New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Another high-profile shooting.

Arkady

President
Oscar Pistorius, the sprinter who became world famous after advancing in the Olympic heats despite being a double amputee, shot and killed his girlfriend. According to him, he mistook her for a burglar. I don't know if that's true or not, but it's not terribly far-fetched. People accidentally shoot loved ones on a fairly regular basis, due to similar mistakes. The scenario is easy enough to picture -- maybe your girlfriend slips in unannounced in the wee hours, planning a pleasant surprise for Valentine's Day. You hear the noise, and, with your brain working about as well as can be expected when awoken in a panic from a sound sleep, you fail to recognize her in the near darkness, and shoot her.

Once, in high school, I sneaked out of my house to meet up with my friend, then sneaked back in a couple hours later, only to be confronted by my baseball-bat-wielding father, who heard me come in and assumed I was a burglar. I assume that even if he'd had a gun, he wouldn't have fired, since he's pretty cool under pressure, and isn't likely to shoot first and ask questions later. But you never know. With a gun, the difference between life and death is literally the twitch of a finger -- a moment of panic, even if mastered a mere quarter second later, could be the quarter second it takes to pull that trigger and leave a loved one dead.

That's something to remember when considering a gun for home defense. Statistically, you're actually putting your family at greater risk. Once you factor in accidents (e.g, the gun going off while cleaning), kids getting hold of the gun, suicides, mistaken shootings like the one I described, and the possibility of a genuine intruder getting in and using the weapon against you, the mortality rate of your family members goes up when you let a gun in your house.

That doesn't necessarily mean we should ban or limit guns in the home. Statistically, having a swimming pool is more dangerous for your family than having a gun. And there are other risks -- like a flight of stairs in a multi-story home, that probably aren't too far off. There are lots of risks we tolerate, even when it comes to our families. It just means that if you're buying a gun with the idea you're making your family safer, you're very likely doing the opposite.
 
breaking news - the case is now being treated as premeditated homicide. they found google searches on his PC on how to elminate fingerprints, and he tried to detroy and hide bloody evidence before contacting police. (this is true)

the networks are theorizing that oscar pistorius will have his attorney enter a plea of "temporary insanity". i say he doesn't have a leg to stand on, however.
 
breaking news - the case is now being treated as premeditated homicide. they found google searches on his PC on how to elminate fingerprints, and he tried to detroy and hide bloody evidence before contacting police. (this is true)

the networks are theorizing that oscar pistorius will have his attorney enter a plea of "temporary insanity". i say he doesn't have a leg to stand on, however.

That's a vile pun.

Anyway, it's possible it was premeditated murder. But the fingerprint search on Google and the hiding of the bloody evidence is not, alone, evidence of that. The timing of the search would be interesting. Picture a situation where he shot her dead when he mistook her as a burglar, just as he said, and then he panicked and tried to cover it up -- not wanting to have the world know he was responsible for the death of the woman he loved, even if it was an accident. That would, of course, still be a crime. But it wouldn't be premeditated murder.

Anyway, whether this particular event was a genuine accidental shooting or a premeditated murder is immaterial to the bigger question I was trying to get at. There are many real events of accidental shootings of the sort he claims, whether or not this is one.
 
yep, read the headline earlier.

I suppose we'll have to see how the trial goes, but your point is correct. Having a gun in the home should be decided with a pro/con list.
 
That's a vile pun.

Anyway, it's possible it was premeditated murder. But the fingerprint search on Google and the hiding of the bloody evidence is not, alone, evidence of that. The timing of the search would be interesting. Picture a situation where he shot her dead when he mistook her as a burglar, just as he said, and then he panicked and tried to cover it up -- not wanting to have the world know he was responsible for the death of the woman he loved, even if it was an accident. That would, of course, still be a crime. But it wouldn't be premeditated murder.

Anyway, whether this particular event was a genuine accidental shooting or a premeditated murder is immaterial to the bigger question I was trying to get at. There are many real events of accidental shootings of the sort he claims, whether or not this is one.


