New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Zombie Ideas

Arkady

President
Paul Krugman uses a great term of "zombie idea" to describe any proposition that has been thoroughly refuted by analysis and evidence, and should be dead - but won't stay dead because it serves a political purpose, appeals to prejudices, or both.

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/06/george-orwell-and-the-zombies/?_r=0

There are a number of examples he cites, but one of the more important ones is the spin that says that US federal government efforts to increase lending to minorities was responsible for the housing collapse and financial meltdown of 2008.

This has been studied by academics and refuted thoroughly -- that pressure to lend was a tiny factor, at most. But the idea can also be refuted, without a need for advanced statistical and economic knowledge, just by applying a little common sense. If all or even most of what was going on was an increase of risky loans to minorities in poor neighborhoods (the practice the government encouraged), the housing collapse would have been mostly confined to those neighborhoods, and the financial damage would have been confined to Fannie and Freddie, which the government caused to underwrite those loans, not private lenders, who were free not to make them. In reality, the housing collapse encompassed all sorts of properties that weren't touched at all by the effort to expand minority lending in poor neighborhoods: McMansions, second homes in vacation locations, sun-belt investment properties, and markets far afield of any US federal government influence, from Ireland to Spain. And the financial damage spread by way of investment banks that were in no way required by government to buy up that bad debt, much less to package it and sell it off in insured tranches (which the government in no way required any insurer to underwrite), as mortgage-backed securities, to investors around the world (whom the government in no way required to buy it). In fact, Fannie and Freddie were followers, not leaders, when it came to making risky loans.

In short, both academic analysis and common sense tell you most of what happened with the financial meltdown was about underregulated speculation and exotic, poorly-understood investment vehicles, not a handful of government-encouraged loans to boost minority homeownership. But it serves a political purpose to claim otherwise. It allows people to believe that government is the problem, and that unregulated financial markets can be trusted, and that's an important thing for libertarians and libertarian-minded Republicans to believe to hold their worldview together. So, the theory marches on, like a zombie, even though by all rights it should have been long dead.

Anyway, I've seen a similar zombie idea in play here on this forum. Several times, when faced with clear evidence of the US's underperformance in public health results, such our as high infant mortality or our low life expectancy numbers, conservatives have posted the argument that those stats are just a reflection of the US supposedly defining "live births" differently from other countries. They never cite any evidence of this, of course. They just assert it's true. Supposedly, the US counts all births with a heartbeat, whereas most countries don't count babies as people unless they survive for some period of time, and thus our infant mortality rates are artificially raised relative to theirs, and our life expectancy numbers are artificially depressed.

The US ranks 34th in Infant Mortality:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate

We rank 42 in under-5 mortality:
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?order=wbapi_data_value_2012 wbapi_data_value wbapi_data_value-last&sort=asc

Our Infant mortality is 5.4 (according to the UN, for 2005/2010), compared to 1.92-3.51 for top-10 nations. Our under-5 mortality is 7, compared to 2-3 for top 10 nations (UN numbers for 2010). So, our infant mortality is 1.5 to 2.8 times that of the leading nations, while our age under-5 mortality is 2.3 to 3.5 times that of the leading nations. In other words, as bad bad as our infant mortality is, our mortality for older children is even worse. That's the exact opposite of what we'd expect to see if our infant mortality rate were artificially elevated by definitional games about "live births."

Life expectancy stats bear this out, too:
http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/your-life-expectancy-by-age

At birth, our life expectancy is 37th in the world. That could be affected by high death rates of those "live births" that supposedly other countries don't count. But our life expectancy at age 5 is also 37th, and that can't be affected by overcounting those barely-alive newborns that other countries don't count because they die too soon. And it actually gets worse for older kids. We're ranked 38th for the life expectancies of 10-year-olds, and 39th for life expectancies of 20 year olds. Presumably this isn't because some other countries aren't counting their 20-year-olds as having been "live births."

The one bright spot for the US is that when people get quite a bit older, the US life expectancy starts climbing up the list. For example, we're 27th for life expectancy of 80-year-olds. This shouldn't be terribly surprising when you remember that the differences between the US healthcare system and those of other leading nations mostly vanishes once a person hits 65, and gets access to universal, single-payer socialized medicine. Those older people apparently don't catch up entirely, probably due to the results of having spent so much of their lives in a sub-standard healthcare system, but they at least start to bridge the gap.

