Gun free zones rely on gun owners respecting the policy. Just like the general public relies on gun owners not murdering people with their guns.
and as usual criminals don't give a flip
Gun free zones rely on gun owners respecting the policy. Just like the general public relies on gun owners not murdering people with their guns.
The alternatives being stricter gun control / registration. But you-kn0w-who strongly opposes that.
I have to disagree. If those that would choose to break laws already do so, how would adding another make them obey?The alternatives being stricter gun control / registration. But you-kn0w-who strongly opposes that.
Adding mandatory pat-downs to ticket checking in movie theaters would remove the risk of guns in movie theaters. /sarcasmI have to disagree. If those that would choose to break laws already do so, how would adding another make them obey?
For good reason.The alternatives being stricter gun control / registration. But you-kn0w-who strongly opposes that.
I beg to differ.The first doesn't make the second more likely; the two are not causally connected.
It is actually the only thing that will reduce deaths, once the shooting starts. This guy stopped shooting other people and shot himself, because the cops were coming at him.... in other words "adding guns/shooters" to the situation.Adding mandatory pat-downs to ticket checking in movie theaters would remove the risk of guns in movie theaters. /sarcasm
I wasn't advocating for stricter gun controls, necessarily. I was pointing out the idiocy associated with the comments saying "hey, it was a gun free zone, so obviously there were no guns there." I get that those posters were trying to point out that things such as gun free zones don't guarantee a zone is gun free. But the only thing that will guarantee gun free zones is removing guns period. I know they don't want that. They want more people armed so they can stop shooters (a la a movie hero). But adding guns/shooters in a dark theater is not, IMO, a recipe for reducing gun deaths.
It does happen from time to time, but the numbers of casualties are very low. A guy walked into a police station in LA a year or two ago and started shooting; he got shot down immediately. Out of all the mass shooters in the last twenty years or so, Loughner and Holmes were the only who didn't seem to target a "gun-free zone". (Well actually, Holmes did, but it wasn't a factor in his target selection according to his diary; it was just a coincidence in his case).I beg to differ.
"Crazed" gunmen infrequently take out their anger in police stations and forts. It's not as productive and is the truest display of insanity. More than one gunman has admitted attacking a target where he knew the occupants were unarmed. You are simply wrong.
And most abusers beat their spouse when they're pissed, not their boss. So?I beg to differ.
"Crazed" gunmen infrequently take out their anger in police stations and forts. It's not as productive and is the truest display of insanity. More than one gunman has admitted attacking a target where he knew the occupants were unarmed. You are simply wrong.
I disagree that adding bullets flying in a dark theater would be useful. I think it would only add to the casualty count. The cops would not have gone into a darkened theater and started shooting at the gun flashes.It is actually the only thing that will reduce deaths, once the shooting starts. This guy stopped shooting other people and shot himself, because the cops were coming at him.... in other words "adding guns/shooters" to the situation.![]()
And "death by cop."It does happen from time to time, but the numbers of casualties are very low. A guy walked into a police station in LA a year or two ago and started shooting; he got shot down immediately. Out of all the mass shooters in the last twenty years or so, Loughner and Holmes were the only who didn't seem to target a "gun-free zone". (Well actually, Holmes did, but it wasn't a factor in his target selection according to his diary; it was just a coincidence in his case).
You can't guarantee it. All you are doing is disarming the honest and the innocent by creating gun free zones..... You seem to be arguing there should be no gun free zones since we can't guarantee they are gun free. All I'm saying is that's not the only approach.
Read your two sentences again.
The first declares a "hope" that a rule will be followed.
The next declares a hope that someone not commit acts of senseless murder.
Why does the first intention make the second act more likely, and isn't that a flaw in the policy?
I'm not recommending any other approach, just pointing out that doing away with gun free zones is an approach, but not the only approach.You can't guarantee it. All you are doing is disarming the honest and the innocent by creating gun free zones.
What other approaches do you recommend?
There's some of the dumbest reasoning a person can witness here.I guess we should do away with stop signs...for the same reasons.....
So far the gun free zone approach has been a dismal failure.I'm not recommending any other approach, just pointing out that doing away with gun free zones is an approach, but not the only approach.
The first declares a "hope" that a rule will be followed.There's some of the dumbest reasoning a person can witness here.
A stop sign is not a suggestion, it is a law and if it's broken there are consequences. Your stopping at a stop sign does NOT make you more liable to be hurt by a person breaking the law. So abiding the stop sign is helpful if someone else runs the stop sign.
That is the exact opposite of a "gun-free zone". There, by following the "law" you're actually put into harm's way when someone else disobeys.
Pretty clear the vast difference there!
When Columbine happened, police were criticized for following procedure and waiting for a minimum number of officers before making entry, as it allowed the killers to continue unopposed for a significant amount of time. After much study, tactics were changed; with an active killer, (or a "Rapid Mass Murderer" seems to be the new term) the sooner they are confronted with force, the sooner the killing stops. Either they are stopped by the people who confront them or they suicide out like this guy did, but the killing of innocents ends.I disagree that adding bullets flying in a dark theater would be useful. I think it would only add to the casualty count. The cops would not have gone into a darkened theater and started shooting at the gun flashes.
Adding mandatory pat-downs to ticket checking in movie theaters would remove the risk of guns in movie theaters. /sarcasm
I wasn't advocating for stricter gun controls, necessarily. I was pointing out the idiocy associated with the comments saying "hey, it was a gun free zone, so obviously there were no guns there." I get that those posters were trying to point out that things such as gun free zones don't guarantee a zone is gun free. But the only thing that will guarantee gun free zones is removing guns period. I know they don't want that. They want more people armed so they can stop shooters (a la a movie hero). But adding guns/shooters in a dark theater is not, IMO, a recipe for reducing gun deaths.