New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

American beheaded

ISIS is a group that has proven to be more powerful, rich and supported than Al Qaeda. We declared war on Al Qaeda, and the same needs to be done with ISIS. Wipe them out. I don't care if the video is real or not (though it probably is)--ISIS is the personification of evil and should be destroyed whenever/wherever they show up.

Don't you ever stop to ask where all their money and power came from?
 
I certainly don't mean to excuse Saudi Arabia, and I think the US's complicity in its misconduct is a great national shame. But, all the same, there's a difference when it's a US national being beheaded, especially when his "crime" is just journalism.

It isn't different. A 14 year old girl being beheaded for resisting rape with our support is not different.

In one case we are the perpetrators and in the other we are the victims. It is the same and it is pure hypocricsy to be outraged over one and not outraged over our support for antoher.

I am not attacking you as a hypocrite, Im speaking in general.
 
It is not a question of seeing, it is a question of facts, evidence and reason. Unless you demand an angel show up at your bed side? Actually… perhaps you can suggest to me what would constitute “evidence of the supernatural” for you? Can you provide some examples or possible accounts? - - - - - - Here is what makes it so difficult for me. If, for example, the plaster statue of the Virgin Mary sitting on your night stand started weeping tears of blood right before your very eyes --- you would not take that as a message from God or at least a supernatural matter. No, you, like so many others, would retort “we cannot say what the origins of this blood is or what transpired causing this statue to produce such lacrimations, but it is not evidence for the supernatural --- we simply have not yet discovered the natural explanation for it.” And then you would carry on with your mundane existence thinking there is nothing there for you to consider.

Well it would change for 100,00 or more who will be murdered and for the one million or more turned into refugees. And ISIS is clear they are not stopping in Iraq, make no mistake. And destroying ISIS is a major goodwill move on the USA’s part. We will have curried great favor with all of the Arab nations, with Iran, with Europe, etc. But Obama is too dense to figure that out, even if it were only for policital gain.

In January 2003, prior to the invasion of Iraq, the CIA repeatedly warned the Bush administration that the invasion would increase political Islam. The report, “widely disseminated throughout the Bush administration,” said the invasion “wouldbe likely to spark violent sectarian divides and provide al-Qaeda with new opportunities in Iraq” and that it would “probably would result in a surge of political Islam and increased funding for terrorist groups” in the Muslim world. The report continued that there was “a significant chance that domestic groups would engage in violent conflict with each other unless an occupying force prevented them from doing so.” The high level assessment warned that competing sectarian groups(Sunnis, Shiites, and Kurds) would “encourage terrorist groups to take advantage of a volatile security environment to launch attacks within Iraq.” The lines between Al Qaeda and other terrorist groups “could be blurred” fostering a new generation of terrorists and increase in their funding due to “Muslim outrage over US actions.”(1)

Yet another report said that the invasion “would increase sympathy across the Islamic world for some terrorist objectives” and that former Sunnis from the bath party could “work with existing terrorist groups” to wage “guerilla warfare.”(2)

According to another study, before the war in Iraq Al-Qaeda “was on the ropes” and even engaged in a sort of civil-Jihadist war. Jihadi groups were angered at Bin Laden for attacking the US so rashly. Careful police work had“was steadily shutting down jihadist cells from Morocco to Malaysia.”

But the Iraq war “breathed new life” into both Al-Qaeda and other terrorists organizations, spawning new generations of Jihadists and more decentralized groups. Each day the US was in Iraq was a “boon” for the “broader Jihadist movement.”

The invasion saw huge swaths of foreign jihadists coming to Iraq. The Iraqi invasion had become “the ‘cause celebre’ for jihadists, breeding a deep resentment of US involvement in the Muslim world and cultivating supporters for the global jihadist movement.” As the research stated a lasting effect of the invasion was “the growth of a domestic jihadist movement in Iraq, where none existed before.” These jihadists have “transformed anti – US resistance” and is “concentrated in the Sunni Arab parts of Iraq.” (3)

Perhaps most importantly, “ISIS emerged as al-Qaeda splinter group operating in the wake of the invasion, a fringe, lethal faction within a larger Sunni insurgency. “(4)

