This isn't really a partisan issue, it's a small-d democratic one. It distorts elections in both directions.
Republicans are often astonished that Obama won in 2008, when he was, admittedly, one of the least qualified people ever to mount a serious run for the presidency (only a few years of big-time political experience, none of which were distinguished by any accomplishments, and before that a decidedly D-list career). He's a fairly charismatic guy, but that's not much of an explanation for his success. He's not a Reagan type, with Hollywood charisma to burn, or even a Clinton. He was a proficient but undistinguished debater. He does OK with set-piece speeches, but not memorably so, and he can be a bit of a train wreck without his teleprompter. So, how did he win?
The main factor was that his predecessor was arguably the worst president in history, and his opponent didn't even attempt to distinguish himself from Bush's catastrophic set of policies. But I don't think that's enough explanation. I think the money was a big factor. Obama had the best-funded political campaign in the history of the world. He was able to counter McCain's spin item for item, and still have some left over. McCain was fighting uphill all summer because of that, and it's the reason he eventually got desperate and picked Palin, to charge up the base and rattle some money loose. I think if Obama had been suffering a more typical Democratic 2-1 fundraising disadvantage, McCain would be president today. But Obama got Silicon Valley excited and poached a lot of Wall Street money, and so he became president.