1) I suspect you're lying, for starters. You've actually walked up to people wearing MAGA hats and asked them this question? Really? How many? I call BS . I guess you're going to trick these short bussers you speak of.
2) the answer is simple, somewhat subjective, and of course varies by the individual. America was great when we didn't encourage illegal aliens to vote, reward people for screwing up, when we had the freedom of political association, when the media wasn't a far left propaganda cartel and in general was just fine before a communist- raised, jive- talking racist declared he was going to bring fundamental transformation to the US. I could go on, but this is the most I'm willing to do from a phone keyboard.