New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

are cops constitutional?

WhistleBlower

Council Member
police state is a term one hears and sees more and more as a description of what america is becoming. here is a scholarly work describing how we got here.

Seton Hall Constitutional L.J. 2001, 685
ARE COPS CONSTITUTIONAL?
Roger Roots*
ABSTRACT
Police work is often lionized by jurists and scholars who claim to employ "textualist" and "originalist" methods of constitutional interpretation. Yet professional police were unknown to the United States in 1789, and first appeared in America almost a half-century after the Constitution's ratification. The Framers contemplated law enforcement as the duty of mostly private citizens, along with a few constables and sheriffs who could be called upon when necessary. This article marshals extensive historical and legal evidence to show that modern policing is in many ways inconsistent with the original intent of America's founding documents. The author argues that the growth of modern policing has substantially empowered the state in a way the Framers would regard as abhorrent to their foremost principles.
* Roger Isaac Roots, J.D., M.C.J., graduated from Roger Williams University School of Law in 1999, Roger Williams University School of Justice Studies in 2001, and Montana State University-Billings (B.S., Sociology) in 1995. He is a former federal prisoner and founder of the Prison Crisis Project, a not-for-profit law and policy think tank based in Providence, Rhode Island. He is grateful to Duane Horton of Portsmouth, Rhode Island for his scrupulous proof-reading efforts and thoughtful insights.
http://hourofthetime.com/1-LF/AreCopsConstitutional.pdf
 
The Police started as protecters of the Rich in all countries, the thing is we can now not do without them but absolutly, I think here even they are beginning to question who they are working for and what their job has become.
 
No. Strictly speaking, neither is a standing army nor voting rights for non-whites or females. Anyone who claims to be a Constitutional "originalist" is blowing smoke up your ass for a specific reason that has little to do with original intent.
 
No. Strictly speaking, neither is a standing army nor voting rights for non-whites or females. Anyone who claims to be a Constitutional "originalist" is blowing smoke up your ass for a specific reason that has little to do with original intent.

The standing Army is sanctioned (the current means of appropriating money for that Army is not), as is the Navy. Voting whites for non-whites are constitutional because they were placed there via an amendment, as were voting rights for women.

Anyone claiming the document has no original intent is blowing smoke up your ass for a specific reason that has little to do with respecting the Constitution.
 
"Pussy White Cops???"

Cid and I were just discussing that very issue!

(We have the solution, too! Call 'em names, and everything works out for the better!)
 
The standing Army is sanctioned (the current means of appropriating money for that Army is not), as is the Navy. Voting whites for non-whites are constitutional because they were placed there via an amendment, as were voting rights for women.

Anyone claiming the document has no original intent is blowing smoke up your ass for a specific reason that has little to do with respecting the Constitution.

That argument might fly...except most "Originalists" also throw in "As the Founders intended".

Well, given they wrote the thing they had NO "intentions" of giving women the right to vote, did they? Or they could have easily included it in the Bill of Rights (the first 10 AMENDMENTS).

Originalists want it both ways....both to "do as the Founders wanted" AND claim that they are not opposed to POPULAR updated civil rights that occured over a CENTURY after the last "Founder" died.
 
That argument might fly...except most "Originalists" also throw in "As the Founders intended".

Well, given they wrote the thing they had NO "intentions" of giving women the right to vote, did they? Or they could have easily included it in the Bill of Rights (the first 10 AMENDMENTS).

Originalists want it both ways....both to "do as the Founders wanted" AND claim that they are not opposed to POPULAR updated civil rights that occured over a CENTURY after the last "Founder" died.

Originalists want what the founders intended, a government that obeys its own laws as set forth in the Constitution. Among the things set forth in the Constitution is the amendment process and the means to change the document -- once the document is changed, it is changed. The civil rights were placed into the Constitution as the founder's intended, via the amendment process. One of the majestic beauties of the Constitution is that its creators built into it the capacity for this sort of change.

As an originalist, I object to no accretion of powers that comes via a ratified constitutional amendment. I object to distortions of the Constitution and accretions of power outside the amendment process.
 
I just realized that I hadn't responded to the original question. Yes, "cops" are constitutional. State and local police aren't federal in nature, and establishing them belongs to the states as one of the rights retained under the 10th Amendment.

