New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A Modest Proposal

Canada is a good example. Yes, their population is smaller, meaning they have a lot less opportunity for economies of scale, so their system ought to be more expensive, but they have similar wealth levels and, like the US, they're demographically heterogeneous. Or Japan. Granted, their population is older than ours, meaning their system ought to be more expensive, but like us they're a large and highly industrialized nation. Etc. With any individual nation, you can point to similarities and differences. But, overall, the wealthy nations bear much more resemblance to each other than to the world at large. The really striking thing, though, is how a single one of the wealthy nations manages to spend vastly more on healthcare with vastly worse results.

Canadian health care has been steadily going downhill for the past 30 years. It’s currently ranked 10th out of 11 similar public systems around the developed world, yet spends the sixth-highest amount of money.

In short, said Avery, it is “an expensive system that doesn’t actually give people what they need.”


http://edmontonjournal.com/news/pol...cal-association-pushes-for-national-standards

By 2035 health care's share of GDP will roughly double, according to McKinsey, a consultancy. The burden falls on the state, which foots two-thirds of the bills. Politicians are unwilling to raise taxes, so they squeeze suppliers instead: more than three-quarters of public hospitals operate at a loss.

Like other service industries in Japan, there are cumbersome rules, too many small players and few incentives to improve. Doctors are too few—one-third less than the rich-world average, relative to the population—because of state quotas. Shortages of doctors are severe in rural areas and in certain specialities, such as surgery, paediatrics and obstetrics. The latter two shortages are blamed on the country's low birth rate, but practitioners say that they really arise because income is partly determined by numbers of tests and drugs prescribed, and there are fewer of these for children and pregnant women. Doctors are worked to the bone for relatively low pay (around $125,000 a year at mid-career). One doctor in his 30s says he works more than 100 hours a week. “How can I find time to do research? Write an article? Check back on patients?” he asks.


On the positive side, patients can nearly always see a doctor within a day. But they must often wait hours for a three-minute consultation. Complicated cases get too little attention. The Japanese are only a quarter as likely as the Americans or French to suffer a heart attack, but twice as likely to die if they do.

Some doctors see as many as 100 patients a day. Because their salaries are low, they tend to overprescribe tests and drugs. (Clinics often own their own pharmacies.) They also earn money, hotel-like, by keeping patients in bed. Simple surgery that in the West would involve no overnight stay, such as a hernia operation, entails a five-day hospital stay in Japan.

Emergency care is often poor. In lesser cities it is not uncommon for ambulances to cruise the streets calling a succession of emergency rooms to find one that can cram in a patient. In a few cases people have died because of this. One reason for a shortage of emergency care is an abundance of small clinics instead of big hospitals. Doctors prefer them because they can work less and earn more.

The system is slow to adopt cutting-edge (and therefore costly) treatments. New drugs are approved faster in Indonesia or Turkey, according to the OECD. Few data are collected on how patients respond to treatments. As the Lancet says, prices are heavily regulated but quality is not. This will make it hard for Japan to make medical tourism a pillar of future economic growth, as the government plans.


http://www.economist.com/node/21528660
 
Good example. The EU nations have a whole lot less deb per capita than the US -- less than $29,000 per capita, relative to $63,252 here. Part of our problem is our wildly inefficient healthcare system, which results in higher Medicare, Medicaid, and government-employee healthcare costs than we would have with a more advanced system. This has left the EU in a position where they could literally DOUBLT the debt per capita, in order to do something like pick up more of a share of drug development costs, and they'd STILL have less debt than us.
 
It’s currently ranked 10th out of 11 similar public systems around the developed world, yet spends the sixth-highest amount of money.


And how do they rank compared to the US, in terms of public health outcomes and spending per capita?

I'm open to ideas for better healthcare systems. I'm not in love with the system of Canada or Germany, or any other system. But obviously they're all better than our system, both in terms of public health outcomes and costs. If you have an even better system to advocate, do so. But understand that I won't be won over by dreaming -- it'll take more than naked assertions that an approach will work better. I want to see evidence that it is, in fact, working better, here in the real world. There are about three dozen different national healthcare systems in the world that simultaneously cost less than ours and produce better results. I'm open to being sold on any of those.
 

And how do they rank compared to the US, in terms of public health outcomes and spending per capita?

