New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Assisted suicide

Sorry Jen, it's too late now, they're already heading in the direction of eliminating what they call 'useless eaters'. Instead of cutting back on our empire building, our dear leaders keep cutting back on that which would allow more of the people who want to live stay alive. We have more people dying now for lack of ability to receive care than we've had in a very long time.

At the same time, the one's who really would like to die, sick or not, have a difficult time of it. it's pretty unbalanced.
 
BoltLady, what happened here was that a GP ( Dr Shipman ) who murdered many of his patents was caught and imprisoned ....since then, where as before Doctors would 'up the morfine' now they dare not quite so easily ....................... they still do but have to be careful. As they do in Hospices,

It always upsets me too when these cases end up in Court but it is one of those fine lines which are so difficult. The Judges can only go where the Law leads them and actually changing the relevant Laws is not an easy task. It really is quite a quagmire.

Sometime I don't actually understand why they end up in Court because I have known people whose Morphine was 'upped' at th end and I now know one who will go that way ( not saying any more about that ) It was always unspoken but thanks to Dr 'bloody' Shipman it now has to be spoken about.
 
I believe that any mentally competent person over the age of 65 should have the option of medically assisted suicide. I have a living will which states that no extraordinary measure or resuscitation should be performed should I become incompacitated. I don't want my last days spent in a Nursing Home cussing the @%$#! Republicans.

I do think that there should be a waiting period (two weeks?) to prevent action being taken on a spur of the moment decision.
 
I believe that any mentally competent person over the age of 65 should have the option of medically assisted suicide. I have a living will which states that no extraordinary measure or resuscitation should be performed should I become incompacitated. I don't want my last days spent in a Nursing Home cussing the @%$#! Republicans.

I do think that there should be a waiting period (two weeks?) to prevent action being taken on a spur of the moment decision.

A 2 week waiting period would be fair enough, but I really don't think that there should be an age limit on it other than a legal age beyond childhood. They do that for alcohol consumption and I think it would be a good idea for the suicide thing too. There are a lot of people who are between 21 and 65 who simply might not want to be around anymore for whatever reason. It doesn't necessarily have to be a regular health problem although it could be.

There are a lot of forms of mental pain that people just can't get past. The fact is that we are talking about our own bodies and having the gov't constantly controlling what we can do with them is not right.
 
This was an interesting thread Boltlady. I'm surprised that we didn't have more libertarian posters weigh in on this. I would think that individual sovereignty over one's own life would be a critical issue for them.
 
Oregon's Death with Dignity Law has been an overwhelming success. It requires a terminal illness and/or horrendous pain and a Doctor must prescribe. They dispense less than 200 per year when the critics predicted thousands. Alfarto Gonzales and John "Sheets" Ashcroft tried mightily to overturn it (they really hate States Rights when it's something they disagreed with) to no avail.

It should be the law of the land.
 
This was an interesting thread Boltlady. I'm surprised that we didn't have more libertarian posters weigh in on this. I would think that individual sovereignty over one's own life would be a critical issue for them.

This is probably a situation where religion gets in the way. Heaven forbid that logic should prevail.
Lots of people believe that you are going to h*ll if you commit suicide, even though just as many others seem to believe that you are rewarded if you are a martyr.

Since many of our laws are based on Christianity those are the beliefs that would prevail and people don't want to let folks do that to themselves.

You're right, it's surprising that more libertarians don't defend what should be a basic freedom.
 
The assisted suicide is misnamed where deadly diseases are involved. The reality is that for the states that address the reality of death it has worked. There is absolutely no need to keep a dying person alive against their will and force them to linger so a disease can fully destroy them from the inside out. No reason.

I think in those areas though where life exists simply because of medical gear and aid but no life is actually lived it really is any person's living will that should decide. I personally would not like to be kept breathing because my nose still lives.

In the end, I guess we do for our loved ones what they wish as a last wish, not what we think about subjects when we are not the ones who suffer the pain or the reality of a clinically living nose.
 
No wink of the eye or verbal 'yes' should ever mean they are in agreement at a time like that and not in command of their senses.
 
I believe that any mentally competent person over the age of 65 should have the option of medically assisted suicide. I have a living will which states that no extraordinary measure or resuscitation should be performed should I become incompacitated. I don't want my last days spent in a Nursing Home cussing the @%$#! Republicans.

I do think that there should be a waiting period (two weeks?) to prevent action being taken on a spur of the moment decision.

RC but that is different, in most wills of that type there are two typically a family member and a Dr. agreeing that this is the correct thing.
 
No wink of the eye or verbal 'yes' should ever mean they are in agreement at a time like that and not in command of their senses.

I wonder what is is like to exist in such a condition. It could be a wonderful experience, for all we know. Or, perhaps more likely, it could be a living hell.
 
I wonder what is is like to exist in such a condition. It could be a wonderful experience, for all we know. Or, perhaps more likely, it could be a living hell.

I intend to have a living will.. just as my Mom did.. Under certain conditions .. do not resuscitate would be my request..
Good read and info on these pages..
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________
Let’s Discuss Dying: ‘The Conversation’ About How My Dad Wants To Go
Excerpt:
My dad, Charlie Ritz, has given me countless gifts. One of the more recent ones is his willingness to talk openly about the fact that, though he’s healthy, when you’re 85 you’re not going to be around forever. He has made me cheat sheets of all the numbers and names I’ll need to handle his estate. He has signed his living will. And he has told me in so many words that he only wants to keep living if the quality of his life is good.
But it’s one thing to say that. We both know how hard it is to act when the time comes. Nearly 25 years ago, my mom was in a terrible car accident that left her in a coma and then a persistent vegetative state. After about six months, there was no real hope that she would ever wake up. She’d been a member of the Hemlock Society and had always been clear that she wouldn’t want to live like that. Years earlier, she’d even made my dad promise that if she asked him to bring her suicide pills, he would: “She touched my arm and said, ‘And if I can’t ask you, you’ll know,’” he said.
We knew. Even so, it took us more than a year after all hope was gone to finally bring ourselves to remove my mother’s feeding tube. My dad went to see her every day, and apologized to her for breaking their agreement.
http://commonhealth.wbur.org/2012/08/conversation-project-dying

Readers, if this conversation leaves you with personal questions, you can go to The Conversation Project or post them in the comments below; Dr. McCannon has kindly agreed to respond. And now, our Conversation:
http://theconversationproject.org/about/
 
I wonder what is is like to exist in such a condition. It could be a wonderful experience, for all we know. Or, perhaps more likely, it could be a living hell.

True, I am saying it should be planned ahead with a living will when poeple are of sane mind.
 
We are already killing millions of pre-born babies as it is. And it's legal. Isn't that enough?

My thought is that if someone wants to die, then they shouldn't involve someone else in it. Step up and do the suicide if you(general you, not specific) really want it done.

And, yes, there are times when someone is incapacitated in such a way that they cannot do it themselves. I am fairly certain that those people have a plethora of pain medications that they can just keep saying "the pain is 15 on a scale of 10" until the deed is done. Or someone who is willing to do that will be kind enough to ease them into death without there being anyone to say anything about it. I know of a man who was going to die... no question of if, just when.... and the family had the meds increased over a relatively short span of time resulting in his death and it was fine. A "do not resuscitate" order was already in place.

Like abortion, this is a very personal thing and I don't think we need laws to tell us to kill our old and infirm or to kill our very young and helpless. We do what is appropriate when it's time. Isn't that how it should be?

Well Jen, problem solved. The man has died after refusing food for enough time for his body to give out. He really wanted it to be under more comfortable circumstances.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-19341722
 
Back
Top