New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Assisted suicide

Boltlady

Governor
I simply do not understand why it should be illegal. Of course there would have to be guidelines so that people couldn't just kill folks they didn't want around anymore, but if a person really doesn't want to live he/she shouldn't have to.

We do have a form of it in that a person can agree in advance that life support and other certain extreme measures should not be used if it is determined that there is no hope. That only comes into play if there is an accident or sudden, unexpected trauma. That's pretty limiting.

There are so many people now racking their brains trying to find ways to cut the world population back to about 20 or 30% of what it is now. Bill Gates says we should only have about 10%.

We go all around the world killing all sorts of people who really didn't want to die and yet we refuse to allow those who really want to a comfortable way to make it happen.
Wouldn't it make a lot of sense to provide a 'service' for those who just don't want to be here anymore?
 
BTW, after I wrote this post, I came across the following. This is an extreme case, and heartbreaking to be sure, but I don't believe that it should even be a requirement. Not wanting to be here anymore should be enough.

British man loses high court battle to end his life

Tony Nicklinson, who is paralysed from the neck down, has described his life as “pure torture” and wept as the verdict was announced.

10 hours ago 8,421 Views 69 Comments Share11 Tweet
Tony Nicklinson with his wife Jane (left) and daughters Beth (right) and Lauren. He says he is "devastated and heartbroken" after losing his High Court battle.
Image: Emma Hallett/PA Wire/Press Association Images
A BRITISH MAN who is paralysed from the neck down has lost his high court battle to end his life of “pure torture” with the help of a doctor.
Tony Nicklinson, who suffers from locked-in syndrome, which has left his body paralysed but his mental faculties intact, wept as the verdict was announced.
“You can see from Tony’s reaction he’s absolutely heartbroken,” said his wife Jane, vowing to continue with their legal fight to ensure that any doctor who helped her 58-year-old husband die would not face a murder charge.
Illegal
Euthanasia and assisted suicide remain illegal in Britain, but an inquiry recommended in January that lawmakers should consider changing the law to let doctors help some terminally ill people end their lives.
A second locked-in syndrome sufferer, who cannot be identified and was referred to in court as “Martin”, also lost his challenge to Britain’s ban on assisted dying.
Three judges sitting in London described the two cases as “deeply moving and tragic”.
But they unanimously agreed that it would be wrong for the court to depart from Britain’s long-held legal principle that voluntary euthanasia is a form of murder.
It should be up to parliament to decide whether the law should be changed, the judges added.
‘A life of increasing indignity and misery’
In a statement issued by his lawyer, Nicklinson said: “I am devastated by the court’s decision.
“I thought that if the court saw me as I am, utterly miserable with my life, powerless to do anything about it because of my disability, then the judges would accept my reasoning that I do not want to carry on and should be able to have a dignified death.
“I am saddened that the law wants to condemn me to a life of increasing indignity and misery.”
The Nicklinsons have said they will appeal against the decision and hope there will be a new hearing before the end of the year.
Asked what would happen if the appeal fails, Jane Nicklinson said: “Tony either has to carry on like this until he dies from natural causes or by starving himself.”
There is no cure or treatment for locked-in syndrome.
Nicklinson was left paralysed by a stroke in 2005. He is forced to communicate by controlling a computer with eye movements, and his paralysis is so severe that killing him would go beyond assisted suicide.
- © AFP, 2012
 
In this case, Mr. Nicklinson retains the ability to communicate. How would you feel about assisting him in dying if he couldn't communicate?
 
In this case, Mr. Nicklinson retains the ability to communicate. How would you feel about assisting him in dying if he couldn't communicate?

People who understand the question can usually blink their eyes or something to indicate yes or no. They can even scan the brain to determine which areas light up under different circumstances. If there is nothing, then they should pull the plug. It's pretty ridiculous to keep the power going when a person is not even able to respond, when other people who actually want to live are denied because it's too expensive.

It's a pretty unbalanced deal.
 
We are already killing millions of pre-born babies as it is. And it's legal. Isn't that enough?

My thought is that if someone wants to die, then they shouldn't involve someone else in it. Step up and do the suicide if you(general you, not specific) really want it done.

And, yes, there are times when someone is incapacitated in such a way that they cannot do it themselves. I am fairly certain that those people have a plethora of pain medications that they can just keep saying "the pain is 15 on a scale of 10" until the deed is done. Or someone who is willing to do that will be kind enough to ease them into death without there being anyone to say anything about it. I know of a man who was going to die... no question of if, just when.... and the family had the meds increased over a relatively short span of time resulting in his death and it was fine. A "do not resuscitate" order was already in place.

Like abortion, this is a very personal thing and I don't think we need laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm or to kill our very young and helpless. We do what is appropriate when it's time. Isn't that how it should be?
 
Boltlady.. I watched this story on a news program.. The way I understood it.. This poor guy wants to die... He has ways of communicating.. as you stated..
And he has been able to communicate -- indicating his wishes to die... A sad story..
 
We are already killing millions of pre-born babies as it is. And it's legal. Isn't that enough?

