Arkady
President
In a thread below, a conservative objected to the rich paying higher income tax rates, and suggested that it would be fairer to charge everyone the same rate. That's a frequent conservative assertion, but I wonder whether people have considered what it would mean in terms of real world numbers.
The math is actually surprisingly simple. Right now, individual income tax receipts are about $1.2 trillion per year. That's the figure you'd have to hit with your flat tax to make it a revenue-neutral change. Right now there are approximately 119 million households in America, with mean income of about $68,000 per household. What that means is that even if you could collect taxes with 100% efficiency (not a single successful tax-dodger in the country) and you allowed no exemptions at all, you'd need to charge everyone 15% in federal income taxes in order to collect as much with your new flat tax as under the old tax. If there's any cheating, you'd need to set the rate higher than that.
Now, that would be a HUGE tax break for the rich. The top 1% currently pay around 20.6% as an effective federal income tax rate. But it would be an enormous tax hike on the vast majority of people. Obviously, for the roughly half of all Americans who pay no federal income taxes, that would be a huge hit. And considering a lot of them are barely scraping by as it is, it's not clear how they'd cope with suddenly having 15% of their scanty income taken from them. You'd be driving the lower middle class below the poverty rate and driving the poor into a state of utter dependence on the government. But even for the upper-middle-class, a 15% effective federal income tax rate would be a hit.
See here (Summary Table 1, "effective Tax Rate -- Individual Income Taxes):
http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/12-29-2005FedTaxRates.pdf
You'll see that the average effective federal individual income tax rate for the fourth quintile was 5.9% and for the highest quintile was 13.9%. So, if you're in the 60%-80% range (upper middle class), the flat tax would be an enormous increase in your tax liability, and even for those of us in the top 20%, it would be a slight increase (from 13.9% to 15%).
Essentially, what a flat income tax would do would be to hike taxes on 90% of Americans, in exchange for dropping them for the top 10%. If you're poor, it would devastate you, if you were middle class, it would impoverish you, and even if you were upper-middle class it would be a severe hit to the quality of your life. Between the 80th and the 90th percentile, there wouldn't be much of a change, but if you happen to be top-5% it would be a nice windfall, and if you're top 1%, it would be a huge increase in your already luxurious life.
Keep in mind, those are just the results for a revenue-neutral flat tax.... one that would keep our deficit the same size. If you wanted to do a flat tax while balancing the budget, you'd need to bring in more revenues, meaning a significantly higher rate. Depending on the details, you could easily wind up with a tax scheme that was worse for as much as 99% of the population than a progressive tax structure would be.
Presumably, you've done your taxes for the year. So, go and check out what your effective federal income tax rate was (take your tax liability, not counting social security and Medicare, and divide it by your total income, not your adjusted gross). Unless you're unusually wealthy, chances are you'll come up with a figure well below 15%, which means you'd be a lot worse off with a flat tax. That's because, in the end, the math for a flat tax just doesn't work.
The math is actually surprisingly simple. Right now, individual income tax receipts are about $1.2 trillion per year. That's the figure you'd have to hit with your flat tax to make it a revenue-neutral change. Right now there are approximately 119 million households in America, with mean income of about $68,000 per household. What that means is that even if you could collect taxes with 100% efficiency (not a single successful tax-dodger in the country) and you allowed no exemptions at all, you'd need to charge everyone 15% in federal income taxes in order to collect as much with your new flat tax as under the old tax. If there's any cheating, you'd need to set the rate higher than that.
Now, that would be a HUGE tax break for the rich. The top 1% currently pay around 20.6% as an effective federal income tax rate. But it would be an enormous tax hike on the vast majority of people. Obviously, for the roughly half of all Americans who pay no federal income taxes, that would be a huge hit. And considering a lot of them are barely scraping by as it is, it's not clear how they'd cope with suddenly having 15% of their scanty income taken from them. You'd be driving the lower middle class below the poverty rate and driving the poor into a state of utter dependence on the government. But even for the upper-middle-class, a 15% effective federal income tax rate would be a hit.
See here (Summary Table 1, "effective Tax Rate -- Individual Income Taxes):
http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/12-29-2005FedTaxRates.pdf
You'll see that the average effective federal individual income tax rate for the fourth quintile was 5.9% and for the highest quintile was 13.9%. So, if you're in the 60%-80% range (upper middle class), the flat tax would be an enormous increase in your tax liability, and even for those of us in the top 20%, it would be a slight increase (from 13.9% to 15%).
Essentially, what a flat income tax would do would be to hike taxes on 90% of Americans, in exchange for dropping them for the top 10%. If you're poor, it would devastate you, if you were middle class, it would impoverish you, and even if you were upper-middle class it would be a severe hit to the quality of your life. Between the 80th and the 90th percentile, there wouldn't be much of a change, but if you happen to be top-5% it would be a nice windfall, and if you're top 1%, it would be a huge increase in your already luxurious life.
Keep in mind, those are just the results for a revenue-neutral flat tax.... one that would keep our deficit the same size. If you wanted to do a flat tax while balancing the budget, you'd need to bring in more revenues, meaning a significantly higher rate. Depending on the details, you could easily wind up with a tax scheme that was worse for as much as 99% of the population than a progressive tax structure would be.
Presumably, you've done your taxes for the year. So, go and check out what your effective federal income tax rate was (take your tax liability, not counting social security and Medicare, and divide it by your total income, not your adjusted gross). Unless you're unusually wealthy, chances are you'll come up with a figure well below 15%, which means you'd be a lot worse off with a flat tax. That's because, in the end, the math for a flat tax just doesn't work.