I'm open to ideas for better healthcare systems. I'm not in love with the system of Canada or Germany, or any other system. But obviously they're all better than our system, both in terms of public health outcomes and costs. If you have an even better system to advocate, do so. But understand that I won't be won over by dreaming -- it'll take more than naked assertions that an approach will work better. I want to see evidence that it is, in fact, working better, here in the real world. There are about three dozen different national healthcare systems in the world that simultaneously cost less than ours and produce better results. I'm open to being sold on any of those.

I have come to an agreement with my Marxist sister on this matter. So I'll try that solution out on you. Would giving everyone a "base" health care plan (such as Medicaid) and allowing people to purchase better coverage if they can afford it be okay with you? She's in favor of that.

One method would be based on the auto insurance model, with the government providing coverage to everyone for catastrophic (for lack of a better description, inpatient/outpatient procedures and treatments) care, and leaving people to cover primary care them selves. The poor would have access (as they do now) to Federally Qualified Health Care Centers, and in rural areas, charitable organization run clinics, while the rest of us would buy insurance or pay out of pocket for it. But you could also open Medicaid to everyone, with the cost a function of their income. Or is that not enough wealth redistribution for you? Are you to the left of my communist sister?
 
I have come to an agreement with my Marxist sister on this matter. So I'll try that solution out on you. Would giving everyone a "base" health care plan (such as Medicaid) and allowing people to purchase better coverage if they can afford it be okay with you? She's in favor of that.

Yes. That's akin to what already exists for the elderly, who get Medicare but can also buy supplemental coverage on top of that. It's also akin to what they have in Germany, where there's compulsory basic insurance provided through tightly price-controlled non-profit insurers, but private, for-profit insurers can sell coverage for supplementary coverage on top of that.

Of course, that leaves open the question of what should be included and excluded from the basic care. For example, maybe dentistry gets covered to the extent it relates to preserving tooth health, but not to cover cosmetic issues. Or maybe medically necessary hospital stays are covered, but not with private rooms or any other frills. You could also make the bare-bones coverage less convenient -- for example, non-emergency treatment has to be treated outside of "rush hours" at doctors offices, and not necessarily locally (instead, channeling people to lower-cost, higher-efficiency centralized medical facilities). And then you could pay extra for coverage without such restrictions. That way everyone's basic medical needs are covered, but in a highly cost-effective way, whereas if you want less cost-effective options, you pay for more expensive insurance.

What I wouldn't want to see is coverage limited to catastrophic care, since that encourages people to neglect problems until they become catastrophic, which may mean buying a lot of the "pounds of cure" rather than the "ounces of prevention."
 
Then why is it Cuban-Americans aren't risking their lives in hand made rafts in shark infested waters to go back to Cuba?

People used to routinely hijack boats or planes (safer than a raft crossing) to escape for Cuba. They stopped because the Cuban government unilaterally decided it would start turning all such illegal entrants back to the authorities in their countries of origin as part of Cuba's fight to combat terrorism.

As for why Cubans came to the U.S. on handmade rafts, the U.S. is (as a result of systematic exploitation of the global South) the wealthiest country in the world. If the U.S. guaranteed residency, job training, and housing to Irish immigrants who crossed the ocean on rafts, we'd be flooded with Irish refugees.
 
Canadian health care has been steadily going downhill for the past 30 years. It’s currently ranked 10th out of 11 similar public systems around the developed world, yet spends the sixth-highest amount of money.

In short, said Avery, it is “an expensive system that doesn’t actually give people what they need.”


http://edmontonjournal.com/news/pol...cal-association-pushes-for-national-standards

By 2035 health care's share of GDP will roughly double, according to McKinsey, a consultancy. The burden falls on the state, which foots two-thirds of the bills. Politicians are unwilling to raise taxes, so they squeeze suppliers instead: more than three-quarters of public hospitals operate at a loss.

Like other service industries in Japan, there are cumbersome rules, too many small players and few incentives to improve. Doctors are too few—one-third less than the rich-world average, relative to the population—because of state quotas. Shortages of doctors are severe in rural areas and in certain specialities, such as surgery, paediatrics and obstetrics. The latter two shortages are blamed on the country's low birth rate, but practitioners say that they really arise because income is partly determined by numbers of tests and drugs prescribed, and there are fewer of these for children and pregnant women. Doctors are worked to the bone for relatively low pay (around $125,000 a year at mid-career). One doctor in his 30s says he works more than 100 hours a week. “How can I find time to do research? Write an article? Check back on patients?” he asks.


