New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Why Romney's Losing

Arkady

President
This should have been a relatively easy win for Romney. Unemployment remains high, and almost nothing has been done about it for years. That puts Obama in the tough situation of having to blame the inaction on the Republican Congress, which makes him sound like a whiner and opens him to criticism about being politically ineffectual. Meanwhile, deficits are at a record high, which is one of the few things the self-proclaimed moderate pundits actually care about. Plus Romney's got almost unlimited campaign funding, made possible by his vast personal fortune, his close ties to fellow plutocrats, and the unprecedented opening of the corporate spigot by the infamous Citizens United case. And, despite all that, all indicators point to a very significant lead for Obama -- Intrade now puts Romney's chances at around 33.9%, and the 538 election forecast puts it at 25.3%.

Normally, I prefer to talk policies instead of politics, but I find myself interested in the weakness of the Romney campaign despite myself. What are they doing wrong? I think this article nails it:

http://www.salon.com/2012/09/17/how_romney_can_win_over_the_press/

To summarize, Romney could have won over the press (which is fairly disillusioned with Obama), simply by patterning his campaign after Bush's 2000 campaign. He should have played the part of the compassionate conservative, avoiding direct nastiness, and calling vaguely for bipartisanship and a change in the tone in Washington (something the self-proclaimed moderates in the punditocracy love nearly as much as they hate deficits). He should have flattered the hell out of the leading lights of media, making them feel liked and respected and important. And, most importantly, he should have left all the ugly stuff below the radar -- leaving the race-baiting and the lies to his proxies, and to robo-callers and other difficult-to-trace indirect means.

Bush was a master of that technique, back in 2000.... or, really, Karl Rove was a master of it. Bush was positioned as a kinder conservative -- compassionate about the less fortunate, interested in bipartisanship, and concerned about keeping us a humble nation. Meanwhile, behind the scenes, his proxies waged dirty campaigns (suggesting McCain had fathered a black child, labeling Gore a compulsive liar, and so on). The technique let him do all the damage he needed to do to his opponents, while remaining loved by enough mainstream reporters to bask in an unearned reputation for moderation.

What the article doesn't point out, is that this was also Obama's technique in 2008. Obama didn't run a particularly substantive campaign. He mostly just talked about "Hope" and "Change," while keeping most of the negative stuff at arm's length, to stay in the good graces of the media. It's not that the campaign was consistently positive -- it's just that he kept out of the negativity himself. He had proxies to do things like accusing Hillary Clinton of being a liar, or calling attention to every Palin gaffe.

The pundits may pretend they want a substantive campaign, but that's not what they reward. They reward vagueness, when it's coupled with the right talking points about fiscal responsibility and bipartisanship, and when the candidate mostly keeps his own hands clean. I wonder why it is that Romney, despite the finest campaign team money can by, doesn't realize that. Or is it that he needs to appeal to his party's base, by playing the part of the attack dog himself, even when that makes the election much harder to win? If so, why? Why can't he just make gestures towards the center the way Bush did in 2000? Why can't he mostly leave the viciousness to proxies?
 
You know he is....when you hear all these Rightwing pundits offering him ADVICE on basically "how to save your campaign". And folks INSIDE the Campaign trying to shift blame away from Mitt...and onto Stuart Stevens. And guys like Erick Erickson finally saying That Most Horrid Of Thngs....that if the election was held today, President Obama would win.

Meanwhile, naturally, Mitt's spokespeople have to say "Everything is fine...fine....great, even".....and Obama Deranged Bloggers listening to Rush and Hannity and Dick Morris DESPERATELY try to convince themselves (not even others) that it's true with Rasmussen polls.
 
BTW, the answer to your last questions?

1. Why can't he just make gestures towards the center the way Bush did in 2000?

2.Why can't he mostly leave the viciousness to proxies?


1. Because his own Base doesn't trust him. "Etch-A-Sketch" proved to them they couldn't trust him. And every time he moves to the Center, it points out that Mitt was LYING to the Base during the Primaries.

2. Because his image is that he's "weak"....so for his own ego, he has to "act tough" and be the scrapper....and it blows up in his face and then he backs down and pretends it never happens. Which is worse than if he was just "mean"...it makes him look DOUBLY weak.
 
BTW, the answer to your last questions?

1. Why can't he just make gestures towards the center the way Bush did in 2000?

2.Why can't he mostly leave the viciousness to proxies?


1. Because his own Base doesn't trust him. "Etch-A-Sketch" proved to them they couldn't trust him. And every time he moves to the Center, it points out that Mitt was LYING to the Base during the Primaries.

2. Because his image is that he's "weak"....so for his own ego, he has to "act tough" and be the scrapper....and it blows up in his face and then he backs down and pretends it never happens. Which is worse than if he was just "mean"...it makes him look DOUBLY weak.

