New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A Keystone shutdown question?

Boca

Governor
Last edited:
Biden stated "environmental" and "climate change" issues as he signed the EO. Much of this dates back to when President Obama shut it down. The Native Tribes have fought this for years. It crosses their lands and endangers their water supply. If a line break should occur on Native American land, the collateral damage to water would be disastrous. Biden is also very straight forward in his goal of tackling fossil fuels, hoping to make waves in moves to renewable energy.

The pipeline is designed to move crude from Canada to Gulf of Mexico ports where it will be transported to China. Little, if any, of the crude will be utilized for U.S. refining. Why should we endanger the lives and future of our indigenous people to assist Canada in selling crude to China? The right is complaining about the loss of jobs. There will be a loss of 1,000 to 1,500 construction jobs in the near term. The project was scheduled for completion in the next two years. Once complete, a staff of 36 workers would be employed... some of those 36 residing in Canada.
 
Biden stated "environmental" and "climate change" issues as he signed the EO. Much of this dates back to when President Obama shut it down. The Native Tribes have fought this for years. It crosses their lands and endangers their water supply. If a line break should occur on Native American land, the collateral damage to water would be disastrous. Biden is also very straight forward in his goal of tackling fossil fuels, hoping to make waves in moves to renewable energy.

The pipeline is designed to move crude from Canada to Gulf of Mexico ports where it will be transported to China. Little, if any, of the crude will be utilized for U.S. refining. Why should we endanger the lives and future of our indigenous people to assist Canada in selling crude to China? The right is complaining about the loss of jobs. There will be a loss of 1,000 to 1,500 construction jobs in the near term. The project was scheduled for completion in the next two years. Once complete, a staff of 36 workers would be employed... some of those 36 residing in Canada.
You said it way better than Rep. Scalise and FOXNews.
 
Biden stated "environmental" and "climate change" issues as he signed the EO. Much of this dates back to when President Obama shut it down. The Native Tribes have fought this for years. It crosses their lands and endangers their water supply. If a line break should occur on Native American land, the collateral damage to water would be disastrous. Biden is also very straight forward in his goal of tackling fossil fuels, hoping to make waves in moves to renewable energy.

The pipeline is designed to move crude from Canada to Gulf of Mexico ports where it will be transported to China. Little, if any, of the crude will be utilized for U.S. refining. Why should we endanger the lives and future of our indigenous people to assist Canada in selling crude to China? The right is complaining about the loss of jobs. There will be a loss of 1,000 to 1,500 construction jobs in the near term. The project was scheduled for completion in the next two years. Once complete, a staff of 36 workers would be employed... some of those 36 residing in Canada.

A possible water leak of unknown proportion as opposed to all of this?

Whatever happened to intelligent leaders weighing the thin odds of something happening against the almost certain odds that something disastrous will?

Reps. Scalise, Herrell: Biden's reckless, job-killing energy executive orders must be reversed | Fox News
 
A possible water leak of unknown proportion as opposed to all of this?

Whatever happened to intelligent leaders weighing the thin odds of something happening against the almost certain odds that something disastrous will?

Reps. Scalise, Herrell: Biden's reckless, job-killing energy executive orders must be reversed | Fox News


Ever hear of the Exxon Valdez or the Deep Seas Horizon blowout?

I guess that something like this is possible with an oil leak of the known proportion...



Isn't Steve Scalise the guy who once called himself "David Duke without the baggage"?

Yep -

Typical Republican. You can't spell RACIST without the (R).

My work here is done. Your argument lies destroyed and your sources exposed for what they are.
​
 
A possible water leak of unknown proportion as opposed to all of this?

Whatever happened to intelligent leaders weighing the thin odds of something happening against the almost certain odds that something disastrous will?

Reps. Scalise, Herrell: Biden's reckless, job-killing energy executive orders must be reversed | Fox News
The probability of a leak looks pretty high given the track record of pipelines and of course the result would be water sources for something like 1/3 of the population becoming permanently unusable.
 

Ever hear of the Exxon Valdez or the Deep Seas Horizon blowout?

I guess that something like this is possible with an oil leak of the known proportion...



Isn't Steve Scalise the guy who once called himself "David Duke without the baggage"?

Yep -

Typical Republican. You can't spell RACIST without the (R).

My work here is done. Your argument lies destroyed and your sources exposed for what they are.
​

an estimated half-acre ...yep your work is done take a break
 
an estimated half-acre ...yep your work is done take a break

You really are too dumb to understand what 383,000 gallons of carcinogens can do to ground water supplies.

You cannot fix stupid. By I sure as hell can laugh at it....