That old saw about a gun in the home being more likely to injure someone in the home is hogwash, and it always has been. One of the 4 basic rules of firearms handling is being sure of your target AND whats behind it, before firing. People are responsible for their own actions; guns don't shoot themselves.
 
I completely agree that a home is a bit safer without a gun. I know of several people in my circle of friends and acquaintances who have been shot. Other than suicides, almost every one was an accident. The only exceptions I can think of are a woman who killed her abusive boyfriend and a guy who killed another guy in a bar fight. (He walked. No one would testify against him. Even though it was an execution type shooting, no one liked the victim and everyone liked the shooter. Real life. Glad I wasn't there that night.)

I've never seen a statistic comparing accidental to intentional (and justified) shootings. I'd put my money on more accidents than righteous shootings.
 
I completely agree that a home is a bit safer without a gun. I know of several people in my circle of friends and acquaintances who have been shot. Other than suicides, almost every one was an accident. The only exceptions I can think of are a woman who killed her abusive boyfriend and a guy who killed another guy in a bar fight. (He walked. No one would testify against him. Even though it was an execution type shooting, no one liked the victim and everyone liked the shooter. Real life. Glad I wasn't there that night.)

I've never seen a statistic comparing accidental to intentional (and justified) shootings. I'd put my money on more accidents than righteous shootings.
Even the lowest estimates of defensive gun use in America, far out number accidental shootings... or even suicides. However, defensive use of a gun doesn't mean it was fired, so the estimates are pretty broad, something like 2 and a half million times a year at the top end. Its probably a good bit lower than that.
 
Even the lowest estimates of defensive gun use in America, far out number accidental shootings... or even suicides. However, defensive use of a gun doesn't mean it was fired, so the estimates are pretty broad, something like 2 and a half million times a year at the top end. Its probably a good bit lower than that.

That is ignorant as hell! All it takes is one show off with a gun,and it is an accident waiting to happen!
 
I think the notion of home security is an entirely different kettle of fish when you live in Pretoria
 
That old saw about a gun in the home being more likely to injure someone in the home is hogwash, and it always has been. One of the 4 basic rules of firearms handling is being sure of your target AND whats behind it, before firing. People are responsible for their own actions; guns don't shoot themselves.

If by "hogwash" you mean "statistically correct," then, yes.
 
Even the lowest estimates of defensive gun use in America, far out number accidental shootings... or even suicides. However, defensive use of a gun doesn't mean it was fired, so the estimates are pretty broad, something like 2 and a half million times a year at the top end. Its probably a good bit lower than that.

If by "defensive use" you mean "any time someone waves a gun around" in a situation where he fears a crime, then I have no doubt that defensive uses are high. If you mean "uses of the gun where the alternative would have been the death of an innocent" then they're hard to count, since nobody can be really sure in any given circumstance what would have happened if not for the presence of a gun.

Just to illustrate the concept, imagine two groups of homes. Group A has guns, Group B doesn't. Let's say that homes are broken into 100 times for each group, in instances where the home owner is home and awake (and thus potentially able to defend his home).

Let's say that in 90 of those hundred, for Group A, the intruder flees in panic when confronted by the gun-wielding owner, and in an additional 5 instances the intruder is shot dead by the owner. So, in 95 out of 100, the owner successfully stopped the burglary. In the remaining 5, let's say the homeowner is killed (either by his own gun, or by the intruder's gun). And let's also say that in Group A there are an additional 10 people killed over the course of a year by accidents and suicides (above those who would have been even without the presence of the guns).

And let's say that in 90 of the Group B home intrusions, the intruder flees when confronted with a non-gun-wielding owner (most burglars flee confrontation, regardless of whether the homeowner is armed, since he presumably called the cops). Of the other ten cases, let's say the homeowner is killed in five of them, and is robbed, raped, or beaten up in the other five.

