New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Anti-Semitism

Arkady

President
My family's closest friends are Jewish, so we occasionally are involved in Jewish events -- bar and mat mitzvah's, etc. So, over the weekend, we went to a menorah lighting with our friends (basically, standing on a street corner with a bunch of people in yarmulkes lighting a giant candelabra). During the ceremony two separate cars drove by, rolled down their windows, and shouted anti-semitic comments at the group. Needless to say, the group had done nothing to provoke it. These wonderful people were just there with their young kids, having a lovely holiday ceremony with donuts and cocoa, and they had to put up with that crap! I've been to many, many Christmas events and never once encountered that kind of thing directed at Christians.

The irony is that the rabbi's comments before the lighting included an attack on anti-Muslim bigotry. He was preaching tolerance of other religions as a fundamental Jewish value, even as his people were being subjected to the hate of strangers based on their faith. They all pretended they didn't even hear the slurs, which showed a level of dignified endurance I couldn't have mustered in their place -- it's a good thing I didn't have a gun, because I was murderously angry and ashamed.

To be clear, the people who shouted anti-semitism were in a small minority. Hundreds of cars drove by quietly or with a friendly honk of support, and we goyim were well represented at the ceremony, too, including a Christian state legislator who lit one of the flames. The days of broad anti-Jewish sentiment are mercifully in the past. But I've got to admit I was surprised it still exists to the level it does. If it had been just one hateful passer-by, I might have written it off as bad luck with a one-in-a-million jackass. But two of them in just a half hour suggests much more persistent bigotry than I'd appreciated. And that's in a distinctly liberal state with a Jewish population twice the national average. If we still have such anti-semitism, it's probably even more common elsewhere.

I just don't get this. As irrational as all group hatreds are, I can at least see how some of it is sustained. For example, Muslims are carrying out a disproportionate share of terrorist attacks these days. Latinos often represent an unfamiliar, as-yet-little-assimilated minority in this country. Blacks are involved in a disproportionate share of violent crimes. None of that excuses the bigotry, but I at least grasp fundamentally where it's coming from and how it gets sustained. Anti-semitism, in Western nations at least, is a different matter entirely. We're talking about hating a highly-assimilated, educated, productive, tolerant group, disproportionately involved in humanitarian and civic efforts and little represented among the criminal class. I can't think of a single Jew I've ever met in real life with whom I didn't get along well -- which is something I couldn't say about Christians, atheists, or almost any other group. Even from an anti-religion perspective like mine, where all religion seems a bit foolish and the Old Testament is horrifying, Jews are a group I can appreciate, in that they're often allies in defending the wall between church and state. How people can generate and sustain hate against such a group is a puzzle to me.
 
My family's closest friends are Jewish, so we occasionally are involved in Jewish events -- bar and mat mitzvah's, etc. So, over the weekend, we went to a menorah lighting with our friends (basically, standing on a street corner with a bunch of people in yarmulkes lighting a giant candelabra). During the ceremony two separate cars drove by, rolled down their windows, and shouted anti-semitic comments at the group. Needless to say, the group had done nothing to provoke it. These wonderful people were just there with their young kids, having a lovely holiday ceremony with donuts and cocoa, and they had to put up with that crap! I've been to many, many Christmas events and never once encountered that kind of thing directed at Christians.

The irony is that the rabbi's comments before the lighting included an attack on anti-Muslim bigotry. He was preaching tolerance of other religions as a fundamental Jewish value, even as his people were being subjected to the hate of strangers based on their faith. They all pretended they didn't even hear the slurs, which showed a level of dignified endurance I couldn't have mustered in their place -- it's a good thing I didn't have a gun, because I was murderously angry and ashamed.

To be clear, the people who shouted anti-semitism were in a small minority. Hundreds of cars drove by quietly or with a friendly honk of support, and we goyim were well represented at the ceremony, too, including a Christian state legislator who lit one of the flames. The days of broad anti-Jewish sentiment are mercifully in the past. But I've got to admit I was surprised it still exists to the level it does. If it had been just one hateful passer-by, I might have written it off as bad luck with a one-in-a-million jackass. But two of them in just a half hour suggests much more persistent bigotry than I'd appreciated. And that's in a distinctly liberal state with a Jewish population twice the national average. If we still have such anti-semitism, it's probably even more common elsewhere.

