New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A parable.

I hope you're right. This may, in fact, hurt the Republicans' hopes of winning broader political power, since centrists will see them as poisonous, and liberals will be more motivated to turn out. But I'd be surprised if it personally hurt the Republicans in the arch-conservative House districts who engineered this crisis, and so why wouldn't they just do the same thing again and again? From their perspective, there's little downside and much upside.


Losing in such an overwhelming and embarrassing manner will depress voter turnout among the Tea Party rabble in upcoming elections. Add to that the fact that one of their primary motivations for turnout in the 2010 midterms (getting that black guy out of our White House) is no longer on the table, and I don't see much of a Tea Party movement in 2014.

Republicans have already lost the homophobia issue that led to the reelection of W in 2004. Meanwhile, their continued attempts to impose religious based patriarchy has turned women against the Republican Party like never before. Their intransigence regarding immigration reform will continue to whittle away at their electoral base over the coming months.

Come 2014, we will be leaving Afghanistan and signing up people who were never before able to sign up for medical insurance. Our economy will continue to improve, in spite of (not because of) Republican obstructionism. We will be in the process of normalizing diplomatic relations with Iran. What will Republicans run on in 2014? It damned sure won't be their record of achievement.

Politics is a long game. The trend for Republicans is toward electoral irrelevance. As I said, hide and watch.
 
Arkady I think you missed the brilliance in this. Revisiting it after the holidays was set by Obama who orchestrated and it should not go without notice that he got everything he asked for and everything he asked for was strategically well thought out. The republican party whose new minority members took the hostages harming all family members have already been captured by the people, the party is divided, what better thing than too allow a cooling off period after a lesson was learned that crime doesn't pay? The real genius in this is who will turn state's evidence in court dates set for January and February as a result of evidence and lessons learned.

The police banked on the House putting itself together and trying to avoid going to jail in the public eye with the perps. I fully expected it to be January because that was the headlines when the Police Chief offered the deal to capture them.

The Republican House, now in chaos, will either regain control of their wayward members or the House Republican members will lose their House in foreclosure. This is a high stakes war that will be played out after the holidays, just long enough for them to seal their own fate with the public.

The question within the party is who will be standing in January. Brilliant imo. What you missed is this is what "win again" looks like when the only adult has isolated and charged the criminal and the court of public opinion reflects distain for the criminals crime.

I guess I'm still missing the brilliance. We've just been set up to go through the whole thing again in a few months -- far enough down the line that we're going to be stuck in "hostage standoff" mode for a damaging amount of time, but not so long that the political calculus will be significantly different next time. Why wouldn't the right-wingers in the House just do it again?

My only hope is that they see that the ransom payments Obama and the Democrats are willing to make keep declining, so they'll figure next time it just isn't worth the effort.
 
It depends upon the tactic they used. The only reason that republicans surrendered was because of the intractability of the democrats and the unpopularity of the tactic. If the republicans actually came up with a tactic that would not be viewed as negative, I think the democrats would have to bargain.

But I thought the Democrats were already set to bargain. Didn't Obama say anything would be on the table, so long as he didn't have "a gun pointed at his head." Well, the gun is gone, where are the negotiations?
 
I can't teach you how to read graphs.

Obviously, not, since you'd need to learn to read them yourself, first.

I said: "The labor participation rate had been declining for years before Obamacare was implemented." As you know (or should know), your graph shows the decline started in mid 2008. As you shold also know, Obamacare was passed in late March 2010, and implementation didn't start until October 2010, with most major provisions not being implemented until just recently. Now, if you look at your graph, you'll see there was a slight decline in the rate between early 2003 and mid-2008, but then a rapid decline that started in mid-2008. So, as you'll see, the labor participation rate had been declining for years before Obamacare was implemented. Which, of course, is what I said. See your error now?
 
It depends upon the tactic they used. The only reason that republicans surrendered was because of the intractability of the democrats and the unpopularity of the tactic. If the republicans actually came up with a tactic that would not be viewed as negative, I think the democrats would have to bargain.

