Arkady
President
This came up in the context of a political argument, but it's really more of a math issue. The question is, if you're playing one-on-one basketball, and you're the better player, should you prefer "make-it-take-it" rules (a player who scores takes the ball out again to start the next possession), or standard rules (after someone scores, it's his opponent's turn to have a possession), strictly in terms of maximizing your chance of winning.
Obviously, not every game is won by the better player. If the players are fairly evenly matched, a few lucky bounces can hand a game to the weaker player. So, the question I posed is essentially a question of how to set up the game rules to minimize the role of luck in the contest (since the less luck factors in, the more likely you, the stronger player, will win). I would have thought that standard rules were better at that, since it cuts down on streaks (a lucky shot leading to the player getting another chance to make a lucky shot). And maybe that's the way it would work out in the real world, where human psychology is at play (and where relative strengths at offense and defense would matter, not just overall strength). But, to my surprise, it doesn't seem to play out that way in the realm of pure numbers.
Here's how I set it up as a simulation. I had a computer play 100,000 games, each of exactly 100 possessions (more like a full 5-on-5 game than 1-on-1, but I was looking for big numbers to generate reliable stats). The game was very simple. Each "player" picked a random number between 0 and 1. But to simulate one player being more skillful than the other, one multiplied his result by 5.1, while the other multiplied his by 4.9. Whoever had the higher number won that "possession." The game starts with a random choice for possession of the ball, and if the team with possession wins the number comparison, he scores a point and gets the ball again for the next possession. If not, nobody scores and the other team gets the ball for the next possession. After 100 total possessions, the points are totaled for each player, to find the winner.
After running the game that way 100,000 times, I changed the rules, so that now if a player with possession won the number comparison, he got the point, but the OTHER player got the next possession, with the rules otherwise being the same. Then I ran 100,000 versions of that game.
Anyway, as I said, the results surprised me. After 20 million total possessions, the computer indicated that the first version of the game ("make-it-take-it"), the stronger player won 63.368% of the games, whereas with standard rules he won 61.589%. In other words, the ability to "streak" to multiple points on consecutive possessions actually benefited the stronger player, rather than acting as a wildcard in favor of the weaker player.
I'm wondering if anyone here has the stats skills to prove or disprove that result, or the programming skills to replicate the experiment through some other method to test my conclusion. It only took me maybe 30 minutes to set up and run the experiment, so it needn't be a big time suck. Thanks for any help someone can provide.
Anyway, if you're curious how this comes up in the political context, it's around the question of how important skill is, versus luck, in economic success. My argument is that how important it is depends on how the system is set up -- that even superficially neutral rules may actually increase or decrease the role of luck in a game. An extreme version can be seen by imagining a game of 1-on-1 where two player compete to be the first to reach 10 points, but first they roll a die and they start with however many points they roll (meaning the luckier player could start with as much as a five point lead, before the ball is even put in play). It's a superficially neutral rule, but it would make the game much worse at showing which player is actually better at basketball, and it would result in weaker/lazier players winning more often than they would without that variation. The make-it-take-it variation, apparently, works the other way: making the better player win more often than he otherwise would. My idea is that our economic system should be designed with an eye to trying to minimize the role of luck (whether it's the luck of being born into a rich family, or the luck of a literal or figurative lottery hit), so that the harder workers and more skillful people tend to come out ahead more often.
Obviously, not every game is won by the better player. If the players are fairly evenly matched, a few lucky bounces can hand a game to the weaker player. So, the question I posed is essentially a question of how to set up the game rules to minimize the role of luck in the contest (since the less luck factors in, the more likely you, the stronger player, will win). I would have thought that standard rules were better at that, since it cuts down on streaks (a lucky shot leading to the player getting another chance to make a lucky shot). And maybe that's the way it would work out in the real world, where human psychology is at play (and where relative strengths at offense and defense would matter, not just overall strength). But, to my surprise, it doesn't seem to play out that way in the realm of pure numbers.
Here's how I set it up as a simulation. I had a computer play 100,000 games, each of exactly 100 possessions (more like a full 5-on-5 game than 1-on-1, but I was looking for big numbers to generate reliable stats). The game was very simple. Each "player" picked a random number between 0 and 1. But to simulate one player being more skillful than the other, one multiplied his result by 5.1, while the other multiplied his by 4.9. Whoever had the higher number won that "possession." The game starts with a random choice for possession of the ball, and if the team with possession wins the number comparison, he scores a point and gets the ball again for the next possession. If not, nobody scores and the other team gets the ball for the next possession. After 100 total possessions, the points are totaled for each player, to find the winner.
After running the game that way 100,000 times, I changed the rules, so that now if a player with possession won the number comparison, he got the point, but the OTHER player got the next possession, with the rules otherwise being the same. Then I ran 100,000 versions of that game.
Anyway, as I said, the results surprised me. After 20 million total possessions, the computer indicated that the first version of the game ("make-it-take-it"), the stronger player won 63.368% of the games, whereas with standard rules he won 61.589%. In other words, the ability to "streak" to multiple points on consecutive possessions actually benefited the stronger player, rather than acting as a wildcard in favor of the weaker player.
I'm wondering if anyone here has the stats skills to prove or disprove that result, or the programming skills to replicate the experiment through some other method to test my conclusion. It only took me maybe 30 minutes to set up and run the experiment, so it needn't be a big time suck. Thanks for any help someone can provide.
Anyway, if you're curious how this comes up in the political context, it's around the question of how important skill is, versus luck, in economic success. My argument is that how important it is depends on how the system is set up -- that even superficially neutral rules may actually increase or decrease the role of luck in a game. An extreme version can be seen by imagining a game of 1-on-1 where two player compete to be the first to reach 10 points, but first they roll a die and they start with however many points they roll (meaning the luckier player could start with as much as a five point lead, before the ball is even put in play). It's a superficially neutral rule, but it would make the game much worse at showing which player is actually better at basketball, and it would result in weaker/lazier players winning more often than they would without that variation. The make-it-take-it variation, apparently, works the other way: making the better player win more often than he otherwise would. My idea is that our economic system should be designed with an eye to trying to minimize the role of luck (whether it's the luck of being born into a rich family, or the luck of a literal or figurative lottery hit), so that the harder workers and more skillful people tend to come out ahead more often.