New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A truism

"Truism" is sorta like "the fact of the matter". Whenever anyone leads with either, what follows is neither a truism nor the fact of the matter.
 
As true about the 2nd Amendment as it is about the 1st AmendmentView attachment 6990

While techonology hasn't really changed the execution of free speech or a free press, technology has changed the execution of the reason why we need the right to bear arms for those who believe in the "well regulated" meaning of the second amendment. It is all dependent upon point of view regarding the amendment. For those who believe in "well regulated", the change in technology does in fact change their perception of how we need to regulate arms. No amendment is absolute and this is especially true of the second amenment where the level of technology has been regulated for a long time. You can't own an automatic weapon in most places.
 
While techonology hasn't really changed the execution of free speech or a free press, technology has changed the execution of the reason why we need the right to bear arms for those who believe in the "well regulated" meaning of the second amendment. It is all dependent upon point of view regarding the amendment. For those who believe in "well regulated", the change in technology does in fact change their perception of how we need to regulate arms. No amendment is absolute and this is especially true of the second amenment where the level of technology has been regulated for a long time. You can't own an automatic weapon in most places.

Well-regulated refers not to the right to keep and bear arms, but to the militia. A "well-regulated" militia was one that could function using arms, ammo and tactics similar or identical to the "regular" Army.

The right of the individual to keep and bear arms is a separate one from the right of the people to participate in the well-regulated militia.
 
"The right of the individual to keep and bear arms is a separate one from the right of the people to participate in the well-regulated militia. " It really depends on how one deconstructs a sentence. We could argue about that one for a very long time and not reach any agreement. I was commenting that what you say isn't a truism for those, like me, who believe in a different interpretation of "well regulated" than you. All of that aside, our right to bear arms has been, and continues to be, heavily influenced by the level of technology. As technology changes, the influence is bound to change.
 
"The right of the individual to keep and bear arms is a separate one from the right of the people to participate in the well-regulated militia. " It really depends on how one deconstructs a sentence. We could argue about that one for a very long time and not reach any agreement. I was commenting that what you say isn't a truism for those, like me, who believe in a different interpretation of "well regulated" than you. All of that aside, our right to bear arms has been, and continues to be, heavily influenced by the level of technology. As technology changes, the influence is bound to change.

Actually, at this point it does not depend on how ONE deconstructs the sentence (it never did, either, as there is no way to get "well-regulated" over to act as a modifier for "the right of the people to keep and bear arms). What it depends on NOW, is, "How did the Supreme Court deconstruct the sentence -- which I already described.
 
"What it depends on NOW, is, "How did the Supreme Court deconstruct the sentence -- which I already described." Which is subject to change. Also of interest that it was the first time in over 200 years that they interpreted it that way. That is strange given that they typically have made the interpretation of the constitution less conservative over that same period, yet they reversed the general direction of the previous rulings that refused to make such a statement. I expressed my own opinion which is independent of the SCOTUS. Because, you know, they haven't always been right. Again, to the first post, technology has changed our view of the extent of the right to bear arms and will continue to do so, regardless of what you and I say here.
 
"What it depends on NOW, is, "How did the Supreme Court deconstruct the sentence -- which I already described." Which is subject to change. Also of interest that it was the first time in over 200 years that they interpreted it that way. That is strange given that they typically have made the interpretation of the constitution less conservative over that same period, yet they reversed the general direction of the previous rulings that refused to make such a statement. I expressed my own opinion which is independent of the SCOTUS. Because, you know, they haven't always been right. Again, to the first post, technology has changed our view of the extent of the right to bear arms and will continue to do so, regardless of what you and I say here.

It was the first time in over 200 years that the individual right to arms was before the court.

As for the SCOTUS and its record, of course it is a human endeavor and it is subject to fallibility. Nonetheless, it did not act "conservatively" to restrict a right in the 2nd Amemdent case. It acted liberally to expand the individual right.
 
It acted liberally to expand the individual right.

The decision wasn't a liberal move by the court. Edit: I base this upon the majority (the conservative justices) versus the minority (the liberal ones).

The first time the individual right was before the court. Maybe. I can't talk to that as I don't know all of the cases before the court and can't say wether or not they had the opportunity to make such a ruling or not.

