New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Another Electoral College Thread

Mr. Friscus

Governor
One of my threads recently drifted towards the prominent issue of the electoral college (which I have no problems with), so I figured I'd start a thread dedicated towards this.

I'll start by saying that I don't view a dissenting opinion here as "evil" and "wrong"... There are many issues where both sides can at least respect the other's opinion, see why they might think that, but have your absolute reasons as to why you think the way you do. I think there's a grey area here, and I think discussion on this topic can remain civil enough and let the points speak for themselves...

So, Why do I think there should be an electoral college?

Well, for starters, it's part of the country's foundation, and for good reason. One thing that causes me to consistently facepalm is when people refuse to acknowledge the history behind their proposal. Bald-faced democracies don't work. They never have, and they never will. Why? Because it turns into tyrannical mob rule, every time. If there were 2 lions and a lamb in a pit, and they were all starving and had to vote on who was to be consumed, the lions would vote the lamb. Sure, that's "democratic", but it's not just. There are defined and clear reasons why the founders of the country were aware of this, feared it, and thus protected the nation against it.


But here are reasons why the EC is a good thing:

1. Winning a presidential election requires a diverse group of voters from all around the country, not just high populated hot spots that would spout one culture.

2. It ensures every state matters. States that aren't as populated aren't dominated by the Californias and New Yorks of the world. Meanwhile, these less populated states supply crucial resources to the nation, i.e. farming and agriculture, and thus giving them a voice to promote their issues is healthy to the country. In a popular vote, they would get drowned out by in-country foreign voters who have no idea what allows them to have all their food they take for granted. These "lesser" states would become expendable to whoever is in power, even if they'd be chopping off their nose to spite their face.

3. It makes it harder to steal an election. The EC makes it impossible to predict which states matter most years in advance. Thus, nobody knows which votes they need to steal. Everyone thought Ohio was going to be close in 2016, but it turns out it went 51%-42% Trump. So even if, for arguments sake, Democrats tried to steal votes in Ohio, the EC ensured their efforts were in vain. Also, it stops the effects of the criminal activity at the state border, and doesn't poison the national outcome as much.

But as mentioned earlier, the most important point for the EC is to avoid a pure democracy. So the 51% cannot tyrannically control and dictate to the 49%. The lions cannot slaughter the lamb.

I have theories as to why the Democrats are making this push for a popular vote, but I'll avoid making partisan charges. I'd rather just focus on the issues and points. I invite others to do the same.
 
2. It ensures every state matters. States that aren't as populated aren't dominated by the Californias and New Yorks of the world.
Nope, it just created a different set of states that matter. Presidential candidates spend all their times Ohio and Florida and a select few swing states. The majority of states are completely ignored during the general election.
 
Nope, it just created a different set of states that matter. Presidential candidates spend all their times Ohio and Florida and a select few swing states. The majority of states are completely ignored during the general election.

Ah, but you see, the Democrats were incorrect in putting so much resources in Ohio in 2016, as proven by the 51-42% GOP win.

So, the EC worked in that example. The Democrats simply either didn't allocate their resources correctly or did not try to appeal to more than one culture in Ohio, Cuyahoga county (aka Cleveland area).

The Democrats clearly didn't have good polling data. There are multiple examples of them ignoring areas, thinking they had it in the bag. I think even Democrats can admit that their party was aloof in some of their assumptions.
 
Ah, but you see, the Democrats were incorrect in putting so much resources in Ohio in 2016, as proven by the 51-42% GOP win.

So, the EC worked in that example. The Democrats simply either didn't allocate their resources correctly or did not try to appeal to more than one culture in Ohio, Cuyahoga county (aka Cleveland area).

The Democrats clearly didn't have good polling data. There are multiple examples of them ignoring areas, thinking they had it in the bag. I think even Democrats can admit that their party was aloof in some of their assumptions.[/QUOTE]
EC- candidates spent their time in swing states.
popular vote- candidates spend their time in popular centers- which happen to be fairly spread out across the country.

Let's not pretend the EC means that every state matters.
 
Nope, it just created a different set of states that matter. Presidential candidates spend all their times Ohio and Florida and a select few swing states. The majority of states are completely ignored during the general election.
Without the EC they would spend all their time in NY, Kali, Tex, & Florida.

All of Hillary's meaningless "popular vote" margin was in one state......Kalifornia. We don't need one state full of nutbags electing a President.
 
Ah, but you see, the Democrats were incorrect in putting so much resources in Ohio in 2016, as proven by the 51-42% GOP win.

So, the EC worked in that example. The Democrats simply either didn't allocate their resources correctly or did not try to appeal to more than one culture in Ohio, Cuyahoga county (aka Cleveland area).

The Democrats clearly didn't have good polling data. There are multiple examples of them ignoring areas, thinking they had it in the bag. I think even Democrats can admit that their party was aloof in some of their assumptions.