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
 
You really are too dumb to understand what 383,000 gallons of carcinogens can do to ground water supplies.

You cannot fix stupid. By I sure as hell can laugh at it....

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
And, they are not taking into consideration the underground strata. Do we have an extensive layer of clay? Or, do we drop into a strata with large aggregate where the oil could flow freely? I've been in excavations 50 feet deep within a few hundred yards of a river and not had a single drop of water. OTOH, my last project was in South Dakota. There, we were almost a quarter mile from the Missouri River and 38 feet deep. The boulders at that elevation allowed for an underground river. Took me only a couple weeks to convince the contractor what needed done to get the hole dry enough to place the required concrete. Meanwhile he was pumping millions of gallons of water/day, simply recirculating it back through his excavation.

Does anyone also understand this oil will not flow by gravity. There will be pumps and air release valves along the way. The high viscosity of the liquid will require pressure to move it along. So... you don't get a drip, drip, drip. A rupture can spray oil a fair distance or have a complete blowout.

I spent a lot of my career working below the surface and designing projects that would be constructed fairly deep. When someone makes a statement that a large oil spill won't negatively affect more than a small area, they are probably unfamiliar with the geotechnical aspect of the area. If they are familiar, I'd like to see some soil analysis reports from every few miles along the proposed pipeline route.
 
And, they are not taking into consideration the underground strata. Do we have an extensive layer of clay? Or, do we drop into a strata with large aggregate where the oil could flow freely? I've been in excavations 50 feet deep within a few hundred yards of a river and not had a single drop of water. OTOH, my last project was in South Dakota. There, we were almost a quarter mile from the Missouri River and 38 feet deep. The boulders at that elevation allowed for an underground river. Took me only a couple weeks to convince the contractor what needed done to get the hole dry enough to place the required concrete. Meanwhile he was pumping millions of gallons of water/day, simply recirculating it back through his excavation.

Does anyone also understand this oil will not flow by gravity. There will be pumps and air release valves along the way. The high viscosity of the liquid will require pressure to move it along. So... you don't get a drip, drip, drip. A rupture can spray oil a fair distance or have a complete blowout.

I spent a lot of my career working below the surface and designing projects that would be constructed fairly deep. When someone makes a statement that a large oil spill won't negatively affect more than a small area, they are probably unfamiliar with the geotechnical aspect of the area. If they are familiar, I'd like to see some soil analysis reports from every few miles along the proposed pipeline route.

Yep - OP is not smart enough to even consider the environmental impact of a spill of 383,0o0 gallons of toxins. Probably doesn't even know what an aquifer is.
 
Biden stated "environmental" and "climate change" issues as he signed the EO. Much of this dates back to when President Obama shut it down. The Native Tribes have fought this for years. It crosses their lands and endangers their water supply. If a line break should occur on Native American land, the collateral damage to water would be disastrous. Biden is also very straight forward in his goal of tackling fossil fuels, hoping to make waves in moves to renewable energy.

The pipeline is designed to move crude from Canada to Gulf of Mexico ports where it will be transported to China. Little, if any, of the crude will be utilized for U.S. refining. Why should we endanger the lives and future of our indigenous people to assist Canada in selling crude to China? The right is complaining about the loss of jobs. There will be a loss of 1,000 to 1,500 construction jobs in the near term. The project was scheduled for completion in the next two years. Once complete, a staff of 36 workers would be employed... some of those 36 residing in Canada.

Great post!

I had this exact argument with a friend this past weekend. He's very Liberal but feels that it should not be shut down. I think what people fail to realize or remember is that we have taken everything away from Native Americans. This is sacred land to them, I had a student that was Navaho Indian - his family live in Arizona on a reservation. He was a full time student and worked full time to send money home to his parents. We had a lot of discussions about the injustices that were and are still carried out. This is all they have, their land.

:)
 
Buffet's railroad gets about 17% of it's revenue from coal. If the democrats were operating in favor of Buffet, why would they be trying to limit the use of coal?

Topic is pipeline and 17% is jack squat when his shares are like $350,000 @
 
You really are too dumb to understand what 383,000 gallons of carcinogens can do to ground water supplies.

You cannot fix stupid. By I sure as hell can laugh at it....

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Karl Rockeman, the director of the state Department of Environmental Quality’s division of water quality said "There are no residences near the site and the wetland is not a source of drinking water."

Comes as no surprise given....

Nov. 10, 2011: The State Department says TransCanada must reroute Keystone XL to avoid an ecologically sensitive region of Nebraska.

Nov. 14, 2011: TransCanada agrees to reroute the line.


Now take that break you need it.
 
Back
Top