The point of all this, though, is that it doesn't matter how thoroughly I've debunked the theory. I've done it before and I'll have to do it in the future, no doubt. It's a zombie, and mere logic and facts can't bring it down. It will shamble on as long as it continues to serve a political purpose. Republicans and libertarians need a way to explain away our horrible health stats in this country, relative to the stats of countries with more socialized medicine, and so this pet theory will continue to catch on with them, without them bothering to ask for a shred of evidence, much less double checking it themselves with the widely available stats.
 
Last edited:
Paul Krugman uses a great term of "zombie idea" to describe any proposition that has been thoroughly refuted by analysis and evidence, and should be dead - but won't stay dead because it serves a political purpose, appeals to prejudices, or both.

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/06/george-orwell-and-the-zombies/?_r=0

There are a number of examples he cites, but one of the more important ones is the spin that says that US federal government efforts to increase lending to minorities was responsible for the housing collapse and financial meltdown of 2008.

This has been studied by academics and refuted thoroughly -- that pressure to lend was a tiny factor, at most. But the idea can also be refuted, without a need for advanced statistical and economic knowledge, just by applying a little common sense. If all or even most of what was going on was an increase of risky loans to minorities in poor neighborhoods (the practice the government encouraged), the housing collapse would have been mostly confined to those neighborhoods, and the financial damage would have been confined to Fannie and Freddie, which the government caused to underwrite those loans, not private lenders, who were free not to make them. In reality, the housing collapse encompassed all sorts of properties that weren't touched at all by the effort to expand minority lending in poor neighborhoods: McMansions, second homes in vacation locations, sun-belt investment properties, and markets far afield of any US federal government influence, from Ireland to Spain. And the financial damage spread by way of investment banks that were in no way required by government to buy up that bad debt, much less to package it and sell it off in insured tranches (which the government in no way required any insurer to underwrite), as mortgage-backed securities, to investors around the world (whom the government in no way required to buy it). In fact, Fannie and Freddie were followers, not leaders, when it came to making risky loans.

In short, both academic analysis and common sense tell you most of what happened with the financial meltdown was about underregulated speculation and exotic, poorly-understood investment vehicles, not a handful of government-encouraged loans to boost minority homeownership. But it serves a political purpose to claim otherwise. It allows people to believe that government is the problem, and that unregulated financial markets can be trusted, and that's an important thing for libertarians and libertarian-minded Republicans to believe to hold their worldview together. So, the theory marches on, like a zombie, even though by all rights it should have been long dead.

Anyway, I've seen a similar zombie idea in play here on this forum. Several times, when faced with clear evidence of the US's underperformance in public health results, such our as high infant mortality or our low life expectancy numbers, conservatives have posted the argument that those stats are just a reflection of the US supposedly defining "live births" differently from other countries. They never cite any evidence of this, of course. They just assert it's true. Supposedly, the US counts all births with a heartbeat, whereas most countries don't count babies as people unless they survive for some period of time, and thus our infant mortality rates are artificially raised relative to theirs, and our life expectancy numbers are artificially depressed.

The US ranks 34th in Infant Mortality:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate

We rank 42 in under-5 mortality:
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?order=wbapi_data_value_2012 wbapi_data_value wbapi_data_value-last&sort=asc

Our Infant mortality is 5.4 (according to the UN, for 2005/2010), compared to 1.92-3.51 for top-10 nations. Our under-5 mortality is 7, compared to 2-3 for top 10 nations (UN numbers for 2010). So, our infant mortality is 1.5 to 2.8 times that of the leading nations, while our age under-5 mortality is 2.3 to 3.5 times that of the leading nations. In other words, as bad bad as our infant mortality is, our mortality for older children is even worse. That's the exact opposite of what we'd expect to see if our infant mortality rate were artificially elevated by definitional games about "live births."

Life expectancy stats bear this out, too:
http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/your-life-expectancy-by-age

At birth, our life expectancy is 37th in the world. That could be affected by high death rates of those "live births" that supposedly other countries don't count. But our life expectancy at age 5 is also 37th, and that can't be affected by overcounting those barely-alive newborns that other countries don't count because they die too soon. And it actually gets worse for older kids. We're ranked 38th for the life expectancies of 10-year-olds, and 39th for life expectancies of 20 year olds. Presumably this isn't because some other countries aren't counting their 20-year-olds as having been "live births."

