New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

A World Without Work

Well, you seemed to be offering Biblical consolation to me for being afraid of robots, AI, and random genetic engineering when in point of fact I expressed hope for robotics and AI but concern over unregulated DIY genetic engineering. So I'm not really following your intentions at all.
It was your fears I was addressing regardless of the source of those fears.

“Therefore do not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has enough trouble of its own.” Matthew 6:34
 
It is a bit scary considering a hard working person may not in the future be able to have the american dream. Maybe Bernie Sanders socialism will return. Else what would happen?
One possibility as the market economy and public sector decline is the growth of a third sector sometimes called a voluntary or community sector that would ally with government to rebuild infrastructure and provide needed social services.

This could be financed through the Pentagon with an understanding that the US Military would become self supporting from new non-profit defense industries rising from a 21st century Green New Deal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_End_of_Work
 
Well, thanks for that.
You're welcome.

IMHO, most of the ills of the world are caused by unnecessary fears. While it's true there are things that should concern us, to live in fear of death is to show a distinct lack of faith in the Lord.

We're all going to die one day. It's how we live that matters, not how long we live.
 
You're right. Spending too much time on a forum certainly falls into this category. :0)
It certainly does. At least if it causes a person to have a conniption as we've seen a few do here like the ones ranting about "greedy Jews" or "Trumpzilla" in dozens of threads.
 
I think the answer depends on separating GDP (production, expenditure, and income) from the profit motive. Some recent figures on US income inequality reveal the richest 20 citizens now have acquired more wealth than the poorest 160,000,000 US citizens. The answer to your valid question "just where does the money come" is: the money comes from society. Under the current economic system, those who "own" the means of production are entitled to the lion's share of increasing productivity. IMHO, that is what will have to change to prevent the next crash.

What you stated makes sense, but then is it fair to tax a small group way different than the rest, that seems to go against the constitution. i is really a tough question, but it needs the right answer for society to survive.
 
I have a theory that - if everyone walked out of their jobs tomorrow --- everyone. And then everyone took up the jobs that they would love to do - that the World would run smoothly because there really are people who are fascinated by even sewerage ;-)

The whole pack of cards is crumbling because of the lack of love and excellence. Never ever in mans History has 'our most excellent' been out of the equation until now --- it will fail and quite soon, I imagine. Mediocrity does not sustain us, it is so unsatisfying and the spirit has always proved to be stronger --- eh?

Our present day life with the middle class is an anomaly of history, almost all of history things have been ruled by a few with the masses living on very little. It looks like we are returning to that mold as the industrial revolution runs its course and puts people out of work, the circle is almost complete.
 
What you stated makes sense, but then is it fair to tax a small group way different than the rest, that seems to go against the constitution. i is really a tough question, but it needs the right answer for society to survive.
It may be one of those "Big Questions" were are hearing nothing about from our political "leaders." If society is at one of those historical tipping points, like the one that occurred when the Industrial Revolution transformed taxation by taxing wages and rents instead of agricultural crops as had been done before industrialization, income may no longer serve a realistic basis for funding necessary government services.

Any solution would include shifting the burden of taxation from individuals to corporations, for example, or seeking ways for government to fund itself?
 
Our present day life with the middle class is an anomaly of history, almost all of history things have been ruled by a few with the masses living on very little. It looks like we are returning to that mold as the industrial revolution runs its course and puts people out of work, the circle is almost complete.
That's a scary thought.
If you're correct, the huge population increase that's occurred over the past 250 years will make it difficult for the few to rule in the way they did before industrialization taught the masses how to read.
 
It may be one of those "Big Questions" were are hearing nothing about from our political "leaders." If society is at one of those historical tipping points, like the one that occurred when the Industrial Revolution transformed taxation by taxing wages and rents instead of agricultural crops as had been done before industrialization, income may no longer serve a realistic basis for funding necessary government services.

Any solution would include shifting the burden of taxation from individuals to corporations, for example, or seeking ways for government to fund itself?

That may be what has to happen, but there goes our Global competitiveness that we are already bad at. Maybe Tariffs at the same time. Things will sure need to change.
 
Hobbies are great and I hope people do worthwhile things with their time, but the money to live is still the question.

I am not so sure that is just a matter of money but that people are so stressed about it. One could in times past have a quality of life on meager means which is less apparent now a days because we no longer entertain ourselves. Many of those things we take for granted, as in, they are a massive part of our lives, TV for instance, should be re-thought really.
 
Our present day life with the middle class is an anomaly of history, almost all of history things have been ruled by a few with the masses living on very little. It looks like we are returning to that mold as the industrial revolution runs its course and puts people out of work, the circle is almost complete.

Quality is gone though, which is why at some point the whole unnatural structure will fall.
 
I am not so sure that is just a matter of money but that people are so stressed about it. One could in times past have a quality of life on meager means which is less apparent now a days because we no longer entertain ourselves. Many of those things we take for granted, as in, they are a massive part of our lives, TV for instance, should be re-thought really.

YES, once people get past the basics their is a lot of room for projects like art and science, but most people are so leveraged and wages are falling, so getting out from under might be a generational thing. I wonder what percentage would do useful things VS those that watch TV all day or sit at the pub.
 
