New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Anything wrong with that sentence?

Barbella

Senator
“Anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation—that is what it means to have laws and to have a country.”

If so, I don't see it. Does anyone? And if so, care to explain?

And while you're at it, want to deal with this part, too? Or is it "RACIST" to even TALK about these very real concerns?

“Not everyone who seeks to join our country will be able to successfully assimilate.”

Whether we are measuring by economic success, criminal offenses, national security threats, or contributions to the arts and sciences—not all immigrants are equal. Not all immigration sources are equal either. Eighty-three percent of immigrants from India arrive with a college degree or higher, as compared to only 13 percent of immigrants from Latin America. These effects persist over two and three generations. Refugees from the communist crackdown in Hungary in 1956 have flourished in America. More than a quarter century after they began to arrive in America, Somali refugees have not.

First-generation Japanese immigrants committed crimes at rates much lower than that of other Americans; Mexican immigrants have historically offended at elevated rates. Why is any of this surprising? Nobody who valued the protections of a welfare state would voluntarily migrate from France to the United States—but a person with a billion-dollar idea very well might. The opposite would be true from a country like Brazil.

“Most illegal immigrants are lower-skilled workers with less education who compete directly against vulnerable American workers, and that these illegal workers draw much more out from the system than they will ever pay in.”

Low-income workers in the United States receive much more in benefits and transfers than they pay in taxes, especially if they live past age 65. Upper-income people will pay much more than they receive. That’s how the system is designed in every advanced society. What it means, however, is that loose talk about needing immigrants to solve the problems of, for example, Medicare is like the old joke about losing money on every sale but trying to make it up on volume.

Many of these redistributive programs are available to illegal immigrants too, especially the programs financed by state taxes. Illegal immigrants send their children to public schools. They use public clinics, roads, and prisons. They are eligible for per-child tax credits—and often receive the Earned Income Tax Credit. These are all exhaustively documented facts. Plans to put millions of illegal immigrants on a path to citizenship—and thus Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Section 8 housing, and so on—will cost billions more. Those costs don’t go away because proponents think it is somehow bad form to mention them.

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...cking-about-trumps-immigration-speech/498386/
 
Last edited:
“Anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation—that is what it means to have laws and to have a country.”

If so, I don't see it. Does anyone? And if so, care to explain?
It's just amazing to me that in my own lifetime we've gone from borders being a no brainer to borders being a racist tool of the Man.
 
“Anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation—that is what it means to have laws and to have a country.”

Agreed in principle. If a person wants to become an american citizen, go thru the proper protocols. Period.

jmo
 
Superb article. I can't wait to see a principled and logical response from the left.
 
“Anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation—that is what it means to have laws and to have a country.”

If so, I don't see it. Does anyone? And if so, care to explain?

And while you're at it, want to deal with this part, too? Or is it "RACIST" to even TALK about these very real concerns?

“Not everyone who seeks to join our country will be able to successfully assimilate.”

Whether we are measuring by economic success, criminal offenses, national security threats, or contributions to the arts and sciences—not all immigrants are equal. Not all immigration sources are equal either. Eighty-three percent of immigrants from India arrive with a college degree or higher, as compared to only 13 percent of immigrants from Latin America. These effects persist over two and three generations. Refugees from the communist crackdown in Hungary in 1956 have flourished in America. More than a quarter century after they began to arrive in America, Somali refugees have not.

First-generation Japanese immigrants committed crimes at rates much lower than that of other Americans; Mexican immigrants have historically offended at elevated rates. Why is any of this surprising? Nobody who valued the protections of a welfare state would voluntarily migrate from France to the United States—but a person with a billion-dollar idea very well might. The opposite would be true from a country like Brazil.

“Most illegal immigrants are lower-skilled workers with less education who compete directly against vulnerable American workers, and that these illegal workers draw much more out from the system than they will ever pay in.”