Basically you are arguing about tactics intended to gather votes in one or two states. Trump won three key states by less than 1% and you think that indicates that the sheep won and the wolves went hungry.

The EC did not "work" in that it did not reflect the will of the majority of voters, much less the will of the population. About 80,000 people in three states gave Trump the White House and you think that somehow is a win for one culture over another.

Now that the court has ruled that Electors are not bound to vote for the candidate who won the popular vote in their state...just as the original design had in mind...now what?
 
1.)How is that any worse than candidates spending all their time in Ohio and Florida?

Where is evidence for this claim that the candidates spent "all of their time" in Ohio and Florida? There were probably 10-12 states that could have gone either way. They were campaigning in many other places than just those two states, and a lot.
 
Where is evidence for this claim that the candidates spent "all of their time" in Ohio and Florida? There were probably 10-12 states that could have gone either way. They were campaigning in many other places than just those two states, and a lot.
In 2016 They spent 2/3 of their time in 6 states.
map-2016-campaign-events-v2-2019-04-14.png

https://www.nationalpopularvote.com/campaign-events-2016
 
One of my threads recently drifted towards the prominent issue of the electoral college (which I have no problems with), so I figured I'd start a thread dedicated towards this.

I'll start by saying that I don't view a dissenting opinion here as "evil" and "wrong"... There are many issues where both sides can at least respect the other's opinion, see why they might think that, but have your absolute reasons as to why you think the way you do. I think there's a grey area here, and I think discussion on this topic can remain civil enough and let the points speak for themselves...

So, Why do I think there should be an electoral college?

Well, for starters, it's part of the country's foundation, and for good reason. One thing that causes me to consistently facepalm is when people refuse to acknowledge the history behind their proposal. Bald-faced democracies don't work. They never have, and they never will. Why? Because it turns into tyrannical mob rule, every time. If there were 2 lions and a lamb in a pit, and they were all starving and had to vote on who was to be consumed, the lions would vote the lamb. Sure, that's "democratic", but it's not just. There are defined and clear reasons why the founders of the country were aware of this, feared it, and thus protected the nation against it.


But here are reasons why the EC is a good thing:

1. Winning a presidential election requires a diverse group of voters from all around the country, not just high populated hot spots that would spout one culture.

2. It ensures every state matters. States that aren't as populated aren't dominated by the Californias and New Yorks of the world. Meanwhile, these less populated states supply crucial resources to the nation, i.e. farming and agriculture, and thus giving them a voice to promote their issues is healthy to the country. In a popular vote, they would get drowned out by in-country foreign voters who have no idea what allows them to have all their food they take for granted. These "lesser" states would become expendable to whoever is in power, even if they'd be chopping off their nose to spite their face.

3. It makes it harder to steal an election. The EC makes it impossible to predict which states matter most years in advance. Thus, nobody knows which votes they need to steal. Everyone thought Ohio was going to be close in 2016, but it turns out it went 51%-42% Trump. So even if, for arguments sake, Democrats tried to steal votes in Ohio, the EC ensured their efforts were in vain. Also, it stops the effects of the criminal activity at the state border, and doesn't poison the national outcome as much.

But as mentioned earlier, the most important point for the EC is to avoid a pure democracy. So the 51% cannot tyrannically control and dictate to the 49%. The lions cannot slaughter the lamb.

I have theories as to why the Democrats are making this push for a popular vote, but I'll avoid making partisan charges. I'd rather just focus on the issues and points. I invite others to do the same.

If every state mattered then the presidential campaign would have taken place nation wide...It didn't. Here are the number of campaign events in each state....

map-2016-campaign-events-v2-2019-04-14.png
 
Basically you are arguing about tactics intended to gather votes in one or two states. Trump won three key states by less than 1% and you think that indicates that the sheep won and the wolves went hungry.

Yes, because these three key states (whatever they are) will not always be the "key" states. The popular vote would ensure that every single election there will be only a few states whose issues will be addressed, and those would be the same states, every time.

The EC did not "work" in that it did not reflect the will of the majority of voters, much less the will of the population. About 80,000 people in three states gave Trump the White House and you think that somehow is a win for one culture over another.

It did work. Hillary and Trump had to campaign to appeal to a diverse group of voters across the entire country, not just highly populated areas, who have a ton of issues that they don't have to deal with, but would be able to dictate how to address them.

It's like having a sociology professor telling a farmer how to achieve better soil conditions. Why not just rely on the farmers expertise?
 
campaign events in each state

not really, look at all those states who didn't see a single campaign stop.

You're looking at one election. Go back 4, 8, 30 years, you'll see different numbers. That's the point. Through time, the EC ensures diversity in what states are important. That's healthy for the country.
 