The one bright spot for the US is that when people get quite a bit older, the US life expectancy starts climbing up the list. For example, we're 27th for life expectancy of 80-year-olds. This shouldn't be terribly surprising when you remember that the differences between the US healthcare system and those of other leading nations mostly vanishes once a person hits 65, and gets access to universal, single-payer socialized medicine. Those older people apparently don't catch up entirely, probably due to the results of having spent so much of their lives in a sub-standard healthcare system, but they at least start to bridge the gap.

The point of all this, though, is that it doesn't matter how thoroughly I've debunked the theory. I've done it before and I'll have to do it in the future, no doubt. It's a zombie, and mere logic and facts can't bring it down. It will shamble on as long as it continues to serve a political purpose. Republicans and libertarians need a way to explain away our horrible health stats in this country, relative to the stats of countries with more socialized medicine, and so this pet theory will continue to catch on with them, without them bothering to ask for a shred of evidence, much less double checking it themselves with the widely available stats.

Yep. I posted that to another a few days ago in a thread arky. https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/the-obamacare-wingnut-hole.63303/page-2#post-928609

It's precisely why it's largely a waste of time and text to "debate" rightwingers on much of anything. As you know, there's a big diff between what goes into/is acceptable in "debate" in this court of public opinion and what prevails in a court of law. Evidence can be ignored here. I've long called it the "triple-D". They premise their BS on some dishonesty, then dodge when that's demonstrated, ultimately leaving them little but denial. Denial is what keeps their dishonest BS animated, and makes the bubble it forms inpenetratable.
 
Yep. I posted that to another a few days ago in a thread arky. https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/the-obamacare-wingnut-hole.63303/page-2#post-928609

It's precisely why it's largely a waste of time and text to "debate" rightwingers on much of anything. As you know, there's a big diff between what goes into/is acceptable in "debate" in this court of public opinion and what prevails in a court of law. Evidence can be ignored here. I've long called it the "triple-D". They premise their BS on some dishonesty, then dodge when that's demonstrated, ultimately leaving them little but denial. Denial is what keeps their dishonest BS animated, and makes the bubble it forms inpenetratable.
The tendency for those on the right to insist on their own set of factoids, unrelated to any verifiable real-world facts, is the frustrating thing. If I hashed out an argument with a right-winger and we ultimately came down to a difference of interpretation about some unknown things, are just different value judgments about matters that are qualitative (e.g., the relative importance of the freedom to own a gun versus the importance of a human life), I could handle that, since at least then we would have narrowed down the scope of the controversy to some genuinely unresolvable things, and we'd both be thinking more clearly about it, having identified the crux of the issue. But when we can't even agree on the basic facts in play, despite them being widely available and subject to no sensible controversy, we never even approach a resolution. For example, yesterday a conservative here demanded to know what I thought about poverty having risen over Clinton's first term when, according to the official poverty stats, poverty fell considerably over Clinton's first term. How can you even get down to the crux of the disagreement when arguing with someone who clings to alternative-universe factoids?
 
The tendency for those on the right to insist on their own set of factoids, unrelated to any verifiable real-world facts, is the frustrating thing. If I hashed out an argument with a right-winger and we ultimately came down to a difference of interpretation about some unknown things, are just different value judgments about matters that are qualitative (e.g., the relative importance of the freedom to own a gun versus the importance of a human life), I could handle that, since at least then we would have narrowed down the scope of the controversy to some genuinely unresolvable things, and we'd both be thinking more clearly about it, having identified the crux of the issue. But when we can't even agree on the basic facts in play, despite them being widely available and subject to no sensible controversy, we never even approach a resolution. For example, yesterday a conservative here demanded to know what I thought about poverty having risen over Clinton's first term when, according to the official poverty stats, poverty fell considerably over Clinton's first term. How can you even get down to the crux of the disagreement when arguing with someone who clings to alternative-universe factoids?


Perhaps you are speaking to the wrong people?
 
The idea that depriving law-abiding citizens of their civil rights will somehow reduce crime is one of these "zombie" ideas...
 