Low-income workers in the United States receive much more in benefits and transfers than they pay in taxes, especially if they live past age 65. Upper-income people will pay much more than they receive. That’s how the system is designed in every advanced society. What it means, however, is that loose talk about needing immigrants to solve the problems of, for example, Medicare is like the old joke about losing money on every sale but trying to make it up on volume.

Many of these redistributive programs are available to illegal immigrants too, especially the programs financed by state taxes. Illegal immigrants send their children to public schools. They use public clinics, roads, and prisons. They are eligible for per-child tax credits—and often receive the Earned Income Tax Credit. These are all exhaustively documented facts. Plans to put millions of illegal immigrants on a path to citizenship—and thus Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Section 8 housing, and so on—will cost billions more. Those costs don’t go away because proponents think it is somehow bad form to mention them.

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...cking-about-trumps-immigration-speech/498386/
Hillacaust Denial

OMG! Libby snobs at The Atlantic have fallen under the spell of Trump! Batten down the hatches, Demwits! The Trumpicane is coming to blow you to smithereens! Hide Ms. Rodham in the basement with Mata Huma!
 
“Anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation—that is what it means to have laws and to have a country.”

If so, I don't see it. Does anyone? And if so, care to explain?

And while you're at it, want to deal with this part, too? Or is it "RACIST" to even TALK about these very real concerns?

“Not everyone who seeks to join our country will be able to successfully assimilate.”

Whether we are measuring by economic success, criminal offenses, national security threats, or contributions to the arts and sciences—not all immigrants are equal. Not all immigration sources are equal either. Eighty-three percent of immigrants from India arrive with a college degree or higher, as compared to only 13 percent of immigrants from Latin America. These effects persist over two and three generations. Refugees from the communist crackdown in Hungary in 1956 have flourished in America. More than a quarter century after they began to arrive in America, Somali refugees have not.

First-generation Japanese immigrants committed crimes at rates much lower than that of other Americans; Mexican immigrants have historically offended at elevated rates. Why is any of this surprising? Nobody who valued the protections of a welfare state would voluntarily migrate from France to the United States—but a person with a billion-dollar idea very well might. The opposite would be true from a country like Brazil.

“Most illegal immigrants are lower-skilled workers with less education who compete directly against vulnerable American workers, and that these illegal workers draw much more out from the system than they will ever pay in.”

Low-income workers in the United States receive much more in benefits and transfers than they pay in taxes, especially if they live past age 65. Upper-income people will pay much more than they receive. That’s how the system is designed in every advanced society. What it means, however, is that loose talk about needing immigrants to solve the problems of, for example, Medicare is like the old joke about losing money on every sale but trying to make it up on volume.

Many of these redistributive programs are available to illegal immigrants too, especially the programs financed by state taxes. Illegal immigrants send their children to public schools. They use public clinics, roads, and prisons. They are eligible for per-child tax credits—and often receive the Earned Income Tax Credit. These are all exhaustively documented facts. Plans to put millions of illegal immigrants on a path to citizenship—and thus Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Section 8 housing, and so on—will cost billions more. Those costs don’t go away because proponents think it is somehow bad form to mention them.

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...cking-about-trumps-immigration-speech/498386/
...what's wrong with it is that Trump said it. Who knows if he meant it? Could it be sarcasm? He does that you know. Could he change it by later saying that's not what he said, he said (___fill in the blank) ? Probably.
 
...what's wrong with it is that Trump said it. Who knows if he meant it? Could it be sarcasm? He does that you know. Could he change it by later saying that's not what he said, he said (___fill in the blank) ? Probably.

So then there's nothing wrong with it. I agree.
 
“Anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation—that is what it means to have laws and to have a country.”

If so, I don't see it. Does anyone? And if so, care to explain?

The thing is, we can't deport citizens, but if we could, we'd probably try it.

