New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

12 Vs. 2000

You literally believe that if there was a God there should be no evil and the world should be perfect from the get go (hint: it is for its purpose).

What makes you think that's what I think? I understand the standard talking point from religious types that evil is a natural consequence of God allowing free will. I have never seen evil as evidence against the existence of God, or many gods, or fairies, or spaghetti monsters, or pegasi, or any other hypothetical being you want to invent. The reason not to believe in God is simply that it's an extraordinary claim for which we have absolutely no evidence. As with the existence of leprechauns, or telepathic communication, or fire-breathing dragons, etc., the sensible approach to a claim that's at odds with what we've observed of the world, and for which we lack any evidence, is simple disbelief.

Try to think of it in terms of some supernatural hypothetical you disbelieve. Consider, for example, the idea that when nobody is looking, garden gnomes come to life and dance around the garden -- always careful to leave no evidence. Now imagine that someone said that the reason you don't believe this is true is because you think that if garden gnomes really did that, there would be no evil. Now, perhaps, you're getting an idea of just how silly your non sequitur appears to me. The existence of evil has nothing to do with why you don't believe in those living garden gnomes, just as the existence of evil has nothing to do with why I don't believe in God.

There is nothing in the New Testament for the LRA to hang its hat on

They disagree. And a peaceful Muslim will claim there's nothing in the Koran for a Wahabist to hang his hat on, and the Wahabist will disagree.
 
i know . . . i know . .. call on me !!!

the reason the 16 (not 12) french people got more media attention is because they're WHITE !!

it's the same reason american newspapers ignore the thousands and thousands of black on black homicides each year, but fall all over themselves to raise attention in the event its a white who pulls the trigger.
 
What makes you think that's what I think? I understand the standard talking point from religious types that evil is a natural consequence of God allowing free will. I have never seen evil as evidence against the existence of God, or many gods, or fairies, or spaghetti monsters, or pegasi, or any other hypothetical being you want to invent. The reason not to believe in God is simply that it's an extraordinary claim for which we have absolutely no evidence. As with the existence of leprechauns, or telepathic communication, or fire-breathing dragons, etc., the sensible approach to a claim that's at odds with what we've observed of the world, and for which we lack any evidence, is simple disbelief.

Try to think of it in terms of some supernatural hypothetical you disbelieve. Consider, for example, the idea that when nobody is looking, garden gnomes come to life and dance around the garden -- always careful to leave no evidence. Now imagine that someone said that the reason you don't believe this is true is because you think that if garden gnomes really did that, there would be no evil. Now, perhaps, you're getting an idea of just how silly your non sequitur appears to me. The existence of evil has nothing to do with why you don't believe in those living garden gnomes, just as the existence of evil has nothing to do with why I don't believe in God.



They disagree. And a peaceful Muslim will claim there's nothing in the Koran for a Wahabist to hang his hat on, and the Wahabist will disagree.

I've debated better on this matter spaghetti monsters and all.

Simplistically: DNA codes for proteins. Proteins are needed to replicate DNA, regardless of billions of years, the needed confluence of lined up probabilities for a highly ordered biochemistry to arise for life to just have happened is absurd (highly selective environment or not). All abiotic systems closed or not tend towards entropy and life is antithetical to that concept because of the highly ordered nature of life even in energy consumption.

Not only that there are many supposedly global disasters that obliterated life on earth that you are undoubtedly aware of that impart either a fiery obliteration on the one hand or a complete global freezing on the other.

Only a hubristic personality asserts that they know for sure what has transpired over the course of billions of years. It does take an atheist to assert that the proof there is no need for God for creation is the fact that look we are here. Don't you just love that kind of logic.
 
They disagree. And a peaceful Muslim will claim there's nothing in the Koran for a Wahabist to hang his hat on, and the Wahabist will disagree.

Maybe you should read the quran and the literature from which Sharia law is derived before you go relying on what a peaceful muslim has claimed to you. The bastards aren't pulling it out of their ass.
 
Last edited:
Simplistically: DNA codes for proteins.

So? That isn't evidence for the existence of God any more than it's evidence for the existence of Leprechauns. All it is evidence for is some earlier stage of development where some precursor to DNA didn't require proteins. It's like a chicken-and-egg problem, where you can't have a chicken without an egg for it to have come from and you can't have an egg without a chicken to lay it. That's not actually a paradox, since all you need is for each to have developed incrementally to their current point, from some earlier stages that required neither the chicken nor the chicken egg.

the needed confluence of lined up probabilities for a highly ordered biochemistry to arise for life to just have happened is absurd

It's hard to say what the probabilities are from what amounts to a sample-size of one: a single planet known to have life. When we have more of an opportunity to explore the galaxy, we'll have a better idea of whether the formation of life is a fairly high probability thing in any system with the necessary chemical components, or whether it's a real long-shot. Neither of those, however, will be evidence in favor of the existence of a god or leprechauns, or any other supernatural phenomenon.