On the positive side, patients can nearly always see a doctor within a day. But they must often wait hours for a three-minute consultation. Complicated cases get too little attention. The Japanese are only a quarter as likely as the Americans or French to suffer a heart attack, but twice as likely to die if they do.

Some doctors see as many as 100 patients a day. Because their salaries are low, they tend to overprescribe tests and drugs. (Clinics often own their own pharmacies.) They also earn money, hotel-like, by keeping patients in bed. Simple surgery that in the West would involve no overnight stay, such as a hernia operation, entails a five-day hospital stay in Japan.

Emergency care is often poor. In lesser cities it is not uncommon for ambulances to cruise the streets calling a succession of emergency rooms to find one that can cram in a patient. In a few cases people have died because of this. One reason for a shortage of emergency care is an abundance of small clinics instead of big hospitals. Doctors prefer them because they can work less and earn more.

The system is slow to adopt cutting-edge (and therefore costly) treatments. New drugs are approved faster in Indonesia or Turkey, according to the OECD. Few data are collected on how patients respond to treatments. As the Lancet says, prices are heavily regulated but quality is not. This will make it hard for Japan to make medical tourism a pillar of future economic growth, as the government plans.


http://www.economist.com/node/21528660

"Ranked 10th out of 11 similar (public) systems" ... means most public systems work better than Canada's, which still works better than the U.S.'s.
 
I get it. There's a fundamental difference of opinion about what the government's role should be. The majority of people in every wealthy nation on Earth believe the government should be making sure that people can afford decent basic health care. On the other hand, a vocal minority believe that if a laissez faire market would only provide that to the rich, then the government has no business interfering merely to save countless lives.

For now, the former group is winning. But while that debate is happening, we should at least make sure that the system we have is well-maintained. In the same sense, even if you're someone who thinks that if God had wanted people to have cars, we'd have been born with wheels, it still doesn't make sense to drive around with under-inflated tires. As long as you're going to be using a car, anyway, it should at least be kept in good repair. And for as long as Obamacare is the law of the land, we should try to keep it running like a well oiled machine.


Nowthat the Parliamentarian has decided much would require 60 votes to kill the ACA, it does not seem they are winning.
 
Canada is a good example. Yes, their population is smaller, meaning they have a lot less opportunity for economies of scale, so their system ought to be more expensive, but they have similar wealth levels and, like the US, they're demographically heterogeneous. Or Japan. Granted, their population is older than ours, meaning their system ought to be more expensive, but like us they're a large and highly industrialized nation. Etc. With any individual nation, you can point to similarities and differences. But, overall, the wealthy nations bear much more resemblance to each other than to the world at large. The really striking thing, though, is how a single one of the wealthy nations manages to spend vastly more on healthcare with vastly worse results.

So you have no examples, exactly as I expected. Thanks for playing.
 
People used to routinely hijack boats or planes (safer than a raft crossing) to escape for Cuba. They stopped because the Cuban government unilaterally decided it would start turning all such illegal entrants back to the authorities in their countries of origin as part of Cuba's fight to combat terrorism.

As for why Cubans came to the U.S. on handmade rafts, the U.S. is (as a result of systematic exploitation of the global South) the wealthiest country in the world. If the U.S. guaranteed residency, job training, and housing to Irish immigrants who crossed the ocean on rafts, we'd be flooded with Irish refugees.

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/10/...lead-canadas-immigration-website-buckled.html
Do you have a link to that? I haven't see it.


http://www.healthcarefinancenews.co...riday-derails-aca-replacement-simple-majority

LeRoy misses you but can not get in touch.
 
so your idea is to "double down' on the obamacare features which the MOST hated, and most problematic?

- fines/penalties on those who opt out
- increased subsidies for low income workers, which increase costs - yet again - on those who are trying to cover their own families health expenses as well as subsidize everyone else?

its a good thing your not actually in charge of anything.

your idea is simply a retread of 'tax and spend'. but you're probably too lost in the weeds to evey realize this.

good decision to drive your old car though. 'winter is coming', from an economic perspective.
 
so why do so many Canadians come to America for care?

Very few Canadians do so compared to, say, the number of Americans who go to Canada seeking care. But the U.S. does offer advantages (e.g., short wait times) for those rich enough to pay out of pocket at American rates.

Sane people want a system that works for more than the very rich.
 
Back
Top