I do have a problem with this underlined sentence from your posted article:

First-generation Japanese immigrants committed crimes at rates much lower than that of other Americans; Mexican immigrants have historically offended at elevated rates.​

since I know undocumented immigrant Mexicans create less crime than the native born, but fortunately the author of your article has a link to this passage:

Likewise, in the 1920's, Mexicans had elevated violent crime rates, while Japanese entrants did not.​

from a book titled The Rise and Fall of Violent Crime in America. I guess the author didn't know what the book was called, and if the author did know, even better not to mention it.

From that I take it violent crime is on the downswing, a meme Arkady often promotes.
 
Last edited:
Whether we are measuring by economic success, criminal offenses, national security threats, or contributions to the arts and sciences—not all immigrants are equal.

I wonder if anyone thinks all people are equal, immigrant or not?
 
About this paragraph from the article with Barbella's bolding:

Many of these redistributive programs are available to illegal immigrants too, especially the programs financed by state taxes. Illegal immigrants send their children to public schools. They use public clinics, roads, and prisons. They are eligible for per-child tax credits—and often receive the Earned Income Tax Credit. These are all exhaustively documented facts.Plans to put millions of illegal immigrants on a path to citizenship—and thus Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Section 8 housing, and so on—will cost billions more. Those costs don’t go away because proponents think it is somehow bad form to mention them.​

Doesn't one need to pay taxes to get an earned income credit?

If so, and the undocumented immigrants are paying taxes, wouldn't it be wise and, more importantly, just to put them on a path to citizenship?
 
I do generally agree with this paragraph:

“Most illegal immigrants are lower-skilled workers with less education who compete directly against vulnerable American workers, and that these illegal workers draw much more out from the system than they will ever pay in.”​

except for the fact no one knows if an undocumented worker will draw more out of the system than pay in.
 
Given many work for cash, it's an easy bet they'll draw out more than pay in.

Some, perhaps.

Nevertheless, I imagine there are some who are paid via paycheck with taxes removed and who pay more in taxes than they receive in the way of benefits.

In any case, the real criminal in your scenario is the employer who knowingly hired an undocumented worker. By the way, I have an idea that would put an end to that criminal practice in a short period of time.


False:

The Mythical Connection Between Immigrants and Crime

Newcomers to the U.S. are less likely than the native population to commit violent crimes or be incarcerated.
​

http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-mythical-connection-between-immigrants-and-crime-1436916798
 
Last edited:
Everything Trump advocates is really nothing more than enforce our existing laws. There is nothing racist about enforcing border laws, every country does it.
 
Some, perhaps.

Nevertheless, I imagine there are some who are paid via paycheck with taxes removed and who pay more in taxes than they receive in the way of benefits.

In any case, the real criminal in your scenario is the employer who knowingly hired an undocumented worker. By the way, I have an idea that would put an end to that criminal practice in a short period of time.



False:

The Mythical Connection Between Immigrants and Crime

Newcomers to the U.S. are less likely than the native population to commit violent crimes or be incarcerated.
​

http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-mythical-connection-between-immigrants-and-crime-1436916798

Yes, hopefully most people who work and pay taxes pay in more than they take out. But given illegal aliens, if we are talking those who pay taxes, are likely to learn lower wages and thus get welfare subsidies via EIC and other programs, I suspect they're a net loss.

I am fine with going after employers who hire illegals. Why isn't it happening?

Finally, your WSJ article talks about "immigrants". The article I posted is specific to ILLEGAL immigrants. I know you leftists have trouble distinguishing between the two, but there is a difference. So my article stands as fact.
 
In any case, the real criminal in your scenario is the employer who knowingly hired an undocumented worker. By the way, I have an idea that would put an end to that criminal practice in a short period of time.
Treason Is Not a Property Right. Patriots Call for Forfeiture Without Compensation.

What is your solution? Mine is to confiscate the business of anyone who hires an illegal and immediately sell it to a patriot. I'd even give citizenship to an illegal who participated in the sting.

Also, anyone who can't speak English is illegal. Perfectionism leads to paralysis, which is the true intention of the xenophiles who want to hamstring enforcement by silly what-ifs.
 
Back
Top