I just don't get this. As irrational as all group hatreds are, I can at least see how some of it is sustained. For example, Muslims are carrying out a disproportionate share of terrorist attacks these days. Latinos often represent an unfamiliar, as-yet-little-assimilated minority in this country. Blacks are involved in a disproportionate share of violent crimes. None of that excuses the bigotry, but I at least grasp fundamentally where it's coming from and how it gets sustained. Anti-semitism, in Western nations at least, is a different matter entirely. We're talking about hating a highly-assimilated, educated, productive, tolerant group, disproportionately involved in humanitarian and civic efforts and little represented among the criminal class. I can't think of a single Jew I've ever met in real life with whom I didn't get along well -- which is something I couldn't say about Christians, atheists, or almost any other group. Even from an anti-religion perspective like mine, where all religion seems a bit foolish and the Old Testament is horrifying, Jews are a group I can appreciate, in that they're often allies in defending the wall between church and state. How people can generate and sustain hate against such a group is a puzzle to me.
Anti-Semitic acts are the most common hate crime in the United States and the number of anti-Semitic attacks have almost doubled in the U.K.

Today, the FBI released its annual hate crimes statistics for 2012. And the results are nearly the same as they were for 2011, except in Black hate crimes against Whites, which are up 30%. Jews are still the victims of nearly two-thirds of all religion-based hate crimes in America. Muslims only about ten percent.

http://www.debbieschlussel.com/6747...e-hate-crimes-growing-fast-muslims-only-11-6/

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/ukn...-soared-94-last-year-police-figures-show.html
 
Anti-Semitic acts are the most common hate crime in the United States and the number of anti-Semitic attacks have almost doubled in the U.K.

Today, the FBI released its annual hate crimes statistics for 2012. And the results are nearly the same as they were for 2011, except in Black hate crimes against Whites, which are up 30%. Jews are still the victims of nearly two-thirds of all religion-based hate crimes in America. Muslims only about ten percent.

http://www.debbieschlussel.com/6747...e-hate-crimes-growing-fast-muslims-only-11-6/

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/ukn...-soared-94-last-year-police-figures-show.html
It's baffling to me. If ever there were a group that was hard to hate, it would be modern Jews in Western nations. I mean, I get where the middle-eastern hate of Jews is coming from -- it doesn't excuse hating individuals, but at least the abuses by Israel are an understandable source of that anger. But here in the US, or in the UK, it's just bizarre.
 
My family's closest friends are Jewish, so we occasionally are involved in Jewish events -- bar and mat mitzvah's, etc. So, over the weekend, we went to a menorah lighting with our friends (basically, standing on a street corner with a bunch of people in yarmulkes lighting a giant candelabra). During the ceremony two separate cars drove by, rolled down their windows, and shouted anti-semitic comments at the group.

As you've said on many occasions, you live in a highly "enlightened" community full of left-wing, Obama worshiping Democrats. This should come as no surprise to you, unless you think several people drove all the way from one of those horrible red states to yell at your Jewish "friends"...
 
Much anti-Semitism is motivated by the mistaken belief that the world's banking industry is largely controlled by people of Jewish descent. The great international Jewish banking conspiracy, in short. You have some of those posters right here on Political Jack.
 
I get where the middle-eastern hate of Jews is coming from -- it doesn't excuse hating individuals, but at least the abuses by Israel are an understandable source of that anger.

You "get" it the way John Kerry "gets" the Charlie Hebdo terrorists.
 