How can you even get down to the crux of the disagreement when arguing with someone who clings to alternative-universe factoids?

you can't my friend, which is why it is futile to try in most cases, and why I largely don't even try with most around here.

The problem is as I've long argued it, the product of the calculated destruction of the concept of "agreed upon facts" that largely prevailed until the calculated and concerted effort on the part of the rightwingters to destroy it, starting decades ago with the abolition of the Fairness Doctrine, and the adoption of the "the ends justify the means" rationale that provides the necessary moral justification for their willful dishonesty, at least in terms of the political world. One of the few things Raygun got right was his observation or declaration anyway, that morality and politics are inseparable.

What makes it such an impossible obstacle to overcome is the positive reinforcement all the rightwing participants in it provide each other, whether you're talking about the pols and pundits, or their little minions spreading the word here on PJ's. The shame that use to accompany being so abysmally wrong and serve as a deterrent to such as well as a bahavior modifier, no longer exists in any meaningfull measure, but remains our only tool and source of hope. Back in the days of Cronkite, Hunt and Brinkley, and the other truthtellers before them -- by the standards of today anyway -- the kinda wholesale and perpetual lying by rightwingers would have likely been shamed outta existence. In the world of today for example, all those who got the Iraq War thing right are dying in obscurity, whereas those who got it wrong are found every weekend on the "liberal" talk shows.

As far as I have long been concerned, in many ways the abandonment of that concept underlies almost all of our current political problems, as well as with the political discourse through which remedies are sought, if you consider incivility a problem. It's why I've long argued that civility in this day and age are way overrated -- a conclusion I'm happy to see many on the left adopting http://www.balloon-juice.com/2014/01/05/late-to-the-game-3/ and also why I've long argued that their dishonesty is the reason for whatever moral outrage lefties express in the course of their political commentary -- the primary source of the incivility they whine about if and only if they are the victims of it.

It's also why my posting habits and practices differ from yours in terms of the extent to which we respectively go in beating our heads against the proverbial wall all these things have created. I'm not being critical of, and actually admire the tenacity you and others display while trying to overcome these hurdles. Other than the top posts I post to rebut their garbage as factual matters, I simply haven't the time or interest in engaging many of them in protracted battles that culminate in no forward progress or resolution, and simply take for granted that the other posters of like mind like you know what the flaw in their BS is.

And the worst part about it is arky, is that there's such a humongous compilation of things they are and have been so grosssly wrong about as factual matters, that it has become as an individual matter for many if not most, a matter of ego preservation, hence the denial cure for whatever ails them of the fact-challenged kind. It's like trying to deprogram a longtime cult member. This is why I think those who have been deprogrammed to some extent, like Sullivan, Frum, Bartlett, and a few other more obscure talking heads have become some of the rightwinger best or worst critics -- however you wanna see it -- as a way of doing penance or maintaining some denial of their role in creating the very monster they are condemning.

Keep up the good work, because silence will get us nowhere, and like "civility" in the face of all their incivility, it really only contributes to the problem imo. Sooner or later their credulity and dishonesty are gonna crash and burn on the wall of reality, and I've long been convinced that global warming is gonna be that wall that shows the costliness of their foray into unreality they've long been on. There's nothing like an existential threat to snap one outta such, and that one will require "socialistic" solutions their ideology as it is currently practiced can provide no solutions for.

have a good one dude -- gotta scoot
 
The idea that depriving law-abiding citizens of their civil rights will somehow reduce crime is one of these "zombie" ideas...
We have about forty examples, around the world, of wealthy, pluralistic democracies. I'm a very practical guy: if we want to reduce crime, I favor studying those real-world examples to see what works and what doesn't, rather than just relying on naked rhetoric and political orthodoxy to set our policies.

The great news is that there are lots and lots of pluralistic democracies to choose from that seem to be doing a better job than us, when it comes to keeping crime down. In fact, all of them are doing a better job than us, so there are models to learn from wherever we look.

Since intentional homicide is the most consistently compiled stat (as opposed to, say, assault, where one country may mean any assault and one may mean aggravated assault), let's use that one. Of the 40 or so wealthy, pluralistic democracies that all have lower murder rates than us, here are the major ones (those with at least 20 million citizens), to use as models: Japan, Spain, Germany, Italy, Australia, France, and South Korea, at least. Their murder rates range from 0.3 (Japan) to 2.6 (South Korea). If the US could mimic their success, we'd have between one-half and one-sixteenth as many murders as we currently have.

