New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Another killer illegal

Think it's time to start enforcing our country's immigration laws?

If he's been deported five times, it sounds like they are being enforced. The problem is an ineffectual focus for enforcement.

This is a potentially offensive analogy, but I'll use it anyway. Picture you keep getting ants in your kitchen, because you've got lots of crumbs and unsealed food containers. You're not going to fix that by picking up the ants and carrying them back outside. You won't fix it by trying to hermetically seal the house off from the outside world, either. If there's enough space to let in air, the ants will find their way in. But, if you seal the food and clean up the crumbs, they'll stop coming, because that's what's drawing them in. Without that, an occasional ant will wander in to look for food, but he'll go back empty handed and not leave a scent trail for thousands of his buddies to follow.

Illegal immigration is similar. Short of some sort of genocidal mass poisoning of unwanted guests, we have limited options for effective action. We can pick them up and dump them back outside the country, but that's expensive and time consuming and they'll just return. We can try to seal the borders, but that's a fool's errand... we have too much border and coastline to seal it cost effectively, and even if we managed to do so people would just come here legally on tourist, study, and temporary work visas and overstay. So, the only effective option is to eliminate what lures undocumented laborers in the first place: jobs.

This can be much more effective, because illegal employers typically have a lot more to lose than their illegal employees do, so focusing on the demand side of the equation, rather than the supply side, allows for some real deterrence. If you run a business, you're not going to want to risk losing that business, or being thrown behind bars, just to save a little money by hiring an undocumented worker.

So, focus on throwing the book at illegal employers. Ferret them out with sting operations. Offer green cards to the whole immediate family of any undocumented worker who turns in an illegal employer. Make it so potential illegal employers don't DARE hire anyone without proper documentation, because they know the person they offer the job to has a huge personal incentive to go states' evidence and see them behind bars.
 
If he's been deported five times, it sounds like they are being enforced. The problem is an ineffectual focus for enforcement.

This is a potentially offensive analogy, but I'll use it anyway. Picture you keep getting ants in your kitchen, because you've got lots of crumbs and unsealed food containers. You're not going to fix that by picking up the ants and carrying them back outside. You won't fix it by trying to hermetically seal the house off from the outside world, either. If there's enough space to let in air, the ants will find their way in. But, if you seal the food and clean up the crumbs, they'll stop coming, because that's what's drawing them in. Without that, an occasional ant will wander in to look for food, but he'll go back empty handed and not leave a scent trail for thousands of his buddies to follow.

Illegal immigration is similar. Short of some sort of genocidal mass poisoning of unwanted guests, we have limited options for effective action. We can pick them up and dump them back outside the country, but that's expensive and time consuming and they'll just return. We can try to seal the borders, but that's a fool's errand... we have too much border and coastline to seal it cost effectively, and even if we managed to do so people would just come here legally on tourist, study, and temporary work visas and overstay. So, the only effective option is to eliminate what lures undocumented laborers in the first place: jobs.

This can be much more effective, because illegal employers typically have a lot more to lose than their illegal employees do, so focusing on the demand side of the equation, rather than the supply side, allows for some real deterrence. If you run a business, you're not going to want to risk losing that business, or being thrown behind bars, just to save a little money by hiring an undocumented worker.

So, focus on throwing the book at illegal employers. Ferret them out with sting operations. Offer green cards to the whole immediate family of any undocumented worker who turns in an illegal employer. Make it so potential illegal employers don't DARE hire anyone without proper documentation, because they know the person they offer the job to has a huge personal incentive to go states' evidence and see them behind bars.
No can do! Ants are not people (Unless your a PETA person) They've got to create the new voting block, I do however agree to a point with your post to remove the incentives they see to come here, jobs, free money, health care, instant citizenship, lots of jobs.

Bust the illegal employers and deport the illegals make it an unprofitable trip for them, if they decide to come back jail them and work them hard for a year then deport them with a serious warning that the next tour of duty will be 5 years with sheriff Joe. You and I both know that will not happen ever.
 
No can do! Ants are not people (Unless your a PETA person) They've got to create the new voting block, I do however agree to a point with your post to remove the incentives they see to come here, jobs, free money, health care, instant citizenship, lots of jobs.