George W Bush asked the question “Why do they hate us?” His response was of course they hate our freedoms. But while he was making these statements the defense science task force(at GWB’s urging) produced a report studying in detail the causes of terrorism. The report reads that the Muslim world sees the “US as a long standing ally and prop of the corrupt dictators in the region” that block development. That when we talk of democracy it is little more than “self-serving” propaganda. The report adamantly denied that we are “at war against Islam” but rather stated we are at war against “the tactic of terrorism.” The report concludes that all terrorists share the main goal of “overthrowing the tyrannies of Egypt,Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Jordan, and the Gulf

States” who are the main target of the “broader Islamist movement.” The US finds itself in dangerous situation of “being an alliance partner of these authoritarian regimes.” The US has taken their side, over the people, the report notes, and “without the US these regimes could not survive.” But the report suggests better propaganda, rather than a change in policy, because “regimes based on consent may oppose US polices” and interests. Polices should be made based off of our “interests” and not “public opinion.” (5)

But the risks of terrorism have nothing to do with our policy in the Middle East. Instead, it is as the US government has stated in internal record for over 6 decades. That the US regards Middle East oil as a “Strategic lever” over world affairs. As the head of Tony Blair’s foreign intelligent service said, “the facts are being fixed around the policy,” referring to the manipulating of evidence to justify war against Iraq. If strategic interests favor supporting Sadaam with chemical weapons, then so be it. If it favors supporting Saudi Arabia while it beheads 14 year old girls resisting 70 year old men raping them, so be it. If it favors supporting SISI while he murders thousands then so be it. We are quite willing to incur the risks of terror so that huge American companies can make profit. Period.

As for Obama, his supposed stand against the Iraq war is utter rubbish. His stand was based off of his thoughts that it “was a strategic blunder,” not a war crime. Thus his stand is totally unprincipled and never once when citing his reasons against the war did he mention Iraqi civilian casualties, some of which are suffering worse effects than Hiroshima as a result of US made uranium tipped tank shells. Incidentally, the rest of the world has agreed to ban them, except the US, a stand-alone determination reiterated by Obama. Obama, who praised Mubarak in 2009, has continued this policy of supporting monsters to the benefit of our rich companies and to the detriment of the American people. During the Arab spring he supported Saudi Arabia crushing peaceful college kids in Bahrain and in the Saudi Homeland itself. In Egypt, he held out support to the very end until Mubarak’s hold on [power was unsustainable. Now reports are coming out that the Morsi regime was destabilized by the CIA and the SISI coup was orchestrated by Washington’s whose deep ties to the Egyptian military(who rob the country of their wealth) are well known.

Ending terrorism will require a broad reform of our bi-partisan polices. But more importantly, to end terror, we must stop exporting our special brand of it, which is murderous, tyrannical and genocidal in character.


1.http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/05/25/AR2007052501380.html

2.http://www.nytimes.com/2004/09/28/politics/28intel.html

3.http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/2007/07/iraqterrorism

4.http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs...aqs-crisis-dont-forget-the-2003-u-s-invasion/

5.September, 2004. Department of Defense: Defense Science Task Report On Terrorism
 
It is not a question of seeing, it is a question of facts, evidence and reason. Unless you demand an angel show up at your bed side? Actually… perhaps you can suggest to me what would constitute “evidence of the supernatural” for you? Can you provide some examples or possible accounts? - - - - - - Here is what makes it so difficult for me. If, for example, the plaster statue of the Virgin Mary sitting on your night stand started weeping tears of blood right before your very eyes --- you would not take that as a message from God or at least a supernatural matter. No, you, like so many others, would retort “we cannot say what the origins of this blood is or what transpired causing this statue to produce such lacrimations, but it is not evidence for the supernatural --- we simply have not yet discovered the natural explanation for it.” And then you would carry on with your mundane existence thinking there is nothing there for you to consider.

Well it would change for 100,00 or more who will be murdered and for the one million or more turned into refugees. And ISIS is clear they are not stopping in Iraq, make no mistake. And destroying ISIS is a major goodwill move on the USA’s part. We will have curried great favor with all of the Arab nations, with Iran, with Europe, etc. But Obama is too dense to figure that out, even if it were only for policital gain.

Read my other reply.

I don’t know if there is a god. I don’t know why if there is one he created dinosaurs first only to destroy them 65 million years before us. I do know if there is a god, he or she or whatever, has nothing to do with any organized religion. The human race has been around quite some time and the best evidence you have is that there was moisture on a statue?

What I do know is no matter how the earth was created, we as humans now have the ability to destroy it. Weird to me.