I agree.....that would be called civility
 
I agree.....that would be called civility

"civility"? THAT is what it would be called in your opinion, "civility"?

In response to the statement, "If the republicans actually came up with a tactic that would not be viewed as negative, I think the democrats would have to bargain.", the first thing that popped into your mind to describe that was, "civility"?????????

Really?

Well if you don't mind my asking would YOU care to take a shot at presenting us all with ANY tactic that could be used by republicans that would NOT be deemed to be a negative by the Democrats?

Other than one that just allowed Democrats whatever it is they are demanding be done I mean. Anything that could possibly qualify as an opposing point of view on a matter and could NOT be labeled to be a negative by the Democrats.

What you desire or would accept coming from republicans, you would define as "civility" from republicans, the people who voted for these republicans rather than for the Democrats running against them would define as "dishonesty", or to be more precious, "dim-lite".
 
Once upon a time, a team of professional extortionists issued a ransom notice -- either pay them a million dollars by midnight, October 16, or they'd shoot a hostage. Officials, who'd found themselves repeatedly faced with demands like this and had repeatedly made payments, decided to make a stand this time -- they would give nothing, because they knew giving up anything would simply encourage future hostage-taking. As time ticked down, officials changed their mind and negotiated a small payment for a stay of execution. For $100, the extortionists agreed not to shoot the hostage until early February. Inexplicably, some members of the hostage-taking team were livid at this deal, while the officials patted themselves on the back for having extended the hostage crisis by nearly four months.
We were hoping for a limerick. Or one of those "Nantucket" rhyme deals...
:)
 
"civility"? THAT is what it would be called in your opinion, "civility"?

In response to the statement, "If the republicans actually came up with a tactic that would not be viewed as negative, I think the democrats would have to bargain.", the first thing that popped into your mind to describe that was, "civility"?????????

Really?

Well if you don't mind my asking would YOU care to take a shot at presenting us all with ANY tactic that could be used by republicans that would NOT be deemed to be a negative by the Democrats?

Other than one that just allowed Democrats whatever it is they are demanding be done I mean. Anything that could possibly qualify as an opposing point of view on a matter and could NOT be labeled to be a negative by the Democrats.

What you desire or would accept coming from republicans, you would define as "civility" from republicans, the people who voted for these republicans rather than for the Democrats running against them would define as "dishonesty", or to be more precious, "dim-lite".


They did fine last night. The senate spoke together and were civil. Ted Cruz and his boys are just contrary and and downright nasty.
 
They did fine last night. The senate spoke together and were civil. Ted Cruz and his boys are just contrary and and downright nasty.

AND??????

Last night the republicans were merely "dim-lites", which was exactly what I was saying earlier. The republicans last night opposed nothing the Democrats did/said/want/demand/propose etc., so sure, from the dim's perspective they would be quite "civil".........

From the perspective of those who elected them to go to Washingron and do things differently from what the dim candidate who was running against them would do, how would this inaction by them, this accepting whatever the dim position was, be labeled?

I suspect, "civil" would be fairly far down the list of possibilities, know what I mean?
 
Obviously, not, since you'd need to learn to read them yourself, first.

I said: "The labor participation rate had been declining for years before Obamacare was implemented." As you know (or should know), your graph shows the decline started in mid 2008. As you shold also know, Obamacare was passed in late March 2010, and implementation didn't start until October 2010, with most major provisions not being implemented until just recently. Now, if you look at your graph, you'll see there was a slight decline in the rate between early 2003 and mid-2008, but then a rapid decline that started in mid-2008. So, as you'll see, the labor participation rate had been declining for years before Obamacare was implemented. Which, of course, is what I said. See your error now?
True enough, I went back and reread your post and did misinterpret your statement. However, the point being that there is no point in the tenure of Obama that shows any significant rise in labor participation. Obama has in no way addressed the job situation, which would, if fixed, increase revenues into the government, and require less people to be on government assistance. Obama is now going to focus on immigration reform....again. Ignoring jobs completely....again, while our labor participation is as low as during the great depression.
 
