat tax.... one that would keep our deficit the same size. If you wanted to do a flat tax while balancing the budget, you'd need to bring in more revenues, meaning a significantly higher rate. Depending on the details, you could easily wind up with a tax scheme that was worse for as much as 99% of the population than a progressive tax structure would be.

Presumably, you've done your taxes for the year. So, go and check out what your effective federal income tax rate was (take your tax liability, not counting social security and Medicare, and divide it by your total income, not your adjusted gross). Unless you're unusually wealthy, chances are you'll come up with a figure well below 15%, which means you'd be a lot worse off with a flat tax. That's because, in the end, the math for a flat tax just doesn't work.
 
Run the numbers...or just notice the "plutophilia" (love of the wealthy) that the Right has....and you know that a "Flat Tax" is simply a means by which they tax the rich less...and everybody else MORE (to cover the difference).

It's also political gamesmanship. You get a Flat Tax....then once it's passed you tell the middle class "You are taxed TOO much" and they start cutting and cutting and cutting the "Flat Tax".

With no means of recouping the lost revenue....the money dries up and they target Social Security and Medicare (to protect Defense) and they demand those programs be eliminated....sorry, sorry..."privatized".

In the end, the wealthy move their wealth to off-shore accounts and live off investment income, not wage income.....and you end up with the Right's endgame-

Feudalism....the poor and middle class paying for a military establishment/government...with no social safety net...and the "nobles"...pay little or nothing.
 
Run the numbers...or just notice the "plutophilia" (love of the wealthy) that the Right has....and you know that a "Flat Tax" is simply a means by which they tax the rich less...and everybody else MORE (to cover the difference).

It's also political gamesmanship. You get a Flat Tax....then once it's passed you tell the middle class "You are taxed TOO much" and they start cutting and cutting and cutting the "Flat Tax".

With no means of recouping the lost revenue....the money dries up and they target Social Security and Medicare (to protect Defense) and they demand those programs be eliminated....sorry, sorry..."privatized".

In the end, the wealthy move their wealth to off-shore accounts and live off investment income, not wage income.....and you end up with the Right's endgame-

Feudalism....the poor and middle class paying for a military establishment/government...with no social safety net...and the "nobles"...pay little or nothing.

GG, I believe you have this figured out. Now if we could get the information to everyone...
 
Yep. Even if someone isn't willing to crunch the numbers, a reality check is just to look at who pushes hardest for a flat tax. It's generally guys like Steve Forbes, who know they would get a gigantic decrease in their effective tax rates. From there, all you need to realize, to see that it's a scam against the poor and middle class, is that the money's got to come from somewhere. You can't have one person paying millions of dollars less in taxes per year without others collectively paying millions more. And so, for every rich guy who gets a big cut, you wind up with dozens of regular folks who get hit with hikes.
 
In a thread below, a conservative objected to the rich paying higher income tax rates, and suggested that it would be fairer to charge everyone the same rate. That's a frequent conservative assertion, but I wonder whether people have considered what it would mean in terms of real world numbers.

The math is actually surprisingly simple. Right now, individual income tax receipts are about $1.2 trillion per year. That's the figure you'd have to hit with your flat tax to make it a revenue-neutral change. Right now there are approximately 119 million households in America, with mean income of about $68,000 per household. What that means is that even if you could collect taxes with 100% efficiency (not a single successful tax-dodger in the country) and you allowed no exemptions at all, you'd need to charge everyone 15% in federal income taxes in order to collect as much with your new flat tax as under the old tax. If there's any cheating, you'd need to set the rate higher than that.

Now, that would be a HUGE tax break for the rich. The top 1% currently pay around 20.6% as an effective federal income tax rate. But it would be an enormous tax hike on the vast majority of people. Obviously, for the roughly half of all Americans who pay no federal income taxes, that would be a huge hit. And considering a lot of them are barely scraping by as it is, it's not clear how they'd cope with suddenly having 15% of their scanty income taken from them. You'd be driving the lower middle class below the poverty rate and driving the poor into a state of utter dependence on the government. But even for the upper-middle-class, a 15% effective federal income tax rate would be a hit.

See here (Summary Table 1, "effective Tax Rate -- Individual Income Taxes):

http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/12-29-2005FedTaxRates.pdf

You'll see that the average effective federal individual income tax rate for the fourth quintile was 5.9% and for the highest quintile was 13.9%. So, if you're in the 60%-80% range (upper middle class), the flat tax would be an enormous increase in your tax liability, and even for those of us in the top 20%, it would be a slight increase (from 13.9% to 15%).

Essentially, what a flat income tax would do would be to hike taxes on 90% of Americans, in exchange for dropping them for the top 10%. If you're poor, it would devastate you, if you were middle class, it would impoverish you, and even if you were upper-middle class it would be a severe hit to the quality of your life. Between the 80th and the 90th percentile, there wouldn't be much of a change, but if you happen to be top-5% it would be a nice windfall, and if you're top 1%, it would be a huge increase in your already luxurious life.