My thought is that if someone wants to die, then they shouldn't involve someone else in it. Step up and do the suicide if you(general you, not specific) really want it done.

And, yes, there are times when someone is incapacitated in such a way that they cannot do it themselves. I am fairly certain that those people have a plethora of pain medications that they can just keep saying "the pain is 15 on a scale of 10" until the deed is done. Or someone who is willing to do that will be kind enough to ease them into death without there being anyone to say anything about it. I know of a man who was going to die... no question of if, just when.... and the family had the meds increased over a relatively short span of time resulting in his death and it was fine. A "do not resuscitate" order was already in place.

Like abortion, this is a very personal thing and I don't think we need laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm or to kill our very young and helpless. We do what is appropriate when it's time. Isn't that how it should be?


So then, what you're saying is that it should remain illegal and that people should simply break the law when they feel that it is justified to do so?

That's how we handled abortions prior to Roe v. Wade. Ladies visited illegal doctors and hoped that they didn't get caught.
 
I wish things like that didn't have to have laws. Common sense and communication should prevail between a doctor and patient and what happens should remain between them and the patient's family. But, laws are required in our "modern" world.

Normally I wouldn't have a problem making euthanasia legal but with our government taking charge of who gets what meds and treatment and when........... I have to be against it so that if someone wants "assisted suicide" in my opinion, they'd better figure out how to do it themselves or find someone who is willing to bear the consequences if their are any.

Something tells me, though, that not to far in the future, we are going to deal with assisted suicide for those who are deemed too old and decrepit and needy to be dealt with ... they are just.......... helped out.........of this world.......

So then, what you're saying is that it should remain illegal and that people should simply break the law when they feel that it is justified to do so?

That's how we handled abortions prior to Roe v. Wade. Ladies visited illegal doctors and hoped that they didn't get caught.
 
Jen, you said: "Like abortion, this is a very personal thing and I don't think we need laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm or to kill our very young and helpless. We do what is appropriate when it's time. Isn't that how it should be?"

You don't seem to have understood my point here. Although I did C&P that article about the man who cannot do it himself, I'm not suggesting that there be laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm. I'm suggesting that there not be laws telling us we can't if that's what a person wants. I don't think that just anybody should be able to do it either. I think it's Norway that now has teams that go to people's homes for the purpose. They should be trained for the process.

So many people who argue against the right of a woman to choose abortion are just fine with in-vitro clinics to help those who can't conceive. Except for 'octo-mom's' doctor, the doctors at those clinics regularly 'eliminate' excess zygotes or fetuses so that a woman won't have too many at one time which can be harmful all around. They generally implant more eggs than what are needed because they don't know how many will 'take'. Do you think they should close all of those clinics?
 
I wish things like that didn't have to have laws. Common sense and communication should prevail between a doctor and patient and what happens should remain between them and the patient's family. But, laws are required in our "modern" world.

Normally I wouldn't have a problem making euthanasia legal but with our government taking charge of who gets what meds and treatment and when........... I have to be against it so that if someone wants "assisted suicide" in my opinion, they'd better figure out how to do it themselves or find someone who is willing to bear the consequences if their are any.

Something tells me, though, that not to far in the future, we are going to deal with assisted suicide for those who are deemed too old and decrepit and needy to be dealt with ... they are just.......... helped out.........of this world.......


Okay, let me get this straight. You want the government to maintain laws that limit your freedom because you are afraid of the government gaining too much control over your freedom?
 
I don't think I missed your point at all......... I pointed out that if/when we make euthanasia legal, there are lots of reasons to justify it and yes, we can "train" people to do it painlessly and "right". But then we risk coming to a time where we may do that just because someone will never again be able to contribute to society so that person is worthless and, thus, we can come nearer to our goal of lowering the population if this one person, this one group of people (who will never again contribute) are just quietly done away with. That is the risk and that is the fear. Throughout history there are many moments where millions of people were snuffed out just because of someone's agenda or reasoning that it was the "wise" thing to do. We think it could never happen now, but it could.

If we have one powerful person or one group of powerful people who believe that the world's population should be only 10% of what it is now.......... it seems like those same people would be in favor of getting rid of those who do not contribute in a viable way.


Jen, you said: "Like abortion, this is a very personal thing and I don't think we need laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm or to kill our very young and helpless. We do what is appropriate when it's time. Isn't that how it should be?"

You don't seem to have understood my point here. Although I did C&P that article about the man who cannot do it himself, I'm not suggesting that there be laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm. I'm suggesting that there not be laws telling us we can't if that's what a person wants. I don't think that just anybody should be able to do it either. I think it's Norway that now has teams that go to people's homes for the purpose. They should be trained for the process.

So many people who argue against the right of a woman to choose abortion are just fine with in-vitro clinics to help those who can't conceive. Except for 'octo-mom's' doctor, the doctors at those clinics regularly 'eliminate' excess zygotes or fetuses so that a woman won't have too many at one time which can be harmful all around. They generally implant more eggs than what are needed because they don't know how many will 'take'. Do you think they should close all of those clinics?
 
Back
Top