New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A question

Yes, I did hear about it--but please stop calling me "man" and "dude." Wrong gender. :D I'm hoping we see a MUCH better team next year!

No, TS was not brain dead. She couldn't have functioned at all if she was. She WAS severely brain-damaged, tho.

Oh crap, i'm sorry! Goes to show you how wrong perceptions can be!!

Wow, thanks for straightening out my cluelessness! :(
 
Nothing.. she's already dead.

Many don't know the difference between the condition of death and life. The same machines that save people by temporarily taking over functions as they heal or go through procedures can cause a deceased person to function by machine long after they are gone. That little girl is deceased and it is a tragic story. Science has developed wonderful machines to help save lives but when these machines are abused it is preserving death.
 
If, when our hearts stop beating, we are considered dead...why, when our hearts start beating (in the womb), are we not considered alive?
If only the compassion of blathering wingnuts for unwanted children endured beyond the womb and all the way into infancy. At that point, they become a part of the 47%. "They don't matter"....oh....unless they vote Republican.
 
Many don't know the difference between the condition of death and life. The same machines that save people by temporarily taking over functions as they heal or go through procedures can cause a deceased person to function by machine long after they are gone. That little girl is deceased and it is a tragic story. Science has developed wonderful machines to help save lives but when these machines are abused it is preserving death.

Kind of creepy when you think about it. You could keep someone "alive" for a hundred years after their death.

From a spiritual perspective, it's horribly wrong.
 
Which also brings up the case in Texas where a young woman is considered brain dead after a possible blood clot in the lung. She also happens to be five months pregnant, and the baby's heart is beating. The father and parents of the mother want the mother taken off life support--Texas says after the baby can either be born naturally or taken by C-section when it has developed enough to survive, as they cannot sanction killing this baby. Parents and husband are fighting this.

That is messed up. That should be the families decision considering they are in agreement if she is deceased. Funny that in the little girls case the hospital did the right thing but in the Texas case they are forcing preservation on death as if this deceased woman is nothing more than a planter.
 
Which also brings up the case in Texas where a young woman is considered brain dead after a possible blood clot in the lung. She also happens to be five months pregnant, and the baby's heart is beating. The father and parents of the mother want the mother taken off life support--Texas says after the baby can either be born naturally or taken by C-section when it has developed enough to survive, as they cannot sanction killing this baby. Parents and husband are fighting this.
That's a case of law being way ahead of science. They actually don't know all of the effects on a baby of using a brain dead human body as an incubator. It's an incidental experiment. How much does lack of brain activity in the mother affect development of the fetus? Gee. I guess Texas is intent on finding out.

Luckily, this is only happening in a backwards, third world country where the laws are based on superstition. Hopefully, America will never look like this.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Kind of creepy when you think about it. You could keep someone "alive" for a hundred years after their death.

From a spiritual perspective, it's horribly wrong.


more along the lines of simulation...via machinery...

sadly.
 
Kind of creepy when you think about it. You could keep someone "alive" for a hundred years after their death.

From a spiritual perspective, it's horribly wrong.

There was an old comedy movie about hooking a nose up to life support. Seems we have reached that moment in time.
 
If, when our hearts stop beating, we are considered dead...why, when our hearts start beating (in the womb), are we not considered alive?

We are, the question is whether we can we breath/survive alone. At the point that a baby can survive outside the womb, alone, it is then it's legally a seperate and so its own person, until that point it is the mothers business because it is her body that baby is surviving on.

I understand the argument but are we to say that a womans' body belongs to the State? If the State rule aborting a child illegal.

I have had abortions, two, and suffered greatly because of them but it was my business. The bond is made at conception -

I think these arguments are somewhat unhelpful in the battle to stop so many aborted ones. Why do women feels so strongly that their babies should not be born into this World that they abort - or why do women need to feel that connection with the Mystery of life but have not the strength to give birth ...........those sorts of questions are more constructive, I feel.
 