You're looking at one election. Go back 4, 8, 30 years, you'll see different numbers.
They haven't changed that much. Ohio has been the center of presidential politics for my entire life.
That's the point. Through time, the EC ensures diversity in what states are important. That's healthy for the country.
Population centers change over the course the time, Some cities grow and some wane over the course of time which ensures the geographical diversity of presidential politics.
 
They haven't changed that much. Ohio has been the center of presidential politics for my entire life.

Population centers change over the course the time, Some cities grow and some wane over the course of time which ensures the geographical diversity of presidential politics.

Let's take a look at the differences between the two of our points.

Here, I've used wikipedia for results of every election since 1988, or the last 7 elections. Listed under each year are the close races, ones that were under 5% victory.

1988
Washington, 1.59%
Illinois, 2.09%
Pennsylvania, 2.31%
Maryland, 2.91%
Vermont, 3.52%
California, 3.57%
Wisconsin, 3.61%
Missouri, 3.98%
New York, 4.10%
Oregon, 4.67%
West Virginia, 4.74%
New Mexico, 4.96%

1992
Georgia – 0.59%
North Carolina – 0.79%
New Hampshire – 1.22%
Ohio – 1.83%
Florida – 1.89%
Arizona – 1.95%
New Jersey – 2.37%
Montana – 2.51%
Nevada – 2.63%
Kentucky – 3.21%
Texas – 3.48%
South Dakota – 3.52%
Colorado – 4.26%
Wisconsin – 4.35%
Virginia – 4.37%
Louisiana – 4.61%
Tennessee – 4.65%

1996
Kentucky, 0.96%
Nevada, 1.02%
Georgia, 1.17%
Colorado, 1.37%
Virginia, 1.96%
Arizona, 2.22%
Tennessee, 2.41%
Montana, 2.88%
South Dakota, 3.46%
North Carolina, 4.69%
Texas, 4.93%

2000
Florida, 0.0092%
New Mexico, 0.061%
Wisconsin, 0.22%
Iowa, 0.31%
Oregon, 0.44%
New Hampshire, 1.27%
Maine, 1.87%
Minnesota, 2.40%
Missouri, 3.34%
Ohio, 3.51%
Nevada, 3.55%
Tennessee, 3.86%
Pennsylvania, 4.17%

2004
Wisconsin 0.38%
Iowa 0.67%
New Mexico 0.79%
New Hampshire 1.37%
Ohio 2.11%
Pennsylvania 2.50%
Nevada 2.59%
Michigan 3.42%
Minnesota 3.48%
Oregon 4.16%
Colorado 4.67%

2008
Missouri 0.13%
North Carolina 0.33%
Indiana 1.03%
Nebraska 1.21%
Montana 2.26%
Florida 2.82%
Ohio 4.59%

2012
Florida, 0.88%
North Carolina, 2.04%
Ohio, 2.98%
Virginia, 3.87%


2016
Michigan, 0.23%
New Hampshire, 0.37%
Pennsylvania, 0.72%
Wisconsin, 0.77%
Florida, 1.20%
Minnesota, 1.52%
Nebraska, 2.24%
Nevada, 2.42%
Maine, 2.96%
Arizona, 3.55%
North Carolina, 3.66%
Colorado, 4.91%


Look at the diversity in these results. Over 30 years, let's look at all the states that have been included, and thus, all the states that have been appealed to by presidential candidates, trying to earn their vote.

Ohio - 6
Florida - 6
Wisconsin - 5
North Carolina - 5
Pennsylvania - 4
New Hampshire - 4
Nevada - 4
Colorado - 4
Missouri - 3
Oregon - 3
Arizona - 3
Montana - 3
Virginia - 3
Tennessee - 3
Minnesota - 3
New Mexico - 2
Georgia - 2
Kentucky - 2
Texas - 2
South Dakota - 2
Iowa - 2
Maine - 2
Michigan - 2
Nebraska - 2
Indiana
New Jersey
West Virginia
Louisiana
Washington
Illinois
Maryland
Vermont
California
New York

Again, look at this diversity. Look how many states from different parts of the country have had a large say in the direction of the country? And why is this? Because it's a close state race, and candidates are almost required to hedge their bets on these states.

If you had it your way, over the past 7 elections, it would be this or something close to this as the states that pretty much decided the direction of our country. These 10.

New York
California
Texas
Florida
Illinois
Pennsylvania
Ohio
Michigan
Georgia
North Carolina

They have that large of populations. They would hold a tyrannical mob rule on the rest of the country. America guarded against this, thankfully, with the Electoral College.
 
Let's take a look at the differences between the two of our points.

Here, I've used wikipedia for results of every election since 1988, or the last 7 elections. Listed under each year are the close races, ones that were under 5% victory.