People don't go through the huge hardship of leaving their friends and family and immigrating to the US for a pittance of "free money" and healthcare, which will leave them living with a lower quality of life than they'd have if they'd stayed at home. The jobs are all that really matters. They come here because they can earn a lot more money here with work than they can earn at home -- enough to support a higher quality of life with some left over to send back to those who stayed behind. If you don't want them coming here, focus on eliminating those jobs. It's a classic demand-side problem, and attempting to solve it through supply side changes is going to fail.

Your focus on deterring the undocumented immigrants is likely to fail as well. These are desperate people with very little to lose. Deterrence relies on someone having a lot to lose. That's why deterrence will be vastly more effective if you focus on the employers. Some poor low-skill starving Mexican may be willing to risk jail for a shot at a decent paying job (jail might be not so much worse than what they would experience at home, anyway), but is a successful American entrepreneur going to want to risk jail for a shot at some below-market-wages employees? Will a wealthy American home owner risk jail just to get some cheap landscaping done on his yard? Focusing deterrence where it is likely to be ineffective is just pointless cruelty. Focus it where it's likely to make a difference.
 
Maybe Trump wasn't so 'wrong' on his accusations. In fact, I know he wasn't. Yes, not all of them are bad people, but there's enough of them to warrant stopping ALL from coming in here illegally!

Are you saying that illegal immigration didn't happen while Reagan, Bush or Clinton were president? If stopping all illegal immigration was easy why haven't previous presidents done so? There are more immigration enforcement personnel on the border than ever before. We are deporting thousands. Trump was wrong. His gross over simplification in categorizing all Mexican immigrants as rapists was extraordinarily stupid.
 
Are you saying that illegal immigration didn't happen while Reagan, Bush or Clinton were president? If stopping all illegal immigration was easy why haven't previous presidents done so? There are more immigration enforcement personnel on the border than ever before. We are deporting thousands. Trump was wrong. His gross over simplification in categorizing all Mexican immigrants as rapists was extraordinarily stupid.

He didn't say ALL. And no, I never said it didn't happen with all other presidents. But right now Obama is President and the problem with illegals have grown. Hell, they get deported and come back over and over again! Do it legally or the next time you get caught it won't be so nice. How does Mexico treat Americans that enter their country illegally? Are they pampered and handed medical care, food, a job? Hell, our own President let an ex Marine sit in a Mexican jail for MONTHS and never did a thing to get him out.
 
He didn't say ALL. And no, I never said it didn't happen with all other presidents. But right now Obama is President and the problem with illegals have grown. Hell, they get deported and come back over and over again! Do it legally or the next time you get caught it won't be so nice. How does Mexico treat Americans that enter their country illegally? Are they pampered and handed medical care, food, a job? Hell, our own President let an ex Marine sit in a Mexican jail for MONTHS and never did a thing to get him out.

You are the one who said all: but there's enough of them to warrant stopping ALL from coming in here illegally

Actually there are fewer illegals at the present time. Probably because there are fewer jobs.
The marine who smuggled illegal weapons into Mexico was not jailed for entering illegally. It was about the guns. If you like the idea of the US government intervening in Mexican law...how would you feel about the government of Mexico interfering in US courts? If a Mexican citizen went to jail for having illegal guns and the Mexican government insisted on his release...would that be ok?
 
You are the one who said all: but there's enough of them to warrant stopping ALL from coming in here illegally

Actually there are fewer illegals at the present time. Probably because there are fewer jobs.
The marine who smuggled illegal weapons into Mexico was not jailed for entering illegally. It was about the guns. If you like the idea of the US government intervening in Mexican law...how would you feel about the government of Mexico interfering in US courts? If a Mexican citizen went to jail for having illegal guns and the Mexican government insisted on his release...would that be ok?

YOU said ALL....
His gross over simplification in categorizing all Mexican immigrants as rapists was extraordinarily stupid.

I responded with "He didn't say all".

And I stand by what I said.....ALL illegals should be immediately deported. Even though many haven't murdered & raped, they're still here ILLEGALLY and so are also breaking the law.

Mexico would never demand us to return anyone jailed here for breaking the law.....they don't want them either.