As for your statement on ISIS is rests on the assumption that the United States cares about people in the middle east, which it doesn’t . The you show no outrage over our support of Saudi Arabia who beheads young girls for resisting rate or people for being “Apostates.” With our support. Thus, you are a hypocrite. You view this as some sort of holy war and you are essentially calling for a jihad against those you deem infidels. You are no different.


US policy in the region has been to support dictators over people be cause as the pentagon says polices “based on consent might not be in our strategic interests.”(DSTB, 2004)

The CIA told Bush, explicitly, that an invasion of Iraq would spawn a new generation of terrorists, would increase the danger to Americans and would increase “political Islam.” ISIS is a group that came out of the insurgency in Iraq.

You are a nice person, it seems. But you insist on just spinning things out of your head.

Come on dude, you impose ignorance on yourself.
 
perhaps you can suggest to me what would constitute “evidence of the supernatural” for you?

If there were evidence, it wouldn't be "supernatural" -- it would just be something natural we didn't yet understand. To borrow from Carl Sagan, it's easy to imagine a creator being having placed into the laws of the universe discoverable messages making it clear that the universe was designed. This could take the form, for example, of a decipherable code somewhere within the infinite, non-repeating digits of pi. Or, to take a less subtle example, it could be a constellation that, when viewed from Earth, created a perfect map of the continents of Earth -- something a sufficiently powerful and intelligent creator-being could cause to come into existence, but which would be infinitely improbable to have occurred by chance, and impossible to accomplish through natural means that were even close to our current understanding (since they would require coordinating activities across vast distances at faster than the speed of light, and the ability to move whole star systems or even galaxies around). There are any number of real-world phenomenon that could convince me that there was a "god," in the sense of some sort of intelligence and power vastly beyond the human, which either created the universe, or at least has the ability to manipulate it on a scale so far beyond ours as to seem completely miraculous. I just haven't seen any such phenomena. Have you?

“we cannot say what the origins of this blood is or what transpired causing this statue to produce such lacrimations, but it is not evidence for the supernatural --- we simply have not yet discovered the natural explanation for it.” And then you would carry on with your mundane existence thinking there is nothing there for you to consider.

I would, in fact, assume there was some natural explanation. You'd, presumably, do the same if the "miracle" didn't fit in with the dogma you were taught from youth. For example, what if, during next year's Haj, there are a huge number of seemingly miraculous spontaneous cancer remissions among Muslim pilgrims who prayed to Allah at the Kaba? Someone raised Muslim would take this to be a genuine miracle, proving that his was the one true faith. The rest of us, even if convinced by reliable evidence that it had actually happened, and that the numbers were too great to be coincidence, would assume something natural had happened... just something we didn't yet understand. For example, maybe there was a previously undetected retrovirus that spread among the pilgrims, which had mutated in such a way that it attacked and killed cancer cells.

In that case, hopefully we would be wise enough not to think "there is nothing there for us to consider." That kind of event, so far outside of normal experience, would be a crucial thing for us to consider. If we could identify that retrovirus, or whatever other unknown means were at work, we could harness the mechanism to save countless lives from the ravages of cancer. But, there's a big difference between assuming there's something vitally important happening, and assuming that because we don't yet understand what happened, it must be supernatural.

And destroying ISIS is a major goodwill move on the USA’s part.

The warmongers told us the same about taking down the Hussein regime. We saw how that turned out. Hussein may have been wildly unpopular in the region, and people from Tehran to Riyadh may have been eager for his downfall, but that didn't change the fact that US approval ratings around the world went in the crapper when we invaded Iraq. In the same way, the mere fact people hate and fear ISIS doesn't mean that bombing Iraq to try to kill some of them is going to win us friends.

Besides, if ISIS is so unpopular that US intervention would be greeted that positively, shouldn't it be unpopular enough that countries in that region can take it out without our help? They know the dynamics of the culture far better than we do, and are less likely to make a mess of it. Better to have it be on their dime, with them becoming targets if things don't go well. We've fumbled around in the Middle East for long enough. Let someone else take a turn.
 

One innocent Yankee was beheaded; but what is worse;
12 innocent people blasted to pieces by US drone and another 15 wounded/maimed.

I think we are going to see far more of these illegal US government attacks..


All life is precious not only American life.


