New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A break

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why was slavery considered constitutional?

Non sequitur. Slavery was considered constitutional because the Founding Fathers could think of no way to end it. And we didn't think of any way to end it, short of a civil war that almost led to the dissolution of the country. But what in the world does that question have to do with gun control???
 
Give me the style of a single court case that challenged the assault weapons ban. No challenge of the ban was ever heard at the Supreme Court.

For what its worth, I think the law was constitutional before the Heller and MacDonald decisions, but the court has now provided a more rigorous definition of the boundary of individual firearms ownership. In Heller, it said that outright bans of a specific class of weapons do no pass constitutional muster. A reinstituted "assault" weapons ban would be such an ban on a specific class of weapons and would certainly face a tougher time in the court system as a result of these decisions.

Here is a prominent law professor who clearly disagrees with you, Trap:

In the wake of recent mass shootings, the White House (under pressure from gun control advocates) has said it generally supports a federal assault weapons ban, though Congress is not moving in that direction. But if Congress were to act, would an assault weapons ban be constitutional?

Assault weapons bans have mostly been adjudicated in state courts thus far, where judges have generally been inclined to uphold them, according to Professor Adam Winkler of the UCLA School of Law. A federal ban, however, were it to end up before the Supreme Court, would most likely be evaluated in terms of the Second Amendment without much regard to state precedent, Winkler said.

The federal courts have not given much previous guidance on whether a federal assault weapons ban would pass Second Amendment muster, but Winkler says he suspects one would be upheld by the Supreme Court.

“In the Heller case, the courts said a handgun ban is not constitutional because handguns are in ‘common use,’” which is a common standard in jurisprudence, Winkler said. “A shoulder-launched missile is not in common use for self-defense; a machine gun is not in common use. The assault rifle is a slightly more difficult question. … I suspect [the court] would uphold such a ban, especially after such high-profile shootings. And I suspect that many judges, like many other people, would believe you don’t need an assault weapon for self-defense.”

In June 2010, the Supreme Court’s ruling in McDonald v. Chicago extended to states the decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, which held that a D.C. ban on owning handguns violated the Second Amendment. The decision in McDonald struck down Chicago and Oak Park’s handgun bans by incorporating the Second Amendment through the 14th. Since the invalidation of handgun bans, both pro- and anti-gun advocates have turned their attention to assault weapons bans.

And in Heller, Scalia, writing for the majority, seems to indicate that restrictions on certain types of weapons remain constitutional.

“The Second Amendment extends, prima facie, to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding,” Scalia wrote. But he also said a 1939 Supreme Court case, United States v. Miller, allows for limitations on the right to bear arms, “supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of ‘dangerous and unusual weapons.’”

“We … read Miller to say only that the Second Amendment does not protect those weapons not typically possessed by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes, such as short-barreled shotguns,” Scalia writes.

A follow-up to Heller, Heller v. District of Columbia (known as “Heller II”) challenged laws prohibiting large-capacity ammunition magazines and assault weapons. In October 2011, the D.C. Circuit Court ruled 2-1 to uphold those bans as constitutional, remanding certain registration requirements back to the lower court for further review. Judge Douglas Ginsburg, delivering the opinion of the court, used the logic of the first Heller to conclude some restrictions on the Second Amendment are constitutional. He says these restrictions must pass an “intermediate scrutiny test” — and the court found the assault weapons ban in question did.

“To pass muster under intermediate scrutiny the District must show [registration requirements] are ‘substantially related to an important governmental objective,’” and the means must be a “close fit” with the ends, Ginsburg writes.

Also working its way through the courts is Wilson v. Cook County, which challenges a Cook County, Ill., assault weapons ban. An Illinois appellate court was ordered by the Illinois Supreme Court to reconsider the case in light of the McDonald ruling.

In a unanimous February 2011 opinion, the appellate court upheld the ordinance. The court cited Heller II's interpretation of Scalia’s Heller I opinion to find some restrictions on arms are constitutional. The court also rejected the plaintiffs’ challenge that banning “assault weapons” was overbroad.

This April, however, the Illinois Supreme Court sent the case back to trial court, saying more facts needed to be presented before the ordinance could be scrutinized under any standard.

“We note that unlike Heller II, the County has not had an opportunity to present evidence to justify the nexus between the ordinance and the governmental interest it seeks to protect,” Justice Mary Jane Theis wrote for the seven-member panel.

As for the 1994 federal assault weapons ban, which Congress allowed to sunset in 2004, there were no substantial challenges to it under the Second Amendment.

“In the 1990s, the NRA was determined to avoid a Supreme Court ruling on the Second Amendment and refused to bring Second Amendment challenges,” Winkler said. “At the time, they were convinced the Supreme Court would be hostile to the Second Amendment.”