So, what policies do those countries have in common, that might be related to crime... policies where the US differs considerably? That seems like a decent place to start an analysis grounded in real-world facts, rather than flights of propaganda, don't you think?
 
We have about forty examples, around the world, of wealthy, pluralistic democracies. I'm a very practical guy: if we want to reduce crime, I favor studying those real-world examples to see what works and what doesn't, rather than just relying on naked rhetoric and political orthodoxy to set our policies.

The great news is that there are lots and lots of pluralistic democracies to choose from that seem to be doing a better job than us, when it comes to keeping crime down. In fact, all of them are doing a better job than us, so there are models to learn from wherever we look.

Since intentional homicide is the most consistently compiled stat (as opposed to, say, assault, where one country may mean any assault and one may mean aggravated assault), let's use that one. Of the 40 or so wealthy, pluralistic democracies that all have lower murder rates than us, here are the major ones (those with at least 20 million citizens), to use as models: Japan, Spain, Germany, Italy, Australia, France, and South Korea, at least. Their murder rates range from 0.3 (Japan) to 2.6 (South Korea). If the US could mimic their success, we'd have between one-half and one-sixteenth as many murders as we currently have.

So, what policies do those countries have in common, that might be related to crime... policies where the US differs considerably? That seems like a decent place to start an analysis grounded in real-world facts, rather than flights of propaganda, don't you think?


interestingly, the US ranks worse not only vs many similar democracies, but also vs many authoritarian nations.. china, syria, cuba...to cite but a few examples..
 
Paul Krugman uses a great term of "zombie idea" to describe any proposition that has been thoroughly refuted by analysis and evidence, and should be dead - but won't stay dead because it serves a political purpose, appeals to prejudices, or both

and Paul Krugman is an idiot
 
The shame that use to accompany being so abysmally wrong and serve as a deterrent to such as well as a bahavior modifier, no longer exists in any meaningfull measure, but remains our only tool and source of hope.

I think you get at the heart of the matter there. And it's the part that really bugs me, because my own behavior is so different. It's not that I never screw up my facts. Of course I do. But I feel genuinely ashamed when I do, and that keeps me on the toes. That's what causes me, for example, to keep a little mental list of untrustworthy liberal sources. When a source tells me something I'm predisposed to believe, and I pass it along, and it ends up being wrong, I'm really embarrassed, and I'm angry at the source for setting me up to embarrass myself that way, and so I make a mental note. From there on out, I double-check material coming from that source before I pass it along. Michael Moore is an example of such a source. He is sloppy with his facts in his blogging and media appearances (less so in his films), and he burned me once, so now whenever I get a tidbit from him, I check it against reputable sources before using it.

But conservatives never seem to be doing that. They can get horribly misleading information time and again from a sloppy or dishonest source like Fox News or Breitbart, and they can get humiliated again and again by passing along those things as facts, and it never seems to alert them to the fact those are bad sources. They just don't seem to feel shame about it. And I don't get that mentality. When I put my name behind something, and I'm proven wrong, I'm angry at myself and everyone involved in steering me in the wrong direction. Why aren't conservatives that way?

Back in the days of Cronkite, Hunt and Brinkley, and the other truthtellers before them -- by the standards of today anyway -- the kinda wholesale and perpetual lying by rightwingers would have likely been shamed outta existence.
I think they've identified a weakness in the way our news media work. Calling someone a liar is treated as out-of-bounds. In the interest of the appearance of impartiality, the media almost always stick to a "he said, she said" format. At most, they'll quote a democrat pointing out that the Republican was lying. They'll never just come out and say that, yes, they researched the facts, and the Republican was lying (or even just wrong). Once Republicans realized that weakness in our system, they could exploit it mercilessly. They could say any old nonsense, and the he-said, she-said format would imply that the truth was halfway between whatever the Dems were saying and whatever they were saying. If the Dems were trying to stick somewhat close to the middle ground of truth, and the Republicans were pushing a view that was way, way out in right field, and all the media would do is point out what each side was saying, your typical person would come to the false assumption that the truth was halfway between the two, which is still fairly far out in right field.