A Wedding That Became a Funeral

US Drone Attack on Marriage Procession in Yemen

February 20, 2014
This 28-page report calls on the US government to investigate the strike, publish its findings, and act in the event of wrongdoing. The December 12 attack killed 12 men and wounded at least 15 other people, including the bride. US and Yemeni officials said the dead were members of the armed group Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP), but witnesses and relatives told Human Rights Watch the casualties were civilians. Obama said in a major address in May that US policy requires “near-certainty” that no civilians will be harmed in targeted attacks.
 
One innocent Yankee was beheaded; but what is worse;
12 innocent people blasted to pieces by US drone and another 15 wounded/maimed.

I think we are going to see far more of these illegal US government attacks..


All life is precious not only American life.


A Wedding That Became a Funeral

US Drone Attack on Marriage Procession in Yemen

February 20, 2014
This 28-page report calls on the US government to investigate the strike, publish its findings, and act in the event of wrongdoing. The December 12 attack killed 12 men and wounded at least 15 other people, including the bride. US and Yemeni officials said the dead were members of the armed group Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP), but witnesses and relatives told Human Rights Watch the casualties were civilians. Obama said in a major address in May that US policy requires “near-certainty” that no civilians will be harmed in targeted attacks.

20-30 million killed by US bombs since WWII - and counting - but who is counting? Not Americans.

If it happened which is doubtful - an American journalist by choice was , in a dangerous area of the World, and was murdered by an Englishman - should we be expecting a US carpeting bombing feast here do you suppose? By the USs' usual logic it really wouldn't surprise me if Birmingham was on their list -
 
You're "technically" not a hooker?

Okey dokey.

;-)

Nope I am not - Why these silly girls think throwing in my face something I have never tried to hide nor feel shame for should be upsetting, is beyond me, but they really should at least use the correct word(s) - slang or otherwise -

Nor am I either actually or technically an Anti Semite

Nor am I infatuated, actually or technically, with any Historical character

And I think she was wrong on count 4 but forget now what it was -


okey dokey ? :)
 
Read my other reply.

I don’t know if there is a god. I don’t know why if there is one he created dinosaurs first only to destroy them 65 million years before us. I do know if there is a god, he or she or whatever, has nothing to do with any organized religion. The human race has been around quite some time and the best evidence you have is that there was moisture on a statue?

What I do know is no matter how the earth was created, we as humans now have the ability to destroy it. Weird to me.


As for your statement on ISIS is rests on the assumption that the United States cares about people in the middle east, which it doesn’t . The you show no outrage over our support of Saudi Arabia who beheads young girls for resisting rate or people for being “Apostates.” With our support. Thus, you are a hypocrite. You view this as some sort of holy war and you are essentially calling for a jihad against those you deem infidels. You are no different.


US policy in the region has been to support dictators over people be cause as the pentagon says polices “based on consent might not be in our strategic interests.”(DSTB, 2004)

The CIA told Bush, explicitly, that an invasion of Iraq would spawn a new generation of terrorists, would increase the danger to Americans and would increase “political Islam.” ISIS is a group that came out of the insurgency in Iraq.

You are a nice person, it seems. But you insist on just spinning things out of your head.

Come on dude, you impose ignorance on yourself.

Once again, I have not much zeal to say much about anything.

I do not doubt our American presence in the affairs of Middle East conflicts draws up greater ire, even recruits, to the cause against us infidels and the Jews. But I do doubt it would still not be what it always has been, i.e. an enemy of the one true God. Consequently, I do not place much blame on America for all of the hatred and death. What did the Jews really do to interrupt these Muslims way of life? Yet they are set on destroying them utterly.

You do not have much interest in knowing who God really is and what teaching He has given us. Or so it appears to me. I doubt I can make an impression on you.

War is the result of man's sins, simple as that.

As far as our close ties with Saudi Arabia, well, war makes strange bed fellows. That has been demonstrated countless times. Russia in WW2 comes to mind. The Saudi princes may fund fundamental crazies and their madrasses, but it is only so they do not get attacked and dethroned themselves. They probably wish they would disappear as much as we do. They have their hands tied, sort of.

I doubt what you report is common that much at all, i.e. 14 year old girls beheaded for refusing the advances of old men. I do think those accounts would become world news. Just like when some demon throws acid in the face of a girl who refused his advances.

But the U.S. is in the business of preservation of its own. And we do need their oil and we do need to remain partners with evil regimes. Evil, but nothing compared to the demonic zealots like ISIS. It's a complicated world and our own greed or sin makes matters worse for us, that I agree.
 