True enough, I went back and reread your post and did misinterpret your statement. However, the point being that there is no point in the tenure of Obama that shows any significant rise in labor participation. Obama has in no way addressed the job situation, which would, if fixed, increase revenues into the government, and require less people to be on government assistance. Obama is now going to focus on immigration reform....again. Ignoring jobs completely....again, while our labor participation is as low as during the great depression.

Would you expect labor participation rates to rise? If you'd asked way back in 2000 what would be happening to the labor participation rate in 2013, pretty much every economist and sociologist, left or right, would have told you it would be falling, even though we had no idea about 9/11 or Obamacare or any other political developments that would come. What we knew was that the Baby Boom demographic bulge started in 1946, so, the first Boomers would reach SS eligibility age in 2008, and then first hit full benefits eligibility in 2011, and that by 2013 there'd be a large and ever-growing segment of Americans who would have recently reached normal retirement age. That's going to show up as a falling labor participation rate even when unemployment rates are falling.

In this case, I think the relevant consideration would be demographically-adjusted participation -- find the participation rate for each age cohort, then recalculate based on the idea that the relative sizes of the cohorts hadn't changed. I'm sure someone must have done number crunching of that sort, and it would suggest whether what we're seeing is the kind of participation-rate decline we had in the Bush years, which was based on worker discouragement, or just age-related decline, or some combination.
 
True enough, I went back and reread your post and did misinterpret your statement. However, the point being that there is no point in the tenure of Obama that shows any significant rise in labor participation. Obama has in no way addressed the job situation, which would, if fixed, increase revenues into the government, and require less people to be on government assistance. Obama is now going to focus on immigration reform....again. Ignoring jobs completely....again, while our labor participation is as low as during the great depression.

Addressing immigration reform could help the jobs situation. Currently, undocumented workers can be made to work over 40 hours per week, without paying them overtime, because they don't dare make a formal complaint. That allows fewer people to do more work on an economically viable basis for employers, which decreases the number of jobs. Giving those workers a legal worker status, such that they could sue for back pay when employers short-change them time-and-a-half and the economics change for employers: they're then encouraged to hire more workers, rather than working a few intimidated undocumented workers to the bone.
 
Addressing immigration reform could help the jobs situation. Currently, undocumented workers can be made to work over 40 hours per week, without paying them overtime, because they don't dare make a formal complaint. That allows fewer people to do more work on an economically viable basis for employers, which decreases the number of jobs. Giving those workers a legal worker status, such that they could sue for back pay when employers short-change them time-and-a-half and the economics change for employers: they're then encouraged to hire more workers, rather than working a few intimidated undocumented workers to the bone.
This does not encourage people to hire more workers. First off, hiring more workers increases taxes and, in many cases, forces smaller companies into the Obamacare regulatory morass. Also, much of the reason these people are employing illegals is because they can pay substandard wages. Forcing smaller employees to pay more will make it harder for them to expand their workforces.

Is Obama so beaten by the job situation that he's not even going to bother anymore? Just pander to special interests until the 2014 elections?
 
This does not encourage people to hire more workers. First off, hiring more workers increases taxes and, in many cases, forces smaller companies into the Obamacare regulatory morass. Also, much of the reason these people are employing illegals is because they can pay substandard wages. Forcing smaller employees to pay more will make it harder for them to expand their workforces.

Is Obama so beaten by the job situation that he's not even going to bother anymore? Just pander to special interests until the 2014 elections?

In what way would hiring more workers increase taxes?
 
For $100, the extortionists agreed not to shoot the hostage until early February.


One Hundred Dollars?

Bullshit! More like Fifty Cents.

More like; "Hey if you guys come out and give up, we'll give you a sip of cold Coca-Cola."

Mmmmm... Coca-Cola... Sounds good, don't it? Y'all gettin' thirsty in there? ;)
 
Back
Top