New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Acupuncture

You are obviously unaware that there is a movement afoot to discredit pretty much any form of health care that does not involve expensive drugs and/or surgeries.


While placebo treatments are discouraged as unethical behavior on the part of medical doctors, these admonishments are largely ignored by practicing physicians. They understand that a placebo is often the best treatment option.
 
While placebo treatments are discouraged as unethical behavior on the part of medical doctors, these admonishments are largely ignored by practicing physicians. They understand that a placebo is often the best treatment option.

In cases where a person is given a placebo, and it seems to do the trick, they're simply examples of how powerful our belief system really is in controlling things in our body. For those folks who totally believe in the ability of practicing physicians to heal, that belief can cause a certain amount of healing if they are given a pill of some sort. Unfortunately that doesn't work for everybody since the body often needs some actual help in strengthening it's immune system.

Everybody is entitled to his beliefs. If it provides comfort to believe that the best solution to physical maladies is to swallow whatever drugs the medical profession prescribes without question, then fine. It's just a shame that their children are not taught to think for themselves and be willing to investigate further.
 
I have no qualm with the use of placebo treatments when they are effective. Whether such treatment takes the form of a an incantation, a sugar pill, ingesting water with magical molecular memory, or piercing the skin with pins and needles -- if it works, it works.
 
I have no qualm with the use of placebo treatments when they are effective. Whether such treatment takes the form of a an incantation, a sugar pill, ingesting water with magical molecular memory, or piercing the skin with pins and needles -- if it works, it works.

It isn't just piercing the skin with pins. It has the effect of a deep massage, it relaxes 'knots' within our bodies. Just piercing the skin ,that deeply, with pins is extremely dangerous and I would never ever go to an acupuncturist who had not been practicing for at least than 20 years.

They should never practice alone until they have had at the very least ten years practice under the supervision of an experienced practitioner.
 
Whatever... An experienced practitioner is still merely poking you with needles when all is said and done.


Mmmm so could be said of someone with an ice pick I guess.

Does massage work ? How does it work ? If one can dig deeper into the body would it at times work better ? It is the same and the better a practitioner understands the working of our bodies the better no ? They don't just take one pulse either ................ not like our lot who look at the body fragmented and never anymore as a the whole.
 
About a decade and a half ago, "Consumer Reports" conducted a rather extensive review and analysis of both acupuncture and chiropractic. Their ultimate conclusion was that there's no scientific basis whatsoever, for either, even as their surveys suggested that many were convinced that they "worked".

"Consumer Report's" conclusion was that even as there was no medical/physiological evidence in support of them, they're relatively harmless and if people think they make them feel better, they couldn't hurt (no pun).

In my opinion, the way they "work" is that they don't CAUSE healing, they OVERLAP healing. In other words, if we had two patients with the exact same condition and one went to his acupuncturist every week for the next 6, and the other followed his physician's instructions, both would heal. And, the former would be convinced that it was a result of the acupuncture.

Fair, the placebo effect has cured many ills. The "sugar pill" just triggers a part of the brain which controls the pain and makes it think it is cured. A mother's kiss has the same effect with a child who has an "oowe!" (BTW, a mother's spit is also an unparalleled cleanser.)

Pain is relative. For instance, if you are using a hammer and hit your thumb, you will drop the hammer, grab the thumb, hop around and coin a few new words while your thumb throbs and turns blue. Even as much as that thumb is hurting, if you will just place your finger on a solid surface and give if a hefty blow, you will forget about the thumb and concentrate solely on the finger. With one blow the pain has been transferred from the thumb to the finger.

Now, Fair, if you would like to test this hypothesis, I would be willing to wield the hammer if you would volunteer the use of your thumb!
 
Some 20 years ago, my general contractor friend would hire me for side jobs on the weekends. One Saturday, I was tasked with wielding one of those 16 oz. framing hammers with the waffle face. In short order, I mashed my thumb to a fair-thee-well. We bandaged up my thumb with gauze and duct tape and I got back to work. And...the very next swing of that hammer landed square on my previously mashed thumb!

It hurt the first time. It really hurt the second time.
 
Some 20 years ago, my general contractor friend would hire me for side jobs on the weekends. One Saturday, I was tasked with wielding one of those 16 oz. framing hammers with the waffle face. In short order, I mashed my thumb to a fair-thee-well. We bandaged up my thumb with gauze and duct tape and I got back to work. And...the very next swing of that hammer landed square on my previously mashed thumb!

It hurt the first time. It really hurt the second time.

Fair, since there was no third time I assume that you were a fast learner! I've had more than my share of bruised fingers and thumbs, but in the process have contributed greatly to Websters!"
 
I have not, Boldlady. But I have some fairly constant pain that might be able to benefit from something like that. Do keep us posted as to how it works for you if you don't mind.

While I have believed it to be a very useful tool in maintaining the balance needed for good health for much of my life, I had never tried it. That is until yesterday. I had my first session of it and it really is an interesting experience. It will take a bit of time to find out just how much good it will do for me, but I was surprised at how much effect it had on me already.

Has anybody else gone through a program of acupuncture for treatment of anything? I'm curious as to how well it has worked for whatever.
 
The source of my pain isn't stress (or problems, etc).......it's from misaligned bones(that can't be fixed), but when I am worried or stressed the pain is worse, so I know that what you are saying here is definitely true.

Yes, my Son did to relieve neck and back pain. It works,but does not solve the problem.

His Osteopathic Doctor gave him much more relief with the body being out of alignment. he swears by her.

After reading many books about pain,one thing keeps coming back.If you have emotional pain,worries,problems, stress, etc., the body will create a real pain.
 
Bolt---I have had experience with acupuncture AFTER trying many other medical methods.

My personal experience is very different from the majority of what has been posted here.
For me it worked very very well and was LONG TERM.

NERVE damage in my neck and arms causing excrutiating pain. No doctor could help. First trip to acupuncture got relief, enough so could sleep for the first time in days. After 3 Treatments I was "cured"....

Needless to say I have gone back to this guy for other ailments and 1 to 3 treatments anI am better with "permanent" effect.
 
Back
Top