Nope I am not - Why these silly girls think throwing in my face something I have never tried to hide nor feel shame for should be upsetting, is beyond me, but they really should at least use the correct word(s) - slang or otherwise -

Nor am I either actually or technically an Anti Semite

Nor am I infatuated, actually or technically, with any Historical character

And I think she was wrong on count 4 but forget now what it was -


okey dokey ? :)

How is it that you are "technically" not a hooker?

Did you get paid with counterfeit money?

;-)
 
If there were evidence, it wouldn't be "supernatural" -- it would just be something natural we didn't yet understand. To borrow from Carl Sagan, it's easy to imagine a creator being having placed into the laws of the universe discoverable messages making it clear that the universe was designed. This could take the form, for example, of a decipherable code somewhere within the infinite, non-repeating digits of pi. Or, to take a less subtle example, it could be a constellation that, when viewed from Earth, created a perfect map of the continents of Earth -- something a sufficiently powerful and intelligent creator-being could cause to come into existence, but which would be infinitely improbable to have occurred by chance, and impossible to accomplish through natural means that were even close to our current understanding (since they would require coordinating activities across vast distances at faster than the speed of light, and the ability to move whole star systems or even galaxies around). There are any number of real-world phenomenon that could convince me that there was a "god," in the sense of some sort of intelligence and power vastly beyond the human, which either created the universe, or at least has the ability to manipulate it on a scale so far beyond ours as to seem completely miraculous. I just haven't seen any such phenomena. Have you?



I would, in fact, assume there was some natural explanation. You'd, presumably, do the same if the "miracle" didn't fit in with the dogma you were taught from youth. For example, what if, during next year's Haj, there are a huge number of seemingly miraculous spontaneous cancer remissions among Muslim pilgrims who prayed to Allah at the Kaba? Someone raised Muslim would take this to be a genuine miracle, proving that his was the one true faith. The rest of us, even if convinced by reliable evidence that it had actually happened, and that the numbers were too great to be coincidence, would assume something natural had happened... just something we didn't yet understand. For example, maybe there was a previously undetected retrovirus that spread among the pilgrims, which had mutated in such a way that it attacked and killed cancer cells.

In that case, hopefully we would be wise enough not to think "there is nothing there for us to consider." That kind of event, so far outside of normal experience, would be a crucial thing for us to consider. If we could identify that retrovirus, or whatever other unknown means were at work, we could harness the mechanism to save countless lives from the ravages of cancer. But, there's a big difference between assuming there's something vitally important happening, and assuming that because we don't yet understand what happened, it must be supernatural.



The warmongers told us the same about taking down the Hussein regime. We saw how that turned out. Hussein may have been wildly unpopular in the region, and people from Tehran to Riyadh may have been eager for his downfall, but that didn't change the fact that US approval ratings around the world went in the crapper when we invaded Iraq. In the same way, the mere fact people hate and fear ISIS doesn't mean that bombing Iraq to try to kill some of them is going to win us friends.

Besides, if ISIS is so unpopular that US intervention would be greeted that positively, shouldn't it be unpopular enough that countries in that region can take it out without our help? They know the dynamics of the culture far better than we do, and are less likely to make a mess of it. Better to have it be on their dime, with them becoming targets if things don't go well. We've fumbled around in the Middle East for long enough. Let someone else take a turn.

If there were evidence, it wouldn't be "supernatural" -- it would just be something natural we didn't yet understand.

Well that’s a shock to me. I guess Jesus did not perform enough miracles for you, but it certainly was enough for the apostles and other martyrs to go gladly to their deaths.

Fatima will convict any honest man of the truth. Those who try to spin that into folly are spinning their own demise.

The life of Joan of Arc is recorded in thousands of pages in French courts and the testimonies of even her enemies bear witness to the reality of Jesus Christ as God.

But I am totally lazy tonight. Maybe another day.


I would, in fact, assume there was some natural explanation. You'd, presumably, do the same if the "miracle" didn't fit in with the dogma you were taught from youth. For example, what if, during next year's Haj, there are a huge number of seemingly miraculous spontaneous cancer remissions among Muslim pilgrims who prayed to Allah at the Kaba? Someone raised Muslim would take this to be a genuine miracle, proving that his was the one true faith.

