Arkady
President
Paul Krugman uses a great term of "zombie idea" to describe any proposition that has been thoroughly refuted by analysis and evidence, and should be dead - but won't stay dead because it serves a political purpose, appeals to prejudices, or both.
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/06/george-orwell-and-the-zombies/?_r=0
There are a number of examples he cites, but one of the more important ones is the spin that says that US federal government efforts to increase lending to minorities was responsible for the housing collapse and financial meltdown of 2008.
This has been studied by academics and refuted thoroughly -- that pressure to lend was a tiny factor, at most. But the idea can also be refuted, without a need for advanced statistical and economic knowledge, just by applying a little common sense. If all or even most of what was going on was an increase of risky loans to minorities in poor neighborhoods (the practice the government encouraged), the housing collapse would have been mostly confined to those neighborhoods, and the financial damage would have been confined to Fannie and Freddie, which the government caused to underwrite those loans, not private lenders, who were free not to make them. In reality, the housing collapse encompassed all sorts of properties that weren't touched at all by the effort to expand minority lending in poor neighborhoods: McMansions, second homes in vacation locations, sun-belt investment properties, and markets far afield of any US federal government influence, from Ireland to Spain. And the financial damage spread by way of investment banks that were in no way required by government to buy up that bad debt, much less to package it and sell it off in insured tranches (which the government in no way required any insurer to underwrite), as mortgage-backed securities, to investors around the world (whom the government in no way required to buy it). In fact, Fannie and Freddie were followers, not leaders, when it came to making risky loans.
In short, both academic analysis and common sense tell you most of what happened with the financial meltdown was about underregulated speculation and exotic, poorly-understood investment vehicles, not a handful of government-encouraged loans to boost minority homeownership. But it serves a political purpose to claim otherwise. It allows people to believe that government is the problem, and that unregulated financial markets can be trusted, and that's an important thing for libertarians and libertarian-minded Republicans to believe to hold their worldview together. So, the theory marches on, like a zombie, even though by all rights it should have been long dead.
Anyway, I've seen a similar zombie idea in play here on this forum. Several times, when faced with clear evidence of the US's underperformance in public health results, such our as high infant mortality or our low life expectancy numbers, conservatives have posted the argument that those stats are just a reflection of the US supposedly defining "live births" differently from other countries. They never cite any evidence of this, of course. They just assert it's true. Supposedly, the US counts all births with a heartbeat, whereas most countries don't count babies as people unless they survive for some period of time, and thus our infant mortality rates are artificially raised relative to theirs, and our life expectancy numbers are artificially depressed.
The US ranks 34th in Infant Mortality:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate
We rank 42 in under-5 mortality:
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?order=wbapi_data_value_2012 wbapi_data_value wbapi_data_value-last&sort=asc
Our Infant mortality is 5.4 (according to the UN, for 2005/2010), compared to 1.92-3.51 for top-10 nations. Our under-5 mortality is 7, compared to 2-3 for top 10 nations (UN numbers for 2010). So, our infant mortality is 1.5 to 2.8 times that of the leading nations, while our age under-5 mortality is 2.3 to 3.5 times that of the leading nations. In other words, as bad bad as our infant mortality is, our mortality for older children is even worse. That's the exact opposite of what we'd expect to see if our infant mortality rate were artificially elevated by definitional games about "live births."
Life expectancy stats bear this out, too:
http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/your-life-expectancy-by-age
At birth, our life expectancy is 37th in the world. That could be affected by high death rates of those "live births" that supposedly other countries don't count. But our life expectancy at age 5 is also 37th, and that can't be affected by overcounting those barely-alive newborns that other countries don't count because they die too soon. And it actually gets worse for older kids. We're ranked 38th for the life expectancies of 10-year-olds, and 39th for life expectancies of 20 year olds. Presumably this isn't because some other countries aren't counting their 20-year-olds as having been "live births."
The one bright spot for the US is that when people get quite a bit older, the US life expectancy starts climbing up the list. For example, we're 27th for life expectancy of 80-year-olds. This shouldn't be terribly surprising when you remember that the differences between the US healthcare system and those of other leading nations mostly vanishes once a person hits 65, and gets access to universal, single-payer socialized medicine. Those older people apparently don't catch up entirely, probably due to the results of having spent so much of their lives in a sub-standard healthcare system, but they at least start to bridge the gap.
The point of all this, though, is that it doesn't matter how thoroughly I've debunked the theory. I've done it before and I'll have to do it in the future, no doubt. It's a zombie, and mere logic and facts can't bring it down. It will shamble on as long as it continues to serve a political purpose. Republicans and libertarians need a way to explain away our horrible health stats in this country, relative to the stats of countries with more socialized medicine, and so this pet theory will continue to catch on with them, without them bothering to ask for a shred of evidence, much less double checking it themselves with the widely available stats.