In Navegar v. U.S., the law was challenged under the Commerce Clause and Bill of Attainder Clause, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in Oct. 1999 upheld it 3-0.

In August 2002, an appeals court upheld the law 3-0 again. This time, in Olympic Arms v. Buckles, the ban was (unfruitfully) challenged under the Fifth Amendment equal protection clause.

Though the assault weapons ban never made it before the Supreme Court, the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act, which was passed the same year, was challenged in Printz v. United States. A provision of the act required state officers to perform background checks on individuals seeking to buy handguns. The court ruled 5-4 that that aspect of the law was unconstitutional because the government cannot compel states to enact or enforce a federal program -- though the law, including other parts of the background check provision, remained in place and is still in place today. In his concurrent opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas briefly discussed the Second Amendment, lamenting the fact that no arguments were presented on Second Amendment grounds so the court could not examine the law’s constitutionality under it.

As for the NRA, “of course, that’s all changed now,” Winkler said, and an assault weapons ban would most likely be challenged on Second Amendment grounds.

The next court battle in gun control litigation, Winkler said, will not be a hypothetical assault weapons ban but, rather, concealed carry legislation. Court watchers should keep an eye on Woollard v. Sheridan, Winkler said, in which a Maryland district court invalidated in March the state’s requirement of a “good and substantial reason” for a concealed weapon permit. The ruling was stayed pending appeal Aug. 1 by the 4th Circuit Court, which is expected to hear it in October.

Another case of note in the area of unusual or exotic weapons: Maloney v. Cuomo. As part of a three-judge panel on the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, now-Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor heard the case, brought by a man challenging a New York ban on owning nunchuks. The per curiam opinion found no merit in Maloney’s argument that the Second Amendment protected his right to own the martial arts-associated fighting sticks. The case was part of a testy exchange during Sotomayor’s confirmation hearings. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court, but the justice sent it back to a New York federal court in light of the McDonald ruling. The case remains pending.
 
Non sequitur. Slavery was considered constitutional because the Founding Fathers could think of no way to end it. And we didn't think of any way to end it, short of a civil war that almost led to the dissolution of the country. But what in the world does that question have to do with gun control???

Slavery was ended constitutionally, so should the right to bear arms.
 
Here is a prominent law professor who clearly disagrees with you, Trap:

In the wake of recent mass shootings, the White House (under pressure from gun control advocates) has said it generally supports a federal assault weapons ban, though Congress is not moving in that direction. But if Congress were to act, would an assault weapons ban be constitutional?

Assault weapons bans have mostly been adjudicated in state courts thus far, where judges have generally been inclined to uphold them, according to Professor Adam Winkler of the UCLA School of Law. A federal ban, however, were it to end up before the Supreme Court, would most likely be evaluated in terms of the Second Amendment without much regard to state precedent, Winkler said.

The federal courts have not given much previous guidance on whether a federal assault weapons ban would pass Second Amendment muster, but Winkler says he suspects one would be upheld by the Supreme Court.

“In the Heller case, the courts said a handgun ban is not constitutional because handguns are in ‘common use,’” which is a common standard in jurisprudence, Winkler said. “A shoulder-launched missile is not in common use for self-defense; a machine gun is not in common use. The assault rifle is a slightly more difficult question. … I suspect [the court] would uphold such a ban, especially after such high-profile shootings. And I suspect that many judges, like many other people, would believe you don’t need an assault weapon for self-defense.”

In June 2010, the Supreme Court’s ruling in McDonald v. Chicago extended to states the decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, which held that a D.C. ban on owning handguns violated the Second Amendment. The decision in McDonald struck down Chicago and Oak Park’s handgun bans by incorporating the Second Amendment through the 14th. Since the invalidation of handgun bans, both pro- and anti-gun advocates have turned their attention to assault weapons bans.

And in Heller, Scalia, writing for the majority, seems to indicate that restrictions on certain types of weapons remain constitutional.

“The Second Amendment extends, prima facie, to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding,” Scalia wrote. But he also said a 1939 Supreme Court case, United States v. Miller, allows for limitations on the right to bear arms, “supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of ‘dangerous and unusual weapons.’”

“We … read Miller to say only that the Second Amendment does not protect those weapons not typically possessed by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes, such as short-barreled shotguns,” Scalia writes.

A follow-up to Heller, Heller v. District of Columbia (known as “Heller II”) challenged laws prohibiting large-capacity ammunition magazines and assault weapons. In October 2011, the D.C. Circuit Court ruled 2-1 to uphold those bans as constitutional, remanding certain registration requirements back to the lower court for further review. Judge Douglas Ginsburg, delivering the opinion of the court, used the logic of the first Heller to conclude some restrictions on the Second Amendment are constitutional. He says these restrictions must pass an “intermediate scrutiny test” — and the court found the assault weapons ban in question did.