All abiotic systems closed or not tend towards entropy and life is antithetical to that concept because of the highly ordered nature of life even in energy consumption.

That's a common misunderstanding of entropy among the poorly educated. Entropy doesn't say systems can't get more ordered. It just requires external energy for that to happen. And on Earth, we have a whole hell of a lot of it, in the form of the Sun.

Only a hubristic personality asserts that they know for sure what has transpired over the course of billions of years.

The hubris, in this case, is on the part of the theists, who insist they KNOW there is a God, without even a shred of evidence. If you met people who insisted they KNEW there were leprechauns, in the absence of any evidence to support that, you'd consider them to be somewhere between dangerously egomaniacal and downright nuts. That's how rational people regard those who claim to know there is a God.

Keep in mind, I'm not trying to disprove the existence of God, any more than you'd try to disprove leprechauns, or the existence of the Olympian Pantheon, or flying spaghetti monsters, etc. Such a disproof is likely impossible, in all those cases. But that doesn't mean any rational person will believe in them, absent any evidence. With extraordinary claims such as those, the default position is to assume they're untrue, until some evidence comes along indicating they're true.

The extraordinary nature of the claim is an important caveat there. There are different levels of disbelief. I can be agnostic about claims for which I have no evidence but that aren't out of line with what I've observed about the world. For example, if you told me that there was a kind of deep sea shark that lives 500 years, I'd be skeptical, but ultimately agnostic. That would be an unusually long lifespan for an animal, but there are corals and sponges that live longer, and more complex animals that live well within an order of magnitude of that lifespan, so it could be. But if you told me, instead, that there is an intelligent species of mermen who live in shining cities far beneath the waves, my position would go beyond agnosticism to active disbelief, because it is so inconsistent with the world that we have evidence for. The claim about the existence of God is like the one about mermen, only more so. It goes way beyond hypothesizing a 500-year-old shark.
 
Maybe you should read the quran and the literature from which Sharia law is derived before you go relying on what a peaceful muslim has claimed to you. They bastards aren't pulling it out of their ass.
I have. I've also read the Bible, and those bastards aren't pulling that material out of their asses, either. Both the Koran and the Bible are moral abominations. But, in both cases, civilized modern people try to rehabilitate the texts by explaining away the immorality. You're well familiar with that process, since you do it all the time for the Bible. You just haven't familiarized yourself with your Muslim counterparts who play the same dishonest game with their holy text.
 
it's between the lines you post
easily understood unless a blue lib
I post a basic fact...but you...magic dawg...can read "between the lines".

Boko Haram has a very tiny little piece of Africa...

The continent consists of 11.67 million square miles. Boko Haram is said to control about 20,000 square miles. Don't think those streets are empty though.

You see this as me being OK with slaughter. Because you're OK with it...

There is nothing in my post that would engender such an absurd conclusion. You have a terrible habit of responding to what you think people say instead of what they actually say.
 
That's a common misunderstanding of entropy among the poorly educated. Entropy doesn't say systems can't get more ordered. It just requires external energy for that to happen. And on Earth, we have a whole hell of a lot of it, in the form of the Sun.

Name some number of abiotic system (to prove some reasonable ubiquity of the concept) to which you add energy and whose entropy does not increase? I'll start. Carbon heated will form graphene and under pressure diamonds. So added energy gives you a more ordered final state. After some more examples like the above, argue that organic molecules with added energy (and necessarily cooled I guess) provide more order in such a manner as to facilitate life. Give me an example of an organic molecule with energy added becoming more ordered than its initial state? Come on illustrate abiogenesis for us mere mortals.

The blind or random addition of energy to a system does not necessarily create a more ordered state from which life can come forth. It is not trivial. It may well be impossible. If it was true those studying abiogenisis would be done and nobel laureates.

Don't forget that often enough adding energy leads to a less ordered final state. Think rust.
 
Last edited:
I post a basic fact...but you...magic dawg...can read "between the lines".



You see this as me being OK with slaughter. Because you're OK with it...