I would not doubt the miracle. I might doubt its source. Miracles alone are hardly what the Catholic Church has to share for its veracity and claim to the truth. The historical record, the testimonies of its glorious saints, it unparalleled charity to the world, its civilizing a barbaric world, and all of the myriad of reason and connection between all its claims are other evidence for its God. Sorry, I am not in the mood.


Besides, if ISIS is so unpopular that US intervention would be greeted that positively, shouldn't it be unpopular enough that countries in that region can take it out without our help? They know the dynamics of the culture far better than we do, and are less likely to make a mess of it. Better to have it be on their dime, with them becoming targets if things don't go well. We've fumbled around in the Middle East for long enough. Let someone else take a turn.

What Middle East country is going to take out ISIS? Iran? Why? So they become a convenient target? Arabs don’t like the Persians? Saudi Arabia? The saud princes are already living in fear with their own zealots in their country. They are too close to the action. I think they are all waiting and hoping the USA steps in, and will wait a good while before forced to take their own risks. I still maintain destroying ISIS is a win-win situation for the USA.
 
I guess Jesus did not perform enough miracles for you, but it certainly was enough for the apostles and other martyrs to go gladly to their deaths.

There are "martyrs" who go to their deaths all the time from all sorts of religions. There were ghost-shirt cultists who were fully convinced they were immune to bullets until the moment they were gunned down. People believe what they want to leave. But none of them had any evidence, just as you and I have absolutely no evidence that Jesus ever performed any miracle.

Fatima will convict any honest man of the truth. Those who try to spin that into folly are spinning their own demise.
True. But you are not an honest man, so you have not yet been convinced of the truth that it is a hoax.

The life of Joan of Arc is recorded in thousands of pages in French courts and the testimonies of even her enemies bear witness to the reality of Jesus Christ as God.
In precisely the same way, there are great histories written of Islamic martyrs, in the sick struggles between Shiites and Sunnis, and both of those sides are fully convinced that Muhamed is the true prophet, and Allah is God. That doesn't make it so. In the same way, the belief of Various flavors of Christians that Jesus Christ is God, even as they burned each other to death, doesn't make it true.

its civilizing a barbaric world, and all of the myriad of reason and connection between all its claims are other evidence for its God.

It took the civilized Roman world an drove it into a thousand years of barbarism. Fortunately, its Popes were so patently evil and comically corrupt, that eventually almost everybody realized it, and Schism tore the church apart, weakening it to the point that the Renaissance and finally the enlightenment could come along and end the darkness.

What Middle East country is going to take out ISIS?

Possibly none. It depends on how much they really dislike it -- enough to put their own money and citizens on the line, or just enough to try to goad stupid Americans into doing the hard work for them?
 
Once again, I have not much zeal to say much about anything.

I do not doubt our American presence in the affairs of Middle East conflicts draws up greater ire, even recruits, to the cause against us infidels and the Jews. But I do doubt it would still not be what it always has been, i.e. an enemy of the one true God. Consequently, I do not place much blame on America for all of the hatred and death. What did the Jews really do to interrupt these Muslims way of life? Yet they are set on destroying them utterly.

You do not have much interest in knowing who God really is and what teaching He has given us. Or so it appears to me. I doubt I can make an impression on you.

War is the result of man's sins, simple as that.

As far as our close ties with Saudi Arabia, well, war makes strange bed fellows. That has been demonstrated countless times. Russia in WW2 comes to mind. The Saudi princes may fund fundamental crazies and their madrasses, but it is only so they do not get attacked and dethroned themselves. They probably wish they would disappear as much as we do. They have their hands tied, sort of.

I doubt what you report is common that much at all, i.e. 14 year old girls beheaded for refusing the advances of old men. I do think those accounts would become world news. Just like when some demon throws acid in the face of a girl who refused his advances.

But the U.S. is in the business of preservation of its own. And we do need their oil and we do need to remain partners with evil regimes. Evil, but nothing compared to the demonic zealots like ISIS. It's a complicated world and our own greed or sin makes matters worse for us, that I agree.

The us has been allied with Saudi Arabia for 6 decades, we'll before any terrorist war with them. Further there are hundreds of countries around the world who don't give them weapons and survive just fine.

The logic is you used that even though supporting terror causes people to hate us we must support terror to fight people who hates us is a joke and you know it. As for the 14 year old girl she was from Nepal and beheaded for rape. Check it and see. Last year 78 people were beheaded this year so far 35. Saudi Arabia is ISIS only they are in power.

