Arkady
President
During the Republican convention, the mother of one of the two Americans killed in the attack on the Benghazi diplomatic compound criticized Hillary Clinton in very harsh terms, calling her personally responsible for her son's death and accusing her of lying about it later. Clinton responded by saying her heart goes out to the mothers of the Americans killed in Benghazi, and she suggested that the understandable grief involved could have caused the woman to misremember what Clinton had said to her.
Now, imagine an alternate reality in which Clinton acted like Trump. She would immediately attack, demanding to know why the woman's husband hadn't spoken at the convention. Then she'd say that the woman had no right to question her security decisions. Then, once the media had reacted with horror to those missteps, she'd start whining about how unfair it was that she could be attacked by a grieving mother but criticized for counter-attacking. She'd also start whinging about how hard she works and how many sacrifices she's made, while bragging about what a "tremendous success" she's been.
It's hard to imagine an alternate reality like that. Whatever Clinton's faults as a person or politician, she handles herself with dignity and class, and is smart enough to realize that there's no way to win that kind of fight with a parent who lashes out after losing a child. She has the wisdom to know which battles to fight, and the tact and self-discipline to keep her mouth shut in situations where she can only hurt herself by engaging. That's part of what we call being presidential.
Presidential behavior isn't everything. If Trump is just auditioning for his next lowest-common-denominator reality TV show, his instinct for outrageousness, his thin-skin, and his lack of filters are all big assets. Like Simon Cowell, Paris Hilton, and Honey Boo Boo, he's showing he's got the right stuff for that job. But that's not the job he's nominally applying for. He's applying for a job where he may have to represent our nation in nuclear negotiations, or to be the calming figure in the face of a crisis, or to lead our nation in grieving a national tragedy, or find a way to bring the sides together to prevent a debt default, etc. That role calls for the ability to adopt a certain solid manner, and that's a skill Trump has never shown. He's a shit stirrer. That's great if he wants to be a contestant on next season's Survivor, but who wants that in the Oval Office?
Now, imagine an alternate reality in which Clinton acted like Trump. She would immediately attack, demanding to know why the woman's husband hadn't spoken at the convention. Then she'd say that the woman had no right to question her security decisions. Then, once the media had reacted with horror to those missteps, she'd start whining about how unfair it was that she could be attacked by a grieving mother but criticized for counter-attacking. She'd also start whinging about how hard she works and how many sacrifices she's made, while bragging about what a "tremendous success" she's been.
It's hard to imagine an alternate reality like that. Whatever Clinton's faults as a person or politician, she handles herself with dignity and class, and is smart enough to realize that there's no way to win that kind of fight with a parent who lashes out after losing a child. She has the wisdom to know which battles to fight, and the tact and self-discipline to keep her mouth shut in situations where she can only hurt herself by engaging. That's part of what we call being presidential.
Presidential behavior isn't everything. If Trump is just auditioning for his next lowest-common-denominator reality TV show, his instinct for outrageousness, his thin-skin, and his lack of filters are all big assets. Like Simon Cowell, Paris Hilton, and Honey Boo Boo, he's showing he's got the right stuff for that job. But that's not the job he's nominally applying for. He's applying for a job where he may have to represent our nation in nuclear negotiations, or to be the calming figure in the face of a crisis, or to lead our nation in grieving a national tragedy, or find a way to bring the sides together to prevent a debt default, etc. That role calls for the ability to adopt a certain solid manner, and that's a skill Trump has never shown. He's a shit stirrer. That's great if he wants to be a contestant on next season's Survivor, but who wants that in the Oval Office?
Last edited: