Arkady
President
My family's closest friends are Jewish, so we occasionally are involved in Jewish events -- bar and mat mitzvah's, etc. So, over the weekend, we went to a menorah lighting with our friends (basically, standing on a street corner with a bunch of people in yarmulkes lighting a giant candelabra). During the ceremony two separate cars drove by, rolled down their windows, and shouted anti-semitic comments at the group. Needless to say, the group had done nothing to provoke it. These wonderful people were just there with their young kids, having a lovely holiday ceremony with donuts and cocoa, and they had to put up with that crap! I've been to many, many Christmas events and never once encountered that kind of thing directed at Christians.
The irony is that the rabbi's comments before the lighting included an attack on anti-Muslim bigotry. He was preaching tolerance of other religions as a fundamental Jewish value, even as his people were being subjected to the hate of strangers based on their faith. They all pretended they didn't even hear the slurs, which showed a level of dignified endurance I couldn't have mustered in their place -- it's a good thing I didn't have a gun, because I was murderously angry and ashamed.
To be clear, the people who shouted anti-semitism were in a small minority. Hundreds of cars drove by quietly or with a friendly honk of support, and we goyim were well represented at the ceremony, too, including a Christian state legislator who lit one of the flames. The days of broad anti-Jewish sentiment are mercifully in the past. But I've got to admit I was surprised it still exists to the level it does. If it had been just one hateful passer-by, I might have written it off as bad luck with a one-in-a-million jackass. But two of them in just a half hour suggests much more persistent bigotry than I'd appreciated. And that's in a distinctly liberal state with a Jewish population twice the national average. If we still have such anti-semitism, it's probably even more common elsewhere.
I just don't get this. As irrational as all group hatreds are, I can at least see how some of it is sustained. For example, Muslims are carrying out a disproportionate share of terrorist attacks these days. Latinos often represent an unfamiliar, as-yet-little-assimilated minority in this country. Blacks are involved in a disproportionate share of violent crimes. None of that excuses the bigotry, but I at least grasp fundamentally where it's coming from and how it gets sustained. Anti-semitism, in Western nations at least, is a different matter entirely. We're talking about hating a highly-assimilated, educated, productive, tolerant group, disproportionately involved in humanitarian and civic efforts and little represented among the criminal class. I can't think of a single Jew I've ever met in real life with whom I didn't get along well -- which is something I couldn't say about Christians, atheists, or almost any other group. Even from an anti-religion perspective like mine, where all religion seems a bit foolish and the Old Testament is horrifying, Jews are a group I can appreciate, in that they're often allies in defending the wall between church and state. How people can generate and sustain hate against such a group is a puzzle to me.
The irony is that the rabbi's comments before the lighting included an attack on anti-Muslim bigotry. He was preaching tolerance of other religions as a fundamental Jewish value, even as his people were being subjected to the hate of strangers based on their faith. They all pretended they didn't even hear the slurs, which showed a level of dignified endurance I couldn't have mustered in their place -- it's a good thing I didn't have a gun, because I was murderously angry and ashamed.
To be clear, the people who shouted anti-semitism were in a small minority. Hundreds of cars drove by quietly or with a friendly honk of support, and we goyim were well represented at the ceremony, too, including a Christian state legislator who lit one of the flames. The days of broad anti-Jewish sentiment are mercifully in the past. But I've got to admit I was surprised it still exists to the level it does. If it had been just one hateful passer-by, I might have written it off as bad luck with a one-in-a-million jackass. But two of them in just a half hour suggests much more persistent bigotry than I'd appreciated. And that's in a distinctly liberal state with a Jewish population twice the national average. If we still have such anti-semitism, it's probably even more common elsewhere.
I just don't get this. As irrational as all group hatreds are, I can at least see how some of it is sustained. For example, Muslims are carrying out a disproportionate share of terrorist attacks these days. Latinos often represent an unfamiliar, as-yet-little-assimilated minority in this country. Blacks are involved in a disproportionate share of violent crimes. None of that excuses the bigotry, but I at least grasp fundamentally where it's coming from and how it gets sustained. Anti-semitism, in Western nations at least, is a different matter entirely. We're talking about hating a highly-assimilated, educated, productive, tolerant group, disproportionately involved in humanitarian and civic efforts and little represented among the criminal class. I can't think of a single Jew I've ever met in real life with whom I didn't get along well -- which is something I couldn't say about Christians, atheists, or almost any other group. Even from an anti-religion perspective like mine, where all religion seems a bit foolish and the Old Testament is horrifying, Jews are a group I can appreciate, in that they're often allies in defending the wall between church and state. How people can generate and sustain hate against such a group is a puzzle to me.