In the world of today for example, all those who got the Iraq War thing right are dying in obscurity, whereas those who got it wrong are found every weekend on the "liberal" talk shows.

You're spot-on with that criticism, too. The corporate media treats support for war --any war anyone cares to propose-- as a test of seriousness. Better, from the media's perspective, to be wildly, hilariously wrong about a war, in the company of all the other "serious" people, than to be right about it, out among the "unhinged peaceniks." Repeated evidence that a commentator knows less than nothing about the topic on which he is presented as an expert simply doesn't matter. Think of all the neoconservative "middle east experts" who have proven wrong about every major foreign policy question of the last twenty years, who somehow continue to be handed seats on the Sunday shows and sinecures at the Washington Post. "Expertise" in this case merely means "willingness to shill for Likud's wish list."

I'm not being critical of, and actually admire the tenacity you and others display while trying to overcome these hurdles.
I have this persistent, irrational belief that, deep down, it's a failure on my part to find just the right magic combination of words to slip past the prejudices of the conservatives and get them to think honestly about a topic. So I keep varying it up a little here and there, thinking eventually I'll have honed the argument to the point it can slice through their walls.

This is why I think those who have been deprogrammed to some extent, like Sullivan, Frum, Bartlett, and a few other more obscure talking heads have become some of the rightwinger best or worst critics

David Brock, one-time author of a vicious attack on Anita Hill, is a great example. When he wised up, be became an invaluable source for information on how things actually work at the Washington Times and the conservative think tanks.

I've long been convinced that global warming is gonna be that wall that shows the costliness of their foray into unreality they've long been on.
I'm not sure they'll ever wise up to their error. Even once it becomes painfully obvious how wrong they were, they'll just rewrite history to pretend they didn't take the stances they took.. Just look at the history of the Civil Rights movement. A couple decades after the big battles of the mid-1960s, you'd be hard-pressed to find any major public figure who'd argue that the Civil Rights Act, Voting Rights Act, forced desegregation, invalidation of anti-miscegenation laws, etc., were bad things. But you'd also be hard-pressed to find anyone who admitted they EVER thought they were bad things. The role of countless conservatives in fighting on the wrong side of those things was simply whitewashed -- erased from their legacies, for all practical purposes. When Reagan died, how many times did you hear anyone mention his aggressive opposition to civil rights efforts in the 1960s? In the same way, the politicians today fighting tooth and nail against the consensus on climate change will simply have that whitewashed from their legacies, in twenty years, when everybody but the wildest crackpots realize the truth.
 
interestingly, the US ranks worse not only vs many similar democracies, but also vs many authoritarian nations.. china, syria, cuba...to cite but a few examples..
Yep. There are different ways to acheive desired social stats of different kinds. It appears you can get low violent crime rates either through the route taken by many wealthy nations (encouraging broad prosperity, excellent education, liveable cities, etc.), or you can get there the way authoritarian nations do (police-state spying on citizens, draconian penalties for even the most minor offenders, etc.) I don't want to try to replicate the methods of the authoritarian countries, even if they are successful on that particular stat. Instead, I look to our peers as a model... other large, wealthy, pluralistic democracies that have fairly open societies and essentially capitalistic market economies. They're the ones I think are more likely to have found more palatable solutions to problems we suffer.
 
Yep. There are different ways to acheive desired social stats of different kinds. It appears you can get low violent crime rates either through the route taken by many wealthy nations (encouraging broad prosperity, excellent education, liveable cities, etc.), or you can get there the way authoritarian nations do (police-state spying on citizens, draconian penalties for even the most minor offenders, etc.) I don't want to try to replicate the methods of the authoritarian countries, even if they are successful on that particular stat. Instead, I look to our peers as a model... other large, wealthy, pluralistic democracies that have fairly open societies and essentially capitalistic market economies. They're the ones I think are more likely to have found more palatable solutions to problems we suffer.


i imagine theres a continuum..not solely draconian (inmany cases),..but yes
 
I think you get at the heart of the matter there. And it's the part that really bugs me, because my own behavior is so different. It's not that I never screw up my facts. Of course I do. But I feel genuinely ashamed when I do, and that keeps me on the toes. That's what causes me, for example, to keep a little mental list of untrustworthy liberal sources. When a source tells me something I'm predisposed to believe, and I pass it along, and it ends up being wrong, I'm really embarrassed, and I'm angry at the source for setting me up to embarrass myself that way, and so I make a mental note. From there on out, I double-check material coming from that source before I pass it along. Michael Moore is an example of such a source. He is sloppy with his facts in his blogging and media appearances (less so in his films), and he burned me once, so now whenever I get a tidbit from him, I check it against reputable sources before using it.