Many don't know the difference between the condition of death and life. The same machines that save people by temporarily taking over functions as they heal or go through procedures can cause a deceased person to function by machine long after they are gone. That little girl is deceased and it is a tragic story. Science has developed wonderful machines to help save lives but when these machines are abused it is preserving death.
I think that in THIS case, you're right.
 
That's a case of law being way ahead of science. They actually don't know all of the effects on a baby of using a brain dead human body as an incubator. It's an incidental experiment. Luckily, this is only happening in a backwards, third world country where the laws are based on superstition. Hopefully, America will never look like this.
The law says that it's a woman's right to choose. Who is to say what the mother would have wanted for the child? The woman had already expressed her wish that she would never want to be kept alive by artificial means--but it was not LEGALLY expressed. As the law sees it, it would be killing a viable child.
 
Kind of creepy when you think about it. You could keep someone "alive" for a hundred years after their death.

From a spiritual perspective, it's horribly wrong.
In the medical world it is easy to keep someone alive for a period of time. Imagine a person who has lost his heart or lungs for example. They can keep that person alive via artificial means so that the person can say his/her goodbyes to family that has to come from a distance. I think it is ghastly, but if it's the patient's wish.......
 
The legal "decision" of whether or not a beating heart means a person is alive is based on the desirability of being able to allow a person to die, or kill a pre-born infant without the "murder" ramifications.

To those who believe abortion is fine, that a heart, beating on its own without any mechanical aid in doing so, does not indicate that life is present. It's purely legal and not based on reality.
 
The law says that it's a woman's right to choose. Who is to say what the mother would have wanted for the child? The woman had already expressed her wish that she would never want to be kept alive by artificial means--but it was not LEGALLY expressed. As the law sees it, it would be killing a viable child.

It is a strange one isn't it? ...................... I ask if they always choose so though............ I mean if there was no way of paying for it would they choose so? I think a baby in the womb lives for about six hours after the death of its mother.
 
The only doctor who said she wasn't brain dead was a Republican Senator who was unfamiliar with any details of her case and had never examined her in any way. Bill Frist. The Weaselzippers of doctors.


It is a nitpick, but Terri Shiavo was not "brain dead" according to Doctors who examined her condition. She was in what is known as a persistent vegetative state. Although she had no consciousness and was unaware of her own existence, her brain stem was still functional and she was able to maintain breathing and heartbeat without the assistance of a mechanical ventilator.

Brain death is a condition in which even the most primitive brain structures are no longer functional. A brain dead person cannot breathe without a ventilator and if their breathing stops, then their heartbeat will soon stop as well. No person has ever been known to "live" for more than a month after brain death, in spite of employing ventilators or any other artificial life support systems.
 
It was merely a question.

I did not express my own POV in any way, except to post the query.

Having never been faced with whether to have a child, or not, I cannot imagine the thought that goes into that decision.

My post want not meant to offend.

However, in true PJ fashion, some could not refrain from attacking and simply answering without rancor.

So, its a new year, but the same old bs has carried over....smh
 
It was merely a question.

I did not express my own POV in any way, except to post the query.

Having never been faced with whether to have a child, or not, I cannot imagine the thought that goes into that decision.

My post want not meant to offend.

However, in true PJ fashion, some could not refrain from attacking and simply answering without rancor.

So, its a new year, but the same old bs has carried over....smh

:) ................
 
It is a nitpick, but Terri Shiavo was not "brain dead" according to Doctors who examined her condition. She was in what is known as a persistent vegetative state. Although she had no consciousness and was unaware of her own existence, her brain stem was still functional and she was able to maintain breathing and heartbeat without the assistance of a mechanical ventilator.

Brain death is a condition in which even the most primitive brain structures are no longer functional. A brain dead person cannot breathe without a ventilator and if their breathing stops, then their heartbeat will soon stop as well. No person has ever been known to "live" for more than a month after brain death, in spite of employing ventilators or any other artificial life support systems.
Yeah....I was remembering it wrong. What was determined by the autopsy was that the damage was worse than the lowest expectation and irreversible. That seemed like such a given that I had forgotten that it was what was in dispute....by people like Frist and a family that hung on to hope because of them.
 
Back
Top