ISIS is a group that has proven to be more powerful, rich and supported than Al Qaeda. We declared war on Al Qaeda, and the same needs to be done with ISIS. Wipe them out. I don't care if the video is real or not (though it probably is)--ISIS is the personification of evil and should be destroyed whenever/wherever they show up.
There is ALWAYS some new "personification of evil" that people will say compels us to wage war. Before ISIS, it was Khadafi's regime, and before that the Taliban and Hussein and Al Qaeda, and before that Karadžić, Mladić, Milosovic, etc., and before that Aidid, Noriega, Ho Chi Minh, and on and on. There's no doubt about the evil of ISIS or these others. The doubt is about the ability of the US to work a positive change on the world by dropping bombs on people or invading countries.
I don't deny that sometimes war is necessary. During WWII, for example, we were facing an alliance of openly expansionist superpowers that were attacking our closest allies, and which then attacked us. We didn't really have the option of staying out of it. And I don't deny that sometimes even when it's not necessary, our intervention can end up having a positive impact -- as in Kosovo and Bosnia, where national security didn't compel intervention, but things probably turned out better because we intervened. But those rare successes are the exception, not the rule, and we'd be wise to remember all those times our military force did no good or even made things worse.
I think a useful way of thinking about war is not in terms of "surgical strikes" and other false analogies to modern medicine, with all its precision, relative predictability, and sterile conditions. Instead, think of it like field surgery during the Civil War era: a brutal ordeal with dirty hacksaws, no anesthesia, and little medical understanding. Such surgery is, sometimes, better than doing nothing: a soldier with a gangrenous limb is probably better off submitting to the fumbling, filthy hands of a Civil War sawbones than just hoping it gets better on its own. But if there seem to be
any other non-fatal options, better to rely on them, instead. When it comes to ISIS, we have other options. We have the option of standing aside and letting their own countrymen deal with them. That isn't a great option, but there's little reason to think raining death on the country is going to be any better, and it could actually be worse.