I'm not saying those are the real numbers. I'm just using them as illustrations of the principle. As you'll see, if you define "defensive use" broadly, as nearly all gun enthusiasts do, Group A had a lot of defensive uses: 95, in fact. One could rightly say that "defensive gun uses in Group A far outnumber accidental shootings or even suicides," right? There are 95 defensive uses, and only 10 accidents and suicides. Even if you were "generous" and only counted half those 95 incidents as "defensive use" you could still claim that they far outnumber accidents and suicides. Yet, when you move beyond definitional games and rhetoric and look at the end result for overall mortality, a different conclusion emerges.

In Group A, the gun-toting group, you have 15 deaths of homeowners associated with those firearms. In Group B, you have 5, plus another 5 people beaten up, robbed, and/or raped. Even if you regard battery, robbery, and rape as being as bad as murder, Group B is still better off.

And that's before even counting the burglars themselves, who are, after all, human beings. If Group A is shooting a lot of intruders, that's going to inevitably include people who are relatively harmless, notwithstanding the fact many states regard them as fair game for killing, once they break into a home, with no duty of homeowner retreat, or any delay to assess danger before firing. For example, picture some dumb kid breaking into what he assumes is an empty house, just to steal from the liquor cabinet. He's the kind who is likely to flee the moment he knows there's someone home, but he can easily wind up dead in one of these so-called "defensive uses" of firearms, when a trigger-happy homeowner decides it's better to put him down immediately rather than risk him being dangerous.

Like I said, those aren't the real stats. I just came up with them to illustrate the point. But when you look at the overall violent crime victimization rates in the US versus in most wealthy nations, it's pretty clear that the real statistics are fundamentally in-line with the illustration. Yes, the US has a lot more per capita "defensive uses" of firearms than most other wealthy nations. But, like the people in Group A, in my illustration, that doesn't make us safer. We are, in fact, in greater jeopardy. Some of that is due to the elevated instances of gun accidents of various kinds, and gun suicides, and unjustifiable but legally permitted gun shootings (under "stand your ground and "castle" laws). And some has to do with the fact that, when you have a lot more guns within the society, crooks, hot-heads, and madmen inevitably get their hands on them more often, so you get more killings.

So, the issue isn't how many "defensive uses" there are -- a question that just gets bogged down in semantics. The issue is whether homeowners who have guns are statistically safer, overall, than those who don't. And it turns out they aren't. They're less safe. And, in a larger sense, nations that have lots of gun ownership have citizens that are less safe, overall, than nations that have less, on average.
 
That old saw about a gun in the home being more likely to injure someone in the home is hogwash, and it always has been. One of the 4 basic rules of firearms handling is being sure of your target AND whats behind it, before firing. People are responsible for their own actions; guns don't shoot themselves.

Frey, you don't want it to be true so you call it hogwash. It is true. THE STATISTICS PROVE IT TRUE! Your brain wants to ignore so you yell hogwash. You righties have badly wired craniums. This is also proven.

Get used to it. Facts are hard things.
 
Cite your source then... "research" that was done to further a political agenda, is the chief reason the CDC was defunded from doing anymore of these studies.

As you know, the CDC was defunded because it was producing impartial scientific results that tended to support the gun control policies.
 
If by "defensive use" you mean "any time someone waves a gun around" in a situation where he fears a crime, then I have no doubt that defensive uses are high. If you mean "uses of the gun where the alternative would have been the death of an innocent" then they're hard to count, since nobody can be really sure in any given circumstance what would have happened if not for the presence of a gun.

Just to illustrate the concept, imagine two groups of homes. Group A has guns, Group B doesn't. Let's say that homes are broken into 100 times for each group, in instances where the home owner is home and awake (and thus potentially able to defend his home).

Let's say that in 90 of those hundred, for Group A, the intruder flees in panic when confronted by the gun-wielding owner, and in an additional 5 instances the intruder is shot dead by the owner. So, in 95 out of 100, the owner successfully stopped the burglary. In the remaining 5, let's say the homeowner is killed (either by his own gun, or by the intruder's gun). And let's also say that in Group A there are an additional 10 people killed over the course of a year by accidents and suicides (above those who would have been even without the presence of the guns).