Keep in mind, those are just the results for a revenue-neutral flat tax.... one that would keep our deficit the same size. If you wanted to do a flat tax while balancing the budget, you'd need to bring in more revenues, meaning a significantly higher rate. Depending on the details, you could easily wind up with a tax scheme that was worse for as much as 99% of the population than a progressive tax structure would be.

Presumably, you've done your taxes for the year. So, go and check out what your effective federal income tax rate was (take your tax liability, not counting social security and Medicare, and divide it by your total income, not your adjusted gross). Unless you're unusually wealthy, chances are you'll come up with a figure well below 15%, which means you'd be a lot worse off with a flat tax. That's because, in the end, the math for a flat tax just doesn't work.

USSR had flat tax system, but don't tell it to Lukey and his ward, don't confuse them with the commie/socialist whatever is ingrained in little brains falsehoods..
 
Flat taxes have permutations too including tables, floors and ceilings. There's no shortage of various tax proposals. Flat taxes work in the sense that they will raise revenue in accordance with the tax itself, they don't work to the extent that one doesn't think the payor shoukdn't be compelled to contribute.
 
There's a lot of circumstances and options you leave out. The elimination of many loopholes, the setting of a flat tax on business income, minimized incentives to pay less tax or avoid paying altogether (this also results in less spending to monitor tax-paying/dodging activities, eliminating Social Security taxes which stifle job creation, and the application of a "fair tax" rather than a flat tax. The corporate tax we have today is one of the highest in the world, but with one of the lowest collection rates. What good is that?

A flat tax gets rid of all inefficiencies and produces more incentive to work, produce, and advance.
By removing waste, fraud, abuse, shelters, a rate of 12.5 would easily make up the tax revenue we collect presently.
 
The belief that a flat tax would end loopholes is nothing more than a fantasy.

The flat tax is merely a proposal, the person making the proposal controls the parameters. Simply because a political initiative might permit deductions from income says nothing regarding the underlying theory itself. All you're saying is the obvious, the proposal is currently DOA, has no chance, won't even be proposed since its simply outside the realm of possible political solutions.
 
The flat tax is merely a proposal, the person making the proposal controls the parameters. Simply because a political initiative might permit deductions from income says nothing regarding the underlying theory itself. All you're saying is the obvious, the proposal is currently DOA, has no chance, won't even be proposed since its simply outside the realm of possible political solutions.


Yes, if only we could freeze time and prevent the forward march of history. The conservative dream...
 
There's too many people and lobbies that profit from our convoluted almost alien-language tax code. They won't allow such a change that could put so many analysts, CPA's, auditors, and IRS people out of work.
 
Yes, if only we could freeze time and prevent the forward march of history. The conservative dream...

Unfortunately that march is to insolvency. The system is NOT fiscally sound. You can veil the cost of government through the sale of bonds for only so long.

When you go to an Exxon station and spend a $1 on gas. How much goes to Exxon's bottom line, its shareholders? Now how much goes to the various governments?

Do you really think that our society will prosoper with government spending at all levels in excess of 40% of GDP?
 
This flat tax calculator says something different.
LINK
The flat tax proposal does give certain deductions. I tried it with an income of $30,000 and 3 children and there was $0 tax due. I tried it on several incomes with varying situations and the tax called for took into account the lower income folks and they were not hit.
Link to the home site.
 
I was happy with the result I got from my income too. It was about 11% on mine too.
I am not completely sold on the flat tax idea but I think it should be looked at as a possibility.

Happy with the result that gave me. Came out to be about 11% of my gross.
 
Yep. Even if someone isn't willing to crunch the numbers, a reality check is just to look at who pushes hardest for a flat tax. It's generally guys like Steve Forbes, who know they would get a gigantic decrease in their effective tax rates. From there, all you need to realize, to see that it's a scam against the poor and middle class, is that the money's got to come from somewhere. You can't have one person paying millions of dollars less in taxes per year without others collectively paying millions more. And so, for every rich guy who gets a big cut, you wind up with dozens of regular folks who get hit with hikes.


Steve Forbes is to publishing, what Paris Hilton is to the hotel bidness. How ANY run-of-the-mill GOP could seriously believe that what's good for Steve Forbes good for them, is beyond me.

Anyway, might I suggest one additional problem with these various flat tax shemes. Their "beauty" according to their advocates, is their simplicity. Everyone knows exactly what the rate is, and to what it is applied. It "hits" everyone exactly the same. But..that sort of "thinking" is just a tad naive. In order for such a scheme to be simple, it would have to be applied to a circumscribed set of "things" - income, capital gains, real estate, whatever. Even we of the 98% who're fortunate to no longer being living paycheck to paycheck, know that our opportunity for shifting our assets in order to minimize our exposure to a flat tax, would be quite limited. But...the filthy rich person? It would be impossible for us to design a tax scheme that was both sufficient AND simple, that the filthy rich couldn't find ways of skirting it.
 
Back
Top