New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About that second amendment.

No, Degs -- licensing has been determined not to be an infringement on a right -
Not true. A deniable license - particularly deniable for simple suspicion or operational capability - is very much an infringmenet. So for example, denying someone the right to build explosives in their apartment is based on the danger posed to their neighbors. OK then the same logic should apply to firearms. And yet the claim under heller and McDonald is that it is not.

No not really. Because they invoke no fact based analysis in defining what is dangerous That's their core weakness. Alito and Scalia make their claims up out of whole cloth.
They don't have to -- as has been pointed out, that determination goes back to Aymette.
sure they do. Becuase Aymette STILL REQUIRES A FACTUAL FINDING that a weapon IS NOT DANGEROUS.

Mortars/bombards
None of these had the power you claim for them, the power to level a city within a few hours. [/quote]
Sure they did. Not necessarily the largest and most defended cities but an undefended port built out of common material (like wood) would easily be destroyed in that manner.

That a "hardened target" (Copehagen, Baltimore) was not leveled does not tell us that a city like Portsmouth ME or Kennebunkport could not be so leveled (and in fact this happened on the St. Lawrence seaway)
 
basically I agree it goes back to Aymette, but I disagree that Aymette requires that ALL the tests be met or that there is any hierarchy. The relevant quote being.

The legislature, therefore, have a right to prohibit the wearing, or keeping weapons dangerous to the peace and safety of the citizens, and which are not usual in civilized warfare, or would not contribute to the common defence.

Note the grammar here. The use of an "or" with a preceding comma indicates it is an elided set of basis, not a hierarchical or contingent one. Thus ANY "weapons dangerous to the peace and safety of the citizens" is regulatable.

Grammar-schrammar, note the syntax . . .

The "or" is between two criteria that each, separately must be deemed inapplicable for the "dangerous" characterization to even begin to be considered. They are exceptions of the application of "dangerous to the peace and safety of the citizens". The weapon can not be considered "dangerous" if any one of those 'useful' criteria is met.

I didn't mean that the weapon must meet "ALL", just that each of those criteria are separate and all of them must be applied and either affirmed or rejected on their merits. If the type of arm meets any one of them then it can not be deemed 'dangerous and unusual' and the right to keep and bear that weapon must be preserved. As I said earlier, those criteria are an "and/or" set of tests:

Dangerous and unusual is not a stand alone criteria . . . It is what's left after the type of arm fails ALL the long-standing inclusion / protection tests.

They are, to refresh your memory:

  • In common use at the time and/or
  • are usually employed in civilized warfare and/or
  • that constitute the ordinary military equipment and/or
  • can be employed advantageously in the common defence of the citizens.

Failing ALL those tests, the arm could then be argued to be "dangerous and unusual" and the legislature could be said to possess the legitimate power to restrict that type of arm.. . .

Let's see if your reading can survive if we switch the passage up a bit:

The legislature, therefore, have a right to prohibit the speaking or writing of words dangerous to the peace and safety of the citizens, and which are not part of political discourse, or would not contribute to petitioning the government for redress.

The speech is first held to see if it is part of political discourse. If it meets that test the speech can not be deemed dangerous to peace and safety. Now, if the speech fails the political discourse test the petition test is applied; failing that, then and only then could the legislature empowering "dangerous to peace and safety of the citizens" characterization be applied.

Alito and Scalia basically make up out of whole gun fetishist cloth - the notion that handguns are not dangerous.

Handguns, being of the type of arm in common use and being usually employed in civilized warfare and being part of the ordinary military equipment and able to be employed advantageously in the common defence, extinguishes all opportunity for assigning them the LEGAL designation of "dangerous and unusual" by four orders of magnitude. One criteria being met would be enough but you are arguing against four protection criteria being met. That legal reality does not of course handicap you calling handguns "dangerous" but your emotional feeling has zero legal weight and does not impugn the opinions of Scalia and Alito no matter how forcefully you state it.

Now as to how to read the 2nd Amendment - Remember that States retained their incorporated rights at the time of ratification. And since Phillyand Boston both had gun control laws on the books at the time and afterwards, that were not challenged, and that militias stored their arms in common storage sheds, the notion that somehow there is a historic right to unfettered carriage of all manner of weapons in the public sphere is hardly based in a looking at it through "rights not granted".

The principle is either -rights not surrendered- or -powers not granted- and that certainly is the ONLY way to look at it. I have no clue why you think that holding up state laws and local regulations speaks to the federally protected right and honestly, I'm not interested in hearing your faulty reasoning for doing so.

And it is intellectually dishonest . . .

Trying to discern what the right to arms is and what it protects by dissecting and "interpreting" words that the right does not in any manner depend is what's intellectually dishonest. if you want to discover the exact nature and scope of the right of the people to keep and bear arms you should inspect the body of the Constitution for the express power granted to the federal government to dictate upon or impact the personal arms of the private citizen.

"[T]he right of the people to keep and bear arms is not a right granted by the Constitution. Neither is it in any manner dependent upon that instrument for its existence."

Presser v. Illinois, 116 U.S. 252 (1886)​

Please explain why you think it is Constitutionally legitimate and intellectually honest to completely disregard the clear and unambiguous determination of SCOTUS and invent dependencies, conditions, qualifications and restrictions on the right from words that can't create such limitations.
 
Notice the commas in use.... They distinguish separate CATEGORIES of arms that can be regulated, not an aggregate of requirements that ALL must be met.

They address the "type" of arm and those criteria distinguish types of arms that CAN NOT be regulated. My use of "all' is explained in the previous post

So what Scalia in Heller but more generally Alito in McDonald both did was to assert - WITHOUT EVIDENTIARY SUPPORT - that handguns are not "dangerous to the Peace and Safety of the Citizens". Well we know from almost all the non-cooked data, that this is not the case.

The process is not that the government gets to open the inspection and argue that a type of arm (i.e., handgun) is dangerous and then game over, it can be regulated . . . The process is that the criteria's for protection are applied to the type of arm and if the arm is of the type that meets any of the protection criteria then "dangerous and unusual" is finished, off the table. An arm meeting of any of the protection criteria and the arm being "dangerous" can not co-exist.

So what remains is for a jurisdiction to identify them to be dangerous arms (and the MD case wending its way up is somewhat predicated on that) and its done.

Perhaps in state court but once it gets into the federal sphere your fantasy goes poof!

There is no question that Heller and McDonald HAVE invalidated wide swaths of existing gun control But they have done so based on fetishized logic.

Heller and McDonald were reserved and very measured decisions that could have gone much further. Count your blessings.

BTW The Constitution grants to The Government "incorporated rights" as a principle

Do you just invent this crap as you go along?

You are basically arguing a gun fetishism view without any desire to actually invoke the basis why the 2nd Amendment was put in place in the first place

Yawn . . .
 
Back
Top