Arkady
President
This should have been a relatively easy win for Romney. Unemployment remains high, and almost nothing has been done about it for years. That puts Obama in the tough situation of having to blame the inaction on the Republican Congress, which makes him sound like a whiner and opens him to criticism about being politically ineffectual. Meanwhile, deficits are at a record high, which is one of the few things the self-proclaimed moderate pundits actually care about. Plus Romney's got almost unlimited campaign funding, made possible by his vast personal fortune, his close ties to fellow plutocrats, and the unprecedented opening of the corporate spigot by the infamous Citizens United case. And, despite all that, all indicators point to a very significant lead for Obama -- Intrade now puts Romney's chances at around 33.9%, and the 538 election forecast puts it at 25.3%.
Normally, I prefer to talk policies instead of politics, but I find myself interested in the weakness of the Romney campaign despite myself. What are they doing wrong? I think this article nails it:
http://www.salon.com/2012/09/17/how_romney_can_win_over_the_press/
To summarize, Romney could have won over the press (which is fairly disillusioned with Obama), simply by patterning his campaign after Bush's 2000 campaign. He should have played the part of the compassionate conservative, avoiding direct nastiness, and calling vaguely for bipartisanship and a change in the tone in Washington (something the self-proclaimed moderates in the punditocracy love nearly as much as they hate deficits). He should have flattered the hell out of the leading lights of media, making them feel liked and respected and important. And, most importantly, he should have left all the ugly stuff below the radar -- leaving the race-baiting and the lies to his proxies, and to robo-callers and other difficult-to-trace indirect means.
Bush was a master of that technique, back in 2000.... or, really, Karl Rove was a master of it. Bush was positioned as a kinder conservative -- compassionate about the less fortunate, interested in bipartisanship, and concerned about keeping us a humble nation. Meanwhile, behind the scenes, his proxies waged dirty campaigns (suggesting McCain had fathered a black child, labeling Gore a compulsive liar, and so on). The technique let him do all the damage he needed to do to his opponents, while remaining loved by enough mainstream reporters to bask in an unearned reputation for moderation.
What the article doesn't point out, is that this was also Obama's technique in 2008. Obama didn't run a particularly substantive campaign. He mostly just talked about "Hope" and "Change," while keeping most of the negative stuff at arm's length, to stay in the good graces of the media. It's not that the campaign was consistently positive -- it's just that he kept out of the negativity himself. He had proxies to do things like accusing Hillary Clinton of being a liar, or calling attention to every Palin gaffe.
The pundits may pretend they want a substantive campaign, but that's not what they reward. They reward vagueness, when it's coupled with the right talking points about fiscal responsibility and bipartisanship, and when the candidate mostly keeps his own hands clean. I wonder why it is that Romney, despite the finest campaign team money can by, doesn't realize that. Or is it that he needs to appeal to his party's base, by playing the part of the attack dog himself, even when that makes the election much harder to win? If so, why? Why can't he just make gestures towards the center the way Bush did in 2000? Why can't he mostly leave the viciousness to proxies?
Normally, I prefer to talk policies instead of politics, but I find myself interested in the weakness of the Romney campaign despite myself. What are they doing wrong? I think this article nails it:
http://www.salon.com/2012/09/17/how_romney_can_win_over_the_press/
To summarize, Romney could have won over the press (which is fairly disillusioned with Obama), simply by patterning his campaign after Bush's 2000 campaign. He should have played the part of the compassionate conservative, avoiding direct nastiness, and calling vaguely for bipartisanship and a change in the tone in Washington (something the self-proclaimed moderates in the punditocracy love nearly as much as they hate deficits). He should have flattered the hell out of the leading lights of media, making them feel liked and respected and important. And, most importantly, he should have left all the ugly stuff below the radar -- leaving the race-baiting and the lies to his proxies, and to robo-callers and other difficult-to-trace indirect means.
Bush was a master of that technique, back in 2000.... or, really, Karl Rove was a master of it. Bush was positioned as a kinder conservative -- compassionate about the less fortunate, interested in bipartisanship, and concerned about keeping us a humble nation. Meanwhile, behind the scenes, his proxies waged dirty campaigns (suggesting McCain had fathered a black child, labeling Gore a compulsive liar, and so on). The technique let him do all the damage he needed to do to his opponents, while remaining loved by enough mainstream reporters to bask in an unearned reputation for moderation.
What the article doesn't point out, is that this was also Obama's technique in 2008. Obama didn't run a particularly substantive campaign. He mostly just talked about "Hope" and "Change," while keeping most of the negative stuff at arm's length, to stay in the good graces of the media. It's not that the campaign was consistently positive -- it's just that he kept out of the negativity himself. He had proxies to do things like accusing Hillary Clinton of being a liar, or calling attention to every Palin gaffe.
The pundits may pretend they want a substantive campaign, but that's not what they reward. They reward vagueness, when it's coupled with the right talking points about fiscal responsibility and bipartisanship, and when the candidate mostly keeps his own hands clean. I wonder why it is that Romney, despite the finest campaign team money can by, doesn't realize that. Or is it that he needs to appeal to his party's base, by playing the part of the attack dog himself, even when that makes the election much harder to win? If so, why? Why can't he just make gestures towards the center the way Bush did in 2000? Why can't he mostly leave the viciousness to proxies?