The various federal enforcements have largely been with us since the beginning in the form of enforcing customs law, and in regulating interstate trade. They are necessary and proper to the exercise of constitutionally delegated authorities.
 
Originalists want what the founders intended, a government that obeys its own laws as set forth in the Constitution. Among the things set forth in the Constitution is the amendment process and the means to change the document -- once the document is changed, it is changed. The civil rights were placed into the Constitution as the founder's intended, via the amendment process. One of the majestic beauties of the Constitution is that its creators built into it the capacity for this sort of change.

As an originalist, I object to no accretion of powers that comes via a ratified constitutional amendment. I object to distortions of the Constitution and accretions of power outside the amendment process.

trap, if the Founders had INTENDED to give women the vote....what prevented them?
 
trap, if the Founders had INTENDED to give women the vote....what prevented them?

I didn't say they did. I said they recognized that there would be changes in the future, and provided the method for those changes -- they knew that an amendment would change the provisions of the Constitution. Following the document, as amended, is in keeping with the original intent of the document -- to change its structure when necessary, via the amendment process.
 
trap...YOU said- "Originalists want what the founders intended..."

And given NOTHING would have prevented them, they obviously DIDN'T INTEND for women to have the right to vote....

ergo to be an "Originalist"....you would have to SUPPORT the Founders' intention, wouldn't you????
 
trap...YOU said- "Originalists want what the founders intended..."

And given NOTHING would have prevented them, they obviously DIDN'T INTEND for women to have the right to vote....

ergo to be an "Originalist"....you would have to SUPPORT the Founders' intention, wouldn't you????

The founders intended that changes be made to the Constitution using the amendment process. I AM supporting the founders intentions.
 
trap, again....there was NOTHING to prevent the Founders from extending the rights of citizenship to women.....they didn't. Despite TEN amendments to the Constitution at that time which we call the Bill of Rights.

They didn't. Why?....because they INTENDED for women to not be allowed to vote. They were smart guys...I don't think they "forgot" or were saying "Oh, don't worry...ONE HUNDRED AND THIRTY YEARS from now, it'll be fixed. We're just too busy worrying about the poor ladies being being forced to quarter soldiers in their homes."

:D
 
thank you all for your responses, but by them, i can only conclude that nobody has read the essay. here is the first page to get you started :

INTRODUCTION
Uniformed police officers are the most visible element of America's criminal justice system. Their numbers have grown exponentially over the past century and now stand at hundreds of thousands nationwide.1 Police expenses account for the largest segment of most municipal budgets and generally dwarf expenses for fire, trash, and sewer services.2 Neither casual observers nor learned authorities regard the sight of hundreds of armed, uniformed state agents on America's roads and street corners as anything peculiar -- let alone invalid or unconstitutional.
Yet the dissident English colonists who framed the United States Constitution would have seen this modern 'police state' as alien to their foremost principles. Under the criminal justice model known to the Framers, professional police officers were unknown.3 The general public had broad law enforcement powers and only the executive functions of the law (e.g., the execution of writs, warrants and orders) were performed by constables or sheriffs (who might call upon members of the community for assistance).4 Initiation and investigation of criminal cases was the nearly exclusive province of private persons.
At the time of the Constitution's ratification, the office of sheriff was an appointed position, and constables were either elected or drafted from the community to serve without pay.5 Most of their duties involved civil executions rather than criminal law enforcement. The courts of that period were venues for private litigation -- whether civil or criminal -- and the state was rarely a party. Professional police as we know them today originated in American cities during the second quarter of the nineteenth century, when municipal governments drafted citizens to maintain order.6 The role of these "nightly watch" officers gradually grew to encompass the catching of criminals, which had formerly been the responsibility of individual citizens.7
While this historical disconnect is widely known by criminal justice historians, rarely has it been juxtaposed against the Constitution and the Constitution's imposed scheme of criminal justice.8 "Originalist" scholars of the Constitution have tended to be supportive, rather than critical of modern policing.9 This article will show, however, that modern policing violates the Framers' most firmly held conceptions of criminal justice.
The modern police-driven model of law enforcement helps sustain a playing field that is fundamentally uneven for different players upon it. Modern police act as an army of assistants for state prosecutors and gather evidence solely with an eye toward the state's interests. Police seal off crime scenes from the purview of defense investigators, act as witnesses of convenience for the state in courts of law, and instigate a substantial amount of criminal activity under the guise of crime fighting. Additionally, police enforce social class norms and act as tools of empowerment for favored interest groups to the disadvantage of others.10 Police are also a political force that constantly lobbies for increased state power and decreased constitutional liberty for American citizens.