But conservatives never seem to be doing that. They can get horribly misleading information time and again from a sloppy or dishonest source like Fox News or Breitbart, and they can get humiliated again and again by passing along those things as facts, and it never seems to alert them to the fact those are bad sources. They just don't seem to feel shame about it. And I don't get that mentality. When I put my name behind something, and I'm proven wrong, I'm angry at myself and everyone involved in steering me in the wrong direction. Why aren't conservatives that way?


I think they've identified a weakness in the way our news media work. Calling someone a liar is treated as out-of-bounds. In the interest of the appearance of impartiality, the media almost always stick to a "he said, she said" format. At most, they'll quote a democrat pointing out that the Republican was lying. They'll never just come out and say that, yes, they researched the facts, and the Republican was lying (or even just wrong). Once Republicans realized that weakness in our system, they could exploit it mercilessly. They could say any old nonsense, and the he-said, she-said format would imply that the truth was halfway between whatever the Dems were saying and whatever they were saying. If the Dems were trying to stick somewhat close to the middle ground of truth, and the Republicans were pushing a view that was way, way out in right field, and all the media would do is point out what each side was saying, your typical person would come to the false assumption that the truth was halfway between the two, which is still fairly far out in right field.



You're spot-on with that criticism, too. The corporate media treats support for war --any war anyone cares to propose-- as a test of seriousness. Better, from the media's perspective, to be wildly, hilariously wrong about a war, in the company of all the other "serious" people, than to be right about it, out among the "unhinged peaceniks." Repeated evidence that a commentator knows less than nothing about the topic on which he is presented as an expert simply doesn't matter. Think of all the neoconservative "middle east experts" who have proven wrong about every major foreign policy question of the last twenty years, who somehow continue to be handed seats on the Sunday shows and sinecures at the Washington Post. "Expertise" in this case merely means "willingness to shill for Likud's wish list."


I have this persistent, irrational belief that, deep down, it's a failure on my part to find just the right magic combination of words to slip past the prejudices of the conservatives and get them to think honestly about a topic. So I keep varying it up a little here and there, thinking eventually I'll have honed the argument to the point it can slice through their walls.



David Brock, one-time author of a vicious attack on Anita Hill, is a great example. When he wised up, be became an invaluable source for information on how things actually work at the Washington Times and the conservative think tanks.


I'm not sure they'll ever wise up to their error. Even once it becomes painfully obvious how wrong they were, they'll just rewrite history to pretend they didn't take the stances they took.. Just look at the history of the Civil Rights movement. A couple decades after the big battles of the mid-1960s, you'd be hard-pressed to find any major public figure who'd argue that the Civil Rights Act, Voting Rights Act, forced desegregation, invalidation of anti-miscegenation laws, etc., were bad things. But you'd also be hard-pressed to find anyone who admitted they EVER thought they were bad things. The role of countless conservatives in fighting on the wrong side of those things was simply whitewashed -- erased from their legacies, for all practical purposes. When Reagan died, how many times did you hear anyone mention his aggressive opposition to civil rights efforts in the 1960s? In the same way, the politicians today fighting tooth and nail against the consensus on climate change will simply have that whitewashed from their legacies, in twenty years, when everybody but the wildest crackpots realize the truth.

I'll address the last thing here arky. The reason I think it will be different and transformative is because people will be living and dealing with it, and will have to rely upon the gov for solutions that "free markets" can no longer provide to the problem that originated with it. In the final analysis, in this scenario it really doesn't matter whether or not whether they own up or not, I'm arguing that they will still morph into something more like the creatures they have much scorn for now, like you and I...lol

This is not to say that the "con" ideology will die, just that the one that has developed in recent years that is so anti-science and fact-averse will. What I'm basically talking about is the unmerciful death of those goons, and hopefully the rise of a more sane bunch, like we use to have http://boldprogressives.org/2012/08/the-surprisingly-progressive-republican-party-platform-of-1956/
 
Back
Top