1988
Washington, 1.59%
Illinois, 2.09%
Pennsylvania, 2.31%
Maryland, 2.91%
Vermont, 3.52%
California, 3.57%
Wisconsin, 3.61%
Missouri, 3.98%
New York, 4.10%
Oregon, 4.67%
West Virginia, 4.74%
New Mexico, 4.96%

1992
Georgia – 0.59%
North Carolina – 0.79%
New Hampshire – 1.22%
Ohio – 1.83%
Florida – 1.89%
Arizona – 1.95%
New Jersey – 2.37%
Montana – 2.51%
Nevada – 2.63%
Kentucky – 3.21%
Texas – 3.48%
South Dakota – 3.52%
Colorado – 4.26%
Wisconsin – 4.35%
Virginia – 4.37%
Louisiana – 4.61%
Tennessee – 4.65%

1996
Kentucky, 0.96%
Nevada, 1.02%
Georgia, 1.17%
Colorado, 1.37%
Virginia, 1.96%
Arizona, 2.22%
Tennessee, 2.41%
Montana, 2.88%
South Dakota, 3.46%
North Carolina, 4.69%
Texas, 4.93%

2000
Florida, 0.0092%
New Mexico, 0.061%
Wisconsin, 0.22%
Iowa, 0.31%
Oregon, 0.44%
New Hampshire, 1.27%
Maine, 1.87%
Minnesota, 2.40%
Missouri, 3.34%
Ohio, 3.51%
Nevada, 3.55%
Tennessee, 3.86%
Pennsylvania, 4.17%

2004
Wisconsin 0.38%
Iowa 0.67%
New Mexico 0.79%
New Hampshire 1.37%
Ohio 2.11%
Pennsylvania 2.50%
Nevada 2.59%
Michigan 3.42%
Minnesota 3.48%
Oregon 4.16%
Colorado 4.67%

2008
Missouri 0.13%
North Carolina 0.33%
Indiana 1.03%
Nebraska 1.21%
Montana 2.26%
Florida 2.82%
Ohio 4.59%

2012
Florida, 0.88%
North Carolina, 2.04%
Ohio, 2.98%
Virginia, 3.87%


2016
Michigan, 0.23%
New Hampshire, 0.37%
Pennsylvania, 0.72%
Wisconsin, 0.77%
Florida, 1.20%
Minnesota, 1.52%
Nebraska, 2.24%
Nevada, 2.42%
Maine, 2.96%
Arizona, 3.55%
North Carolina, 3.66%
Colorado, 4.91%


Look at the diversity in these results. Over 30 years, let's look at all the states that have been included, and thus, all the states that have been appealed to by presidential candidates, trying to earn their vote.

Ohio - 6
Florida - 6
Wisconsin - 5
North Carolina - 5
Pennsylvania - 4
New Hampshire - 4
Nevada - 4
Colorado - 4
Missouri - 3
Oregon - 3
Arizona - 3
Montana - 3
Virginia - 3
Tennessee - 3
Minnesota - 3
New Mexico - 2
Georgia - 2
Kentucky - 2
Texas - 2
South Dakota - 2
Iowa - 2
Maine - 2
Michigan - 2
Nebraska - 2
Indiana
New Jersey
West Virginia
Louisiana
Washington
Illinois
Maryland
Vermont
California
New York
That isn't a list of where candidate campaign. Which is what the electoral college is suppose to ensure. Nebraska made you list of close victories but received a grand total of 1 campaign visit. in 2016. The electoral college ensure that candidates throw some states to the wayside while they spend all their time and resources in others.

They have that large of populations. They would hold a tyrannical mob rule on the rest of the country. America guarded against this, thankfully, with the Electoral College.
No, if it was direct popular vote candidates wouldn't care about states at all. They would flock to the population centers. Which coincidentally

And you can still can still mob rule with 47% of the population... just look at 2016-2018. The electoral college didn't do anything about "mob rule".
 
That isn't a list of where candidate campaign. Which is what the electoral college is suppose to ensure. Nebraska made you list of close victories but received a grand total of 1 campaign visit. in 2016.
That's more than they would have received without an EC, and what about previous elections?
The electoral college ensure that candidates throw some states to the wayside while they spend all their time and resources in others.
And the popular vote doesn't? So you think Joe Biden is going to visit Montana if it doesn't hold EC votes? Neither "solution" makes every state equal, but the EC certainly encourages far more diversity than a popular vote, as far as being pandered to by candidates, which is how one controls the direction of the country.

No, if it was direct popular vote candidates wouldn't care about states at all. They would flock to the population centers.
Exactly my point. That's a bad thing, no matter which side it favors.
And you can still can still mob rule with 47% of the population... just look at 2016-2018. The electoral college didn't do anything about "mob rule".

The term "mob" and "minority" don't often correlate in a given situation. Just because a side loses doesn't mean they were tyrannically dominated by a phantom "mob". Otherwise, you'll have to call every single presidential victory a "mob rule", which makes no sense.
 
Back
Top