“To pass muster under intermediate scrutiny the District must show [registration requirements] are ‘substantially related to an important governmental objective,’” and the means must be a “close fit” with the ends, Ginsburg writes.

Also working its way through the courts is Wilson v. Cook County, which challenges a Cook County, Ill., assault weapons ban. An Illinois appellate court was ordered by the Illinois Supreme Court to reconsider the case in light of the McDonald ruling.

In a unanimous February 2011 opinion, the appellate court upheld the ordinance. The court cited Heller II's interpretation of Scalia’s Heller I opinion to find some restrictions on arms are constitutional. The court also rejected the plaintiffs’ challenge that banning “assault weapons” was overbroad.

This April, however, the Illinois Supreme Court sent the case back to trial court, saying more facts needed to be presented before the ordinance could be scrutinized under any standard.

“We note that unlike Heller II, the County has not had an opportunity to present evidence to justify the nexus between the ordinance and the governmental interest it seeks to protect,” Justice Mary Jane Theis wrote for the seven-member panel.

As for the 1994 federal assault weapons ban, which Congress allowed to sunset in 2004, there were no substantial challenges to it under the Second Amendment.

“In the 1990s, the NRA was determined to avoid a Supreme Court ruling on the Second Amendment and refused to bring Second Amendment challenges,” Winkler said. “At the time, they were convinced the Supreme Court would be hostile to the Second Amendment.”

In Navegar v. U.S., the law was challenged under the Commerce Clause and Bill of Attainder Clause, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit in Oct. 1999 upheld it 3-0.

In August 2002, an appeals court upheld the law 3-0 again. This time, in Olympic Arms v. Buckles, the ban was (unfruitfully) challenged under the Fifth Amendment equal protection clause.

Though the assault weapons ban never made it before the Supreme Court, the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act, which was passed the same year, was challenged in Printz v. United States. A provision of the act required state officers to perform background checks on individuals seeking to buy handguns. The court ruled 5-4 that that aspect of the law was unconstitutional because the government cannot compel states to enact or enforce a federal program -- though the law, including other parts of the background check provision, remained in place and is still in place today. In his concurrent opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas briefly discussed the Second Amendment, lamenting the fact that no arguments were presented on Second Amendment grounds so the court could not examine the law’s constitutionality under it.

As for the NRA, “of course, that’s all changed now,” Winkler said, and an assault weapons ban would most likely be challenged on Second Amendment grounds.

The next court battle in gun control litigation, Winkler said, will not be a hypothetical assault weapons ban but, rather, concealed carry legislation. Court watchers should keep an eye on Woollard v. Sheridan, Winkler said, in which a Maryland district court invalidated in March the state’s requirement of a “good and substantial reason” for a concealed weapon permit. The ruling was stayed pending appeal Aug. 1 by the 4th Circuit Court, which is expected to hear it in October.

Another case of note in the area of unusual or exotic weapons: Maloney v. Cuomo. As part of a three-judge panel on the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, now-Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor heard the case, brought by a man challenging a New York ban on owning nunchuks. The per curiam opinion found no merit in Maloney’s argument that the Second Amendment protected his right to own the martial arts-associated fighting sticks. The case was part of a testy exchange during Sotomayor’s confirmation hearings. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court, but the justice sent it back to a New York federal court in light of the McDonald ruling. The case remains pending.

Looks like an open matter to me, not a settled one. Both Heller and MacDonald invited future challenges to clarify the law -- as reported here, those cases are still working their way through the court system. But another, far earlier case (and I'm sorry, I can't remember its style, I'll find and post it), sets the standard for what is "dangerous and unusual" as described by Scalia. Under the standard set in that case, semiautomatic weapons are neither dangerous nor unusual. We'll see what the courts do, of course, and I could be proven wrong or the court could reverse its earlier stance as it has in the past.
 
Looks like an open matter to me, not a settled one. Both Heller and MacDonald invited future challenges to clarify the law -- as reported here, those cases are still working their way through the court system.

I agree that it's an open matter, but I also agree with this:

The federal courts have not given much previous guidance on whether a federal assault weapons ban would pass Second Amendment muster, but Winkler says he suspects one would be upheld by the Supreme Court.
 
For crying out loud, read the post immediately above yours. We can have gun control without violating the Constitution. The courts have NEVER ruled otherwise.

LeRoy --you have mountains of evidence that abundantly illustrates and establishes that Right Wingers simply cannot think in portions or shades of colours or in any degrees. They can only think in all on or all off, all guns or no guns.... They have different brains then the rest of us.
 
For crying out loud, read the post immediately above yours. We can have gun control without violating the Constitution. The courts have NEVER ruled otherwise.

So what you are saying is....., We the People have the right to bear arms regulated to single bolt, 22 caliber or less, with traceable serial numbers to target shoot and hunt, for now. Maybe?

That makes regulating the right to vote to only property owners or those with a net income of $250K or more seem reasonable.
 
So what you are saying is....., We the People have the right to bear arms regulated to single bolt, 22 caliber or less, with traceable serial numbers to target shoot and hunt, for now. Maybe?

That makes regulating the right to vote to only property owners or those with a net income of $250K or more seem reasonable.

What I am saying is that there are reasonable, common-sense restrictions on the right to bear arms, just as there are reasonable, common-sense restrictions on the freedom of religion, the freedom of speech, and the freedom of the press. Just as our courts have ALWAYS understood, and you have NOT. Going by your 'reasoning', we would need to repeal the Second Amendment in order to prohibit private citizens from owning nuclear warheads.

People reading your posts need to understand that that is your position.
 
I guess the reasonable thing to do is repeal the 2nd amendment.

I would be all for it.
the most idiotic Constitutional amendment in humans history, granting the men the right to play with dangerous toys.
There is no 2 amendment in Germany, norway, or elsewhere,but people still can buy hunting rifles and shoot deer, bears , rabbits etc...
 
Re-read the question you provided. You asked about what automatic weapons were available, not at the time of the writing of the Constitution, but in the "19th century" (the Constitution was written in the 18th century). I provided information about automatic weapons available in the 19th century.

see, that's why I am talking about intellectual integrity and weaseling. you knew perfectly well, i was asking about 2 amendment if it were written providing all those weapons were available at the time, yes , i did mention 19th century generally, sorry
 
I would be all for it.
the most idiotic Constitutional amendment in humans history, granting the men the right to play with dangerous toys.
There is no 2 amendment in Germany, norway, or elsewhere,but people still can buy hunting rifles and shoot deer, bears , rabbits etc...

Do they have the right to defend themselves too?

Of course Hitler had strict gun control laws ( None were allowed)

Today in the EU, only the rich have the privilege to hunt.
 
see, that's why I am talking about intellectual integrity and weaseling. you knew perfectly well, i was asking about 2 amendment if it were written providing all those weapons were available at the time, yes , i did mention 19th century generally, sorry

Actually, that wasn't clear at all from your phrasing. Phrased that way, the answer is "yes." The founding fathers fought a war using the technology available to them as private citizens of England, plus some military arms (cannon) stolen from England. If they'd fought a modern war under the same circumstances, they'd have allowed the ownership of modern weapons, under the same circumstances.
 
Re-read the question you provided. You asked about what automatic weapons were available, not at the time of the writing of the Constitution, but in the "19th century" (the Constitution was written in the 18th century). I provided information about automatic weapons available in the 19th century.
[h=2]here is exact was my question was provided:[/h]
would we have a second amendment if there were automatic assault weapons, tanks , etc in the 19th century?

for anybody who is not weasel and honest obviously the matter was regarding if those weapons were available at the time the 2 amendment was written


​

 
Actually, that wasn't clear at all from your phrasing. Phrased that way, the answer is "yes." The founding fathers fought a war using the technology available to them as private citizens of England, plus some military arms (cannon) stolen from England. If they'd fought a modern war under the same circumstances, they'd have allowed the ownership of modern weapons, under the same circumstances.

no , they would not. They would advocate that type of weapons available only to "well regulated militia" to fight off foreign aggression and/or colonial power, not to just any private citizen
Can you prove me wrong?
 
[h=2]here is exact was my question was provided:[/h]
would we have a second amendment if there were automatic assault weapons, tanks , etc in the 19th century?

for anybody who is not weasel and honest obviously the matter was regarding if those weapons were available at the time the 2 amendment was written


​


Yuri, if you are so anti-second amendment, why are you so adamantly opposed to repealing it?
 
Do they have the right to defend themselves too?

Of course Hitler had strict gun control laws ( None were allowed)

Today in the EU, only the rich have the privilege to hunt.

yea, sure, those German citizens with their weapons if available would be able to fight off Hitler's armies. I recall ,that required cooperation of USSR and Western allies, full might of them.
There are strict gun laws in other European countries, did not see any fascistic dictatorship establishing in any of them.
If by any chance our government would become fascistic, how much resistance idiotic 2 amendment aficionados would provide and for how long?
 
Here is the thing Yuri, I would be more than happy to JOIN YOUR CAUSE to regulate/ban arms if we do so constitutionally by repealing or amending the 2nd.

By banning guns thru regulation, or executive order will only sow the seeds of discontent and make a mockery of our constitution.

You say, ARMS HAVE BEEN REGULATED BEFORE!

Guess that proves regs not working. However, now you are pushing the BANISHMENT of semi-autos which is 95% of all guns including shot guns, by labeling semi's as "assault" weapons..

I want to join your cause in regulating arms, but lets do it constitutionally.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top