If you read what our leaders say it is quite clear they are not fighting terror but they are protecting profiys. So hussein, one of the worst monsters ever, was getting chemical and biological weapons from us because of "our duty to support us exporters" according to George bush.

The us is producing a shot load of oil right now and in no way needs the saudi. According the cia Al Qaida was close to being defeated, mainly by careful police work, before the iraqi invasion. They told gwb if he invaded it would be a savior for Al Qaida and spread it. Isis is a splinter group developed from the insurfency. But fighting terror is not the issue or goal.

Your refusal to cite facts refutes you before you right.

As for your religious words, when you speak of infidels you are no better than extremist muslims. You bringing up Jews is pointless and absurd as it has nothing to do with thus. You know nothing of God or jesus. You don't think on your own.

But yea I'm sure jesus would be an advocate of us supporting beheading monsters for no reason cause we profit of oil.

Read, study, learn. You contradict the leaders you apologize for. In the interim learn religious tolerance.

Religion is santana Claus for adults. God is an inquiry in your own mind that means something different to everyone. You have no right to impose your baseless view of it on anyone. Just like Islam us extremists dont.
 
If there were evidence, it wouldn't be "supernatural" -- it would just be something natural we didn't yet understand.

Well that’s a shock to me. I guess Jesus did not perform enough miracles for you, but it certainly was enough for the apostles and other martyrs to go gladly to their deaths.

Fatima will convict any honest man of the truth. Those who try to spin that into folly are spinning their own demise.

The life of Joan of Arc is recorded in thousands of pages in French courts and the testimonies of even her enemies bear witness to the reality of Jesus Christ as God.

But I am totally lazy tonight. Maybe another day.


I would, in fact, assume there was some natural explanation. You'd, presumably, do the same if the "miracle" didn't fit in with the dogma you were taught from youth. For example, what if, during next year's Haj, there are a huge number of seemingly miraculous spontaneous cancer remissions among Muslim pilgrims who prayed to Allah at the Kaba? Someone raised Muslim would take this to be a genuine miracle, proving that his was the one true faith.

I would not doubt the miracle. I might doubt its source. Miracles alone are hardly what the Catholic Church has to share for its veracity and claim to the truth. The historical record, the testimonies of its glorious saints, it unparalleled charity to the world, its civilizing a barbaric world, and all of the myriad of reason and connection between all its claims are other evidence for its God. Sorry, I am not in the mood.


Besides, if ISIS is so unpopular that US intervention would be greeted that positively, shouldn't it be unpopular enough that countries in that region can take it out without our help? They know the dynamics of the culture far better than we do, and are less likely to make a mess of it. Better to have it be on their dime, with them becoming targets if things don't go well. We've fumbled around in the Middle East for long enough. Let someone else take a turn.

What Middle East country is going to take out ISIS? Iran? Why? So they become a convenient target? Arabs don’t like the Persians? Saudi Arabia? The saud princes are already living in fear with their own zealots in their country. They are too close to the action. I think they are all waiting and hoping the USA steps in, and will wait a good while before forced to take their own risks. I still maintain destroying ISIS is a win-win situation for the USA.
You destroy Isis you'll simply create a whole cauldron of new enemies as Iraq created isis.

You think America owns the world yet it does nit. Again you don't criticize isis on moral grounds since you are ok with the us supporting religious nut murderers in Saudi Arabia who are just as bad. The hypocrisy, defined on the gospels by jesus, fits you perfectly.
 
You destroy Isis you'll simply create a whole cauldron of new enemies as Iraq created isis.

You think America owns the world yet it does nit. Again you don't criticize isis on moral grounds since you are ok with the us supporting religious nut murderers in Saudi Arabia who are just as bad. The hypocrisy, defined on the gospels by jesus, fits you perfectly.
When Bush first started the process of stampeding the stupid and fearful people in this country into backing an invasion of Iraq, my opposition focused partly on the idea that even though Hussein was evil, and even though we certainly could take out his regime quickly, there was no guarantee that what came after him would be any better. I specifically remember analogizing the aftermath to Afghanistan -- which, after all, was similarly the aftermath of heavy-handed superpower intervention in a region they didn't understand. I could picture Iraq, like Afghanistan, descending into civil war, where warlords fought theocrats. I could see it becoming a place where terrorists found fertile grounds for recruitment, and a chaotic situation in which to set up bases and plan attacks. What actually played out isn't that different from what I predicted. Iraq did, in fact, descend into civil war. There are, in fact, warlords and theocrats fighting each other, and the country has, in fact, been made more hospitable to terrorists.