Edit: From 1939 Miller: "In the absence of any evidence tending to show that possession or use of a "shotgun having a barrel of less than eighteen inches in length" at this time has some reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well regulated militia, we cannot say that the Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear such an instrument. Certainly it is not within judicial notice that this weapon is any part of the ordinary military equipment or that its use could contribute to the common defense." It appears that in the case of Miller, that the SCOTUS did have the chance to redefine the interpretation of the meaning of "well regulated militia" relative to an individuals right.

It also appears that the court again had the opportunity in the 1997 case concerning the Brady bill where they referenced the Miller case, military equipemnt, and common defense. That was a great opportunity to interpret what they referenced, but they failed to do so.

I am not a lawyer so I really could be wrong here.
 
Last edited:
"The right of the individual to keep and bear arms is a separate one from the right of the people to participate in the well-regulated militia. " It really depends on how one deconstructs a sentence. We could argue about that one for a very long time and not reach any agreement. I was commenting that what you say isn't a truism for those, like me, who believe in a different interpretation of "well regulated" than you. All of that aside, our right to bear arms has been, and continues to be, heavily influenced by the level of technology. As technology changes, the influence is bound to change.


With that kind of logic
Saying that Obama said "You didn't build that someone else did." while talking about entrepeneurs is valid
 
It was the first time in over 200 years that the individual right to arms was before the court.

As for the SCOTUS and its record, of course it is a human endeavor and it is subject to fallibility. Nonetheless, it did not act "conservatively" to restrict a right in the 2nd Amemdent case. It acted liberally to expand the individual right.

There are two ways of looking at this one. We could say the ruling was liberal and that the conservative call would've been to leave things as they were - which was actually pretty muddy! Or, we can say the ruling was conservative in that it simply codified the popular understanding. In this particular case, I lean towards the latter.

Truth be told, The Court's Heller v. D.C. ruling has had very little practical effect, ACCEPT to the extent that it's taken a whole lot of wind out of the NRA's sails. Even those who wish The Court had gone the other way, have to concede that we'd be confronting a whole lot more upheaval today, if they had!
 
There are two ways of looking at this one. We could say the ruling was liberal and that the conservative call would've been to leave things as they were - which was actually pretty muddy! Or, we can say the ruling was conservative in that it simply codified the popular understanding. In this particular case, I lean towards the latter.

Truth be told, The Court's Heller v. D.C. ruling has had very little practical effect, ACCEPT to the extent that it's taken a whole lot of wind out of the NRA's sails. Even those who wish The Court had gone the other way, have to concede that we'd be confronting a whole lot more upheaval today, if they had!

Please -- you're missing the follow on rulings. The biggest was McDonald, but there are a couple of others working their way through the system. Heller (taken together with McDonald) were huge victories for the NRA and all people who care about their civil rights to firearms.
 
The decision wasn't a liberal move by the court. Edit: I base this upon the majority (the conservative justices) versus the minority (the liberal ones).

The first time the individual right was before the court. Maybe. I can't talk to that as I don't know all of the cases before the court and can't say wether or not they had the opportunity to make such a ruling or not.

Edit: From 1939 Miller: "In the absence of any evidence tending to show that possession or use of a "shotgun having a barrel of less than eighteen inches in length" at this time has some reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well regulated militia, we cannot say that the Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear such an instrument. Certainly it is not within judicial notice that this weapon is any part of the ordinary military equipment or that its use could contribute to the common defense." It appears that in the case of Miller, that the SCOTUS did have the chance to redefine the interpretation of the meaning of "well regulated militia" relative to an individuals right.

It also appears that the court again had the opportunity in the 1997 case concerning the Brady bill where they referenced the Miller case, military equipemnt, and common defense. That was a great opportunity to interpret what they referenced, but they failed to do so.

I am not a lawyer so I really could be wrong here.