My own gut tells me he can ignore his own base, and they'll still show up and vote in more or less the same high numbers they always do, because they're driven primarily by their hate for the opponent, not their love for whoever is on the GOP ticket. I think that's been the case at least since 1988 -- the right is seldom particularly enamored with the nominee, but they can be made to despise the opponent to the point they'd vote for just about anyone else in order to register that hatred. So, if I were advising Romney, I'd tell him the moment he had the nomination wrapped up, he should have moved to the center, counting on Obama's very existence to get him those base votes.

However, the fact Romney hasn't done that makes me wonder whether they have internal polling suggesting that wouldn't work. For example, are they concerned that they'll lose the libertarian vote (there's a libertarian on the ballot in almost every state), if they don't placate the base? Have polls indicated hard-right voters really will jump that way, if Romney doesn't present himself as a feral conservative?
 
LeRoy: I think it is an exaggeration to say that "Obama didn't run a particularly substantive campaign" in 2008. "Hope and Change" was simply the slogan. Almost every successful Presidential campaign has an effective slogan. For Reagan in 1984, it was "It's Morning in America". Etc. Obama promised to end the war in Iraq; he has done so. He promised to FOCUS on Afghanistan; he has done so. [There seems to be a myth among some Democrats that Obama promised to end the war in Afghanistan just as fast as the war in Iraq; he most certainly did not do that. And yes, I think we should get out of Afghanistan as quickly as possible, today; now that Osama bin Laden is dead.] He argued that America needed to focus on "nation-building at home", that we needed more investments in infrastructure, in education, in alternative energy sources, and that we should start to combat global warming. He has only partially succeeded on those initiatives, of course, because of fierce and determined Republican opposition.
 
He argued that America needed to focus on "nation-building at home", that we needed more investments in infrastructure, in education, in alternative energy sources, and that we should start to combat global warming. He has only partially succeeded on those initiatives, of course, because of fierce and determined Republican opposition.

Not exactly. Our esteemed government didn't properly allocate sufficient proportion (i.e. the vast majority) of stumulus to infrastructure spending. I don't dwell on this point much - because I oppose stimulus no matter how the state seeks to allocate it...but if you're going to do it infrastructure would have been the best place to spend the lion's share.
 
LeRoy: He argued that America needed to focus on "nation-building at home", that we needed more investments in infrastructure, in education, in alternative energy sources, and that we should start to combat global warming. He has only partially succeeded on those initiatives, of course, because of fierce and determined Republican opposition.

RickWA: Not exactly. Our esteemed government didn't properly allocate sufficient proportion (i.e. the vast majority) of stumulus to infrastructure spending. I don't dwell on this point much - because I oppose stimulus no matter how the state seeks to allocate it...but if you're going to do it infrastructure would have been the best place to spend the lion's share.

LeRoy: A good chunk of the stimulus program also went to scientific/technological research & development. [Are you opposed to that??] It is VERY hard to say how 'productive' that spending was. We may not know for years, or even decades. In fact, we may not know for centuries. I am reminded of a famous professor of the history of technology, who was asked the question: Which invention was more important, fire or the wheel? He pondered for a moment, and then replied: "Too soon to tell!!"
 
I would argue that it's two things:

1) Incumbents have a decided advantage (historically, the bully pulpit, free and constant media coverage, etc.). Like Notre Dame...President Obama is 'always on'. It helps with recruiting and it helps with familiarity/recognition.
2) Romney is a decidedly weak candidate. As was the case with a wounded and unpopular President Bush in '04...a weak challenger often can't close the deal. Romney is the right's Kerry in many respects.

Folks disagree on Romney as to his relative capacity, but it's clear that he's not really a terribly accomplished politician. I'm a poor prognosticator, but the odds to me look about like 55/45 in Obama's favor.
 
The pundits may pretend they want a substantive campaign, but that's not what they reward. They reward vagueness, when it's coupled with the right talking points about fiscal responsibility and bipartisanship, and when the candidate mostly keeps his own hands clean. I wonder why it is that Romney, despite the finest campaign team money can by, doesn't realize that. Or is it that he needs to appeal to his party's base, by playing the part of the attack dog himself, even when that makes the election much harder to win? If so, why? Why can't he just make gestures towards the center the way Bush did in 2000? Why can't he mostly leave the viciousness to proxies?

the repub activist base in the primaries wanted their candidate to be the best red meat thrower. that's a function of their ODS. that's all they talked about.....who could best trash Pres Obama. they won't let Romney veer from that course and Romney lacks the leadership skills to take his base in a better direction.
 
Well, I oppose ALL of it, but if I were the allocator it would have been weighted heavily in favor of infrastructor design/construction - bridges, highways, large public works projects. I'm a huge R&D guy, but I think we all agree that stimulus' primary goal was stimulation here and now. Jumpstart, shovel-ready, etc.