Nothing was proven that the marine was 'smuggling' guns. It wasn't proven that he did NOT make a wrong turn. It's all hearsay by leftists. Seems you trust the mexican government to tell the truth! Lol!
 
YOU said ALL....
His gross over simplification in categorizing all Mexican immigrants as rapists was extraordinarily stupid.

I responded with "He didn't say all".

And I stand by what I said.....ALL illegals should be immediately deported. Even though many haven't murdered & raped, they're still here ILLEGALLY and so are also breaking the law.

Mexico would never demand us to return anyone jailed here for breaking the law.....they don't want them either.

Nothing was proven that the marine was 'smuggling' guns. It wasn't proven that he did NOT make a wrong turn. It's all hearsay by leftists. Seems you trust the mexican government to tell the truth! Lol!

Have you ever been to that border crossing? There is no way that he didn't know for miles that he was coming up to the border. There is a traffic jam going back miles. There are several places along the way to turn around. He didn't. He had guns that would be illegal to bring into Mexico. He brought them anyway and got arrested. Have you ever heard the phrase "Ignorance is no defense"?

Trump's comment was basically that most of those crossing the border were violent criminals. His statement was amazingly stupid.
 
Have you ever been to that border crossing? There is no way that he didn't know for miles that he was coming up to the border. There is a traffic jam going back miles. There are several places along the way to turn around. He didn't. He had guns that would be illegal to bring into Mexico. He brought them anyway and got arrested. Have you ever heard the phrase "Ignorance is no defense"?

Trump's comment was basically that most of those crossing the border were violent criminals. His statement was amazingly stupid.

this is stupid

11666153_946409398749089_6370910170993852157_n.png
dumb & dumber
 
Reading comprehension is fading fast on the left, nothing proves it more than the search:

"immigrants commit fewer crimes than the native born"

as an explanation of how ILLEGALS commit fewer violent crimes.

That's why the left is so gullible.

Listen, I support Trump for the Republican nomination as well, but I don't have to be stupid to do so, so you don't have to be stupid, either.

The evidence is clear, immigrants, whether documented or not, commit violent crime at a lower rate than the native-born. Trump is simply flapping his gums to assuage the nativists--he wants to compete in the primary--and it seems to be working.

Go Trump!
 
ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT DEPORTED 6 TIMES CHARGED IN FELONY HIT-AND-RUN OF FAMILY THAT INJURED YOUNG CHILDREN

A six-time-deported illegal immigrant is charged in the felony hit-and-run of an Arizona mother and her two young children. The man allegedly admitted to being high on marijuana while causing the severe lacerations to a five-year-old boy. The five-year-old and a two-year-old were both taken to an area hospital.

This tragedy comes within one week of two separate incidents involving previously deported illegal immigrants allegedly murdering women in two U.S. states: California and Texas. The California case involved a young woman in San Fransisco taking photos with her father on a pier when an illegal immigrant who had been deported five time prior allegedly murdered her. The Texas case involved an illegal immigrant who had been deported four time prior. Police say the man admitted to murdering his wife with a hammer.


Think it's time to start enforcing our country's immigration laws?

Of course this administration is bent on producing thousands of loyal democrat voters no matter how many lives it costs.


welcome to what the left won't tell you.
 
It is based on studies of both, so both documented and undocumented immigrants commit violent crime at a lower rate than the native-born, but you shouldn't let that fact interfere with support for Trump.

What a dumb stupid statement.

Illegals have a crime rate of 100 percent. Fact
 
What a dumb stupid statement.

Illegals have a crime rate of 100 percent. Fact

Talk about dumb stupid statements:

... documented and undocumented immigrants commit violent crime at a lower rate than the native-born...​
 
If the truth hurts, the horse can eat jimsonweed instead.
Leftists love to tell "the truth" (what they imagine is true) and then when you ask for proof they post you anything but.

BP doesn't like it, now snipes at anyone pointing it out. Pretty weak.
 
Talk about dumb stupid statements:

... documented and undocumented immigrants commit violent crime at a lower rate than the native-born...​
How do you know?...is this documented? and by whom? ...btw dumbass I never said violent crime...how did you get to be so stupid? By thinking you weren't? well it worked!
 
Back
Top