New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A Modest Proposal

Why? I've made no claim that it was sold on those ratios. This is a common debate technique among right-wingers. They fear debating the actual points that their opponents make. So, instead, they try to hand their opponents a position to defend. Now I'm supposed to defend the idea it was sold on that particular ratio. But that's not what I said and I have no interest in reading your script.

This is what is so dishonest about lefty debate tactics. I point out that something like 4/5ths of the "insurance" gains under Obamacare were from the expansion of Medicaid and you acted like that was certainly in concert with its original intent, but when I ask for proof that it was made clear when the program was being shoved down our throats, I mean "sold" you try to hide behind the fig leaf suggestion that the ratio wasn't germane to the effort. When we both know that if it had been "sold" as a huge expansion of Medicaid (which is what it turned out to be) it never would have passed...
 
This is what is so dishonest about lefty debate tactics. I point out that something like 4/5ths of the "insurance" gains under Obamacare were from the expansion of Medicaid and you acted like that was certainly in concert with its original intent, but when I ask for proof that it was made clear when the program was being shoved down our throats, I mean "sold" you try to hide behind the fig leaf suggestion that the ratio wasn't germane to the effort. When we both know that if it had been "sold" as a huge expansion of Medicaid (which is what it turned out to be) it never would have passed...
You asked me for proof of a claim you just invented. If your goal is to debate with yourself, have fun. I'm not going to read your script just so you have a debate you can finally win. If, on the other hand, you want to debate with me, then address the points I've made, not the ones you wish I'd made.
 
You asked me for proof of a claim you just invented. If your goal is to debate with yourself, have fun. I'm not going to read your script just so you have a debate you can finally win. If, on the other hand, you want to debate with me, then address the points I've made, not the ones you wish I'd made.

Something like 4/5ths of the people who got "insurance" through Obamacare were Medicaid. That's a FACT, not a debate. The "debate" is over your claim that that is consistent with the Obama Administration's efforts to "sell" the program to the American people.
 
Not "your" health insurance. Your analogy would be apt if we each got our own set of roads that we could use or not use as we require. And according to your analogy here, you could "require" a million dollars worth of roads, that we would have to provide for you even though we aren't allowed to use them, even while only using a few thousand dollars worth of roads ourselves.

Providing health care to those who could not otherwise afford it is a public health benefit. It means fewer people transmitting preventable or treatable diseases to others, less lost productivity due to these diseases, etc.
 
Because the US funds the vast majority of medical research which they then use their single payer systems to negotiate pricing for the drugs and equipment based on marginal rather than average cost. Once the US goes single payer, the whole world engages in a race to the bottom of the health care quality scale. Be careful what you wish for.

Of course, it's not like medical excellence is what you are seeking, is it? It's the wealth redistribution. It's always the wealth redistribution with you people...

Changing the distribution of access to health care would have little to no effect on the research that is overwhelmingly publicly funded.
 
Providing health care to those who could not otherwise afford it is a public health benefit. It means fewer people transmitting preventable or treatable diseases to others, less lost productivity due to these diseases, etc.

Yes, you guys are always telling us how the "commune" is better off as long as we keep giving more and more of our hard earned money to support those who can't (or won't) support themselves. What's funny is how that is basically the whole platform of the "don't call us commies" Democratic party...
 
Yes, you guys are always telling us how the "commune" is better off as long as we keep giving more and more of our hard earned money to support those who can't (or won't) support themselves. What's funny is how that is basically the whole platform of the "don't call us commies" Democratic party...

Proof of the pudding is in the eating ... Cuba despite being decades behind the U.S. economically (no matter how much the gap has narrowed since 1959) has a healthier populace and engages in cutting-edge medical research.
 
Proof of the pudding is in the eating ... Cuba despite being decades behind the U.S. economically (no matter how much the gap has narrowed since 1959) has a healthier populace and engages in cutting-edge medical research.

You have personal experience with that? No, you say? What a surprise...
 
Proof of the pudding is in the eating ... Cuba despite being decades behind the U.S. economically (no matter how much the gap has narrowed since 1959) has a healthier populace and engages in cutting-edge medical research.

Then why is it Cuban-Americans aren't risking their lives in hand made rafts in shark infested waters to go back to Cuba?
 
What distinguishes science from a "faith" is that it works whether you believe in it or not.
Oh really?

Does "M-Theory" work? What about pilot-wave theory? Or Freudian vs. Humanist Psychology? Which one of them works?

It's called "science" not "Utilitarianism."

And then there is love. Prove love. You can't. And yet it works.
 
Something like 4/5ths of the people who got "insurance" through Obamacare were Medicaid. That's a FACT, not a debate. The "debate" is over your claim that that is consistent with the Obama Administration's efforts to "sell" the program to the American people.
I've made no claim at all about whether Obama pushed the 4/5 figure. You just wish I did.
 
And triggering, as I suggested, a grinding halt to medical research, as those nations' HC systems are already buckling under the current costs. That's the problem with these navel gazes of yours, they bear no semblance to the real world...
As a reminder, those other systems are in a better condition than ours, in terms of per capita costs. They could add 50% to their funding, to pick up the slack on funding medical research, and they'd still be significantly more affordable systems than ours.
 
Similar population and demographics? I missed that, which countries with population and demographics similar to us have you included?
Canada is a good example. Yes, their population is smaller, meaning they have a lot less opportunity for economies of scale, so their system ought to be more expensive, but they have similar wealth levels and, like the US, they're demographically heterogeneous. Or Japan. Granted, their population is older than ours, meaning their system ought to be more expensive, but like us they're a large and highly industrialized nation. Etc. With any individual nation, you can point to similarities and differences. But, overall, the wealthy nations bear much more resemblance to each other than to the world at large. The really striking thing, though, is how a single one of the wealthy nations manages to spend vastly more on healthcare with vastly worse results.
 
Back
Top