New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

are cops constitutional?

Interesting argument, which is becoming increasingly rare on our little forum. I would point out, however, that professional law enforcement in what would become the United States actually predates out constitution:


' the New York City Sheriff has more to do with tow trucks than with gunfights. EstablisheD in 1626, the Sheriff's office in Manhattan and its equivalents in the other boroughs served as a major part of the patchwork of law-enforcement agencies that existed before the city's consolidation in 1898.





http://www.nytimes.com/1994/11/27/nyregion/fyi-930393.html

this is actually one of the biggest of the smaller forums that i've stumbled on and one of the most heavily polarized left vs. right

Ive seen.
'
'that may be why you feel there is a dearth of interesting arguments around here because that the whole right vs left schtick is so contrived and played out.
 
Zam-Zam;394209 I don't find it that interesting. Law enforcement at the federal level is necessary and proper to the delegated powers (how can you regulate interstate trade or customs without law enforcement officers?). Policing at the state level is a power reserved to "the states or the people" under the 10th Amendment.[/QUOTE said:
the next time one of my postings isnt that interesting to you, i ll thank you to keep your off topic remarks out of the thread. clearly you did not read the essay.
 
the next time one of my postings isnt that interesting to you, i ll thank you to keep your off topic remarks out of the thread. clearly you did not read the essay.

My comment wasn't off topic. The initial question posted was "Are cops Constitutional?" I answered that question yes, because local policing falls under state authority (the 10th Amendment) and the national policing authorities rest on customs and commerce. A lengthy paper saying otherwise would have to jump through a lot of linguistic hoops to make its case -- and that sort of circumlocution isn't interesting to me.
 
Back
Top