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/06/george-orwell-and-the-zombies/?_r=0
There are a number of examples he cites, but one of the more important ones is the spin that says that US federal government efforts to increase lending to minorities was responsible for the housing collapse and financial meltdown of 2008.
This has been studied by academics and refuted thoroughly -- that pressure to lend was a tiny factor, at most. But the idea can also be refuted, without a need for advanced statistical and economic knowledge, just by applying a little common sense. If all or even most of what was going on was an increase of risky loans to minorities in poor neighborhoods (the practice the government encouraged), the housing collapse would have been mostly confined to those neighborhoods, and the financial damage would have been confined to Fannie and Freddie, which the government caused to underwrite those loans, not private lenders, who were free not to make them. In reality, the housing collapse encompassed all sorts of properties that weren't touched at all by the effort to expand minority lending in poor neighborhoods: McMansions, second homes in vacation locations, sun-belt investment properties, and markets far afield of any US federal government influence, from Ireland to Spain. And the financial damage spread by way of investment banks that were in no way required by government to buy up that bad debt, much less to package it and sell it off in insured tranches (which the government in no way required any insurer to underwrite), as mortgage-backed securities, to investors around the world (whom the government in no way required to buy it). In fact, Fannie and Freddie were followers, not leaders, when it came to making risky loans.
In short, both academic analysis and common sense tell you most of what happened with the financial meltdown was about underregulated speculation and exotic, poorly-understood investment vehicles, not a handful of government-encouraged loans to boost minority homeownership. But it serves a political purpose to claim otherwise. It allows people to believe that government is the problem, and that unregulated financial markets can be trusted, and that's an important thing for libertarians and libertarian-minded Republicans to believe to hold their worldview together. So, the theory marches on, like a zombie, even though by all rights it should have been long dead.
Anyway, I've seen a similar zombie idea in play here on this forum. Several times, when faced with clear evidence of the US's underperformance in public health results, such our as high infant mortality or our low life expectancy numbers, conservatives have posted the argument that those stats are just a reflection of the US supposedly defining "live births" differently from other countries. They never cite any evidence of this, of course. They just assert it's true. Supposedly, the US counts all births with a heartbeat, whereas most countries don't count babies as people unless they survive for some period of time, and thus our infant mortality rates are artificially raised relative to theirs, and our life expectancy numbers are artificially depressed.
The US ranks 34th in Infant Mortality:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate
We rank 42 in under-5 mortality:
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?order=wbapi_data_value_2012 wbapi_data_value wbapi_data_value-last&sort=asc
Our Infant mortality is 5.4 (according to the UN, for 2005/2010), compared to 1.92-3.51 for top-10 nations. Our under-5 mortality is 7, compared to 2-3 for top 10 nations (UN numbers for 2010). So, our infant mortality is 1.5 to 2.8 times that of the leading nations, while our age under-5 mortality is 2.3 to 3.5 times that of the leading nations. In other words, as bad bad as our infant mortality is, our mortality for older children is even worse. That's the exact opposite of what we'd expect to see if our infant mortality rate were artificially elevated by definitional games about "live births."
Life expectancy stats bear this out, too:
http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/your-life-expectancy-by-age
At birth, our life expectancy is 37th in the world. That could be affected by high death rates of those "live births" that supposedly other countries don't count. But our life expectancy at age 5 is also 37th, and that can't be affected by overcounting those barely-alive newborns that other countries don't count because they die too soon. And it actually gets worse for older kids. We're ranked 38th for the life expectancies of 10-year-olds, and 39th for life expectancies of 20 year olds. Presumably this isn't because some other countries aren't counting their 20-year-olds as having been "live births."
The one bright spot for the US is that when people get quite a bit older, the US life expectancy starts climbing up the list. For example, we're 27th for life expectancy of 80-year-olds. This shouldn't be terribly surprising when you remember that the differences between the US healthcare system and those of other leading nations mostly vanishes once a person hits 65, and gets access to universal, single-payer socialized medicine. Those older people apparently don't catch up entirely, probably due to the results of having spent so much of their lives in a sub-standard healthcare system, but they at least start to bridge the gap.
The point of all this, though, is that it doesn't matter how thoroughly I've debunked the theory. I've done it before and I'll have to do it in the future, no doubt. It's a zombie, and mere logic and facts can't bring it down. It will shamble on as long as it continues to serve a political purpose. Republicans and libertarians need a way to explain away our horrible health stats in this country, relative to the stats of countries with more socialized medicine, and so this pet theory will continue to catch on with them, without them bothering to ask for a shred of evidence, much less double checking it themselves with the widely available stats.
Last edited: