New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A few random thoughts.

Arkady

President
Biden and the Polls:

Two recent polls came out giving a picture of the Democratic field in the wake of the debate. Taken together, they suggest Biden may be a non-issue. In the Morning Consult poll, which didn't include Biden as an option, Clinton leads with 56%, Sanders has 24%, and everyone else is at 1% or less, with 12% undecided. In the ABC/Post poll, which includes Biden, Clinton leads with 54%, Sanders has 23%, Biden has 16%, and everyone else as 1% or less, with 5% undecided. If you take them both together, it looks like Biden's support mostly goes "undecided" when he's not an option, with the break between Clinton and Sanders being small enough to be within the margin of error (Clinton picks up two, Sanders one). It just doesn't look like Biden's presence or absence matters much -- it neither gives Clinton an unbeatable boost, nor helps Sanders cover the gap. Unless his presence changes the debates or media landscape in some way I'm not picturing, or unless Clinton suffers some serious scandal that drives the conservative Dems from her, I don't see him mattering.

Sanders' Performance:


As a Sanders supporter, I'm happy with his performance so far. With around 24%, he's far behind Clinton, but still one of the strongest candidates overall -- the latest NBC/WSJ poll has Trump at 25, so Sanders is about as strong as the strongest Republican, right now. Sanders is well positioned to build strength over time, as people get more comfortable hearing his ideas and talking points -- which are far enough outside what has been permitted in "polite company" for years, that I'm sure some people are just taken aback by unfamiliarity. There's plenty of time left on the clock for Sanders to win it.

Media Spectra:

That brings me to a point about the way our media behave. The media very much take their cues from the major politicians. As someone jokingly said, if one party in this country officially took the position that the Earth was flat, the media would start writing things like "Shape of the Earth: both sides have a point". The mainstream media care most about their image of neutrality, and so they define the spectrum of their coverage based on the spectrum of positions taken by the major politicians, implicitly coming down in the middle. For years this helped the Republicans, because as they shifted right, the media had to shift right to keep up with the new middle. And it makes "triangulation" by politicians problematic, since you can win the battles but lose the war, by essentially redefining the center in the other side's favor. But because of the way the media acts, this allows a politician who can gather some strength to redefine the political spectrum. Perot did it in the early 90s, and Trump and Sanders are doing so today.

Consider the way the media, for a long time, mindlessly repeated the falsehood that Bush kept us safe. It was a Republican talking point, and major Democrats didn't challenge it, so examining the question was considered outside the proper subject matter of the mainstream media. But then Trump came along and pointed out the obvious fact that Bush did the worst job of any president at keeping us safe, based on us having suffered the worst attack in our history on his watch. And suddenly the media permitted itself to look at that issue. Similarly, for a long time the Republicans and Democrats seemed united on the idea that socialism was bad and we didn't want to be more like Western Europe. Even though academic lefties challenged those ideas, the mainstream politicians didn't, and so the media presented the idea that socialism was bad and Western Europe was a cautionary tale as if it were unquestionable fact. Then Sanders challenged it, and with 24% approval in the primary, he couldn't be ignored. Suddenly, the media permitted itself a more honest look at such questions.

I see this as both an indictment of the media (you can't show independence by being utterly subservient to the worldview promulgated by the major politicians), and also as a defense of quixotic presidential campaigns -- even if they don't win, people like Perot, Trump, Sanders, and Ron Paul can change the dialogue in a meaningful way. They break up that echo-chamber effect where the ambitious politicians only dare take positions within the spectrum of polite opinion reflected by the mainstream media, while the mainstream media is so protective of an image of neutrality that they're only willing to reflect a spectrum of polite opinion that's set forth by ambitious politicians.
 
even if they don't win, people like Perot, Trump, Sanders, and Ron Paul can change the dialogue in a meaningful way. They break up that echo-chamber effect where the ambitious politicians only dare take positions within the spectrum of polite opinion reflected by the mainstream media, while the mainstream media is so protective of an image of neutrality that they're only willing to reflect a spectrum of polite opinion that's set forth by ambitious politicians.

I agree that true political independence from the fishhooks of major political parties is a great thing.

It was amazing watching the hit job via omission FOX news did on Ron Paul, even as he was atop the Republican polls and was a prominent politician.

That being said, we finally live in a media world where there's at least some differing opinions and narratives. Throughout the 60's, 70's and even 80's... it was liberal ABC, NBC, and CBS.. that's it. Then came the Rush Limbaughs, talk radio, and heck, FOX didn't even come around until 1997. The majority of mainstream media is still admittedly and provably liberal, often caught pushing narrative over fact, and many media aristocratics probably aren't enthused that anyone dare question their mightiness and righteousness. However, at least we don't have a monopoly anymore.
 
I agree that true political independence from the fishhooks of major political parties is a great thing.

It was amazing watching the hit job via omission FOX news did on Ron Paul, even as he was atop the Republican polls and was a prominent politician.

That being said, we finally live in a media world where there's at least some differing opinions and narratives. Throughout the 60's, 70's and even 80's... it was liberal ABC, NBC, and CBS.. that's it. Then came the Rush Limbaughs, talk radio, and heck, FOX didn't even come around until 1997. The majority of mainstream media is still admittedly and provably liberal, often caught pushing narrative over fact, and many media aristocratics probably aren't enthused that anyone dare question their mightiness and righteousness. However, at least we don't have a monopoly anymore.
I suppose there's more variety now. In the 60s, 70s, 80s, there was just the corporate, for-profit, center-right media. Then, with talk radio and Fox News, that was complemented by far-right media. That's an increase in diversity, of sorts. But it just shifted things further to the right. It would be nice to see more of a mainstream voice for liberalism. The closest we've got right now, I suppose, is MSNBC, but it's far from a full-throated bastion of liberalism the way Fox News is for conservatism. For example, MSNBC dedicates three solid hours every morning to Morning Joe, the titular head of which is a right-winger and former Gingrichite conservative Republican Congressman. Can you imagine Fox News doing something similar -- for example, giving Barney Frank his own daily three-hour block to talk to their viewers?
 
With Clinton still in the race, Biden won't win. However, if Clinton, for one reason or another, should drop out sometime next year, if Biden already isn't in the race, then he won't be able to enter.

It's my firm belief that Biden is the DNC's Plan B should Clinton have to fall on her sword for the numerous issues associated with her personal conduct in a variety of circumstances.
 
I suppose there's more variety now. In the 60s, 70s, 80s, there was just the corporate, for-profit, center-right media. Then, with talk radio and Fox News, that was complemented by far-right media. That's an increase in diversity, of sorts. But it just shifted things further to the right. It would be nice to see more of a mainstream voice for liberalism. The closest we've got right now, I suppose, is MSNBC, but it's far from a full-throated bastion of liberalism the way Fox News is for conservatism. For example, MSNBC dedicates three solid hours every morning to Morning Joe, the titular head of which is a right-winger and former Gingrichite conservative Republican Congressman. Can you imagine Fox News doing something similar -- for example, giving Barney Frank his own daily three-hour block to talk to their viewers?

Before the talk radio boom, and even after CNN on Cable, The big three were solid Liberal aristocracies by American standards.

Meanwhile, journalism is filled mostly with radical American liberals, so says the polling data. Combine that with ego, and you have lots of examples that resemble the Dan Rather debacle that is trying to be rewritten through movie emotion today.

Narrative over fact.

I don't like the way FOX does a lot of things, but they are merely fighting against a former monopoly and still a clear majority. FOX does report things, important things, that the liberal media (most media) will purposefully avoid to protect Democrats in power.

FOX serves a healthy purpose, even if much of their programming isn't healthy.
 
Before the talk radio boom, and even after CNN on Cable, The big three were solid Liberal aristocracies by American standards.

What makes you think that? They struck me as center-right and still do.

Meanwhile, journalism is filled mostly with radical American liberals, so says the polling data.

There are polls that ask journalists if they're "radical American liberals" and lots of them say yes? How strange.

Combine that with ego, and you have lots of examples that resemble the Dan Rather debacle that is trying to be rewritten through movie emotion today.

Yes, that's a great example. Rather screwed up in a careless, but not particularly uncommon way. He got taken in by a hoax and included a bit of evidence that wasn't solid, into a much larger piece that otherwise was. It effectively ended the career of one of our most accomplished newsmen. If he'd made a similar error in a way that ran contrary to the interests of the Democrats, would it have been a career-ender? I think not. During the shameful Whitewater era, the corporate media jumped on one bit of BS evidence against Clinton after another, and I don't recall any established journalists being put out to pasture over it. The rule at the center-right, for-profit corporate press seems to be that when you're taking shots at Democrats, a little margin for error is tolerable, but if you take shots at Republicans, you better be damned sure all your ducks are in a row or it's over for you, no matter who you are.
 
Sanders isn't running for Governor of Massachusetts or Mayor of San Francisco. Try getting out more...
 
What makes you think that? They struck me as center-right and still do.
It's not surprising, being that you seem like a European Union kinda guy.
There are polls that ask journalists if they're "radical American liberals" and lots of them say yes? How strange.
If you have to resort to exact language, so be it. You've made many claims over your time here about people who never admitted to what you claimed they were. Were all of those an admitted error?

the corporate media jumped on one bit of BS evidence against Clinton after another, and I don't recall any established journalists being put out to pasture over it.

Can you compare the "BS evidence" of whitewater to the admitted and proven fabrications in the Rather controversy?
 
If you have to resort to exact language, so be it. You've made many claims over your time here about people who never admitted to what you claimed they were. Were all of those an admitted error?

I don't know what you're asking. All I'm saying is that I'm skeptical there's been a poll asking journalists if they're radical American liberals. Rather, I assume you are thinking of a poll showing greater Democratic affiliation among reporters, or support for some policies favored by the Democrats. But whether that is "radical" or "liberal" is the question.

Can you compare the "BS evidence" of whitewater to the admitted and proven fabrications in the Rather controversy?

I can certainly compare them. They're not exactly comparable, of course, in the fact that the Whitewater errors were vastly more widespread and persistent and led to a ridiculously expensive special counsel investigation, whereas the Rather controversy involved failing to authenticate one document in one report and it led to nothing important other than destroying some media careers. Anyway, here's some good reading on the topic:

http://mediamatters.org/research/2007/06/05/gerth-blames-ny-times-editors-for-whitewater-mi/139009

For a more in-depth read, see here:

http://www.amazon.com/Fools-Scandal-Media-Invented-Whitewater/dp/1879957523

The double standard was clear. Because the Republicans have spent so long pushing the meme that the media is biased against them, a reporter can be INCREDIBLY sloppy and downright unethical in pushing scandals against Democrats, and any mistakes will be taken as innocent errors and will not hurt the reporter's career. But if the reporter makes mistakes while attacking Republicans, it will be seen as deliberate, and a result of bias, and will destroy the person's credibility, and possibly his or her career.
 
It's not surprising, being that you seem like a European Union kinda guy.

If you have to resort to exact language, so be it. You've made many claims over your time here about people who never admitted to what you claimed they were. Were all of those an admitted error?



Can you compare the "BS evidence" of whitewater to the admitted and proven fabrications in the Rather controversy?
Just as another example of the double-standard I'm talking about, consider Lara Logan, who badly disgraced CBS News with her unethical and sloppy Benghazi reporting. Back in 2013 she was forced to apologize for an inaccurate 60 Minutes report on Benghazi -- like Rather, she'd been taken in by a hoaxster, because she didn't do enough to vet the forged information he provided her. It was actually a bigger mistake, since the false information was all the information her report was based on, unlike with Rather where it was just one piece in a wall of evidence he presented. Worse, unlike Rather, she'd come right out and acted as a political operative (making a speech in which she asserted that the government was lying about the Al Qaeda threat and demanding various actions in response to Benghazi -- creating a conflict of interest when she kept reporting on the story for a nominally neutral position). But, unlike Rather, her mistake had been critical of a Democratic president, rather than a Republican one. So, after a short leave of absence, she was back at work as a featured player for 60 Minutes, and she recently signed a new two-year deal with CBS. Unlike in the case of Rather, there weren't even firings behind the scenes of the responsible producers.

If I worked in the mainstream media, I'd certainly get the message. If I was working on a story that would hurt the Democrats, I'd be very aggressive, even if that aggressiveness might lead to some small errors. I'd figure if I was right, the reward for being first and toughest on the scene would be a Pulitzer, while if I was wrong the worst I could expect was a slap on the wrist. But if I was working on a story that would hurt the Republicans, I'd be incredibly cautious. I'd vet the hell out of any source. I'd make sure every i was dotted and every t crossed. Because I'd know the cost of getting something wrong would be my career.
 
Back
Top