It's coming.
Predictions like 47% of current US jobs at risk of elimination due to automation or Artificial Intelligence mean we are about to confront a dilemma unique in human history: the separation of labor and subsistence.
http://rdwolff.com/content/prof-wolff-david-pakman-show-will-automation-end-full-employment


"The U.S. labor force has been shaped by millennia of technological progress.

"Agricultural technology birthed the farming industry, the industrial revolution moved people into factories, and then globalization and automation moved them back out, giving rise to a nation of services.

"But throughout these reshufflings, the total number of jobs has always increased.

"What may be looming is something different: an era of technological unemployment, in which computer scientists and software engineers essentially invent us out of work, and the total number of jobs declines steadily and permanently.

"This fear is not new.

"The hope that machines might free us from toil has always been intertwined with the fear that they will rob us of our agency.

"In the midst of the Great Depression, the economist John Maynard Keynes forecast that technological progress might allow a 15-hour workweek, and abundant leisure, by 2030."
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/07/world-without-work/395294/

According to the ~10 minute interview with Richard Wolff in the first link, Switzerland and Finland have already begun experimenting with disconnecting work from income.

Voluntary work?

20-25 hours of work per week?

Ready for the Good News?

Mass leisure and the freedom that brings will require suspending the profit motive in human commerce;)
You don't need to suspend the profit motive in human commerce in order to make sure that growing productivity translates into widespread prosperity growth and leisure time increases. We have a model from the industrial revolution, when there was a gigantic increase in productivity. At the time, the labor movement and progressive politicians did things that essentially restricted the pool of man-hours available to commerce: they instituted 40-hour work-weeks and overtime laws, paid vacation, child labor laws, a socialized retirement system (Social Security) that let older workers exit the workforce, and enhanced public education (universal high school, the GI Bill, subsidized colleges), etc. They also had high upper-class taxes, so that plenty of the new wealth was effectively cycled back into the system to fund expanded benefits for the masses. This kept a rough balance in bargaining power between employers and employees, so that the rising tide tended to lift all boats mostly evenly. But the profit motive remained. People could still make huge fortunes.

We could emulate that by similarly using aggressive government intervention to preserve a rough balance in bargaining power. For example, maybe increase the working age, just as child labor laws once did, decrease the age for eligibility for Social Security funds, change the weekly hour cap before time and a half kicks in, and get rid of the concept of "exempted employees," etc. Restrict the pool of available man-hours, so that people can bargain for a decent chunk of the value their labor produces, even as productivity gains apply an ever-bigger multiplier to it. The profit motive will remain, it'll just play out within narrower bounds, just as its bounds were narrowed in response to the industrial revolution.
 
That may be what has to happen, but there goes our Global competitiveness that we are already bad at. Maybe Tariffs at the same time. Things will sure need to change.
One possible component of that Change might be found in how we ground our workplaces:
http://www.rdwolff.com/content/why-debates-over-feds-interest-rate-miss-point

"An economic system grounded on worker co-ops as the chief form of enterprise organization, and thereby exerting democratic control over government policy, would function differently.

"It would not likely sit by and allow the simultaneous emergence of unemployed workers, unutilized productive capacity and unmet social needs for output - the way capitalism routinely does.

"It would mobilize private and government resources immediately to resolve any unwanted interruption in production.

"It would match hours worked to output wanted - with due deference to the natural environment as well as workers' needs for rest, relaxation and non-productive activities.

"Everyone would have equivalent hours worked so no 'unemployment' would ever need to exist."
 
One possible component of that Change might be found in how we ground our workplaces:
http://www.rdwolff.com/content/why-debates-over-feds-interest-rate-miss-point

"An economic system grounded on worker co-ops as the chief form of enterprise organization, and thereby exerting democratic control over government policy, would function differently.

"It would not likely sit by and allow the simultaneous emergence of unemployed workers, unutilized productive capacity and unmet social needs for output - the way capitalism routinely does.

"It would mobilize private and government resources immediately to resolve any unwanted interruption in production.

"It would match hours worked to output wanted - with due deference to the natural environment as well as workers' needs for rest, relaxation and non-productive activities.

"Everyone would have equivalent hours worked so no 'unemployment' would ever need to exist."


This sounds like a good communists dream. It doesn't address the jobs issue, just the management issue and with robotics that will not be an issue.
 
One possible component of that Change might be found in how we ground our workplaces:
http://www.rdwolff.com/content/why-debates-over-feds-interest-rate-miss-point

"An economic system grounded on worker co-ops as the chief form of enterprise organization, and thereby exerting democratic control over government policy, would function differently.

"It would not likely sit by and allow the simultaneous emergence of unemployed workers, unutilized productive capacity and unmet social needs for output - the way capitalism routinely does.

"It would mobilize private and government resources immediately to resolve any unwanted interruption in production.

"It would match hours worked to output wanted - with due deference to the natural environment as well as workers' needs for rest, relaxation and non-productive activities.

"Everyone would have equivalent hours worked so no 'unemployment' would ever need to exist."

So everybody is and wants the same thing?
 
This sounds like a good communists dream. It doesn't address the jobs issue, just the management issue and with robotics that will not be an issue.

Crazy - Instead of looking at why neither system works outside very small societies, so many of us seem to think that we should just keep trying them until they are forced to work!
 
Back
Top