In Iraq we took a bad situation and made it worse. We took a nasty Stalinist dictatorship that was at least stable and deterrable, and we transformed it into something like the country that gave us 9/11. And we did so at the cost of thousands of American lives, a massive drop in US approval ratings globally, a three trillion dollar bill for the taxpayer, and a radicalization of Iraq's neighbors.

Unfortunately, we Americans are very slow learners. People point to the evil of Isis, the same way they did to the evil of Hussein, and act like it's assured that US military intervention will make the situation better. It could, in fact, make it worse. It could, for example, give ISIS the ability to pose as the brave Islamic martyrs standing up against the unpopular Western bully, and that could give them more ability to recruit outside of Iraq, spreading their power. Or, if we take ISIS down, the resulting power vacuum could simply leave room for some group that's equally vicious, but more competent.

When you look at successful use of military power in limited interventions abroad, they just don't tend to look like what we're contemplating in Iraq. Where such limited interventions work is where the side we're backing has strong public support, and a large, dedicated force on the ground, which is merely having trouble because the other side has some equipment advantages -- such as in Bosnia and Kosovo, where the side we backed was having trouble simply because they couldn't compete with the air power and tanks of the other side. In that kind of situation, a limited campaign of air strikes, to take those pieces off the table, can reasonably be expected to swing the conflict in the direction we want it to go. That doesn't necessarily mean such interventions are morally right, but there's at least a clearer path between our proposed action and the ultimate goal we're looking to bring about. Iraq seems more like a situation where we'd be looking to tilt things simply by killing a lot of the right people, similar to Vietnam. It could, conceivably work, but it could also backfire horribly.
 
The US
When Bush first started the process of stampeding the stupid and fearful people in this country into backing an invasion of Iraq, my opposition focused partly on the idea that even though Hussein was evil, and even though we certainly could take out his regime quickly, there was no guarantee that what came after him would be any better. I specifically remember analogizing the aftermath to Afghanistan -- which, after all, was similarly the aftermath of heavy-handed superpower intervention in a region they didn't understand. I could picture Iraq, like Afghanistan, descending into civil war, where warlords fought theocrats. I could see it becoming a place where terrorists found fertile grounds for recruitment, and a chaotic situation in which to set up bases and plan attacks. What actually played out isn't that different from what I predicted. Iraq did, in fact, descend into civil war. There are, in fact, warlords and theocrats fighting each other, and the country has, in fact, been made more hospitable to terrorists.

In Iraq we took a bad situation and made it worse. We took a nasty Stalinist dictatorship that was at least stable and deterrable, and we transformed it into something like the country that gave us 9/11. And we did so at the cost of thousands of American lives, a massive drop in US approval ratings globally, a three trillion dollar bill for the taxpayer, and a radicalization of Iraq's neighbors.

Unfortunately, we Americans are very slow learners. People point to the evil of Isis, the same way they did to the evil of Hussein, and act like it's assured that US military intervention will make the situation better. It could, in fact, make it worse. It could, for example, give ISIS the ability to pose as the brave Islamic martyrs standing up against the unpopular Western bully, and that could give them more ability to recruit outside of Iraq, spreading their power. Or, if we take ISIS down, the resulting power vacuum could simply leave room for some group that's equally vicious, but more competent.

When you look at successful use of military power in limited interventions abroad, they just don't tend to look like what we're contemplating in Iraq. Where such limited interventions work is where the side we're backing has strong public support, and a large, dedicated force on the ground, which is merely having trouble because the other side has some equipment advantages -- such as in Bosnia and Kosovo, where the side we backed was having trouble simply because they couldn't compete with the air power and tanks of the other side. In that kind of situation, a limited campaign of air strikes, to take those pieces off the table, can reasonably be expected to swing the conflict in the direction we want it to go. That doesn't necessarily mean such interventions are morally right, but there's at least a clearer path between our proposed action and the ultimate goal we're looking to bring about. Iraq seems more like a situation where we'd be looking to tilt things simply by killing a lot of the right people, similar to Vietnam. It could, conceivably work, but it could also backfire horribly.


Yes, and more importantly. The idea we would do it to do the right thing is simply not a sustainable position. US policy simply doesn't flow on that basis.
 
Back
Top