New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

12 Vs. 2000

I said you have more genetic similarity to your own cancerous mole than to your real world clone. You insist the theoretical (science fiction) clone is more exact than the real world clone. Once again a cell taken from you and grown in a petri dish to be your clone - its genetic variance to you would be similar to that of your natural born twin. Look it up.
You're still working hard to miss the point. I'll spell it out for you again, since it's my understanding that stupid people can benefit from repetition:

Whether or not a particular organism has unique DNA has exactly nothing to do with whether you feel that organism is deserving of a right to life. If two adults could be shown to be genetically identical, would you conclude that one, or the other, or both, have no right to life? If not, what exactly are you trying to argue here?
 
You're still working hard to miss the point. I'll spell it out for you again, since it's my understanding that stupid people can benefit from repetition:

Whether or not a particular organism has unique DNA has exactly nothing to do with whether you feel that organism is deserving of a right to life. If two adults could be shown to be genetically identical, would you conclude that one, or the other, or both, have no right to life? If not, what exactly are you trying to argue here?
And like I pointed out I put a brain in that mole as a joke to put a finer point on it for you. I'm sure repetition won't work for you. Your repeating yourself isn't helping you to get it right in your own head yet.
 
And like I pointed out I put a brain in that mole as a joke to put a finer point on it for you. I'm sure repetition won't work for you. Your repeating yourself isn't helping you to get it right in your own head yet.
I'm simply trying to focus the conversation on relevant topics by first peeling away the irrelevant ones. The unique-DNA bit is irrelevant. The question of the brain is much more relevant, but I wanted to dispense with the nonsense before getting down to those brass tacks.
 
I'm simply trying to focus the conversation on relevant topics by first peeling away the irrelevant ones. The unique-DNA bit is irrelevant. The question of the brain is much more relevant, but I wanted to dispense with the nonsense before getting down to those brass tacks.
Sure. :0)
 
Sure. :0)
It's true. People throw in a bunch of stuff I consider irrelevant to the question of a right to life. I think it's important to focus more narrowly on what really matters. The "human" bit is also something I consider irrelevant. Picture, for example, that we landed on an alien planet and found life forms there. How would be decide if they had an individual right to life? If those aliens were basically the equivalent of broccoli -- delicious, nutritious, and unthinking -- we wouldn't have a moral problem with killing individuals (perhaps with eradicating whole species, but not with killing the individual organisms). But what if they were Vulcans, Wookiees, Vorlons, etc.? A moral person would still treat them as having an individual right to life, regardless of not being human.

It all comes down to the mind. That is the only moral basis for deciding if something has an individual right to life. We need to dispense with the irrelevancies to focus there.
 
Back
Top