New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A Voice on Abortion

If women feel that men should not have a voice (vote) on regulating abortion (complete ban or free for all), then should men have the legal choice whether to abort their financial obligations to that child wanted by the mother but unwanted by the father?
 
If women feel that men should not have a voice (vote) on regulating abortion (complete ban or free for all), then should men have the legal choice whether to abort their financial obligations to that child wanted by the mother but unwanted by the father?

That sounds fair enough to me. ;)
 
If women feel that men should not have a voice (vote) on regulating abortion (complete ban or free for all), then should men have the legal choice whether to abort their financial obligations to that child wanted by the mother but unwanted by the father?

No because at that point we are talking about a child who Is no longer in the woman's uterus and is no longer an embryo in a woman. It is an independent third person that ishalf his and half hers and they both have a financial obligation
 
No because at that point we are talking about a child who Is no longer in the woman's uterus and is no longer an embryo in a woman. It is an independent third person that ishalf his and half hers and they both have a financial obligation

If men can't vote say at the state level over the matter of abortion as to its regulation applying to all women because they don't have a uterus, then why should men have to pay for children they don't want. Its a rational trade off for women and fair to men.
 
If men can't vote say at the state level over the matter of abortion as to its regulation applying to all women because they don't have a uterus, then why should men have to pay for children they don't want. Its a rational trade off for women and fair to men.

I totally agree, resident. If a woman insists to have the child, and the father is dead set against it, she should be responsible to raise that child. It should be a mutual decision.

If the mother doesn't want the child, but the father DOES, well then, HE'S the responsible party, and SHE'S off the hook.

That SHOULD actually make women re-consider having sex, especially unprotected sex, with just any old Tom, Dick, or Deshawn.....
 
I agree its problematic. Women can choose to terminate or give birth regardless of what the man thinks or wants. I think men should have an ability to opt out, but that could create a bigger problem. Catch 22
 
I totally agree, resident. If a woman insists to have the child, and the father is dead set against it, she should be responsible to raise that child. It should be a mutual decision.

If the mother doesn't want the child, but the father DOES, well then, HE'S the responsible party, and SHE'S off the hook.

That SHOULD actually make women re-consider having sex, especially unprotected sex, with just any old Tom, Dick, or Deshawn.....

Just to be clear I'm for regulating abortion on the consensus of men and women voting on the issue and I'm for men being financially responsible and that responsibility being strongly enforced as long as they have good access to the child(ren).

The reason men (and women) should pay support is that otherwise these children would be the responsibility of the state and that is not acceptable.
 
I agree its problematic. Women can choose to terminate or give birth regardless of what the man thinks or wants. I think men should have an ability to opt out, but that could create a bigger problem. Catch 22

Oh, there is no catch-22 women should have regulated abortions and men and women should pay support for their progeny.
 
If men can't vote say at the state level over the matter of abortion as to its regulation applying to all women because they don't have a uterus, then why should men have to pay for children they don't want. Its a rational trade off for women and fair to men.


Because there is only one person who has the final say......men know this before they have unprotected sex. Aren't you against abortion? Sounds like you want men to have the choice whether to be fathers, but not women who don't want to be mothers. I will repeat again...once there is a child there is a third entity, independent of both parents and both parents are responsible for it.
 
But not legally. And quite often men suffer legal ramifications for avoiding their responsibility that they never necessarily chose.


Sure they did.....men know when they have sex a child can result.....then when it is born they share responsibility. It is no longer an embryo, it is a child.
 
Because there is only one person who has the final say......men know this before they have unprotected sex. Aren't you against abortion? Sounds like you want men to have the choice whether to be fathers, but not women who don't want to be mothers. I will repeat again...once there is a child there is a third entity, independent of both parents and both parents are responsible for it.

My answer - https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/a-voice-on-abortion.57230/#post-804108
 
Sure they did.....men know when they have sex a child can result.....then when it is born they share responsibility. It is no longer an embryo, it is a child.

Same goes for women. They too knew they could end up with a child. It's two parties that chose, but if women believe men shouldn't participate in the regulation of abortion (I'm talking about law making say such as in Texas) because they don't have a uterus then men shouldn't be required to pay for their mistakes much as women aren't.
 
Same goes for women. They too knew they could end up with a child. It's two parties that chose, but if women believe men shouldn't participate in the regulation of abortion (I'm talking about law making say such as in Texas) because they don't have a uterus then men shouldn't be required to pay for their mistakes much as women aren't.

Exactly...women know they could end up with a child and have all the responsibility of either carrying it, or terminating the pregnancy, which is not fun. What you seem to be saying women should have all the responsibility and men none, unless men want the child., that Men should have the final say...only one person can have the final say...if she doesn't want an abortion there is a third person to be considered. Half his, half hers.
 
What you seem to be saying women should have all the responsibility and men none, unless men want the child., that Men should have the final say...


You really don't get it do you? Hmmm... I don't know how else to explain it. Well that's that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
You really don't get it do you? Hmmm... I don't know how else to explain it. Well that's that.


Of course I get it....you are saying that if a man doesn't have say in the abortion issue, then he shouldn't have to pay support. Please correct me if I misunderstood.
 
Back
Top