And let's say that in 90 of the Group B home intrusions, the intruder flees when confronted with a non-gun-wielding owner (most burglars flee confrontation, regardless of whether the homeowner is armed, since he presumably called the cops). Of the other ten cases, let's say the homeowner is killed in five of them, and is robbed, raped, or beaten up in the other five.

I'm not saying those are the real numbers. I'm just using them as illustrations of the principle. As you'll see, if you define "defensive use" broadly, as nearly all gun enthusiasts do, Group A had a lot of defensive uses: 95, in fact. One could rightly say that "defensive gun uses in Group A far outnumber accidental shootings or even suicides," right? There are 95 defensive uses, and only 10 accidents and suicides. Even if you were "generous" and only counted half those 95 incidents as "defensive use" you could still claim that they far outnumber accidents and suicides. Yet, when you move beyond definitional games and rhetoric and look at the end result for overall mortality, a different conclusion emerges.

In Group A, the gun-toting group, you have 15 deaths of homeowners associated with those firearms. In Group B, you have 5, plus another 5 people beaten up, robbed, and/or raped. Even if you regard battery, robbery, and rape as being as bad as murder, Group B is still better off.

And that's before even counting the burglars themselves, who are, after all, human beings. If Group A is shooting a lot of intruders, that's going to inevitably include people who are relatively harmless, notwithstanding the fact many states regard them as fair game for killing, once they break into a home, with no duty of homeowner retreat, or any delay to assess danger before firing. For example, picture some dumb kid breaking into what he assumes is an empty house, just to steal from the liquor cabinet. He's the kind who is likely to flee the moment he knows there's someone home, but he can easily wind up dead in one of these so-called "defensive uses" of firearms, when a trigger-happy homeowner decides it's better to put him down immediately rather than risk him being dangerous.

Like I said, those aren't the real stats. I just came up with them to illustrate the point. But when you look at the overall violent crime victimization rates in the US versus in most wealthy nations, it's pretty clear that the real statistics are fundamentally in-line with the illustration. Yes, the US has a lot more per capita "defensive uses" of firearms than most other wealthy nations. But, like the people in Group A, in my illustration, that doesn't make us safer. We are, in fact, in greater jeopardy. Some of that is due to the elevated instances of gun accidents of various kinds, and gun suicides, and unjustifiable but legally permitted gun shootings (under "stand your ground and "castle" laws). And some has to do with the fact that, when you have a lot more guns within the society, crooks, hot-heads, and madmen inevitably get their hands on them more often, so you get more killings.

So, the issue isn't how many "defensive uses" there are -- a question that just gets bogged down in semantics. The issue is whether homeowners who have guns are statistically safer, overall, than those who don't. And it turns out they aren't. They're less safe. And, in a larger sense, nations that have lots of gun ownership have citizens that are less safe, overall, than nations that have less, on average.
Defensive use of a gun IS a very broad category; it includes everything from putting your hand under your shirt tail to let the BG know your prepared to draw if he keeps coming, to a full on firefight. So, it is all "estimated", because many times, incidents where there was no presentation of the weapon do not get reported. So the range is very broad, between 800,000 to 2.5 million a year; which means even at the LOWEST estimate it is still better to have, than have not... but, hey, its a free country, you don't want to keep a gun, then don't.
 
Frey, you don't want it to be true so you call it hogwash. It is true. THE STATISTICS PROVE IT TRUE! Your brain wants to ignore so you yell hogwash. You righties have badly wired craniums. This is also proven.

Get used to it. Facts are hard things.
So, show me some then...
BTW, don't call me "rightie"; you don't know me...
 
Mr. Arky,

Just goes to show, there's truth behind all those old jokes....

"When you meet a new woman, no matter how beautiful and enchanting she may seem, there at least one guy out there who couldn't wait to get rid of that bitch."
 
Back
Top