Anyhoo - I have to fake it to get fired up on this point because I don't like the notion of Stimulus, QE, or even bloody TARP for that matter.
 
"This should have been a relatively easy win for Romney." You said that and I hear lotsa folks on the right say that. I don't think so. I don't think Chris Christie,Jeb Bush,John Thune,Marco Rubio,Paul Ryan,Mitch Daniels etc.etc. thought so either. Romney might've been able to do those things you suggest if he hadn't had to go hard right to outflank Rick Perry,Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich. He's hung out there now and can't go back. The contested GOP nomination race did not make Willard a better candidate.

Willard,so far,has not put any of his personal fortune into his campaign and contrary to popular belief,does not have "unlimited campaign funding".

http://www.opensecrets.org/pres12/index.php?ql3
 
He might could ignore his base but we've already seen/heard they wouldn't quietly take it. Every time they think he's ignoring them or changing positions on something they hold dear,they scream,including those with an audience.
 
Well, I oppose ALL of it, but if I were the allocator it would have been weighted heavily in favor of infrastructor design/construction - bridges, highways, large public works projects. I'm a huge R&D guy, but I think we all agree that stimulus' primary goal was stimulation here and now. Jumpstart, shovel-ready, etc.

Anyhoo - I have to fake it to get fired up on this point because I don't like the notion of Stimulus, QE, or even bloody TARP for that matter.

LeRoy: Your post seems somewhat contradictory to me. You say "I'm a huge R&D guy", but then follow that up with "I don't like the notion of Stimulus". When the government initiates some massive R&D program----take the moon landing program of the 1960s as a fine example---that is inherently going to 'stimulate' the economy. They are pumping money into universities, high-tech companies, funneling money to scientists, engineers, and technicians---who are going to go out and spend the money, on homes, cars, groceries, furniture, movie tickets, restaurant meals, and so forth.

Some Republicans are opposed to any and all government involvement in research; they say let the private sector do it all. They are wrong, but at least consistent. I guess my question to you is: Do you think there in fact ought to be government-directed research and development programs? And if so, wouldn't it make perfect sense to ramp those up during a deep economic downturn?
 
That's pretty spot on. I remember a few lefties who tried to assure me that Kerry had it won when I expressed the misgivings you posted. Kerry got the same popular vote % that Gore got in 2000. I never thought Kerry was gonna win.
 
Stimulus is intended to net immediate effect. R&D is investment in future. Pretty intuitive stuff there.

As far as being a huge R&D guy - that's what I do for a living...of course with private dollars. :)
 
Stimulus is intended to net immediate effect. R&D is investment in future. Pretty intuitive stuff there.

As far as being a huge R&D guy - that's what I do for a living...of course with private dollars. :)

LeRoy: I guess you want to argue semantics while I wanted to argue substance. For what it's worth, New Scientist magazine called Obama's stimulus program "the largest bet on science and technology that any world leader has ever made, in history". Since I am a noted techno-optimist, I approved of that. And still do.

[About a third of the 'stimulus' program consisted of tax cuts, which Obama put in, in a vain effort to win some Republican support for the package. We know that such tax cuts do little to stimulate the economy in the short run. Most people were probably using those tax cuts to pay down debt....]
 
The liberals could learn a little something from them. Because there is never any political consequence for a Democrat who betrays the left, no matter how directly and dramatically, they all do it as a matter of course -- taking their base wholly for granted. This results in a situation where the Democrats can win more than half of the election battles even as the liberal side loses the ideological war. The Republicans move right, to appease their base, the Democrats move right to capture the new center, and thus, no matter who wins, the center has been redefined to the right. Repeat the process over and over, and before long you have a situation where, for example, the top tax bracket has been brought down from 92% to 35%, and we've gone from spending a bit less on our military than our biggest rival to spending more than five times as much as our biggest rival.
 
The liberals could learn a little something from them. Because there is never any political consequence for a Democrat who betrays the left, no matter how directly and dramatically, they all do it as a matter of course -- taking their base wholly for granted. This results in a situation where the Democrats can win more than half of the election battles even as the liberal side loses the ideological war. The Republicans move right, to appease their base, the Democrats move right to capture the new center, and thus, no matter who wins, the center has been redefined to the right. Repeat the process over and over, and before long you have a situation where, for example, the top tax bracket has been brought down from 92% to 35%, and we've gone from spending a bit less on our military than our biggest rival to spending more than five times as much as our biggest rival.

And don't forget you have a Rightwing Media that ...when President Obama's policies would put him in the category of an "Eisenhower Republican" 50 years ago...

accuses him of being a "Marxist".
 
Back
Top