Arkady
President
Think it's time to start enforcing our country's immigration laws?
If he's been deported five times, it sounds like they are being enforced. The problem is an ineffectual focus for enforcement.
This is a potentially offensive analogy, but I'll use it anyway. Picture you keep getting ants in your kitchen, because you've got lots of crumbs and unsealed food containers. You're not going to fix that by picking up the ants and carrying them back outside. You won't fix it by trying to hermetically seal the house off from the outside world, either. If there's enough space to let in air, the ants will find their way in. But, if you seal the food and clean up the crumbs, they'll stop coming, because that's what's drawing them in. Without that, an occasional ant will wander in to look for food, but he'll go back empty handed and not leave a scent trail for thousands of his buddies to follow.
Illegal immigration is similar. Short of some sort of genocidal mass poisoning of unwanted guests, we have limited options for effective action. We can pick them up and dump them back outside the country, but that's expensive and time consuming and they'll just return. We can try to seal the borders, but that's a fool's errand... we have too much border and coastline to seal it cost effectively, and even if we managed to do so people would just come here legally on tourist, study, and temporary work visas and overstay. So, the only effective option is to eliminate what lures undocumented laborers in the first place: jobs.
This can be much more effective, because illegal employers typically have a lot more to lose than their illegal employees do, so focusing on the demand side of the equation, rather than the supply side, allows for some real deterrence. If you run a business, you're not going to want to risk losing that business, or being thrown behind bars, just to save a little money by hiring an undocumented worker.
So, focus on throwing the book at illegal employers. Ferret them out with sting operations. Offer green cards to the whole immediate family of any undocumented worker who turns in an illegal employer. Make it so potential illegal employers don't DARE hire anyone without proper documentation, because they know the person they offer the job to has a huge personal incentive to go states' evidence and see them behind bars.