here is information.
http://www.justfacts.com/guncontrol.asp#constitution

Constitution
* In the Bill of Rights, the Second Amendment to the Constitution reads:
A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.[160]
* Gun control proponents have argued and some federal courts have ruled that the Second Amendment does not apply to individual citizens of the United States but only to members of militias, which, they assert, are now the state National Guard units.[161] [162] In 2002, a federal appeals court panel ruled that "the people" only "have the right to bear arms in the service of the state."[163]
* Gun rights proponents have argued and some federal courts have ruled that the Second Amendment recognizes "an individual right to keep and bear arms."[164] In 2001, a federal appeals court panel ruled that the Second Amendment "protects the right of individuals, including those not then actually a member of any militia or engaged in active military service or training, to privately possess and bear their own firearms...."[165]
* James Madison was the primary author of the Bill of Rights,[166] is known as the "Father of the Constitution" for his central role in its formation,[167] and was one of three authors of the Federalist Papers, a group of essays published in newspapers and books to explain and lobby for ratification of the Constitution.[168] [169]
* In Federalist Paper 46, James Madison addressed the concern that a standing federal army might conduct a coup to take over the nation. He argued that this was implausible because, based on the country's population at the time, a federal standing army couldn't field more than 25,000-30,000 men. He then wrote:
To these would be opposed a militia amounting to near half a million of citizens with arms in their hands, officered by men chosen from among themselves, fighting for their common liberties, and united and conducted by governments possessing their affections and confidence.
Besides the advantage of being armed, which the Americans possess over the people of almost every other nation, the existence of subordinate governments, to which the people are attached, and by which the militia officers are appointed, forms a barrier against the enterprises of ambition, more insurmountable than any which a simple government of any form can admit of. Notwithstanding the military establishments in the several kingdoms of Europe, which are carried as far as the public resources will bear, the governments are afraid to trust the people with arms.[170]
└ D.C. v Heller
* In 1976, the Washington, D.C. City Council passed a law generally prohibiting residents from possessing handguns and requiring that all firearms in private homes be (1) kept unloaded and (2) rendered temporally inoperable via disassembly or installation of a trigger lock.[171] [172]
* On June 26, 2008, the U.S. Supreme Court, in a 5-4 ruling known as D.C. v Heller, struck down this law as unconstitutional.[173]
* Excerpts from the majority ruling (Justice Scalia, joined by Roberts, Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito):
The District's total ban on handgun possession in the home amounts to a prohibition on an entire class of "arms" that Americans overwhelmingly choose for the lawful purpose of self-defense. Under any of the standards of scrutiny the Court has applied to enumerated constitutional rights, this prohibition ... would fail constitutional muster.
Similarly, the requirement that any lawful firearm in the home be disassembled or bound by a trigger lock makes it impossible for citizens to use arms for the core lawful purpose of self-defense and is hence unconstitutional.
The Second Amendment is naturally divided into two parts: its prefatory clause and its operative clause. The former does not limit the latter grammatically, but rather announces a purpose. The Amendment could be rephrased, "Because a well regulated Militia is necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed."
* Excerpts from a minority dissent (Justice Stevens, joined by Souter, Ginsburg, and Breyer):
[T]he words "the people" in the Second Amendment refer back to the object announced in the Amendment's preamble. They remind us that it is the collective action of individuals having a duty to serve in the militia that the text directly protects and, perhaps more importantly, that the ultimate purpose of the Amendment was to protect the States' share of the divided sovereignty created by the Constitution.
As used in the Second Amendment, the words "the people" do not enlarge the right to keep and bear arms to encompass use or ownership of weapons outside the context of service in a well-regulated militia.
* Excerpt from a minority dissent (Justice Breyer, joined by Stevens, Souter, and Ginsburg):
[The Framers were] unlikely then to have thought of a right to keep loaded handguns in homes to confront intruders in urban settings as central. And the subsequent development of modern urban police departments, by diminishing the need to keep loaded guns nearby in case of intruders, would have moved any such right even further away from the heart of the amendment's more basic protective ends.
* The Bill of Rights includes two Amendments other than the Second that use the phrase "right of the people":
Amendment 1: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."[174]
Amendment 4: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."[175]
* In D.C. v Heller, the Supreme Court Justices debated the meaning of the phrase "right of the people" in the Second Amendment. Below are excerpts of this debate:
• Majority Opinion (Justice Scalia, joined by Roberts, Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito):
The unamended Constitution and the Bill of Rights use the phrase "right of the people" two other times... The Ninth Amendment uses very similar terminology.... All three of these instances unambiguously refer to individual rights, not "collective" rights, or rights that may be exercised only through participation in some corporate body. ...
... Nowhere else in the Constitution does a "right" attributed to "the people" refer to anything other than an individual right.
What is more, in all six other provisions of the Constitution that mention "the people," the term unambiguously refers to all members of the political community, not an unspecified subset.
 
Back
Top