THE CONSTITUTIONAL TEXT
The Constitution contains no explicit provisions for criminal law enforcement.11 Nor did the constitutions of any of the several states contain such provisions at the time of the Founding.12 Early constitutions enunciated the intention that law enforcement was a universal duty that each person owed to the community, rather than a power of the government.13 Founding-era constitutions addressed law enforcement from the standpoint of individual liberties and placed explicit barriers upon the state.14
 
Whistle.....anybody who thinks that police are going to be declared "un-Constitutional"....

has been sniffing too much chem-trail vapor. :)
 
i don't think the author had any such intent. i certainly don't. this is just a look at the history of law enforcement in america, which is pretty dismal if you'll take the time to read the essay.

like the military in the federal budget, municipal police forces are sucking more tax dollars than anything else. that they also suck so much graft in protecting organized crime on top of that is appalling and that they would let themselves be used by big business the way they were to stifle dissent against them is downright frightening.
 
trap, again....there was NOTHING to prevent the Founders from extending the rights of citizenship to women.....they didn't. Despite TEN amendments to the Constitution at that time which we call the Bill of Rights.

They didn't. Why?....because they INTENDED for women to not be allowed to vote. They were smart guys...I don't think they "forgot" or were saying "Oh, don't worry...ONE HUNDRED AND THIRTY YEARS from now, it'll be fixed. We're just too busy worrying about the poor ladies being being forced to quarter soldiers in their homes."

:D

I think you're being obtuse. The founders themselves knew that society would change, that events they could not foresee would happen, and they built into the Constitution a means for dealing with those changes. When I write "I believe we should follow the Constitution as the founder's intended," I recognize that they did not see the Constitution as a static document, but one in which the people could change the system of government via the amendment process.
 
police state is a term one hears and sees more and more as a description of what america is becoming. here is a scholarly work describing how we got here.

Seton Hall Constitutional L.J. 2001, 685
ARE COPS CONSTITUTIONAL?
Roger Roots*
ABSTRACT
Police work is often lionized by jurists and scholars who claim to employ "textualist" and "originalist" methods of constitutional interpretation. Yet professional police were unknown to the United States in 1789, and first appeared in America almost a half-century after the Constitution's ratification. The Framers contemplated law enforcement as the duty of mostly private citizens, along with a few constables and sheriffs who could be called upon when necessary. This article marshals extensive historical and legal evidence to show that modern policing is in many ways inconsistent with the original intent of America's founding documents. The author argues that the growth of modern policing has substantially empowered the state in a way the Framers would regard as abhorrent to their foremost principles.
* Roger Isaac Roots, J.D., M.C.J., graduated from Roger Williams University School of Law in 1999, Roger Williams University School of Justice Studies in 2001, and Montana State University-Billings (B.S., Sociology) in 1995. He is a former federal prisoner and founder of the Prison Crisis Project, a not-for-profit law and policy think tank based in Providence, Rhode Island. He is grateful to Duane Horton of Portsmouth, Rhode Island for his scrupulous proof-reading efforts and thoughtful insights.
http://hourofthetime.com/1-LF/AreCopsConstitutional.pdf




Interesting argument, which is becoming increasingly rare on our little forum. I would point out, however, that professional law enforcement in what would become the United States actually predates out constitution:




the New York City Sheriff has more to do with tow trucks than with gunfights. Established in 1626, the Sheriff's office in Manhattan and its equivalents in the other boroughs served as a major part of the patchwork of law-enforcement agencies that existed before the city's consolidation in 1898.





http://www.nytimes.com/1994/11/27/nyregion/fyi-930393.html
 
Zam-Zam;394209[QUOTE said:
]Interesting argument, which is becoming increasingly rare on our little forum. I would point out, however, that professional law enforcement in what would become the United States actually predates out constitution:

I don't find it that interesting. Law enforcement at the federal level is necessary and proper to the delegated powers (how can you regulate interstate trade or customs without law enforcement officers?). Policing at the state level is a power reserved to "the states or the people" under the 10th Amendment.
 
Back
Top