My family's closest friends are Jewish, so we occasionally are involved in Jewish events -- bar and mat mitzvah's, etc. So, over the weekend, we went to a menorah lighting with our friends (basically, standing on a street corner with a bunch of people in yarmulkes lighting a giant candelabra). During the ceremony two separate cars drove by, rolled down their windows, and shouted anti-semitic comments at the group. Needless to say, the group had done nothing to provoke it. These wonderful people were just there with their young kids, having a lovely holiday ceremony with donuts and cocoa, and they had to put up with that crap! I've been to many, many Christmas events and never once encountered that kind of thing directed at Christians.

The irony is that the rabbi's comments before the lighting included an attack on anti-Muslim bigotry. He was preaching tolerance of other religions as a fundamental Jewish value, even as his people were being subjected to the hate of strangers based on their faith. They all pretended they didn't even hear the slurs, which showed a level of dignified endurance I couldn't have mustered in their place -- it's a good thing I didn't have a gun, because I was murderously angry and ashamed.

To be clear, the people who shouted anti-semitism were in a small minority. Hundreds of cars drove by quietly or with a friendly honk of support, and we goyim were well represented at the ceremony, too, including a Christian state legislator who lit one of the flames. The days of broad anti-Jewish sentiment are mercifully in the past. But I've got to admit I was surprised it still exists to the level it does. If it had been just one hateful passer-by, I might have written it off as bad luck with a one-in-a-million jackass. But two of them in just a half hour suggests much more persistent bigotry than I'd appreciated. And that's in a distinctly liberal state with a Jewish population twice the national average. If we still have such anti-semitism, it's probably even more common elsewhere.

I just don't get this. As irrational as all group hatreds are, I can at least see how some of it is sustained. For example, Muslims are carrying out a disproportionate share of terrorist attacks these days. Latinos often represent an unfamiliar, as-yet-little-assimilated minority in this country. Blacks are involved in a disproportionate share of violent crimes. None of that excuses the bigotry, but I at least grasp fundamentally where it's coming from and how it gets sustained. Anti-semitism, in Western nations at least, is a different matter entirely. We're talking about hating a highly-assimilated, educated, productive, tolerant group, disproportionately involved in humanitarian and civic efforts and little represented among the criminal class. I can't think of a single Jew I've ever met in real life with whom I didn't get along well -- which is something I couldn't say about Christians, atheists, or almost any other group. Even from an anti-religion perspective like mine, where all religion seems a bit foolish and the Old Testament is horrifying, Jews are a group I can appreciate, in that they're often allies in defending the wall between church and state. How people can generate and sustain hate against such a group is a puzzle to me.



Speaking of anti-semitism.....


The National Women’s Studies Association has voted by a huge majority to join the worldwide Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel.

Their annual conference passed the measure by a 653-86 vote, and their full membership of 12,000 will vote on it in the next two months.

That means the NWSA is on the verge of becoming the fifth American academic association to boycott Israel since April 2013. It began then with the Association for Asian American Studies, and since that time the American Studies Association, the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association, the American Anthropological Association, and now the NWSA have joined in.

The BDS movement is linked to the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas, and other radical and terror-supporting groups. Its aim is to “solve” the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by putting an end to Israel. Its leader are quite explicit about that.

For example, As’ad Abu Khalil: “Justice and freedom for the Palestinians are incompatible with the existence of the State of Israel.” Or Ahmed Moor: “OK, fine. So BDS does mean the end of the Jewish state…. In other words, BDS is not another step on the way to the final showdown; BDS is The Final Showdown.”



Complete text: https://pjmedia.com/blog/feminist-academics-join-destroy-israel-movement


Perhaps a slightly bigger deal then some yahoos name-calling from a car passing by......
 
Much anti-Semitism is motivated by the mistaken belief that the world's banking industry is largely controlled by people of Jewish descent. The great international Jewish banking conspiracy, in short. You have some of those posters right here on Political Jack.

Presumably it will get worse as capitalism's crisis deepens and the right seeks a scapegoat to sacrifice in the place of the (gentile) bankers and industrialists.
 
As you've said on many occasions, you live in a highly "enlightened" community full of left-wing, Obama worshiping Democrats. This should come as no surprise to you, unless you think several people drove all the way from one of those horrible red states to yell at your Jewish "friends"...
It wouldn't have come as a surprise to me, at all, in some other states -- the kind that had be be dragged kicking and screaming by the federal government, first from slavery then from Jim Crow.... the kind that, even today, tend to reward politicians who pitch their message to bigots, and that come out on top in almost any attempt to quantify racism (e.g., by number of racist Google searches or racist tweets.) But with Massachusetts we're not talking about the land of George Wallace, Trent Lott, Jesse Helms, and Strom Thurmond. If such anti-semitism is rampant even here, that's really saying something.
 
Much anti-Semitism is motivated by the mistaken belief that the world's banking industry is largely controlled by people of Jewish descent. The great international Jewish banking conspiracy, in short. You have some of those posters right here on Political Jack.
That form of the hatred goes way back, too. It's basically a way of dementing class consciousness and turning it into something less threatening to the aristocracy -- just a another form of ethnic bigotry. It would be dangerous to the aristocracy if there were united resentment of the economic elite by the masses, but if you can turn economic envy by many of them into nutty anti-semitic conspiracy theories, you fracture the force of that class consciousness, while venting much of it against the non-elite.
 
Speaking of anti-semitism.....


The National Women’s Studies Association has voted by a huge majority to join the worldwide Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel.

Their annual conference passed the measure by a 653-86 vote, and their full membership of 12,000 will vote on it in the next two months.

That means the NWSA is on the verge of becoming the fifth American academic association to boycott Israel since April 2013. It began then with the Association for Asian American Studies, and since that time the American Studies Association, the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association, the American Anthropological Association, and now the NWSA have joined in.

The BDS movement is linked to the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas, and other radical and terror-supporting groups. Its aim is to “solve” the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by putting an end to Israel. Its leader are quite explicit about that.

For example, As’ad Abu Khalil: “Justice and freedom for the Palestinians are incompatible with the existence of the State of Israel.” Or Ahmed Moor: “OK, fine. So BDS does mean the end of the Jewish state…. In other words, BDS is not another step on the way to the final showdown; BDS is The Final Showdown.”



Complete text: https://pjmedia.com/blog/feminist-academics-join-destroy-israel-movement


Perhaps a slightly bigger deal then some yahoos name-calling from a car passing by......
You seem to have shared the wrong text. You prefaced you cut-and-paste job with something suggesting you were going to address anti-semitism, but instead addressed a movement to bring economic pressure to bear to encourage a country to behave more lawfully. You seem to be confusing anti-semitism with anti-Israel. That would be like saying that those who support sanctions on Myanmar are anti-Buddhist, or those who support sanctions on Iran are anti-Muslim.
 
You seem to have shared the wrong text. You prefaced you cut-and-paste job with something suggesting you were going to address anti-semitism, but instead addressed a movement to bring economic pressure to bear to encourage a country to behave more lawfully. You seem to be confusing anti-semitism with anti-Israel. That would be like saying that those who support sanctions on Myanmar are anti-Buddhist, or those who support sanctions on Iran are anti-Muslim.


No, I was spot on. You appear to have failed to correctly comprehended its meaning.
 
You seem to have shared the wrong text. You prefaced you cut-and-paste job with something suggesting you were going to address anti-semitism, but instead addressed a movement to bring economic pressure to bear to encourage a country to behave more lawfully. You seem to be confusing anti-semitism with anti-Israel. That would be like saying that those who support sanctions on Myanmar are anti-Buddhist, or those who support sanctions on Iran are anti-Muslim.

HUH????????????

"addressed a movement to bring economic pressure to bear to encourage a country to behave more lawfully."

Seriously?

Please be patient, work with me here, I want to understand this correctly;

Soooo, basically we were actually provided with the aim of this group, the group whose aim YOU claim is to "encourage" a country to, "behave more lawfully", but THEIR LEADERS say is, "to “solve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by putting an end to Israel".................... AND, say that, "Justice and freedom for the Palestinians are incompatible with the existence of the State of Israel.” ..........................AND, “OK, fine. So BDS does mean the end of the Jewish state…. BDS is The Final Showdown.”

Based upon this we have read, seeing the actual goals of this group, as stated by it's leaders, what country in the history of countries on this earth would, SHOULD, feel compelled to even attempt to behave as these people desire? That is to say, if a group says their goal is the elimination of a country what could they possibly do to actually encourage that country to behave "more lawfully"?

We have here a group who openly states they seek to eliminate a country yet the way they are attempting to do what it is they told us they want to do, THAT is seen as, defined by you as, merely encouraging a country to behave more lawfully?

That about size it up?

Oh, and least we forget, there is also THIS little hidden jewel in there;

"Its aim is to “solve” the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by putting an end to Israel."

Let us all ponder on that a bit, shall we?

That is some pretty deep sh it, is it not? Think about it...............the simple genius of it all...............

What conflict in the WORLD could not be resolved with the simple elimination of one of the involved parties?!?!?!?!?!


I'm all in, you? If we are going to support these clabberheads in their quest, lets do so with ALL conflicts. Lets support the elimination of one party and be done with it, makes perfect sense.............right?
 
HUH????????????

"addressed a movement to bring economic pressure to bear to encourage a country to behave more lawfully."

Seriously?

Yes, seriously. I'm referring to the action of the National Women’s Studies Association . If you have some evidence that they're aiming at other goals with their boycott, please feel free to share. But, realize, that I'm not going to impute to them motives of others who are also boycotting.
 
in America, anti-Semitism is a proxy for class warfare.

anti-Semitism is most virulent in

- the inner city, where blacks assume "jewish moneylenders" are the reason they can't get loans - not their crappy fico scores
- "patriots/survivalists" - who take a rather hard line stance against blacks, Hispanics, muslims, jews, new Yorkers, and "the media"
- politicians of either party who hope to perpetually hold onto power by playing into the views of those constituents identified above.
 
Yes, seriously. I'm referring to the action of the National Women’s Studies Association . If you have some evidence that they're aiming at other goals with their boycott, please feel free to share. But, realize, that I'm not going to impute to them motives of others who are also boycotting.

" I'm referring to the action of the National Women’s Studies Association ."

As was I;
"The National Women’s Studies Association has voted by a huge majority to join the worldwide Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel."

That would be the same BDS I spoke about previously.

So we have the BDS whose leaders OPENLY STATE;

1) "Its aim is to “solve” the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by putting an end to Israel"

2) “Justice and freedom for the Palestinians are incompatible with the existence of the State of Israel.”

3) “OK, fine. So BDS does mean the end of the Jewish state…

AND we have,
The National Women’s Studies Association has voted by a huge majority to join the worldwide Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel."

What would this tell any REASONABLE human being concerning their motives?
Why WOULD one join a group whose goals are well known and openly stated if NOT because they share such goals?

But it is ok, I understand. Damned if I would want to have to try to defend and protect those who knowing join such hate groups. You do it as well as anyone I suppose......

I'll bet you could do equally as well defending those who join the KKK but tell people they ar not doing so because they agree with the known goals of the group, huh?

(Ok, "could" but we both know you "would" not. Your hypocrisy has its bounds.)
 
" I'm referring to the action of the National Women’s Studies Association ."

As was I;
"The National Women’s Studies Association has voted by a huge majority to join the worldwide Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel."

That would be the same BDS I spoke about previously.

Yes. And the question is whether you have any evidence that the National Women's Studies Association has motivations for doing so beyond what I stated.

Perhaps this will help you. In December 1941, the United States joined the existing coalition fighting against the Axis. Among the motives of other leading figures in that coalition was preserving and promoting international communism. Based on that, can we conclude that the US joined that coalition in order to preserve and promote international communism? Of course not. We joined in order to defeat the fascist regimes of Japan, Germany, and Italy, not with the other motivations of our communist allies. In the same sense, a person or organization can choose to boycott Israel without having all the goals of any other person in a position of leadership within the coalition that is engaging in that boycott. Do you see your error yet?
 
Back
Top