There is nothing in my post that would engender such an absurd conclusion. You have a terrible habit of responding to what you think people say instead of what they actually say.

listen to the man and the wisdom, blue lib panty waste:

10891955_360257404156214_5096118116754843513_n.png
 
I have. I've also read the Bible, and those bastards aren't pulling that material out of their asses, either. Both the Koran and the Bible are moral abominations. But, in both cases, civilized modern people try to rehabilitate the texts by explaining away the immorality. You're well familiar with that process, since you do it all the time for the Bible. You just haven't familiarized yourself with your Muslim counterparts who play the same dishonest game with their holy text.
You have to date not proven any of your false claims you read in the Bible. You cling to a literal out of context reading every time you try. We've addressed your autistic like approach to the topic and clearly made the case for genetic deficiency on your part. Tragic for you really.
 
show where Christians have beheaded or killed a dozen over a cartoon of Jesus........
I didn't claim they had. But Christians have attacked women's health clinics and OB/Gyns, and are carrying out terror campaigns in central Africa.
 
Name some number of abiotic system (to prove some reasonable ubiquity of the concept) to which you add energy and whose entropy does not increase? I'll start. Carbon heated will form graphene and under pressure diamonds. So added energy gives you a more ordered final state. After some more examples like the above, argue that organic molecules with added energy (and necessarily cooled I guess) provide more order in such a manner as to facilitate life. Give me an example of an organic molecule with energy added becoming more ordered than its initial state? Come on illustrate abiogenesis for us mere mortals.

The blind or random addition of energy to a system does not necessarily create a more ordered state from which life can come forth. It is not trivial. It may well be impossible. If it was true those studying abiogenisis would be done and nobel laureates.

Don't forget that often enough adding energy leads to a less ordered final state. Think rust.
I'm not saying that adding energy always leads to a more ordered state. I'm saying that there's nothing about the concept of entropy that prevents systems from becoming more ordered when they can draw on an external energy source. Crystals are an obvious example. Every time it snows, the process happens countless times, with disordered water molecules forming into exquisitely complex snowflakes. Throw together a planet's worth of chemical reactions, plenty of energy, and run the experiment for a billion years, and there's nothing at all improbable about the idea that one of those interactions will produce a self-reproducing organic molecule that could form the basis for later life. The exact details of how that would play out is still being studied by scientists, who don't have the advantage of a planetary scale lab and a billion years to find the answer by random trial and error. It's possible we'll never know. It's even possible that the original molecules didn't form on Earth. But none of those mysteries in any way require or suggest the existence of a god or leprechauns or flying spaghetti monsters to set the whole thing in motion. In fact, injecting such hypothetical players into the process merely introduces the new mystery of where they came from.
 
You have to date not proven any of your false claims you read in the Bible. You cling to a literal out of context reading every time you try. We've addressed your autistic like approach to the topic and clearly made the case for genetic deficiency on your part. Tragic for you really.
You assume that anyone who is familiar with the actual text of the Bible, rather than swallowing the "Bible Stories for Children" version your pastor fed you, must not have actually read the Bible. It's very weird. Time and again you try to read the Bible in a way that isn't just figurative, but actually renders much of its language utterly meaningless.
 
You assume that anyone who is familiar with the actual text of the Bible, rather than swallowing the "Bible Stories for Children" version your pastor fed you, must not have actually read the Bible. It's very weird. Time and again you try to read the Bible in a way that isn't just figurative, but actually renders much of its language utterly meaningless.
Obviously you haven't taken the them to read the rather clear explanations to you. That aren't in any way as you have just characterized here. Weak Arekady, weak.
 
I'm not saying that adding energy always leads to a more ordered state. I'm saying that there's nothing about the concept of entropy that prevents systems from becoming more ordered when they can draw on an external energy source. Crystals are an obvious example. Every time it snows, the process happens countless times, with disordered water molecules forming into exquisitely complex snowflakes. Throw together a planet's worth of chemical reactions, plenty of energy, and run the experiment for a billion years, and there's nothing at all improbable about the idea that one of those interactions will produce a self-reproducing organic molecule that could form the basis for later life. The exact details of how that would play out is still being studied by scientists, who don't have the advantage of a planetary scale lab and a billion years to find the answer by random trial and error. It's possible we'll never know. It's even possible that the original molecules didn't form on Earth. But none of those mysteries in any way require or suggest the existence of a god or leprechauns or flying spaghetti monsters to set the whole thing in motion. In fact, injecting such hypothetical players into the process merely introduces the new mystery of where they came from.
You still miss the point blinded by your dogma.
 
I didn't claim they had. But Christians have attacked women's health clinics and OB/Gyns, and are carrying out terror campaigns in central Africa.

just as figured, you have nothing to compare Christians with Muslim terrorist.........
doesn't surprise me
 
I couldn't figure out what you were saying.

seems you post that same script daily, especially when you are getting your ass handed to you on a broom pole.............

that explains more of why you have no clients and are here 24/7......................
 
Back
Top